Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I can see you are not interested in a discussion so I'll leave your unsupported claim as it is.

That's a bit rich. Your reason for not reading my answer last time is that you couldn't be bothered to pay attention after having asked the question. Now the fact that I'm not jumping through hoops in order to answer your question for the second time means that I'm the one who's not interested in discussion?

If you're truly interested in the answer, then the onus is on you to pay attention to the answer when you ask the question. If you do not pay attention to the answer, then the onus is on you to do the legwork to find it.

As it is, the very fact that you didn't pay attention to the answer rather indicates to me that you're not interested in a discussion, and that instead this question is some kind of thoughtless, knee-jerk attempt at a "gotcha". And that I certainly have no interest in.

Reply to my already-given answer, and then I'll see if I'm interested in a discussion about it. But, no, I'm not going to bend over backwards to facilitate this conversation just because you couldn't be arsed the first time around.

And I'm certainly not going to do so just because you are calling me out for making an "unsupported claim". I'm not 12.
 
Well, yes of course. But is that information out there now for the agnostic? If the information is objective and based in empiricism, why are there agnostics? Is it just a matter of making them aware of that information?

And if the information is not out there, why are there hard atheists? Why aren't they agnostics, if the information isn't there? Or is it subjective, a matter of opinion? If so, then why claim agnosticism and/or atheism is based in empiricism?


The same information is "out there" for all of us. The discoveries of science for example, are not secret!

But whilst scientifically educated atheists invariably find the explanations of science extremely convincing and persuasive against belief in any supernatural creator, many agnostics and theists very clearly are not at all well educated in science, and that is quite clearly a major reason why they believe that God is likely to exist ... i.e. because they do not understand how and why science shows that the God almost certainly should not exist.

But to ask “why are their hard atheists if the information is not out there”, is obviously an entirely misplaced (not to say naive) question – the information as to why you should believe that the God almost certainly does not exist, is “out there” and it's abundant … in fact all of us are positively drowning in all of that information all day long.

Also … why bring up notions of something called “empiricism”? That's the sort of word/term that you will see used a lot amongst philosophers, but rarely if ever by anyone else. It just confuses and distorts the issue to constantly talk in unusual terms like that. It's almost always better to talk/write in the simplest terms that you can; that way everyone can be clear what is being said. However, when you ask “is it subjective, a matter of opinion? If so, then why claim agnosticism and/or atheism is based in empiricism?” … yes of course belief (or otherwise) in God is a matter of opinion; but for atheists, and certainly for scientists & others whose atheism is often based largely on what they have understood from science, their belief/opinion comes from a logical, objective, honest view of the evidence (in contrast to theists who are ignoring the evidence, or who fail to understand or even be aware of the evidence, or more often who actually just flatly deny the science).
 
Last edited:
No, not really. (Apart from the fact that Ego Death seems to be all about "the mystical nonsense.") It was more like unconsciousness (Wiki) - except that I didn't wake up on the floor but remained standing, which makes me assume that it can't have lasted more than a fraction of a second. To stay in the analogy: like switching a computer off and on again. I was also surrounded by people doing stretching exercises after dancing classes, and nobody noticed anything.

It was the way you talked about not knowing who or what you were that make me think of Ego Death.
 
You're free to think these people are wrong and that it would be a waste of time debating them. That doesn't mean that they don't exist, or that the words used to describe them don't describe them.


Oh, I don't doubt that these people exist, and that certain people will say almost anything. Some people claim they have met space aliens and been transported to Venus, and they say it's an absolute fact. But if you claim to know as an absolute certainty that God cannot possibly exist, without being able to prove it, then your claims really don't have a leg to stand upon.

Well, if the "word" used to describe them is "atheist", then we all know what it means. It means they do not believe the god exists. And if the word is "theist" then that is equally clear - it means they do believe the god exists. Anything else is a grey area in-between where many individuals say they have no clear opinion on what they should believe about God.
 
Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Agnostic theist: I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists.

That didn't answer my question, and there's nothing in the definitions I gave that excludes degrees of knowledge.

Excuse me but if you put in the same sack (category) those that are almost sure of a belief and some that have a slight hint in favour of this belief, you are making a mess. You can do so in abstract but these categories would be irrelevant when members of the same category — your category— turn out to be in strong disagreement.

Because whatever you call it, a person who is almost certain (99%) of a proposition is much more like one who is 100% sure than one who only recognizes a slight hint. The latter would be closer to the one who does not manifest himself in one sense or another. Above all, it is going to be difficult to find someone who is absolutely certain that God does not exist in certain areas, such as the existence of God.

That is why I think that your classification is insufficiently nuanced. And so I think it can be more confusing than clarifying the problem.

It's a start of a definition but again I'll point you back to the word "god" as it is used by the majority of those in the world that believe a god/s exist - their gods are defined by their religions.

I'm not sure how most people use the word "god". I would feel more comfortable if we talked about its use in Western culture, which would be more or less like this:
(a) The Being perfect in power, wisdom, and goodness who is worshipped as creator and ruler of the universe.
If you want something more comprehensive:
(b) a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship
But it would be better to talk about what we in the debate mean by god' than to pretend to speak through the mouths of the majority.

Part of the problem with involving "certainty" or especially "absolute certainty" is that religion constantly pushes its people to be utterly absolutely certain, which creates an incentive for them to claim they are even if they aren't... while the kind of approach that many atheists use does the opposite, treating doubt as a good thing and incentivizing them to overemphasize even a minuscule speck of doubt on principle.
You may be right, but perhaps it would be useful to leave a space for those who defend their atheism as an unarguable dogma. There are also some, even if they are less than the theists.
 
Oh, I don't doubt that these people exist, and that certain people will say almost anything. Some people claim they have met space aliens and been transported to Venus, and they say it's an absolute fact. But if you claim to know as an absolute certainty that God cannot possibly exist, without being able to prove it, then your claims really don't have a leg to stand upon.

Which is all utterly irrelevant to the definition of the word "agnostic".

Well, if the "word" used to describe them is "atheist", then we all know what it means. It means they do not believe the god exists. And if the word is "theist" then that is equally clear - it means they do believe the god exists.

Gods, actually.

Anything else is a grey area in-between where many individuals say they have no clear opinion on what they should believe about God.

Well, I'm not sure how many people would claim to have absolutely no idea whether or not any gods exist. But, again, this doesn't really address what we were talking about.

Perhaps etymology might be a better direction to approach this from?

https://www.etymonline.com/word/agnostic

1870, "one who professes that the existence of a First Cause and the essential nature of things are not and cannot be known" [Klein]; coined by T.H. Huxley, supposedly in September 1869, from Greek agnostos "unknown, unknowable," from a- "not" (see a- (3)) + gnostos "(to be) known," from PIE root *gno- "to know." Sometimes said to be a reference to Paul's mention of the altar to "the Unknown God" in Acts, but according to Huxley it was coined with reference to the early Church movement known as Gnosticism (see Gnostic). The adjective also is first recorded 1870.

I ... invented what I conceived to be the appropriate title of 'agnostic,' ... antithetic to the 'Gnostic' of Church history who professed to know so much about the very things of which I was ignorant. [T.H. Huxley, "Science and Christian Tradition," 1889]

The agnostic does not simply say, "I do not know." He goes another step, and he says, with great emphasis, that you do not know. [Robert G. Ingersoll, "Reply to Dr. Lyman Abbott," 1890]

The word is concerned with whether or not people believe that the existence of gods can be known. There's more of Huxley's words on the subject on this page.
 
It was the way you talked about not knowing who or what you were that make me think of Ego Death.


I see your point, but it was not knowing anything. And the point in this context: Unlike Descartes, I wasn't really concerned about being. That was the first and only obvious thing I knew, but my location was my immediate concern and not like when you wake up in a new place and at first don't remember where you are, but in a much more urgent way: I think, so where the hell am I?! :)
 
Excuse me but if you put in the same sack (category) those that are almost sure of a belief and some that have a slight hint in favour of this belief, you are making a mess. You can do so in abstract but these categories would be irrelevant when members of the same category — your category— turn out to be in strong disagreement.

You can subdivide categories as much as you like. Ultimately, you'll be very unlikely to find two people who agree 100% on any given subject, so you can divide your categories up into as many subcategories as there are people.

Because whatever you call it, a person who is almost certain (99%) of a proposition is much more like one who is 100% sure than one who only recognizes a slight hint.

Well, it wasn't me who coined the word. I'm just discussing what it means.

Above all, it is going to be difficult to find someone who is absolutely certain that God does not exist in certain areas, such as the existence of God.

I don't understand this sentence.

That is why I think that your classification is insufficiently nuanced.

As I have said, you can add as much nuance as you wish. What you're doing is the equivalent of saying that the word "mammal" is "confusing" because a large number of species fall within that categorisation.
 
Part of the problem with involving "certainty" or especially "absolute certainty" is that religion constantly pushes its people to be utterly absolutely certain, which creates an incentive for them to claim they are even if they aren't... while the kind of approach that many atheists use does the opposite, treating doubt as a good thing and incentivizing them to overemphasize even a minuscule speck of doubt on principle.


I think that's about right (and nicely explained). Even if the last three lines may be aimed as a criticism of what I have said here, i.e. "overemphasising even a minuscule spec of doubt on principle".

But I think that if people here believe I have overemphasised the doubt, then they are probably wrong to think that. For example, if I am asked to say how improbable I think God is, then I'd say that upon current evidence it seems to me that his probability is very, very close to zero.
 
I think that's about right (and nicely explained). Even if the last three lines may be aimed as a criticism of what I have said here, i.e. "overemphasising even a minuscule spec of doubt on principle".

But I think that if people here believe I have overemphasised the doubt, then they are probably wrong to think that. For example, if I am asked to say how improbable I think God is, then I'd say that upon current evidence it seems to me that his probability is very, very close to zero.

https://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/whatisscience_12

Science doesn't draw conclusions about supernatural explanations
 
That's a bit rich. Your reason for not reading my answer last time is that you couldn't be bothered to pay attention after having asked the question. Now the fact that I'm not jumping through hoops in order to answer your question for the second time means that I'm the one who's not interested in discussion?

If you're truly interested in the answer, then the onus is on you to pay attention to the answer when you ask the question. If you do not pay attention to the answer, then the onus is on you to do the legwork to find it.

As it is, the very fact that you didn't pay attention to the answer rather indicates to me that you're not interested in a discussion, and that instead this question is some kind of thoughtless, knee-jerk attempt at a "gotcha". And that I certainly have no interest in.

Reply to my already-given answer, and then I'll see if I'm interested in a discussion about it. But, no, I'm not going to bend over backwards to facilitate this conversation just because you couldn't be arsed the first time around.

And I'm certainly not going to do so just because you are calling me out for making an "unsupported claim". I'm not 12.
That you persist in your erroneous claim rather than going back and checking your recollection (which will show you that you are misremembering) is what indicates to me you are not wanting to have a discussion.
 
Excuse me but if you put in the same sack (category) those that are almost sure of a belief and some that have a slight hint in favour of this belief, you are making a mess. You can do so in abstract but these categories would be irrelevant when members of the same category — your category— turn out to be in strong disagreement.

Because whatever you call it, a person who is almost certain (99%) of a proposition is much more like one who is 100% sure than one who only recognizes a slight hint. The latter would be closer to the one who does not manifest himself in one sense or another. Above all, it is going to be difficult to find someone who is absolutely certain that God does not exist in certain areas, such as the existence of God.

That is why I think that your classification is insufficiently nuanced. And so I think it can be more confusing than clarifying the problem.



I'm not sure how most people use the word "god". I would feel more comfortable if we talked about its use in Western culture, which would be more or less like this:
(a) The Being perfect in power, wisdom, and goodness who is worshipped as creator and ruler of the universe.
If you want something more comprehensive:
(b) a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship
But it would be better to talk about what we in the debate mean by god' than to pretend to speak through the mouths of the majority.


You may be right, but perhaps it would be useful to leave a space for those who defend their atheism as an unarguable dogma. There are also some, even if they are less than the theists.
I use the definition the religious use for "god" I really don't see any sense in discussing whether a "god" no theist believes in exists.
 
I use the definition the religious use for "god" I really don't see any sense in discussing whether a "god" no theist believes in exists.

The religious use? What is it? Something as this?:

(a) The Being perfect in power, wisdom, and goodness who is worshipped as creator and ruler of the universe.

Or:
(b) a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship
 
That you persist in your erroneous claim rather than going back and checking your recollection (which will show you that you are misremembering) is what indicates to me you are not wanting to have a discussion.

I'm not playing your silly game.
 
The religious use? What is it? Something as this?:

(a) The Being perfect in power, wisdom, and goodness who is worshipped as creator and ruler of the universe.

Or:
(b) a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship
The RCCs god can be found defined in their creed and Bible, the CofE God in their creed and Bible and so on.
 
As soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world.
It's similar to when you meet people who claim to be Jesus Christ or Napoleon: You know that they're delusional, so you don't begin to consider if there might be slight resemblances between those guys and the paintings you've seen of J.C. and the French general/emperor.
It's not that we cannot be sure if there is a god or not. We actually know both that there is and what it is!
 
As soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world.

I'm not sure that's actually true.

Karen Armstrong's A History Of God is a very well-researched book which details how the Judeo-Christian God evolved (primarily) out of the Caananite god of war Yahweh, and how Judaism evolved out of that pantheistic religion. Armstrong was a nun, and had no agenda in writing the book, and it is noted for the thoroughness and depth of her research. In other words, even religious scholars don't question that the story she tells of the evolution of Christianity and the concept of the Judeo-Christian God is accurate. Yet many of those scholars remain Christians.

Anecdotally, I've heard from more than one source who has been to seminary school that this story, if not Armstrong's book itself, is taught there and that the students are given time after learning of this history to come to terms with it and reconcile it with their own faith. Many do.

So there you have people who have learnt that the God they believe in isn't a real being but is instead a construct created by humans which was created from an older, pantheistic religion - who then choose to carry on believing in that deity anyway, or who manage to rationalise some way to do so.

I suppose it's not that different to people who get taken in by fake cancer cures, or ponzi schemes, or the like. Once you've invested that much in something then it's easier psychologically speaking to rationalise away evidence that your beliefs are untrue than it is to admit to yourself and others that you've put so much faith in a lie.
 
Which is all utterly irrelevant to the definition of the word "agnostic".



Gods, actually.



Well, I'm not sure how many people would claim to have absolutely no idea whether or not any gods exist. But, again, this doesn't really address what we were talking about.

Perhaps etymology might be a better direction to approach this from?

https://www.etymonline.com/word/agnostic



The word is concerned with whether or not people believe that the existence of gods can be known. There's more of Huxley's words on the subject on this page.


We have been around around this before, several times (inc. definitions of the term "agnostic").

If you are endorsing a definition which merely talks of quote "whether or not people believe that the existence of gods can be known", then you are talking about a belief (see your own quote) and not a claimed certainty of fact.

And to repeat (3rd or 4th time) - if that definition merely says that the agnostic says that he/she does not know (or thinks it's not possible to know) whether or not any claimed supernatural god exists, then that is just exactly the case for all theists and atheists too - atheists do not "KNOW" that no such god can exist, and theists do not "KNOW" that such a God does definitely exist ...

... in all three cases, theist, atheist, or agnostic, we are only ever dealing with a personal belief about the existence or otherwise of any god/God.

However the crucial, and quite enormous difference, is that atheists can show overwhelming and quite unarguable evidence against the existence of God. Whereas theists cannot show any genuine evidence at all for the existence of God. In that position, the beliefs of agnostics are really irrelevant, because all they are doing is adopting part of the atheist belief and part of the theist belief at the same time (it's just a bit of both ... or if you prefer - they are just saying they cannot decide strongly in either direction, neither strongly towards theism or strongly towards atheism).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom