Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

But it is black and white, as per my definitions I gave from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.

Those are obviously contradictory statements. Anyway, I agree with the explanations given already. (A) People can look at the same data, and come to different conclusions. (B) Eventually a metaphysical component is required.


Your first definition (of "agnosticism") is actually stated there only as an opinion, i.e. a belief - it begins by saying "it is the view of agnostics that ....", their "view" is only an opinion, i.e. a belief, it's not claimed there to be a literal certainty or "Fact".

You second definition is more confused and deliberately uses a word that can imply either a claim of fact or else imply merely a claim of personal opinion/belief. That is - your definition of "hard atheism" begins "hard atheists assert that ...", ... an assertion may be a claim of asserting fact, or just an assertion of the persons opinion or belief ... the word "asserts" is imprecise, ambiguous and misleading as used there.

But why do you care whether or not the opinion of agnostics is the same as the opinion of atheists? You are saying they are clearly in contradiction (i.e. the wording of your two definitions above), but the whole point of having two different descriptive terms (agnostic vs atheist) is to show that the beliefs are different! An atheist does not believe the God exists vs. an agnostic who has no strong view either way. And of course theists take a third view - they believe the God does exist.

You seem to be constantly (in all your posts in this thread) scrabbling around to find some sort of problem with definitions of atheism or agnosticism, seemingly to defend your own belief in theism & God. But you are not making any sense when you keep writing things like that ... you are constantly writing things that are misconceived and illogical, and very obviously so. For example - you do not need any of the above, or any of what you have said about "inconsistent definitions" ... because what you were asking about, and what the thread asks about, is whether it's possible to "reason" people out of any particular belief (such as God belief), and the answer is very obviously and unarguably "Yes", of course people are reasoned out of such beliefs all the time ...

... of course, religious beliefs are something that people are extremely unwilling ever to be reasoned out of, no matter how enormous the evidence against them is, and no matter how absurd and untrue their own claimed evidence is for the God. But that happens for cultural and social reasons that have lasted within the religion for thousands of years and where the faithful still surround themselves with & immerse themselves in that same cultural/social existence today, and in that situation it's typically very hard to dissuade believers, no matter how much evidence you show them ... they are believing upon "Faith" & deliberately surrounding themselves with that faith to make themselves immune to (or exclude) any honest rational argument, evidence or discussion.
 
Last edited:
Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)? Why doesn't it account for people who may believe in more than one religion? Why doesn't it account for the differences between people who vaguely believe in the Christian God and those who vaguely believe in a general "something" up there? And so on.


Because that's one thing that Dawkins and other hard-core atheists have in common with believers: They all have a hard time understanding that a lot of us just don't give a damn! On the one hand, we don't believe in God(s), but on the other hand, we don't think it's a big deal. Zealous atheism is so twentieth century! Many of us have moved on!

Unlike Dawkins, Zuckerman has actually studied the phenomenon. Here are a couple of facts:

Denmark is said to be 72% irreligious and atheist: List of religious populations: Irreligious and atheist (Wikipedia)
Yet 76% of the population are members of the state church.
 
You said that it was impossible to remain a believer once you'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". I gave you anecdotal examples of people who had remained a believer once they'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". That's what contradicts your assertion.


I don't think that's what you have given me. You gave me anecdotal examples of religious people who had seen and understood that the idea of God evolves. That doesn't prevent them from believing that an actual god is somehow hidden behind all these different ideas. I guess they rationalize that the guys who believed in the God of War were ill-informed and didn't understand how loving and forgiving etc. the real Christian God is, the one and only ...
 
Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)? Why doesn't it account for people who may believe in more than one religion? Why doesn't it account for the differences between people who vaguely believe in the Christian God and those who vaguely believe in a general "something" up there? And so on.

Perhaps it would help if you'd outline what you believe the perfect system of categorisation to be? One that is free from the criticism of being too strict that you're levelling at other systems?

Dawkins says that the separation between atheism and theism is a continuum, but considers that the seven categories satisfy the condition of representing the seven main positions (The God Delusion, p. 74). It also considers the possibility of distinguishing between a `practical' agnosticism —the one you say that does not think about the subject— and an agnosticism "by principle" or reasoned.

In my opinion, this classification fits well when we are simply concerned to defining the positions that can be given in general. Other discussions would force further distinctions to be made. For example, the one you propose between believing in this or that religion. But here I do not find them useful because we are seeking to clarify the intermediate positions between atheism and theism in general and whether one believes in Vishnu or Allah does not change much the definition of someone as a theist.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that's what you have given me. You gave me anecdotal examples of religious people who had seen and understood that the idea of God evolves. That doesn't prevent them from believing that an actual god is somehow hidden behind all these different ideas. I guess they rationalize that the guys who believed in the God of War were ill-informed and didn't understand how loving and forgiving etc. the real Christian God is, the one and only ...

Yes, I said they rationalised it away. If your statement was simply "people who see that God is a man-made construct and don't rationalise that away in order to maintain their beliefs cease to believe in God", then it's tautologous.
 
Dawkins says that the separation between atheism and theism is a continuum, but considers that the seven categories satisfy the condition of representing the seven main positions (The God Delusion, p. 74). It also considers the possibility of distinguishing between a `practical' agnosticism —the one you say that does not think about the subject— and an agnosticism "by principle" or reasoned.

In my opinion, this classification fits well when we are simply concerned to defining the positions that can be given in general. Other discussions would force further distinctions to be made. For example, the one you propose between believing in this or that religion. But here I do not find them useful because we are seeking to clarify the intermediate positions between atheism and theism in general and whether one believes in Vishnu or Allah does not change much the definition of someone as a theist.

You haven't really answered any of my questions. Even the attempt in your last sentence answers a different question to the ones I actually asked.
 
Yes, I said they rationalised it away. If your statement was simply "people who see that God is a man-made construct and don't rationalise that away in order to maintain their beliefs cease to believe in God", then it's tautologous.


It isn't! They think that God (the 'actual' one) was misunderstood by pre-Christians, which doesn't make him "a man-made construct."
 
I don't know what RCC and CofE are. Anyway, the Bible's god is the god of the Bible. There are other uses of the word "god".
All we need to know in a discussion is how participants use the word.

RCC - Roman Catholic Church
CofE - Church Of England

You, for example, what do you understand when someone says "god"?

I don't unless they tell me.
 
Because that's one thing that Dawkins and other hard-core atheists have in common with believers: They all have a hard time understanding that a lot of us just don't give a damn! On the one hand, we don't believe in God(s), but on the other hand, we don't think it's a big deal. Zealous atheism is so twentieth century! Many of us have moved on!
"Ignostic."

Agnostic is when you don't know.
Ignostic is when you don't care.
 
It isn't! They think that God (the 'actual' one) was misunderstood by pre-Christians, which doesn't make him "a man-made construct."

Again, you're saying "if someone finds out that God is a man-made construct but continues to believe that God is not a man-made construct, then they will not believe that God is a man-made construct". That is tautologous.
 
"Ignostic."

Agnostic is when you don't know.
Ignostic is when you don't care.

I am an atheist, because I lack beliefs in any gods.
I am an agnostic, because I don't know if there are any gods and I hold it to be unknowable.
I am an ignostic, because I don't care if a human is religious or not.
 
You haven't really answered any of my questions. Even the attempt in your last sentence answers a different question to the ones I actually asked.

I didn't answer in my comment?

In my opinion, this classification fits well when we are simply concerned to defining the positions that can be given in general. Other discussions would force further distinctions to be made. For example, the one you propose between believing in this or that religion. But here I do not find them useful because we are seeking to clarify the intermediate positions between atheism and theism in general and whether one believes in Vishnu or Allah does not change much the definition of someone as a theist.​

More on this subject in other comment of mine.
 
Last edited:
Again, you're saying "if someone finds out that God is a man-made construct but continues to believe that God is not a man-made construct, then they will not believe that God is a man-made construct". That is tautologous.


Yes, that is tautologous, but it's also a strawman since it's not what I'm saying.
 
I just found this comment from Phil Zuckerman:

Zuckerman has said that 20% of the United States are irreligious, and 30% of citizens under 30 are. Zuckerman has commented that religion is often conflated with patriotism in the United States. He has stated that while "he applauds the passion and purpose" of American Atheists, they are a minority, as the majority of atheists in America "are not angry, do not hate religion and do not need a forum to vent".Phil Zuckerman: Public commentary (Wikipedia)


ETA: I've already recommended this book by Phil Zuckerman: Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us about Contentment (2010)
I just noticed this one: The Nonreligious: Understandng Secular People and Societies (2016)
 
Last edited:
GDon said:
Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.

Those are obviously contradictory statements.
No, they're not.
Well, yes they are. "I don't know" vs "Yes is false" are contradictory.

It's possible to accept a certain conclusion as true while still conceding a degree of uncertainty about that conclusion.
"'At least one deity exists' is a false statement" does not concede a degree of uncertainty. I am comparing agnosticism with hard atheism, as per the definitions given. I'm not sure what you are referring to. What degree of uncertainty do you give to the statement "X is false"?
 
Last edited:
Your first definition (of "agnosticism") is actually stated there only as an opinion, i.e. a belief - it begins by saying "it is the view of agnostics that ....", their "view" is only an opinion, i.e. a belief, it's not claimed there to be a literal certainty or "Fact".
Those aren't my definitions. I'm pulling them from Wiki. If you want to say that you disagree with those definitions, then fine. This conversation can't continue, since we need to agree on definitions before being able to argue on them.

But why do you care whether or not the opinion of agnostics is the same as the opinion of atheists?
Reminder: the opinion of "hard atheists". Not the opinion of atheists. See the definitions I give from Wiki.

You are saying they are clearly in contradiction (i.e. the wording of your two definitions above), but the whole point of having two different descriptive terms (agnostic vs atheist) is to show that the beliefs are different!
WHY are they different, was my question. If two people examined the circumference of the earth, and came to different conclusions, you would ask "why the difference"? What is the set of data that both are using? Seems an obvious question. But I'm happy with the answers given: agnostics and hard atheists are working from incomplete data. Neither can justify their views to the other. One can't reason their way to the other view without making some kind of metaphysical leap.
 
Well, yes they are. "I don't know" vs "Yes is false" are contradictory.


"'At least one deity exists' is a false statement" does not concede a degree of uncertainty. I am comparing agnosticism with hard atheism, as per the definitions given. I'm not sure what you are referring to.

So of my fellow atheists are not 100% certain whether there is at least one deity or not, and they disregard 100% certain atheists, who know there are no gods versus 100% certain agnostics, who hold it impossible to know if there are any gods or not.

With regard
 
So of my fellow atheists are not 100% certain whether there is at least one deity or not, and they disregard 100% certain atheists, who know there are no gods versus 100% certain agnostics, who hold it impossible to know if there are any gods or not.
Remember, I am contrasting agnostics with hard atheists, as per the definitions I gave from Wiki. They are contrary positions. Both can't be right, though both can be wrong. (Yay, Team Theist!)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom