Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

That's coz you're irrationally attached to rationality. :D
But I'm in love with rationality. Surely you're not saying love is irrational? Haven't you heard that love is even better than happiness? :D + :D
 
Last edited:
You are doing a light version of magical thinking.

No I'm not.

It goes like this: That you think/reason reality in toto is in certain way will not determine/cause reality to be in a certain way.

Glad you told me that. I never would have known.

Rather since you are a result of reality, you are caused by reality and you are the result(effect). Your thinking/reasoning is the result of being caused by reality as such.

Wow. I never would have known that either. But I fail to see how being caused by reality prevents me from noticing that I see reality and deal with it all the time. But I've never seen hide nor hair of any of these god(s) people keep talking about.

So you(Y) are caused by natural reality(NR) or you are caused by another reality(AR). Another reality could e.g. be by a god or that you are a Boltzmann brain.
So it goes like this:
NR->Y
OR
AR->Y
but since you are the same, Y, you can't tell if reality is natural reality, NR, or another reality, AR.

The tautologous fact that I am the same either way offers me no clue as to what you think the difference is between Natural Reality and Alternate Reality.

It is what it is and does what it does, whatever you call it. Call it Natural Reality, or Alternate Reality, or call it Drunken Ira Hayes, it won't answer.

All you have given evidence for, is what you believe reality is. Not what reality is independently of your mind.

:wwt

I do not recall saying what I believe realty is. I recall briefly explaining a little bit about how I play the odds.

For all the highlighted parts, they are cases of your thinking about what reality is to you, not what reality is independently of the mind.

And the entirety of all your posts are cases of your thinking about how everyone should think about reality.

And the entirety of them have given me zero cause to suspect that I should abandon my thinking on it in favor of yours.
 
...

The tautologous fact that I am the same either way offers me no clue as to what you think the difference is between Natural Reality and Alternate Reality.
...

There is a difference, but that is not the point per se. The point is that is unknown and it can't be decided by you what reality you are in. Yet some people use the one or the other belief to judge other humans.
But you can't judge any other human based on something, which is unknown, because you don't known which version is correct.

So let us look at wrong in the non-moral sense. I.e. correct and incorrect answers. A human ought to give correct answer and giving an incorrect answer makes that human wrong as in mistaken and in error. But no human can be wrong when it comes to metaphysical beliefs, because there is no way to decide which one version is the correct answer.
So a religious human can't use a belief in God to judge you, but if you do that, you can't use a belief in Natural Reality to judge a religious human, because what reality is independently of the mind is unknown other than that reality is independent of the mind.

All humans judge other humans based on different combinations of subjective biases as per reasoning, logic, evidence and emotions. There is no universal/objective/external standard for judging other humans. It is always a personal and subjective judgement including that other humans are in error and/or mistaken.
You can't observe wrong through external sensory input, you can't using an objectively calibrated instrument to measure wrong and there is no scientific theory for wrong.

A naturalist to a supernaturalist: You are wrong (non-moral sense).
In reverse: No, you are wrong.
The joke is that they are both irrational, because they claim something without reasoning, logic and evidence.

So nobody holds in practice Objective Authority over any other humans, when it comes to judgement and evaluation of worth, because it is always subjective.

I don't want anything from you, other than if you claim that you know that other human can be wrong in the non-moral sense, that you give evidence for that. But if you are a general skeptic, you know that is not possible. I accept you anyway as a human regardless of what you think/believe/feel. I am just pointing out that you are not wrong just because somebody claims that. But that also works the same way in the other direction. :)

With regard
 
There is a difference, but that is not the point per se. The point is that is unknown and it can't be decided by you what reality you are in. Yet some people use the one or the other belief to judge other humans.
But you can't judge any other human based on something, which is unknown, because you don't known which version is correct.

So let us look at wrong in the non-moral sense. I.e. correct and incorrect answers. A human ought to give correct answer and giving an incorrect answer makes that human wrong as in mistaken and in error. But no human can be wrong when it comes to metaphysical beliefs, because there is no way to decide which one version is the correct answer.
So a religious human can't use a belief in God to judge you, but if you do that, you can't use a belief in Natural Reality to judge a religious human, because what reality is independently of the mind is unknown other than that reality is independent of the mind.

All humans judge other humans based on different combinations of subjective biases as per reasoning, logic, evidence and emotions. There is no universal/objective/external standard for judging other humans. It is always a personal and subjective judgement including that other humans are in error and/or mistaken.
You can't observe wrong through external sensory input, you can't using an objectively calibrated instrument to measure wrong and there is no scientific theory for wrong.

A naturalist to a supernaturalist: You are wrong (non-moral sense).
In reverse: No, you are wrong.
The joke is that they are both irrational, because they claim something without reasoning, logic and evidence.

So nobody holds in practice Objective Authority over any other humans, when it comes to judgement and evaluation of worth, because it is always subjective.

I don't want anything from you, other than if you claim that you know that other human can be wrong in the non-moral sense, that you give evidence for that. But if you are a general skeptic, you know that is not possible. I accept you anyway as a human regardless of what you think/believe/feel. I am just pointing out that you are not wrong just because somebody claims that. But that also works the same way in the other direction. :)

With regard

So, long story short, you're trying to reason people out of trying to reason people out of religion.

The yellow is there to highlight your use of absolutism, which is "absolutely" paralyzing when attempting to deal with that which cannot be absolutely known.

I treat my knowledge about that which cannot be absolutely known as scalar values ranging from 0 to 1.

I don't even consider your absolutism valid or worth talking about. I consider it a form of intellectual paralysis.
 
So, long story short, you're trying to reason people out of trying to reason people out of religion.

Yes, in the sense that reason is sterile and you have to combine it with emotions.


The yellow is there to highlight your use of absolutism, which is "absolutely" paralyzing when attempting to deal with that which cannot be absolutely known.

Okay, skepticism on skepticism. We can't really in principle know if I am God, therefore I am God.
In practice gravity and subjective morality/ethics are equally certain, absolute and what not, yet of course the induction problem means that tomorrow the universe will stop existing.

I treat my knowledge about that which cannot be absolutely known as scalar values ranging from 0 to 1.

Okay, nothing can be known to be absolute in the strong sense, I agree, therefore jump out from a 50th floor window and start flying. You in practice act with certainty otherwise you couldn't act. Of course sometimes you doubt, but most of the time you act with certainty or you wouldn't have a normal life. There are humans with a certain kind of brain damage, who can't act in the normal sense, because they keep doubting in effect and reconsider, because they want to be certain with reason alone. They can't say: I stop here and choose, because they continue to reason.

I don't even consider your absolutism valid or worth talking about. I consider it a form of intellectual paralysis.

You want a better world, right?!!! Then start treating everybody different from you as wrong even in the non-moral sense and point out that only you and your "we" can decide right and wrong. And then you are no different that those you oppose.
The point is that I have tried to do that with reason, logic and evidence. I failed! I figured out that reason, logic and evidence are not absolute and in practice I have to include emotions.

You want to convince other humans, right. Okay, you are human and I am a human and neither of us hold authority over each other or other humans. Wait, that is an absolute. Sorry, I hold authority over you, because I say so. ;) Right, you know that is not case. That goes the other way too.

Yes, religious humans can be dangerous, yet they are also humans and if you start treating them in effect in a derogatory way you increase the chance of you and others getting hurt. Treat them as humans, as you would like to be treated.
Do you like be called irrational or wrong? No, then don't use words, which can offend.
You believe differently that me. I accept that. I am just pointing out that all humans are humans and nobody has the upper hand on others with reason, logic and evidence when it comes to morality or what reality really is.

What religious humans do, is natural and they are humans.
We are equal as humans and different as individuals.

With regards

BTW I treat you as an equal, because you are a skeptic and ought to be able to figure out that reason, logic and evidence are not absolute and thus also not able to stand alone when it comes to morality.
 
But not all forms of irrationality is delusional. :D


I think I may have my finger on the reason why you Tommy are not getting thru to so many here. The above sentence for example is nonsensical. I will try and make a sentence that does make sense, with the words irrationality and delusional therein.

- "But not all forms of irrationality result from delusional thought."

Perhaps a clearer way to say it:

- "But not all examples of irrational thought or action result from delusion."

On the other hand you may be trying to say, it may not be delusional to see irrationality as such???

Hope this helps,

With regards,

Thor
 
Last edited:
So, long story short, you're trying to reason people out of trying to reason people out of religion.

The yellow is there to highlight your use of absolutism, which is "absolutely" paralyzing when attempting to deal with that which cannot be absolutely known.

I treat my knowledge about that which cannot be absolutely known as scalar values ranging from 0 to 1.
I don't even consider your absolutism valid or worth talking about. I consider it a form of intellectual paralysis.

I have used "intellectually sterile" and "rabbit hole" and probably could euphemistically call it "intellectual self-abuse" on this forum, but I'd go along with that term too.
 
Centering back on the subject matter of this thread, it would seem that most here agree, that trying to reason someone out of religious belief has limited success. Richard Dawkins claims some credit for turning some around from the fan mail he receives, and the rapid conversion we are seeing in the Western World now to non religious, may be to some degree as a result of his and others publications.

A recent news item in Australia dealt with the disturbing practice of religious nutters "praying the gay" out of homosexuals. Those being treated were told they were afflicted by demon possession and the remedy the expulsion thereof. The effects of this "treatment" was very harmful as reported, and I wonder in the wake of stories such as this, if the religious experience a wake up call?

Difficult to see what other weapons we have at our disposal in the fight, (the good fight), against religions.
 
Centering back on the subject matter of this thread, it would seem that most here agree, that trying to reason someone out of religious belief has limited success. Richard Dawkins claims some credit for turning some around from the fan mail he receives, and the rapid conversion we are seeing in the Western World now to non religious, may be to some degree as a result of his and others publications.

A recent news item in Australia dealt with the disturbing practice of religious nutters "praying the gay" out of homosexuals. Those being treated were told they were afflicted by demon possession and the remedy the expulsion thereof. The effects of this "treatment" was very harmful as reported, and I wonder in the wake of stories such as this, if the religious experience a wake up call?

Difficult to see what other weapons we have at our disposal in the fight, (the good fight), against religions.

Apathy and irrelevance?

My kids generation is significantly less religious than my generation. Many of my peers paid lip-service to the idea of god and and sort-of believed in god, but not so much that they'd consider it important (unlike their parents). A lot of my peers have had kids and they are the offspring of nominally Christian families, but where belief hardly plays any part - and that is also tempered with a belief in Father Christmas. Those kids aren't even bothering to say that they believe in god.
 
Difficult to see what other weapons we have at our disposal in the fight, (the good fight), against religions.
Nip it in the bud . . .

“Provide some evidence your god actually exists or even might exist. If you can’t do that, provide a method by which your god could exist. If you can’t do that, provide some reason your god should exist. If you can’t do that you’ve nothing I’m interested in even considering, because you have nothing of any substance."
 
His point is that when your material needs aren't met, the "no evidence" thing might not bother you so much.
Desperation does make people irrational.
Having needs met fosters rationality.
I think there's a countervailing dynamic also, though. Someone who is focused on survival in probably going to take a pragmatic approach to those immediate concerns, and be casually agnostic about the rest of reality. It takes a pampered mind to really indulge in woo.
 
So you think that the children in Beslan taken hostage by Chechen rebels and fearing for their lives simply weren't focused enough and instead should have taken a more pragmatic approach. to the whole thing? You need a very pampered mind to come up with an idea like that!
If you have access to health care, you go to a doctor if you get AIDS - or even if you suspect that you might be infected with HIV. But what is the approach if you don't have health care? You may find that it's an unfocussed and pampered approach, but in reality it appears to be to go see a witchdoctor.
Poverty and the absence of health care are the best (and only) way to keep witchcraft alive! Education goes a long way, but even educated people tend to resort to magical thinking when science-based medicine gives up on them.
But they're just pampered and indulging, right?!
 
Last edited:
It takes a pampered mind to really indulge in woo.

No, it doesn't. The opposite is true, actually. Religion is a crutch for the desperate, and rationality is a luxury affordable only to those who are safe.
 
Last edited:
Centering back on the subject matter of this thread, it would seem that most here agree, that trying to reason someone out of religious belief has limited success. Richard Dawkins claims some credit for turning some around from the fan mail he receives, and the rapid conversion we are seeing in the Western World now to non religious, may be to some degree as a result of his and others publications.

A recent news item in Australia dealt with the disturbing practice of religious nutters "praying the gay" out of homosexuals. Those being treated were told they were afflicted by demon possession and the remedy the expulsion thereof. The effects of this "treatment" was very harmful as reported, and I wonder in the wake of stories such as this, if the religious experience a wake up call?

Difficult to see what other weapons we have at our disposal in the fight, (the good fight), against religions.

Start reading about the methodologies and theories used by social workers when engaging with humans, which "need" to have their behavior altered.

Here is the first thing that stands out: You treat other humans with respect and acceptance of them as humans. You never claim they are wrong, using any negative labeling of them and try to build trust.

How do you think a religious human would experience reading through enough of these threads to find out that she/he is evil, crazy, delusional, irrational and so on.
Treat all humans with the acceptance that we are humans. Don't degrade them and watch out for neurotypical thinking in your own behavior.

There are no evil/wrong humans and a behavior in another human, which you don't understand, doesn't mean that the other human is like you and also doesn't understand her/his own behavior.
Check out cognitive and moral/ethical relativism. You could start with Protagoras:
"Man is the measure of all things: of the things that are, that they are, of the things that are not, that they are not."

With regard
 
No, it doesn't. The opposite is true, actually. Religion is a crutch for the desperate, and rationality is a luxury affordable only to those who are safe.
I agree, at least when it comes to the religious flavours of woo. I’m not looking forward to the day western societies become less pampered and safe as religions will surely raise their ugly heads again and many will be attracted to the “safety” and “protection” they “offer”. Death of loved ones is a great recruiter for religions. Suffering grief is hardly being pampered.
 
Last edited:
How do you think a religious human would experience reading through enough of these threads to find out that she/he is evil, crazy, delusional, irrational and so on.
They wouldn't accept they are evil, crazy, delusional, irrational and so on, any more than non-religious humans accept they are evil, wicked, inferior, sinners as religious humans claim. The former wouldn't because they're belief blinded, the latter wouldn't because they're knowledge enlightened.

Treat all humans with the acceptance that we are humans. Don't degrade them and watch out for neurotypical thinking in your own behavior.
You mean like religious humans treat non-religious humans by attempting to degrade them as above and threatening them with eternal torture and much wailing and gnashing of teeth?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom