Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

If you are endorsing a definition which merely talks of quote "whether or not people believe that the existence of gods can be known", then you are talking about a belief (see your own quote) and not a claimed certainty of fact.

I'm talking about exactly what the person who coined the word said:

When I reached intellectual maturity, and began to ask myself whether I was an atheist, a theist, or a pantheist; a materialist or an idealist; a Christian or a freethinker, I found that the more I learned and reflected, the less ready was the answer; until at last I came to the conclusion that I had neither art nor part with any of these denominations, except the last. The one thing in which most of these good people were agreed was the one thing in which I differed from them. They were quite sure that they had attained a certain "gnosis"--had more or less successfully solved the problem of existence; while I was quite sure I had not, and had a pretty strong conviction that the problem was insoluble. And, with Hume and Kant on my side, I could not think myself presumptuous in holding fast by that opinion ...

It describes people who are not "sure they ha[ve] attained a certain 'gnosis'".

And to repeat (3rd or 4th time) - if that definition merely says that the agnostic says that he/she does not know (or thinks it's not possible to know) whether or not any claimed supernatural god exists, then that is just exactly the case for all theists and atheists too - atheists do not "KNOW" that no such god can exist, and theists do not "KNOW" that such a God does definitely exist ...

Plenty of theists and atheists do think it's possible to know that, and say that they do. I don't know why you're claiming that they do not.

However the crucial, and quite enormous difference, is that atheists can show overwhelming and quite unarguable evidence against the existence of God. Whereas theists cannot show any genuine evidence at all for the existence of God. In that position, the beliefs of agnostics are really irrelevant, because all they are doing is adopting part of the atheist belief and part of the theist belief at the same time (it's just a bit of both ... or if you prefer - they are just saying they cannot decide strongly in either direction, neither strongly towards theism or strongly towards atheism).

Whether you find certain beliefs to be true or not, and whether you think people who hold them are relevant or not, does't affect what the words describing people who hold those beliefs mean.
 
This thread asks whether theists can be reasoned out of their belief in god(s). It has nothing to do with defining words relating to atheism. Anyone wanting to debate definitions of words relating to atheism should start their own thread for that purpose and stop derailing this one. In fact I’ve just started a thread for that very purpose - HERE (you’re welcome).

Also started a thread to debate "agnostic" HERE
 
Last edited:
I'm talking about exactly what the person who coined the word said:



It describes people who are not "sure they ha[ve] attained a certain 'gnosis'".



Plenty of theists and atheists do think it's possible to know that, and say that they do. I don't know why you're claiming that they do not.



Whether you find certain beliefs to be true or not, and whether you think people who hold them are relevant or not, does't affect what the words describing people who hold those beliefs mean.

I already provided a link to how "agnostic" is commonly used:

"Nowadays, the term “agnostic” is often used (when the issue is God’s existence) to refer to those who follow the recommendation expressed in the conclusion of Huxley’s argument: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false."
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAgno

Agnostics are people who aren't sure.

There might be agnostics "who hold the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknown and probably unknowable", but I've never met one, and it would be interesting to talk to some here, if there are any. That definition sounds a lot like solipsism.
 
The old "you can put whatever meaning you like on a word" crap. So a word, even as simple as the word atheist, is tripped over. If people just put whatever meaning they like on words, how are we going to have any sort of productive discussion?
The old "everybody else's definition is just plain wrong, and I am right, so I don't understand why they have a problem" crap.
 
What a mania of yours! Between metaphysics and science and between absolute certainty and absolute subjectivity there are degrees! If you put the question in black and white terms, you will end up justifying anything.
But it is black and white, as per my definitions I gave from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.

Those are obviously contradictory statements. Anyway, I agree with the explanations given already. (A) People can look at the same data, and come to different conclusions. (B) Eventually a metaphysical component is required.
 
The RCCs god can be found defined in their creed and Bible, the CofE God in their creed and Bible and so on.

I don't know what RCC and CofE are. Anyway, the Bible's god is the god of the Bible. There are other uses of the word "god".
All we need to know in a discussion is how participants use the word.

You, for example, what do you understand when someone says "god"?
 
But it is black and white, as per my definitions I gave from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.

Those are obviously contradictory statements. Anyway, I agree with the explanations given already. (A) People can look at the same data, and come to different conclusions. (B) Eventually a metaphysical component is required.
My last attempt:
Why the "hard" atheism? Is there a "soft" atheism? Is there a "hard" agnosticism? How many types of atheism are classifiable? Only "soft" and "hard"? What makes one classification better than another? What about Dawkins' classification?
To your questions:
(A) Yes. They may differ in the interpretation of these facts. (B) No. A metaphysics is not necessary.
 
Last edited:
My last attempt:
Why the "hard" atheism?
I'll do you one better. Why is Gamora? :)

I gave the definition of "hard atheism" from Wiki. I gave the link earlier as well. Here it is again: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism

Why did I use "hard atheism" in my question? Because it explicitly conflicts with agnosticism, as per the definitions. If both are coming from the same metaphysical standpoint of naturalism, then I wondered how they could conflict, and whether one could be reasoned from one to the other. The answer seems to be that, even though both could be grounded in naturalism, the data is still being evaluated from a subjective experience.

Since I've explained all this earlier, I'll make the above my last attempt to explain this to you.

Is there a "soft" atheism?
Yes. See Wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism

Is there a "hard" agnosticism?
Not that I know about.
 
Last edited:
My last attempt:
Why the "hard" atheism? Is there a "soft" atheism? Is there a "hard" agnosticism? How many types of atheism are classifiable? Only "soft" and "hard"? What makes one classification better than another? What about Dawkins' classification?
To your questions:
(A) Yes. They may differ in the interpretation of these facts. (B) No. A metaphysics is not necessary.

"Hard" agnosticism is in a sense a variant of skepticism. Namely that for knowledge as a justified belief, there is no justification possible.

So here to compare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_of_theistic_probability Dawkins combines science and knowledge. It is possible to claim that science and knowledge are not the same.
So hard agnosticism is the claim that it is unknowable whether there are god(s) or not. I.e. all the probabilities Dawkins list are not knowledge but unjustified beliefs. And thus a hard agnostic is not 50/50, but "it is unknowable if there are any gods and it is not possible to assign any probability as knowledge".

That leads to a contradiction between
Hard atheist: I know that there are no gods. (That is a hard gnostic BTW)
Hard agnostic: It is unknowable if there are any gods.
The contradiction is that is knowable and unknowable!

I am a hard agnostic and Dawkins' list doesn't apply to me, because I don't give a probability for the existence of any gods. I don't make any positive claim of knowledge/probability about the existence of any gods.

With regard
 
I'm talking about exactly what the person who coined the word said:



It describes people who are not "sure they ha[ve] attained a certain 'gnosis'".



Plenty of theists and atheists do think it's possible to know that, and say that they do. I don't know why you're claiming that they do not.

Whether you find certain beliefs to be true or not, and whether you think people who hold them are relevant or not, does't affect what the words describing people who hold those beliefs mean.


If you merely "think" you know something, then that is only a belief or opinion (and I have explained that in detail at least half a dozen times already). To say "I think it's possible to know that God does or does not exist", is totally different from saying "I do know that God does or does not exist".

This is just a very simple matter of correct use of English language. If you say "I know that A is true", then you are claiming it to be an absolute fact (not merely your own belief), which means you must be able to show a proof of certainty (if you cannot produce that absolute proof, then you were wrong ever to claim that you knew the "fact" for "certain").

IOW - what you have written here is constantly talking about peoples individual belief ... you are not actually talking about "fact".

As should be obvious (because I have said it several times), I think the likelihood of God existing, is almost zero (e.g.. not just a 6.9 out of 7 on Dawkins scale but 6.9999...999..), BUT if I then said "I know" that God does not exist then that would be a total mistake and worthless statement for me, unless of course I can give an unassailable proof of nonexistence (and neither I nor anyone else has ever produced any such literal absolute proof against God ... and indeed it seems likely that nobody ever will be able to produce that sort of actual proof, because it seems to be the sort of claim that is not open to a proof either way).

I can show a huge mass of evidence against God. And I can make an extremely convincing objective argument which appears to be difficult to honestly argue against ... but none of that is actually a proof ... and without a proof the most any of us can honestly and accurately say is that we do not believe the claimed God exists.
 
Last edited:
I am a hard agnostic and Dawkins' list doesn't apply to me, because I don't give a probability for the existence of any gods. I don't make any positive claim of knowledge/probability about the existence of any gods.

With regard
Hard agnostic theist or atheist?
 
Last edited:
I already provided a link to how "agnostic" is commonly used:

"Nowadays, the term “agnostic” is often used (when the issue is God’s existence) to refer to those who follow the recommendation expressed in the conclusion of Huxley’s argument: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false."
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAgno

Agnostics are people who aren't sure.

I don't think you read beyond the part you quoted. Not even the rest of the paragraph, I'd wager.

There might be agnostics "who hold the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknown and probably unknowable", but I've never met one, and it would be interesting to talk to some here, if there are any.

Hello.

That definition sounds a lot like solipsism.

I agree.
 
I'm not sure that's actually true.

Karen Armstrong's A History Of God is a very well-researched book which details how the Judeo-Christian God evolved (primarily) out of the Caananite god of war Yahweh, and how Judaism evolved out of that pantheistic religion. Armstrong was a nun, and had no agenda in writing the book, and it is noted for the thoroughness and depth of her research. In other words, even religious scholars don't question that the story she tells of the evolution of Christianity and the concept of the Judeo-Christian God is accurate. Yet many of those scholars remain Christians.


I haven't read her book, but based on your description I don't see how it contradicts what I said: "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists."
When you begin to believe in any kind of god, you start with what you've heard, seen or experienced in other ways. You may base your god simply on the stories your parents tell you, you may pick up a Bible and start adding bits and pieces to your idea of god, or you can invent one on the spot like when the boy deified Harry Potter in Beslan. Basing a new god on a former version is how it often happens. Muhammad did that, and so did Luther and Joseph Smith.
Anyway, a god is always customized to the individual needs of the believer: igod.
 
Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.

Those are obviously contradictory statements.

No, they're not.

It's possible to accept a certain conclusion as true while still conceding a degree of uncertainty about that conclusion. For example, I believe that Pythagoras existed. But given that the vast majority of accounts of his life come from long after it had ended, are contradictory, and that even contemporaneous accounts are mixed with obvious myths and legends, I have to concede that maybe he didn't or, at the very least, that the image we have of him may well be entirely false. That doesn't mean that I don't think that there's enough good evidence that I'm not happy to say that he existed and was how he's characterised - I do think he existed, and I think he was how he is characterised. But I might be wrong, and I recognise that I might be wrong.
 
What about Dawkins' classification?

Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)? Why doesn't it account for people who may believe in more than one religion? Why doesn't it account for the differences between people who vaguely believe in the Christian God and those who vaguely believe in a general "something" up there? And so on.

Perhaps it would help if you'd outline what you believe the perfect system of categorisation to be? One that is free from the criticism of being too strict that you're levelling at other systems?
 
If you merely "think" you know something, then that is only a belief or opinion (and I have explained that in detail at least half a dozen times already). To say "I think it's possible to know that God does or does not exist", is totally different from saying "I do know that God does or does not exist".

Not to the person who has that certainty.

This is just a very simple matter of correct use of English language. If you say "I know that A is true", then you are claiming it to be an absolute fact (not merely your own belief), which means you must be able to show a proof of certainty (if you cannot produce that absolute proof, then you were wrong ever to claim that you knew the "fact" for "certain").

The first part of the sentence is correct. And that's who we're talking about. People who claim it for an absolute fact. That they may be wrong about this is irrelevant. That their standards of "absolute proof" may not meet yours is irrelevant. It's the fact that they will claim it that the word describes.
 
I haven't read her book, but based on your description I don't see how it contradicts what I said: "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists."
When you begin to believe in any kind of god, you start with what you've heard, seen or experienced in other ways. You may base your god simply on the stories your parents tell you, you may pick up a Bible and start adding bits and pieces to your idea of god, or you can invent one on the spot like when the boy deified Harry Potter in Beslan. Basing a new god on a former version is how it often happens. Muhammad did that, and so did Luther and Joseph Smith.
Anyway, a god is always customized to the individual needs of the believer: igod.

You said that it was impossible to remain a believer once you'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". I gave you anecdotal examples of people who had remained a believer once they'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". That's what contradicts your assertion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom