Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Kelly, I forgot I laid all this out in post 56 last night. Tell me which premises you have a problem with.
 
The point of the thread was to reason theists out of religion. Pretend I'm the theist. I've just quoted an atheist expert who said it's either God or the multiverse, and that the evidence for both is zilch, so both are equally possible.

What do you do to counter my argument?


Err .... no.

The point of the thread was whether it was possible to reason someone out of a religion they were not reasoned into. Personally, I believe it difficult but does happen sometimes. I've managed to reason some out of religious belief, although to be honest their belief was wavering before I started on them. I think I may have put a chink in the belief of others who were more ardent, but it's difficult to assess the long term outcome.

Regarding your alternatives of God or multiverse both having no evidence of support and therefore being equally possible I say nonsense. I would suggest as an analogy, many years ago people would have speculated on the cause of thunder. It could have been suggested that either the cause was a god called Thor, (a relative of mine :) ), or some as yet unexplained natural phenomena. Would those two options have had equal chance of being possible?
 
Kelly, I forgot I laid all this out in post 56 last night. Tell me which premises you have a problem with.

Coincidence does not explain prima facie fine-tuning.

I'm not so sure it can't.

6. Because the universes in a multiverse would be causally disconnected from each other, there would never come a time when evidence of their existence appears.

I'm 99% sure that's not true, and some physicists think there might be evidence of a multiverse that can be detected on the quantum level.

Also, there's a missing premise of "something we haven't thought of yet" and a TOE solving some of it.
 
I would suggest as an analogy, many years ago people would have speculated on the cause of thunder. It could have been suggested that either the cause was a god called Thor, (a relative of mine :) ), or some as yet unexplained natural phenomena. Would those two options have had equal chance of being possible?

I think the Thor theory of thunder was perfectly reasonable in the pre-science days. It took a lot of debunking before we, as a species, really started ruling out invisible people doing all this stuff. lol
 
If you're a god you can.

By definition, a claimed god can do anything. Any claimed god. All of them.

Your claim is now that all gods must exist because philosophy and nobody may dispute that.

That is your consequence.

Odin is a god, Ra is a god, Gilgamesh is a god and you simply must accept all of them as valid.

Good luck with that.
 
All this talk of God versus multiverses and fine tuning leaves me unimpressed.

We, (carbon based life form), may be one of many different possibilities. Out there, (in our universe or others), there may be other life forms of a completely different type. They may be pondering why their world is so fine tuned to be complimentary to their own existence. To the god believing theists I ask: What kind of life form is your god?
 
Err… and I raise you an Err… :p

Err...
Lets pretend it's 1600 and we're trying to figure out what makes people sick. So far, people have proposed: hypothesis 1, hypothesis 2, and hypothesis 3.

Do we encourage people so inclined to discover whatever evidence they can
Well I certainly would. Given you champion “anything is possible” do you? Or do you suggest “anything” such as homeopathic “medicine” as some other “anything is possible” champions do?

or just sit around going "so far there's zilch evidence for any then, so they're all equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude any are possible"?
“There’s zilch evidence yet discovered” isn’t the same as “There’s zilch evidence yet to be discovered (but there could be)”.

That zilch evidence means they're all equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude any are possible, doesn’t mean there’s zilch evidence yet to be discovered and we give up. Doesn’t mean there is such evidence yet to be discovered either. We only know what we DO know, not what we MIGHT know.
 
Last edited:
So, same situation with a supernova.

No. Supernovas are naturally occurring events that you don't need to invoke theism for. Predicting one in the next five minutes would make you extremely lucky, but that's it. If you did it again, THEN we would have to start thinking of alternative hypotheses.

A rigged universe, on the other hand, which is the fine-tuning problem, demands something exceptional by way of explanation, whether it's a huge multiverse or a god.
 
I think the Thor theory of thunder was perfectly reasonable in the pre-science days. It took a lot of debunking before we, as a species, really started ruling out invisible people doing all this stuff. lol


You missed my point I think. I was suggesting that the degree of probability of the two options was not identical.

Also I would suggest there was no such time as pre-science days. We have been using the scientific method of finding stuff out from day one. Other animals use it also - albeit at a lesser level than man.
 
Last edited:
I'm not so sure it can't.

The consensus says otherwise, as I've demonstrated in links. Part of the reason multiverse theory is popular is that it solves fine-tuning problems like the flatness problem. Ergo fine-tuning problems exist. Ergo, coincidence is not the preferred explanation.

"Eternal chaotic inflation, which generates multiple universes, builds from the theory of cosmic inflation, originated by physicist Alan Guth at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He formulated cosmic inflation to solve several deep problems in the cosmology of our universe — for example, why was the early universe extremely (and strangely) homogeneous, even though separated regions were causally disconnected? (Regions could not cause effects with others because the distances were too great and the elapsed time was too short, even though information was being exchanged at the speed of light, what theorists call the "horizon problem"."
https://www.space.com/31465-is-our-universe-just-one-of-many-in-a-multiverse.html

The horizon problem is a fine-tuning problem. Inflation theory was proposed to solve these fine-tuning problems. Coincidence as an explanatory hypothesis is not taken seriously.

I'm 99% sure that's not true, and some physicists think there might be evidence of a multiverse that can be detected on the quantum level.

You're 99% wrong. Under inflation theory, other universes exist beyond our observable universe, disoconnected from us in every way. There is speculation about quantum effects, but so far it's just that. Someone who discovers the existence of another universe actually affecting ours will win the Nobel Prize. Guaranteed.

"It is easy to forget that each of these new pocket universes is vastly larger than our observable universe (see next section). But these new universes are not superstrange, since they all exist within the same space-time framework that we know in our universe — though they erupt far beyond what we can see in our observable universe. What's more, once these new pocket universes are born, they are totally and forever disconnected from every other universe (including ours)."
https://www.space.com/31465-is-our-universe-just-one-of-many-in-a-multiverse.html

Also, there's a missing premise of "something we haven't thought of yet" and a TOE solving some of it.

What TOE candidate do you imagine can solve the fine-tuning problem?
 
Err… and I raise you an Err… :p


Well I certainly would. Given you champion “anything is possible” do you? Or do you suggest “anything” such as homeopathic “medicine” as some other “anything is possible” champions do?


“There’s zilch evidence yet discovered” isn’t the same as “There’s zilch evidence yet to be discovered (but there could be)”.

That zilch evidence means they're all equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude any are possible, doesn’t mean there’s zilch evidence yet to be discovered and we give up. Doesn’t mean there is such evidence yet to be discovered either. We only know what we DO know, not what we MIGHT know.

Homeopathy has been so close to ruled out it might as well be totally, 100% ruled out, but at heart, I'm basically a solipsist, so...sure..let the homeopaths and squatchers and anti-vampire brigaders et al keep looking, for all I care. LOL

I don't think there's rock sold strong evidence against a multiverse, tho. I don't think the multiverse theory is shamefully outlandish. There is, from what I understand, a good bit of converging evidence suggesting it's true.
 
Homeopathy has been so close to ruled out it might as well be totally, 100% ruled out,
Can anything ever be 100% ruled out with an "everything is possible (therefore nothing is impossible)" philosophy?

(IMO) "Anything is possible" is a new age (hardly new anymore) "blind positivity" stance that considers itself somehow superior to healthy skepticism and science. I think "everything not yet known is possibly either possible or not possible" is more valid and correct (bit wordy tho).

but at heart, I'm basically a solipsist, so...sure..let the homeopaths and squatchers and anti-vampire brigaders et al keep looking, for all I care. LOL
I wasn't talking "looking" I was talking "practicing" as if it were true. Do you care about that?

I don't think there's rock sold strong evidence against a multiverse, tho. I don't think the multiverse theory is shamefully outlandish. There is, from what I understand, a good bit of converging evidence suggesting it's true.
There would have to be rock solid evidence for a multiverse (that I was capable of understanding) before I would class it as not outlandish (using your word).
 
Last edited:
Can anything ever be 100% ruled out with an "everything is possible (therefore nothing is impossible)" philosophy?

(IMO) "Anything is possible" is a new age (hardly new anymore) "blind positivity" stance that considers itself somehow superior to healthy skepticism and science. I think "everything not yet known is possibly either possible or not possible" is more valid and correct (bit wordy tho).


I wasn't talking "looking" I was talking "practicing" as if it were true. Do you care about that?


There would have to be rock solid evidence for a multiverse (that I was capable of understanding) before I would class it as not outlandish (using your word).

I'm not sure what you mean about practicing vs looking when it comes to anything, really.

Here's some "legit" evidence favoring a multiverse, if the science writing isn't poor, which is possible:


https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/cosmic-bruise-could-be-evidence-multiple-universes-ncna771076

A study recently submitted to “Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society” actually places the multiverse theory on firmer ground. Ruari Mackenzie, a graduate student at England’s University of Durham, took a deeper look at a region in the sky that’s so frigid and so large that most scientists don’t think it can be a statistical fluke. Instead, some astronomers think this so-called “cold spot” is an optical illusion produced by a lack of intervening galaxies. But Mackenzie and his colleagues found that those galaxies are no less dense than anywhere else in the universe, disproving that theory.

Believe it or not, the next reasonable explanation (so long as you don’t buy into the theory that it’s just a statistical fluke) is that the cold spot might be a bruise left after an ancient collision with another universe
.
 
I'm not sure what you mean about practicing vs looking when it comes to anything, really.
Really! :confused:

"Practicing" means putting into practice. Believing and claiming it's true and selling it to others as a credible cure.

"Looking" means examining to see of it's true. Not believing claiming it's either true or false until it has proven to be either.

Think that's enough for me on "everything is possible".
 
We were specifically discussing homeopathy and the “practicing” and “looking” was specific to that.

As part of a larger discussion of competing hypotheses for which there is or was no convincing evidence. I could just as easily have used static universe vs big bang instead of disease theories as an example of how you're wrong to say "If there's zilch evidence for both then both are equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude either are possible."

"Maybe" (aka, "it's possible") is the default if there's no evidence ruling something out. The only real exception is an unfalsifiable hypothesis, and even then it's not because it's literally assumed to be impossible, but because it's scientifically unproductive to just settle for one of those.
 
We were specifically discussing homeopathy and the “practicing” and “looking” was specific to that.

Yes that was quite clear to me and it's puzzling that kellyb missed it.

For the record I do care if someone in practising homeopathy instead of science based medicine. Well not so much for themselves but for their children certainly.

It has been getting a good deal of publicity lately in Australia, that some church groups are subjecting homosexuals to demon driving out rituals, with considerable mental harm being done to those being subjected to it. I care about that sort of stuff too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom