I'd ask for evidence regarding the consensus that this is the case.
The popularity of inflation theory partly as a solution to the fine-tuning problem. Inflation theory is dominant, at the moment, and part of the reason is because it solves issues like the Flatness problem and the hugely inaccurate predictions regarding the Cosmological Constant and
Higgs Boson. I've provided a link to the flatness problem. You can look up the others.
String theory is probably the best known TOE candidate, but it's not popular anymore. The lack of results from the LHC have been devastating to it. Inflation theory leading to a large multiverse IS the leading "theory of everything". It doesn't unify QM and gravity, but if true, it explains a lot of things that have bothered cosmologists over the years.
Do you think homeopathy believers who site MDs who believe in homeopathy are on soli footing?
If the doctors are prestigious, aren't quacks, aren't getting money from it, what they're talking about is in their area of expertise, then of course it would give it a boost. Not enough to overcome the lack of results, but anytime you can get a non-crank expert to agree with you, it helps your cause. If the surgeon general said, "you know what, I think homeopathy is effective at treating cancer", the proponents would have a field day with that.
I'm not arguing that it's nutty. Even the scientists who dispute their "god or multiverse" believing peers aren't claiming it's total crackpottery on par with the antigravity weirdos.
I'm claiming the theist is on rational grounds rejecting one non-evidenced hypothesis (a sufficiently large multiverse) for another (theism). Actually, the rational position would be agnosticism, but there are plenty of scientists who believe there's a really big multiverse we're part of, so they're guilty of the same things theists are. Look up Max Tegmark.