Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Yes that was quite clear to me and it's puzzling that kellyb missed it.

I just thought it was a nonsense question, since it started with my hypothetical of "Lets pretend it's 1600 and we're trying to figure out what makes people sick. So far, people have proposed: hypothesis 1, hypothesis 2, and hypothesis 3."...and then he threw in "Given you champion “anything is possible” do you? Or do you suggest “anything” such as homeopathic “medicine” as some other “anything is possible” champions do?



That's the perspective of scientific curiosity and hypothesis testing, not a practitioner of anything.
 
"Maybe" (aka, "it's possible") is the default if there's no evidence ruling something out. The only real exception is an unfalsifiable hypothesis, and even then it's not because it's literally assumed to be impossible, but because it's scientifically unproductive to just settle for one of those.
It may be your default, but it's not mine. Are you claiming it's the default of science?
 
A thread started by ynot, asking the question if your atheism was the result of a theism fail or a science win, indicated the former as most common from my observation. A science win almost certainly could be interpreted as a reasoned result, but then a theism fail may be also, because the lack of logic and consistency in theistic doctrine. Perhaps there is another reason however ... just lack of interest.


I think you're right about this - and ynot's FTFY was wrong: They didn't get religious because they thought that proof of God existed. They become religious because they need religion, but a question remains: How do they lose this need? How do they become uninterested in religion?
The Death of Religion – not with a bang but with a whimper
 
I think you're right about this - and ynot's FTFY was wrong: They didn't get religious because they thought that proof of God existed. They become religious because they need religion, but a question remains: How do they lose this need? How do they become uninterested in religion?
The Death of Religion – not with a bang but with a whimper

I think most of those types were nominally religious because they were told god is real as children, and people believe what they're told as a general rule, and then as adults got to thinking about it and decided it was stupid, and/or just naturally morphed into apatheism.
 
Just read the "death of religion" post, and definitely. Australia is a very good place for nominal "I dunno, it's just what my mom told me" theists to naturally age into basic apatheism nowadays.
 
Last edited:
For some reason I never heard of apatheism until now - I may have seen the word and considered it to be a spelling mistake, I don't know - but it's a great concept.

An apatheist may not have any interest in the god debate simply for lack of interest in the topic.
(...)
Practical atheism doesn't see the god question as irrelevant, in contrast to apatheism.


As an atheist I think I'm leaning more and more towards apatheism myself. I long for the day when the question of religion is only of historical interest.
 
As an atheist I think I'm leaning more and more towards apatheism myself.

Same. Atheism hasn't been a big part of my identity for a long time now. Skepticism is and probably always will be, tho.
 
I think you're right about this - and ynot's FTFY was wrong: They didn't get religious because they thought that proof of God existed. They become religious because they need religion, but a question remains: How do they lose this need? How do they become uninterested in religion?
The Death of Religion – not with a bang but with a whimper
The question was why atheists were never theists or were then became atheists, not why they became theists.

The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence. Do you think people could or would be apathetic if there was?
 
The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence.

His point is that when your material needs aren't met, the "no evidence" thing might not bother you so much.
Desperation does make people irrational.
Having needs met fosters rationality.
 
The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence.


You're an idealist! You actually imagine people walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con. Most of the time they don't. And the apatheists - and the concept fits extremely well for the Danes, who tend to be members of the state church but rarely believe in God - don't believe because religion has become irrelevant to them because they no longer need it. So they give it up. The question of "credible evidence of any god’s actual existence" simply doesn't concern them and never did. (See my Death of Religion post and the NYT article it links to!)

Do you think people could or would be apathetic if there was?


That is a different question, but the reason why there isn't is that there is no God, not that there is no evidence of one. But in your hypothetical scenario where God not only exists but is on prime time TV every night, it would be stupid not to believe in him, but that is not the case.
(People also don't believe in Santa, but they don't really run around looking for evidence. A few believers devote most of their waking hours to finding evidence for the existence of Sasquatch. That the rest of us don't isn't really because we've been convinced by meticulous studies of the evidence delivered so far that Sasquatch doesn't exist. It's because we don't give a damn if he does or not.)
 
Last edited:
You're an idealist! You actually imagine people walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con. Most of the time they don't. And the apatheists - and the concept fits extremely well for the Danes, who tend to be members of the state church but rarely believe in God - don't believe because religion has become irrelevant to them because they no longer need it. So they give it up. The question of "credible evidence of any god’s actual existence" simply doesn't concern them and never did. (See my Death of Religion post and the NYT article it links to!)
The point is that if there was credible evidence of a god people wouldn't have to be walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con as it would be world-wide headline news on every form of media that would be extremely difficult to ignore. You do realise this is all hypothetical?

That is a different question, but the reason why there isn't is that there is no God, not that there is no evidence of one. But in your hypothetical scenario where God not only exists but is on prime time TV every night, it would be stupid not to believe in him, but that is not the case.
(People also don't believe in Santa, but they don't really run around looking for evidence. A few believers devote most of their waking hours to finding evidence for the existence of Sasquatch. That the rest of us don't isn't really because we've been convinced by meticulous studies of the evidence delivered so far that Sasquatch doesn't exist. It's because we don't give a damn if he does or not.)
The first part you quoted wasn't even a question. If Santa and Sasquatch were proven to be real it would be stupid not to believe in them as well. Although their reality would hardly be on the same level of importance as a god's reality. You do realise this is all hypothetical?
 
Last edited:
The point is that if there was credible evidence of a god people wouldn't have to be walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con as it would be world-wide headline news on every form of media that would be extremely difficult to ignore. You do realise this is all hypothetical?

...

You are aware that lack of evidence is not evidence of lack, right? What reality is independent of the mind is unknown other that a part of reality is independent of the mind.

Any claim of what reality is independent of the mind other than independent of the mind is without evidence and can't be decided using reason and logic. If we look at reality in practice there are humans, who believe in the supernatural, those humans, who believe in the natural and those who doesn't care.
You can't use reason, logic and evidence to decide what reality is independently of the mind. You believe in an un-reflected or reflected manner in something no matter what. Even if you don't care, that is still subjective and a sort of cognitive belief.

From the fact that a human believes in the supernatural nothing else follows. You can have pacifists, militants, communists, libertarians and so on among religious humans. The same with non-religious humans. Even if we remove religion, it doesn't follow that the world would become better.

If you by evidence mean scientific evidence, then you can't use evidence, reason and logic to do moral and ethical evaluations. They are always subjective and not independent of bias.
Any sufficiently complex claim of what reality is, is a variant of cognitive relativism and any claim of good and bad is a subjective bias.

So since you can do scientific evidence, do evidence of what reality really is and what good and bad is!!!

With regards
 
Thanks for the fix ynot.:)

Perhaps a little elaboration is needed here.

The skeptical atheists on this forum are not typical, (may I suggest), of the average non believer, who make up the largest religious/non religious group in my country, Australia, today. I observe most here have strong resentment about religious intrusion and influence in our societies. From my observations the bulk of non believers I am surrounded with do not ... they are indifferent.

I think the reason for this indifference is ignorance. Many have just drifted out of religion because, well just because, that is the way things are with those around them. These folk haven't looked at Biblical scripture and seen the lack of consistency and logic and reasoned their way out. They haven't seen the injustice encouraged by scripture either, and most likely don't make the connection, between for example persecution of gays, and religious influence.

Pretty much the same in the UK in my experience. Thirty years ago, lots of people might sort of say that they believed in god if pushed.


Indifference is the main attitude I think of for most people in the UK. It suits me fine. My kids friends seem more atheistic than their parents - disbelief as opposed to not caring.
 
And there would be no life. That's not the situation we're in.

Correct.

I wonder what you thought that was a counter-argument to.

No, I'm quoting a very well respected atheist scientist who said "It's either God or the multiverse", and I know exactly why she said that. I've tried to explain, but you're not getting it.

You can appeal to authority as much as you like. That doesn't make her right. I've explained how she's wrong.
 
All this talk of God versus multiverses and fine tuning leaves me unimpressed.

We, (carbon based life form), may be one of many different possibilities. Out there, (in our universe or others), there may be other life forms of a completely different type. They may be pondering why their world is so fine tuned to be complimentary to their own existence. To the god believing theists I ask: What kind of life form is your god?

Yes, the weak anthropic principle is all that is needed. It has been alluded to upthread with the metaphor of the water thinking that the form the puddle is designed to fit it.

As an aside, I would say that given the laws of chemistry and physics, carbon-based life would be the most common and there are good reasons for thinking that liquid wayer would also be important... not that invalidates your argument.
 
The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence. Do you think people could or would be apathetic if there was?

Some people are aoathetic about all sorts of important things for which there is plenty of evidence in the real world. Poverty in their own countries, the bad things done by their governments, abuses of democracy, institutionalised racism, etc.

I don't see why the existence of God would be any different.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom