Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Most of them don't seem to get to the point where they're talking with a negotiator, but in general Christians appear to be more afraid of dying than the non-religious:


There may be a grain of truth in this but I would be reluctant to make such a sweeping statement about it. Perhaps that is the difference between you and I.:)
 
Yes, that probably is the difference between you and me, Thor 2. (between is a preposition!) I read and find out what other people have observed and learn from that. You pride yourself on having made the amazing discovery that God doesn't actually exist and hold yourself tremendously superior to everybody who hasn't because that appears to be the only discovery you've ever accomplished.
 
OR: They really believed that dying would give them union with the aliens hiding behind the Hale-Bopp comet. That's a much simpler explanation than the convoluted thinking you suggest.


Yes, much too simple, because religion actually is "convoluted thinking".

What is important is that they have demonstrated that they believed their myths were actually true. They cut off their balls, for Pete's sake! Why would they do that if they didn't believe doing so would help them achieve their goals? By what kind of convoluted thinking is cutting off your balls part of a "comforting fantasy?"


By this kind! In ordinary thinking, you don't have to make sacrifices. When you know the difference between red and green lights in traffic, for instance, you just have to wait when it's red and walk/drive when it's green. No need for any rituals or incantations. It's as simple as that. In religion/superstition, it isn't.

I don't deny there are elements of this. But the overarching point is that none of that would make any sense unless they all believed that the glories of martyrdom were true. That they are also flawed, selfish humans changes none of that.


And there's nothing "convoluted" at all about being willing to make the supreme unselfish sacrifice of your life (and those of thousands of others) but not being willing to give up on a little nookie hours before you (allegedly) meet your Maker (and 72 virgins), is there?! (By the way, you actually share the idea of what constitutes human flaws and selfishness with religious nuts.)

If you (the average radical Muslim, anyway) think that your martyrdom will absolve you of your earthly sins, you might just partake of the carnal desires you have been denying yourself. You are only human after all. You might even rationalize it as religiously acceptable because the prostitute is kafir. Your Allah knows this and sees your sacrifice as the ultimate expression of your faith. He will reward you . . . if you don't truly believe that, then why in the world would you do any of it?


Because that's how people reward themselves: 'I'm going on a suicide mission so before I go I might as well ...' There's nothing religious about that idea (by the way, there's nothing inherently religious about suicide missions either). There's a much simpler explanation, but in this case you're the one who insists on making it convoluted.

The Santa myth is probably one of the biggest tools we have for reasoning people out of religion. Kids believe in Santa because parents, the people kids trust the most in the world, lie to their kids. Santa is a convenient entity that parents can use to bribe kids into behaving. Kids go to sleep on Christmas Eve and wake up with tangible proof of Santa's existence -presents! Kids believe with all their hearts because they don't know any better. But one day, parents tell their kids the truth, there is no Santa -it was the parents all along. Or maybe they hear rumors from other kids who already know the truth and their parents finally confirm those rumors. At some point, the kids get too old to believe in made up fairy tales and it's time to grow up.


Oh, the poor kids! Come on, xjx388, leave Santa alone! I don't know why, but maybe it's your religious upbringing that makes you treat the fairly innocent Santa story as an atrocious betrayal of children's trust. In my country, even the name of Santa is pagan: "julemanden", the yule man! I stopped believing in him when I was three or four and noticed that his beard was obviously fake. I said so out loud, which was a little embarrassing to the poor guy who'd been paid to play Santa, but I hope that he got over it. And that was it! I was in no way disappointed because I knew that it was just a trick my family had played on me like so many others. (Did the bad guys ever tell you that they got your nose?! I hope that there was a kid around to tell you that they didn't, actually!)
The story about julemanden wasn't meant to harm me, and it didn't. So it was in no way the traumatic experience that you make it out to be with your "believe with all their hearts because they don't know any better."
Come on, you are obviously the one who needs to grow up!

Religion is just the Santa myth on a bigger and more complex scale played out over the whole of human existence. Many of us have come to understand that it's a lie told by authority figures who were trusted many, many centuries ago as means to bribe/scare us into conforming to their ideas of good behavior. The problem is that no one ever explicitly told us that it was a lie and it was time to "grow up."


Really?! There wasn't this naughty kid in your neighborhood to tell you that God was just a fairy tale made up by grown ups to make kids behave? Like with Santa? "maybe they hear rumors from other kids who already know the truth." Not at all?! I pity you if the bold kids you grew up with would only tell you about Santa but not about God! (What about where babies come from? No kid revealed that truth to you either? Nobody told you that it wasn't the stork?)

The original lie became truth over the span of time. Therefore, many people are still like those kids, believing with all their heart that those ancient stories are true. Thus, you have people like Islamic plane crashers, abortion clinic bombers, Branch Davidians and even less extreme displays of religious faith like those who believe it's their mission to spread the gospel to places like Africa, the Middle East, Asia, etc. You simply can't credibly explain all that behavior with, "it's comforting."


Yes, the "original lie" blah, blah, blah! If grown ups still believe "with all their heart that those ancient stories are true," it's because they want to and probably need to believe. Even more so if you're not a child but an actual adult who goes and joins a cult.
You still don't get it that people either make up their own beliefs or actively seek out a belief system of their own accord, even though cases like the Heaven's Gaters ought to convince you that your story of the poor innocent victims of religion ("with all their heart") is the lie that you have chosen to believe in!
Not a single one of the Heaven's Gate congregation had been told as children about "The Evolutionary Level Above Human" and the extra-terrestrials and the UFO from Sirius! They were told as adults and chose to believe it.

You really need to grow out of your fairytale about what constitutes religion, xjx388!
 
Last edited:
Yes, much too simple, because religion actually is "convoluted thinking".




By this kind! In ordinary thinking, you don't have to make sacrifices. When you know the difference between red and green lights in traffic, for instance, you just have to wait when it's red and walk/drive when it's green. No need for any rituals or incantations. It's as simple as that. In religion/superstition, it isn't.
Can you come up with a definition of non-convoluted, ordinary thinking that doesn't break down to, "thinks about things in the same way I do?" This is a very egocentric series of statements you've made here. I understand that you don't see the world through a religious prism. I don't either. But that does not mean that anyone who does is not thinking straight. That is just arrogance.
And there's nothing "convoluted" at all about being willing to make the supreme unselfish sacrifice of your life (and those of thousands of others) but not being willing to give up on a little nookie hours before you (allegedly) meet your Maker (and 72 virgins), is there?! (By the way, you actually share the idea of what constitutes human flaws and selfishness with religious nuts.)
Again, this is your egocentrism talking. You only see the world through your own eyes and you cannot fathom how anyone else can think and act differently from the way you imagine you might act. Those people are psychopaths or convoluted thinkers.

Because that's how people reward themselves: 'I'm going on a suicide mission so before I go I might as well ...' There's nothing religious about that idea (by the way, there's nothing inherently religious about suicide missions either). There's a much simpler explanation, but in this case you're the one who insists on making it convoluted.
You are missing something after the ellipsis, "...because Allah will forgive me anyway." That's the simplest explanation. They wouldn't be rewarding themselves if they thought there was a chance it would taint their sacrifice -otherwise, why make the sacrifice at all?


Oh, the poor kids! Come on, xjx388, leave Santa alone! I don't know why, but maybe it's your religious upbringing that makes you treat the fairly innocent Santa story as an atrocious betrayal of children's trust.
Well, I never said it was "an atrocious betrayal of children's trust." It is fairly innocent; parents don't have bad intentions -I certainly didn't. It was fun. But the point of the Santa story was that religious belief is very much like that except no one ever told us it was a lie.
In my country, even the name of Santa is pagan: "julemanden", the yule man! I stopped believing in him when I was three or four and noticed that his beard was obviously fake. I said so out loud, which was a little embarrassing to the poor guy who'd been paid to play Santa, but I hope that he got over it. And that was it! I was in no way disappointed because I knew that it was just a trick my family had played on me like so many others.
And thus, your experience must reflect the experience of every other child?
(Did the bad guys ever tell you that they got your nose?! I hope that there was a kid around to tell you that they didn't, actually!)
Citing wiki for, "got your nose," seems excessive, even for this forum! ;) My favorite people to do magic for are kids. They believe because they don't know any better. So, yeah, in a time I don't remember anymore, my grandpa probably fooled me with that trick like I fool my granddaughter now. Which, really, is the other point I was trying to make with Santa -the religious engage in the same sort of magical thinking that powers the Santa myth. It's just been so engrained in their families, culture and society that many of them never question it.
The story about julemanden wasn't meant to harm me, and it didn't. So it was in no way the traumatic experience that you make it out to be with your "believe with all their hearts because they don't know any better."
Come on, you are obviously the one who needs to grow up!
LOL, I don't think exactly like you so I need to grow up . . . egocentrism.

Really?! There wasn't this naughty kid in your neighborhood to tell you that God was just a fairy tale made up by grown ups to make kids behave? Like with Santa? "maybe they hear rumors from other kids who already know the truth." Not at all?! I pity you if the bold kids you grew up with would only tell you about Santa but not about God! (What about where babies come from? No kid revealed that truth to you either? Nobody told you that it wasn't the stork?)
You probably don't realize it but you are reinforcing my point.

Yes, the "original lie" blah, blah, blah! If grown ups still believe "with all their heart that those ancient stories are true," it's because they want to and probably need to believe. Even more so if you're not a child but an actual adult who goes and joins a cult.
You still don't get it that people either make up their own beliefs or actively seek out a belief system of their own accord, even though cases like the Heaven's Gaters ought to convince you that your story of the poor innocent victims of religion ("with all their heart") is the lie that you have chosen to believe in!
Not a single one of the Heaven's Gate congregation had been told as children about "The Evolutionary Level Above Human" and the extra-terrestrials and the UFO from Sirius! They were told as adults and chose to believe it.

You really need to grow out of your fairytale about what constitutes religion, xjx388!
No . . .you need to understand that not everyone has the same thoughts as you do and that this doesn't make them self-deluding nitwits as you paint them out to be.


ETA: To bring this back to the OP -part of reasoning people out of religion is seeing them as rational people capable of listening to reason. Approaching them with this kind of arrogance as the base of your arguments isn't likely to win any believers over. You must see them as equals, just with a different perspective and then you can approach them on a level playing field and not from a mountain-top silently mocking them for their irrationality.
 
Last edited:
So dann thinks you need to grow up xjx388, and I hold myself tremendously superior to everybody who hasn't discovered the non existence of God, and that appears to be the only discovery I've ever accomplished.

Don't know how dann managed to "discover" the latter - must have spies all over the place.:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom