Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

And if the universe hadn't had the exact values for these factors that it had, then it would have had different ones.

And there would be no life. That's not the situation we're in.


You are again drawing a false equivalence between the existence of human beings in the world as it exists today and the existence of an all-powerful deity.

No, I'm quoting a very well respected atheist scientist who said "It's either God or the multiverse", and I know exactly why she said that. I've tried to explain, but you're not getting it.
 
It's like a lottery: if there are enough players, it's not surprising if someone wins.

It's a certainty that somebody will win no matter how many players there are.

But if you design a lottery, and the odds of winning are a bazillion-to-one, and only one person plays, and they win the first time, then the lottery was rigged.

Nope.

If ANY number between one and bazillion is pulled in said lottery, each one was as unlikely as the other regardless of which number comes up.

Our universe can be the only number pulled out of all potential universes, and we're only here finding it amazing because it was, and it doesn't imply anything was rigged.

Would you find it metaphysically meaningful if some plague wiped out every other human on earth besides you, and you were the last person left on earth?
 
And there would be no life.

Maybe. What difference does it make?

Or maybe there would be something like life in the form of mind orbs traveling in the 6th dimension. Who knows?

No, I'm quoting a very well respected atheist scientist who said "It's either God or the multiverse", and I know exactly why she said that. I've tried to explain, but you're not getting it.

We get it but disagree. As do rather a lot of physicists, it appears.
 
It's a certainty that somebody will win no matter how many players there are.



Nope.

If ANY number between one and bazillion is pulled in said lottery, each one was as unlikely as the other regardless of which number comes up.

Our universe can be the only number pulled out of all potential universes, and we're only here finding it amazing because it was, and it doesn't imply anything was rigged.

Would you find it metaphysically meaningful if some plague wiped out every other human on earth besides you, and you were the last person left on earth?

No. A one-time lottery with astronomical odds for just you and you win? No, you would conclude it's rigged. I can show you the calculus if you like.
 
Maybe. What difference does it make?

Or maybe there would be something like life in the form of mind orbs traveling in the 6th dimension. Who knows?



We get it but disagree. As do rather a lot of physicists, it appears.

The point of the thread was to reason theists out of religion. Pretend I'm the theist. I've just quoted an atheist expert who said it's either God or the multiverse, and that the evidence for both is zilch, so both are equally possible.

What do you do to counter my argument?
 
No. A one-time lottery with astronomical odds for just you and you win? No, you would conclude it's rigged.

A lottery made for a person? I'd consider it likely.

But the universe wasn't designed for us, as far as I can tell, any more than our parents were made to make us, and their parents before them, back to the primordial soup and the big bang before that. Almost everything that has ever happened is too improbable to calculate. You can say the result of a coin flip was 50/50, but what were the chances of the coin even being flipped at that exact moment in time, or the person who flipped the coin ever having been born?
 
The point of the thread was to reason theists out of religion. Pretend I'm the theist. I've just quoted an atheist expert who said it's either God or the multiverse, and that the evidence for both is zilch, so both are equally possible.

What do you do to counter my argument?

First I'd note that a theory of everything might greatly reduce even the appearance of fine tuning, if the fundamental forces are calibrated to one another. If you randomly add or subtract large amounts of just flour from a cake recipe, you'll get something inedible, but if you exactly double it all or cut it in half, etc it's basically the same.

Secondly, I'd advise the theist to see if that atheist expert is presenting the scientific consensus on the topic, or if it's a minority opinion.
 
First I'd note that a theory of everything might greatly reduce even the appearance of fine tuning, if the fundamental forces are calibrated to one another. If you randomly add or subtract large amounts of just flour from a cake recipe, you'll get something inedible, but if you exactly double it all or cut it in half, etc it's basically the same.

And I would respond that it might or it might not, but the consensus now is that a TOE is not going to solve the fine-tuning problem. The consensus is the parameters of the physical constants could have differed. Cosmic inflation resulting in a large-enough multiverse does solve the fine-tuning problem, which is one of the reasons it's so popular at the moment (see flatness fine-tuning problem).

Secondly, I'd advise the theist to see if that atheist expert is presenting the scientific consensus on the topic, or if it's a minority opinion.

Absent a poll, and I'm not aware of one, it would become a question of competing experts, and Faber's not the only expert I could cite. Nor is she a crackpot. Nor is she a Christian with an agenda to push. Quite the opposite.

The fact that the theist can cite any valid non-theist experts that say things like "it's either god or a multiverse" puts the theist on pretty solid footing. Even if you prove it's not the consensus position, it is at least a rational position, backed up by experts.

The theist would be like a physicist who believes in the MWI interpretation of QM. It's not the consensus view, but physicists who believe in the MWI aren't considered nuts either.
 
the consensus now is that a TOE is not going to solve the fine-tuning problem

I'd ask for evidence regarding the consensus that this is the case.


The fact that the theist can cite any valid non-theist experts that say things like "it's either god or a multiverse" puts the theist on pretty solid footing.

Do you think homeopathy believers who site MDs who believe in homeopathy are on soli footing?

The theist would be like a physicist who believes in the MWI interpretation of QM. It's not the consensus view, but physicists who believe in the MWI aren't considered nuts either.

I'm not arguing that it's nutty. Even the scientists who dispute their "god or multiverse" believing peers aren't claiming it's total crackpottery on par with the antigravity weirdos.
 
The point of the thread was to reason theists out of religion. Pretend I'm the theist. I've just quoted an atheist expert who said it's either God or the multiverse, and that the evidence for both is zilch, so both are equally possible.

What do you do to counter my argument?
If there's zilch evidence for both then both are equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude either are possible. Atheist experts can be as wrong as theist experts.

I believe theists misrepresent Faber's words, as they eagerly do with Einsteins "God doesn't play dice with The Universe" quote. Seems "fine-tuning" has become the new "quantum" for theists to argue that science proves a god.
 
Last edited:
If there's zilch evidence for both then both are equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude either are possible.

Err... that's not the way it works.

Pretty much anything is possible until it's essentially proven impossible or too unlikely to worry about.
 
Err... that's not the way it works.

Pretty much anything is possible until it's essentially proven impossible or too unlikely to worry about.
If you want to believe that all dreams and fantasies are actually possible then that's your choice. But you don't have the right to impose that choice on others as if you have their agreement.

"We don't know everything that is possible" isn't the same as "Everything is possible"

ETA - What determines what is "to unlikely to worry about" other than the complete lack of some evidence that determines it's likely enough to worry about? If it's possible to prove anything is impossible then "anything is possible" is redundant. "Pretty much anything is possible" is a contradiction. "Anything is possible" means nothing can ever be impossible. It's like an omnipotent god destroying it's own omnipotence by creating an immovable mountain it can't move.
 
Last edited:
All of this is utter bollocks. In my lifetime, my country has gone from a total ban on any contraception of any sort (which gave rise to an interesting smuggling operation) to being the first country in the world to ratify SSM by popular vote. That just shows how irrelevant religion has become.
 
If you want to believe that all dreams and fantasies are actually possible then that's your choice. But you don't have the right to impose and attribute that choice on others.

"We don't know everything that is possible" isn't the same as "Everything is possible"

Err...
Lets pretend it's 1600 and we're trying to figure out what makes people sick. So far, people have proposed: hypothesis 1, hypothesis 2, and hypothesis 3.

Do we encourage people so inclined to discover whatever evidence they can, or just sit around going "so far there's zilch evidence for any then, so they're all equally improbable with no credible reason to conclude any are possible"?
 
I'd ask for evidence regarding the consensus that this is the case.

The popularity of inflation theory partly as a solution to the fine-tuning problem. Inflation theory is dominant, at the moment, and part of the reason is because it solves issues like the Flatness problem and the hugely inaccurate predictions regarding the Cosmological Constant and Higgs Boson. I've provided a link to the flatness problem. You can look up the others.

String theory is probably the best known TOE candidate, but it's not popular anymore. The lack of results from the LHC have been devastating to it. Inflation theory leading to a large multiverse IS the leading "theory of everything". It doesn't unify QM and gravity, but if true, it explains a lot of things that have bothered cosmologists over the years.



Do you think homeopathy believers who site MDs who believe in homeopathy are on soli footing?

If the doctors are prestigious, aren't quacks, aren't getting money from it, what they're talking about is in their area of expertise, then of course it would give it a boost. Not enough to overcome the lack of results, but anytime you can get a non-crank expert to agree with you, it helps your cause. If the surgeon general said, "you know what, I think homeopathy is effective at treating cancer", the proponents would have a field day with that.



I'm not arguing that it's nutty. Even the scientists who dispute their "god or multiverse" believing peers aren't claiming it's total crackpottery on par with the antigravity weirdos.

I'm claiming the theist is on rational grounds rejecting one non-evidenced hypothesis (a sufficiently large multiverse) for another (theism). Actually, the rational position would be agnosticism, but there are plenty of scientists who believe there's a really big multiverse we're part of, so they're guilty of the same things theists are. Look up Max Tegmark.
 
Last edited:
Suppose I'm to be executed, but my executioners, for some reason, have given me a small chance of survival. A random number generator will spit out a number between 1 and 100 quadrillion right before the poison hits my veins. If a 2 pops up, I get to live.

I close my eyes, wait for my imminent death...and it doesn't happen. A 2 popped up. Now, are you claiming I'm not going to question why I'm still alive? Of course I am. I'm going to naturally conclude the random number generator wasn't so random after all, and it was rigged in my favor. If you do the Bayesian calculus, the hypothesis that someone rigged things in my favor is far more likely than the "I just got lucky" one.

Suppose I'm to be executed, but my executioners, for some reason, have given me a small chance of survival. If a supernova appears in the sky in the next five minutes, I get to live.

I close my eyes, wait for my imminent death...and it doesn't happen. A supernova appeared in the sky.

Still think it was rigged?
 
Suppose I'm to be executed, but my executioners, for some reason, have given me a small chance of survival. If a supernova appears in the sky in the next five minutes, I get to live.

I close my eyes, wait for my imminent death...and it doesn't happen. A supernova appeared in the sky.

Still think it was rigged?

You can't rig a supernova. You can rig a lottery or RNG. Jesus wept.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom