Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

What's your take on garage dragons?


If it's something like a Komodo Dragon, i.e. a dragon which is actually universally accepted as existing (because it can be shown to exist and passes every possible test), then of course it's not inconceivable that someone could find one of those in their garage.

But if you mean to ask - what is the likelihood of finding an imaginary non-existent dragon of the type believed in ancient folklore, or as shown in kids cartoon magazines, then the answer is "if they truly do not exist, then there is zero chance" of finding a real living one of those in a garage (though you might find a pile of kids comics with drawings of that dragon).

As far as actually “knowing” that Komodo Dragons exist … we take that to be true beyond all credible doubt, because any of us can be taken to see the creature for ourselves, and to touch it and spend a lifetime studying every possible aspect of it's existence. That's still not a literal proof (you might just be dreaming for example … or what you see might be just a very clever trick-illusion), but it's as near as we can get to a literal proof when we can see it for ourselves, touch it, examine every conceivable aspect of it in every conceivable way, and show that every test we make always confirms that the creature exists …

… but none of that is the case with God is it! No, it's not. In the case of God not one single microscopic spec of any of that sort of evidence has ever been produced. You are not allowed ever to see that God, or to touch him, or to examine or test him in any way at all.

Though what you can do (as I said earlier), is show beyond all credible doubt that the entire concept of that God (Yahweh) is actually a creation dreamed up by people in the region around Palestine about 1500 BC … and you can further show that when they first started proclaiming that idea of Yahweh, they did it by adapting all sorts of earlier god beliefs taken from Persian, Egyptian and Greek cultures from several thousand BC. And that is extremely strong evidence against the existence of that God (it's extremely strong evidence to show that it was merely an invented superstition).
 
Last edited:
All that really exists are people who either believe in God, or else who do not believe it, but with a large group in-between who have no strong belief either way.

That would be the atheist/theist axis. Agnostic/gnostic is a different axis.

But anyone called a “gnostic theist” who says to quote you “I know for sure that God does not exist.” is simply wrong and is wasting everyones time debating it … because if he truly “knows”, meaning he is claiming literal certainty”, then he has to produce his unassailable proof … where is that proof?? And the exact same has to be said for the equally erroneous mistaken claim of “Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists”.

You're free to think these people are wrong and that it would be a waste of time debating them. That doesn't mean that they don't exist, or that the words used to describe them don't describe them.
 
Because there are more than three alternative answers. Degrees of knowledge.

That didn't answer my question, and there's nothing in the definitions I gave that excludes degrees of knowledge. My definition in no way dictate how big the agnostics think the likelihood of them being wrong is. It covers everybody from those who concede the infinitesimal possibility of God existing - assigning it the same probability as they do that we all live in the Matrix - to those who are barely sure of their beliefs at all.

Furthermore, the defining of these categories in no way excludes the existence of other categories (such as apatheists, for example), or subcatogories within the categories themselves (hard and weak athests, for example, such as the distinction between those who have debated and come to the conclusion that God does not exist, and those like babies who wouldn't even understand the question).
 
Indeed, there can be confusion if you do not notice that you are using the word in a different way than those that are hearing it. This is the classic entanglement of the forums with the term "atheism". Once the confusion has been cleared up, the only thing that can be done is to stop talking about the word and attend to the facts. Or agree on a common meaning. This solution is often hampered because the speakers insist that their meaning is "exact" or "true". This is where the verbal mess begins.

NOTE: To say that X exists is not to define X. It is to affirm an existence of fact that will not change because we change the name of the fact.

It's a start of a definition but again I'll point you back to the word "god" as it is used by the majority of those in the world that believe a god/s exist - their gods are defined by their religions.
 
That didn't answer my question, and there's nothing in the definitions I gave that excludes degrees of knowledge. My definition in no way dictate how big the agnostics think the likelihood of them being wrong is. It covers everybody from those who concede the infinitesimal possibility of God existing - assigning it the same probability as they do that we all live in the Matrix - to those who are barely sure of their beliefs at all.

Furthermore, the defining of these categories in no way excludes the existence of other categories (such as apatheists, for example), or subcatogories within the categories themselves (hard and weak athests, for example, such as the distinction between those who have debated and come to the conclusion that God does not exist, and those like babies who wouldn't even understand the question).

Which god do you believe in?
 
Which god do you believe in?

Since the last time you asked me a similar question in response to a similar post of mine I gave you a long and detailed answer which you ignored, I think my best response to you doing so this time is to refer you back to my previous post. Perhaps if you answer that one and I can see how what you're asking now requires a different answer, I'll feel inclined to answer this post.
 
Your classification is too stark. Between absolute certainty and absolute insecurity there should be some intermediate degree at least. Not all believers and unbelievers are so drastic. For example: see Dawkins' seven degrees: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_of_theistic_probability#Dawkins'_formulation
...what is "too stark" about "I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong" or "I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong"?
Part of the problem with involving "certainty" or especially "absolute certainty" is that religion constantly pushes its people to be utterly absolutely certain, which creates an incentive for them to claim they are even if they aren't... while the kind of approach that many atheists use does the opposite, treating doubt as a good thing and incentivizing them to overemphasize even a minuscule speck of doubt on principle.
 
Since the last time you asked me a similar question in response to a similar post of mine I gave you a long and detailed answer which you ignored, I think my best response to you doing so this time is to refer you back to my previous post. Perhaps if you answer that one and I can see how what you're asking now requires a different answer, I'll feel inclined to answer this post.

Can you give me a hint where that might be found - I rarely notice the names of who I am responding to so it may be I hadn't realised that you've answered the question before.

That aside - No idea why the question would involve a long answer.
 
Question : This was a long time ago. What was your mental outlook about these things back then?

I found your anecdote extremely interesting, as well as, in an odd way, moving. You know, much like some Jesus-worshipper might find moving accounts of Jesus apparently having actually manifested himself, wounds and all, to some fellow Jesus-worshipper. That sort of thing does happen, and when it does, it is generally explained by simple suggestibility : I was wondering if the same can be said for your perception of your consciousness “re-booting”.

I may not have expressed this very well, but you know what I’m driving at, right? Back in the period you mention, were these concepts of consciousness that are being discussed in this thread, were they at all familiar to you? Did this re-booting analogy pop up in your mind, then, directly/primarily as a result of your perception and experience, or might it simply have been suggestibility basis your thoughts around this?

(For instance I myself, back then, probably hadn’t really even heard of or read about, and hadn’t even begun to think of, any/all of these things that are being talked of here. So if I would have had some perception of myself “re-booting”, back then, then it couldn’t possibly have been just suggestibility as far as I am concerned : it would have been bona fide direct experience of this consciousness-rebooting thing. And I don’t think I’ve heard anyone else speak of this in quite this way.)


It didn't affect my world view at all. I hadn't believed in God since I was a child, and I'd started publishing skeptical articles a year or two before I had this weird experience.
My family wasn't very religious, no prayers at meals or before going to sleep, and I only went to Baptist Sunday school when I was three or four because all the other kids from my block did. My (single) mother neither encouraged nor discouraged it, so we went on our own because we enjoyed the singing and Bible stories. Even the Catholic parents of one my buddies didn't seem to mind his going to the wrong brand of Christianity.
And the people at the church were very nice. They weren't First-Testament Bible thumpers, and very tolerant of opposition to their ideas, like, when I insisted that one of the Ten Commandments was that you should never cross a red light! Unfortunately, I no longer remember the exact solution they came up with, but it seemed to satisfy all of us. :)
When I was six or seven I tried praying to God in a very traumatic situation, which made me realize that if God existed, then he wasn't the kind of god who answered prayers, or at least not my prayers. I might as well have been talking to myself, which, of course, was what I did. So I didn't try again, never saw any signs of any kind of god, and gave up on the idea. And that was back in the 1960s.
The experience in Cuba was very ... secular: no Gods, no visions of any kind. Just waking up from nothing, zero, and very different from waking up from sleep or even the one time I have been anesthesized, which is why I use the computer analogy to describe it. And, no, I didn't think of the computer analogy at the time. That is just the tool I use as way of describing what it felt like. - Also no Tron or Neuromancer visions or anything like that. :)
 
Last edited:
Can you give me a hint where that might be found - I rarely notice the names of who I am responding to so it may be I hadn't realised that you've answered the question before.

That aside - No idea why the question would involve a long answer.

You're just as capable of going back over the thread as I am.
 
It didn't affect my world view at all. I hadn't believed in God since I was a child, and I'd started publishing skeptical articles a year or two before I had this weird experience.
My family wasn't very religious, no prayers at meals or before going to sleep, and I only went to Baptist Sunday school when I was three or four because all the other kids from my block did. My (single) mother neither encouraged nor discouraged it, so we went on our own because we enjoyed the singing and Bible stories. Even the Catholic parents of one my buddies didn't seem to mind his going to the wrong brand of Christianity.
And the people at the church were very nice. They weren't First-Testament Bible thumpers, and very tolerant of opposition to their ideas, like, when I insisted that one of the Ten Commandments was that you should never cross a red light! Unfortunately, I no longer remember the exact solution they came up with, but it seemed to satisfy all of us. :)
When I was six or seven I tried praying to God in a very traumatic situation, which made me realize that if God existed, then he wasn't the kind of god who answered prayers, or at least not my prayers. I might as well have been talking to myself, which, of course, was what I did. So I didn't try again, never saw any signs of any kind of god, and gave up on the idea. And that was back in the 1960s.
The experience in Cuba was very ... secular: no Gods, no visions of any kind. Just waking up from nothing, zero, and very different from waking up from sleep or even the one time I have been anesthesized, which is why I use the computer analogy to describe it. And, no, I didn't think of the computer analogy at the time. That is just the tool I use as way of describing what it felt like. - Also no Tron or Neuromancer visions or anything like that. :)

What you describe sounds akin to Ego Death, sans all the mystical nonsense, of course.
 
What you describe sounds akin to Ego Death, sans all the mystical nonsense, of course.


No, not really. (Apart from the fact that Ego Death seems to be all about "the mystical nonsense.") It was more like unconsciousness (Wiki) - except that I didn't wake up on the floor but remained standing, which makes me assume that it can't have lasted more than a fraction of a second. To stay in the analogy: like switching a computer off and on again. I was also surrounded by people doing stretching exercises after dancing classes, and nobody noticed anything.
 
You're just as capable of going back over the thread as I am.

Well I have gone back over the thread and I can't find hl where I asked you the question the first time. At the moment it appears your recollection was incorrect.

Given that was the reason you didn't answer me I'll ask the question again, which God do you believe in?
 
No, not really. (Apart from the fact that Ego Death seems to be all about "the mystical nonsense.") It was more like unconsciousness (Wiki) - except that I didn't wake up on the floor but remained standing, which makes me assume that it can't have lasted more than a fraction of a second. To stay in the analogy: like switching a computer off and on again. I was also surrounded by people doing stretching exercises after dancing classes, and nobody noticed anything.
Sounds like Transient Global Amnesia (TGA) that (if I recall correctly) pixel42 has posted about.
 
No, not at all, fortunately!
"A person having an attack of TGA has almost no capacity to establish new memories, but generally appears otherwise mentally alert and lucid, possessing full knowledge of self-identity and identity of close family, and maintaining intact perceptual skills and a wide repertoire of complex learned behavior." (Wiki)
 
Well I have gone back over the thread and I can't find hl where I asked you the question the first time.

With all due respect, I don't see how that's my problem.

At the moment it appears your recollection was incorrect.

It's not.

Given that was the reason you didn't answer me I'll ask the question again, which God do you believe in?

And, again, I refer you back to my previous post.
 
It didn't affect my world view at all. I hadn't believed in God since I was a child, and I'd started publishing skeptical articles a year or two before I had this weird experience.
My family wasn't very religious, no prayers at meals or before going to sleep, and I only went to Baptist Sunday school when I was three or four because all the other kids from my block did. My (single) mother neither encouraged nor discouraged it, so we went on our own because we enjoyed the singing and Bible stories. Even the Catholic parents of one my buddies didn't seem to mind his going to the wrong brand of Christianity.
And the people at the church were very nice. They weren't First-Testament Bible thumpers, and very tolerant of opposition to their ideas, like, when I insisted that one of the Ten Commandments was that you should never cross a red light! Unfortunately, I no longer remember the exact solution they came up with, but it seemed to satisfy all of us. :)
When I was six or seven I tried praying to God in a very traumatic situation, which made me realize that if God existed, then he wasn't the kind of god who answered prayers, or at least not my prayers. I might as well have been talking to myself, which, of course, was what I did. So I didn't try again, never saw any signs of any kind of god, and gave up on the idea. And that was back in the 1960s.
The experience in Cuba was very ... secular: no Gods, no visions of any kind. Just waking up from nothing, zero, and very different from waking up from sleep or even the one time I have been anesthesized, which is why I use the computer analogy to describe it. And, no, I didn't think of the computer analogy at the time. That is just the tool I use as way of describing what it felt like. - Also no Tron or Neuromancer visions or anything like that. :)


Cool. So : not suggestibility. And therefore, probably (although of course, not necessarily) a direct experience of this.

Like I said, I don't recall ever having heard or read of this kind of experience. Religious experiences are common enough, but secular ones are extremely rare. In fact, before reading about yours, I'd thought they were no such thing as this kind of secular experience at all.

It would be interesting to know if others, elsewhere (not here at ISF, that would be too much of a coincidence : I mean in general) might have experienced something like this.

Thanks for sharing.
 
No, not at all, fortunately!
"A person having an attack of TGA has almost no capacity to establish new memories, but generally appears otherwise mentally alert and lucid, possessing full knowledge of self-identity and identity of close family, and maintaining intact perceptual skills and a wide repertoire of complex learned behavior." (Wiki)
Have a read of their experience http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=322883
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom