Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

You are doing a light version of magical thinking. It goes like this: That you think/reason reality in toto is in certain way will not determine/cause reality to be in a certain way. Rather since you are a result of reality, you are caused by reality and you are the result(effect). Your thinking/reasoning is the result of being caused by reality as such.

So you(Y) are caused by natural reality(NR) or you are caused by another reality(AR). Another reality could e.g. be by a god or that you are a Boltzmann brain.
So it goes like this:
NR->Y
OR
AR->Y
but since you are the same, Y, you can't tell if reality is natural reality, NR, or another reality, AR.

All you have given evidence for, is what you believe reality is. Not what reality is independently of your mind.

For all the highlighted parts, they are cases of your thinking about what reality is to you, not what reality is independently of the mind.

With regard

I had a look at that rabbit hole when I was about twelve, it didn't take long for me to decide it was rather sterile, once you accept that the only certainty is one's own existence at that particular time. I certainly have no proof that the English language means what I think it does, but the most parsimonious explanation is that it generally does and we have an external existence.

Not being a stoner hippy, I find the discussion about whether you can prove reality a bit pointless, maan. (TLDR - you can't, but it's not going to change anything either way).

Given all this, Toontown is correct in saying there is no reason to think that there are any gods.

It's also reasonable to argue that there is evidence against the majority of the deities that people have believed in.
 
You might, but I don't think I have. Perhaps you might suggest what I'm missing.

I think you're talking to someone who thinks the idea that "reality is natural" is nothing more than "psychological belief" lacking proof.
 
I think you're talking to someone who thinks the idea that "reality is natural" is nothing more than "psychological belief" lacking proof.
I'm already regretting asking for a suggestion. I'm expecting something like "love". Why isn't it ever "hate"?
 
I think you're talking to someone who thinks the idea that "reality is natural" is nothing more than "psychological belief" lacking proof.

That and morality/ethics.

We can stay within methodological naturalism and yet there is still something for which you can't use science. Namely morality/ethics, that is subjective/inter-subjective and psychological and not objective, thus science doesn't work on that, yet it is natural.

With regards
 
I'm already regretting asking for a suggestion. I'm expecting something like "love". Why isn't it ever "hate"?

No, e.g. that rationality is better than irrationality is a psychological belief and a subjective bias.

With regards
 
I don't actually think rationality is necessarily always better. I think "better" is a matter of opinion at its core, too.
 
No, e.g. that rationality is better than irrationality is a psychological belief and a subjective bias.

With regards
Rubbish. It's merely true. Give an example of irrationality being better than rationality. ( I will regret this).

If irrational ever became better than rational it would immediately become rational.
 
Last edited:
That and morality/ethics.

We can stay within methodological naturalism and yet there is still something for which you can't use science. Namely morality/ethics, that is subjective/inter-subjective and psychological and not objective, thus science doesn't work on that, yet it is natural.

With regards
Dear god, you do talk/think crap! Morals and ethics are merely abstract human constructs that are essentially rules and guidelines to help our societies to function as harmoniously as possble. There's no such thing as intrinsic morals and ethics. They don't come from invisible, magical gods either
 
Last edited:
Rubbish. It's merely true. Give an example of irrationality being better than rationality. ( I will regret this).

Concentrate on the word "better". It is not objective, because it is not tangible, concrete or observable through external sensation (see, hear, touch and so on).
So better is subjective and not a result of reason and logic. It is an emotional evaluation, yet there are humans who think/feel that "that rationality is better than irrationality" is rational. I.e not a subjective bias/emotion and that it is rational to claim "that rationality is better than irrationality". It is not, it is irrational to claim that.
Thus it is irrationally better for those humans to believe/think/feel "that rationality is better than irrationality".

Note that you use "rubbish", that is an emotion. That "it is merely true" is stated without reason, logic and evidence and as it stands is a dogmatic assertion.

With regard
 
Rubbish. It's merely true. Give an example of irrationality being better than rationality. ( I will regret this).

If irrational ever became better than rational it would immediately become rational.

Irrational delusions can bring happiness.
 
Last edited:
Irrational delusions can bring happiness.
If happiness at any cost is the "better" and irrational delusions bring happiness, then the delusions would be rational for the purpose of bringing happiness.

Is using irrational delusions a "better" way to gain happiness than other options? Do irrational delusions have a "better' effect on the brains of the deluded? How about gaining happiness from drugs that ruin health and kill? Is happiness at any cost ever "better".
 
Last edited:
If happiness is the "better" and irrational delusions bring happiness, then the delusions would be rational for the purpose of bringing happiness.

Is using irrational delusions a "better" way to gain happiness than other options? Do irrational deluesions have a "better effect on the brains of the deluded? How about gaining happiness from drugs that ruin health and kill? Is happiness at any cost ever "better".

That's why I said "better" is a matter of opinion. "Better" (as used in this sense) presumes "chosen metrics".
 
If happiness at any cost is the "better" and irrational delusions bring happiness, then the delusions would be rational for the purpose of bringing happiness.

Is using irrational delusions a "better" way to gain happiness than other options? Do irrational deluesions have a "better effect on the brains of the deluded? How about gaining happiness from drugs that ruin health and kill? Is happiness at any cost ever "better".

I like a nice single malt with friends.
 
That's why I said "better" is a matter of opinion. "Better" (as used in this sense) presumes "chosen metrics".
If irrational delusions are better according to chosen metrics for gaining happiness then the delusions are rational for that purpose.
 
I find some people's obsession with happiness quite saddening.
 
Last edited:
If irrational delusions are better according to chosen metrics for gaining happiness then the delusions are rational for that purpose.

Yeah, but the delusions themselves are still irrational.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom