Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

...

WHY are they different, was my question. If two people examined the circumference of the earth, and came to different conclusions, you would ask "why the difference"? What is the set of data that both are using? Seems an obvious question. But I'm happy with the answers given: agnostics and hard atheists are working from incomplete data. Neither can justify their views to the other. One can't reason their way to the other view without making some kind of metaphysical leap.

Yes, that is the joker, but remember most skeptics are scientific skeptics and haven't learned and understand metaphysics, thus they can't differentiate e.g. between metaphysics and methodological naturalism as an epistemological process.
They don't understand that there are more positions in metaphysics than:
  • Physicalism/materialism/naturalism
  • Dualism
  • Idealism
  • Solipsism

As to incomplete data, it is unknown what reality as independent of the mind is as independent of the mind other than independent of the mind, so any claim of what reality is as independent of the mind, is subjective and not based on objective/complete data.

With regard
 
Yes, that is tautologous, but it's also a strawman since it's not what I'm saying.

Could you explicate what you're saying, please? It seems like a reasonable paraphrase to me, so there's obviously a breakdown in communication between us somewhere.
 
Well, yes they are. "I don't know" vs "Yes is false" are contradictory.

"I don't know for sure" vs. "yes is false" is not.

"'At least one deity exists' is a false statement" does not concede a degree of uncertainty.

That's why atheism and agnosticism are two separate concepts.

I'm not sure what you are referring to. What degree of uncertainty do you give to the statement "X is false"?

I refer you back to my Pythagoras example.

Or, if you only want examples to do with religion, I offer myself up. I'm as sure as I am that the sun exists that no gods exist. I am as sure as I am that the computer I am typing on exists that no gods exist. However, I concede the possibility that I am wrong, because I think that ultimately you have to concede that. Not just because ultimately I think you have to accept that you cannot say anything exists outside of your own thoughts with 100% certainty, but also because I must always remain open to the possibility of new evidence, and perhaps even new evidence which is overwhelming.

So I'm as sure as I can possibly be that no gods exist. However, that doesn't mean that I'm comfortable in saying that it's a cold, hard, fact that absolutely, 100% could never be contradicted.
 
I don't think you read beyond the part you quoted. Not even the rest of the paragraph, I'd wager.



Hello.



I agree.

So you identify as someone "who holds the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknown and probably unknowable"?

Are you a materialist? Do you think it equally likely that A) you're in a dream B) you're in a physical universe C) you're a brain-in-a-vat D) the Christian god created the universe roughly 10,000 years go?
 
Last edited:
So I'm as sure as I can possibly be that no gods exist. However, that doesn't mean that I'm comfortable in saying that it's a cold, hard, fact that absolutely, 100% could never be contradicted.
I have been comparing agnosticism with hard atheism. You seem to be giving me a separate option. If so, you are answering a separate question to the one I asked.

Which does your example above fall into? Agnosticism or hard atheism?

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Hard Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement.
 
"

That leads to a contradiction between
Hard atheist: I know that there are no gods. (That is a hard gnostic BTW)
Hard agnostic: It is unknowable if there are any gods.
The contradiction is that is knowable and unknowable!

I am a hard agnostic and Dawkins' list doesn't apply to me, because I don't give a probability for the existence of any gods. I don't make any positive claim of knowledge/probability about the existence of any gods.
Well, then you just add a distinction to the concept of agnosticism between hard agnosticism and soft agnosticism. No problem.

Of course, the contradiction between both options is total. This happens with theories that believe they have absolute or total knowledge of things. "Hard" whatever.
But I don't see what the problem is.

I am a hard agnostic and Dawkins' list doesn't apply to me, because I don't give a probability for the existence of any gods. I don't make any positive claim of knowledge/probability about the existence of any gods.

I'm not interested in how it's called, I'm interested in what you believe.
"God doesn't exist."
Do you think that is justified?
Do you think you can neither assert nor refuse it?
Are you sure about this? To what extent?
These are the issues. The names we give them only mess the discussion up.
 
Last edited:
Not to the person who has that certainty.


They do not "have certainty" ... there is not a certainty just for you and then a different certainty for the next person! .... "Certainty" means it's an absolute fact which is true for everyone. You are constantly talking merely about a persons opinion and trying to claim their opinion is known to them to be an absolute fact of certainty about the universe (about the existence of a god in this case).

You are just trying to change the meaning of the word "fact" to claim that things become facts if someone merely believe they are facts ... if someone says it's a fact that the Earth is flat then according to you that really does make the Earth become flat!


The first part of the sentence is correct. And that's who we're talking about. People who claim it for an absolute fact. That they may be wrong about this is irrelevant. That their standards of "absolute proof" may not meet yours is irrelevant. It's the fact that they will claim it that the word describes.


Well if they are wrong about it, then it was not an absolute fact, was it!

And you cannot claim certainty of fact for things that you cannot actually prove. Just because someone says they know for a "fact" that the Earth is flat, that does make the Earth flat! Just because an atheist says they "know for a fact" that God does not exist, that does mean that God cannot possibly exist.

You cannot force things to become true simply by saying “I say it's a fact!”.

You are just constantly making a whopping great misuse of the most basic rules of English language. And it looks as if the reason you keep doing that is because you simply cannot bring yourself to admit that we do not actually know for certain whether any such god could possibly exist. It looks as if, as an atheist, you have persuaded yourself into deliberately being untruthful about it … you do not know, I do not know, nobody here actually knows, and nobody anywhere else knows for a fact that God certainly could not exist … it's NOT a FACT (it's our opinion, based upon the evidence).
 
Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)? Why doesn't it account for people who may believe in more than one religion? Why doesn't it account for the differences between people who vaguely believe in the Christian God and those who vaguely believe in a general "something" up there? And so on.

Perhaps it would help if you'd outline what you believe the perfect system of categorisation to be? One that is free from the criticism of being too strict that you're levelling at other systems?


Because that's one thing that Dawkins and other hard-core atheists have in common with believers: They all have a hard time understanding that a lot of us just don't give a damn! On the one hand, we don't believe in God(s), but on the other hand, we don't think it's a big deal. Zealous atheism is so twentieth century! Many of us have moved on!

Unlike Dawkins, Zuckerman has actually studied the phenomenon. Here are a couple of facts:

Denmark is said to be 72% irreligious and atheist: List of religious populations: Irreligious and atheist (Wikipedia)
Yet 76% of the population are members of the state church.


When reading his book (admittedly some yeas ago) I did not get the impression that his 1 to 7 scale was intended as anything more than a very simple illustration just for him to say he'd personally rate (very very roughly) as 6.9, i.e. just trying to put a simple notional figure upon it for readers to see clearly that he was saying that he thinks God is extremely unlikely, but where he is also emphasising that of course he cannot honestly claim to “know” as a “fact” that God does not exist. That's the point of him saying he rates 6.9 rather than 7.0 … he's just emphasising that of course none of us can really claim to rate 7 out of 7 … that would be making the same whopping absurd mistake that so many in this thread keep making!

As for why he chose to say 6.9 out of 7 rather than saying 99% (for example), I expect he thought that by saying “a scale of 1 to 7” that would stick in the readers mind more (it's far more unusual than saying "99%") ... it's a way of trying to make readers pay attention & think more about how sure they feel about their own beliefs either way.
 
Last edited:
So you identify as someone "who holds the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknown and probably unknowable"?

More-or-less. I identify as someone who holds the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknowable for sure.

Are you a materialist?

Very much so.

Do you think it equally likely that A) you're in a dream B) you're in a physical universe C) you're a brain-in-a-vat D) the Christian god created the universe roughly 10,000 years go?

No. I think the probabilities of a, c, & d are vanishingly small. I think the probability of b being untrue is vanishingly small.
 
Last edited:
They do not "have certainty" ... there is not a certainty just for you and then a different certainty for the next person!

Of course there is. Different people can be certain about mutually-exclusive things. A gambler in Vegas can be certain that she'll roll a 12 with her next throw. Whether she will or not is irrelevant to her certitude.

"Certainty" means it's an absolute fact which is true for everyone.

https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/certainty

1 Firm conviction that something is the case.

‘she knew with absolute certainty that they were dead’

[...]

1.2 A general air of confidence.
‘a man exuding certainty’

People can be certain of things which are not true.

You are just trying to change the meaning of the word "fact" to claim that things become facts if someone merely believe they are facts ... if someone says it's a fact that the Earth is flat then according to you that really does make the Earth become flat!

This is a very odd straw man.

And you cannot claim certainty of fact for things that you cannot actually prove.

Of course you can.

Look at this reporting of a survey. People were asked to check which statement they agreed with. One of those statements was "I am certain God exists". 83.6% of people in the Philippines checked that statement. That's 83.6% of those surveyed in that country who claimed certainty that God existed.

Whether or not you agree with their claim is irrelevant to whether or not they can make that claim. People who do make that claim do exist, regardless of whether or not you want to believe they do, or whether or not you think they are entitled to make that claim.

And it looks as if the reason you keep doing that is because you simply cannot bring yourself to admit that we do not actually know for certain whether any such god could possibly exist.

I can't bring myself to admit what I've literally just told another poster is my own personal opinion? Okay.

I think perhaps that should be a call to you to take a step back and ponder why you're reading things in to my posts that I'm not putting there, rather than addressing what I've actually said. You appear to be consistently assuming things about me and what I think and arguing against that, instead of paying attention to what I'm saying.
 
Those aren't my definitions. I'm pulling them from Wiki. If you want to say that you disagree with those definitions, then fine. This conversation can't continue, since we need to agree on definitions before being able to argue on them.


Reminder: the opinion of "hard atheists". Not the opinion of atheists. See the definitions I give from Wiki.


WHY are they different, was my question. If two people examined the circumference of the earth, and came to different conclusions, you would ask "why the difference"? What is the set of data that both are using? Seems an obvious question. But I'm happy with the answers given: agnostics and hard atheists are working from incomplete data. Neither can justify their views to the other. One can't reason their way to the other view without making some kind of metaphysical leap.


Well you are constantly trying to look for inconsistencies and contradictions where they actually do not exist. And it seems fairly clear that you are doing that, i.e. inventing problems, just to support your religious belief.

There really is no such thing as "hard atheism". And you cannot create a real thing that is "hard atheism" merely by inventing the term and writing a definition for yourself in a dictionary (i.e. the dictionary compliers doing that for themselves). There is only atheism i.e. atheists, some of whom feel more strongly than others about how likely it is for God to exist ... just as some theists feel more strongly that God does exist (other theists would readily admit that they are not quite so sure about it) ... it's really a sort of straight-line scale ...

... at one end you have theists who believe God does exist, and at the other end you have atheists who believe God does not exist ...

... as you move away from either end of that scale, their beliefs become less firmly held ...

... and somewhere in the middle of that scale/line, you have so-called "agnostics" who are simply not at all sure in their mind what to think about the existence of God ... they are not all exactly in the dead-centre/middle of that scale/line ... they occupy a range on the line between theists and atheists ...

... just to put a notional (rough) figure on it, and putting that linear scale at 100% for the most extreme end of theism vs 0% for the opposite end at atheism - you might reasonably describe agnostics to occupy very roughly the region from around 90% to around 10% ...

... i.e. - at 90% they are 90% of the way to being firmly theist, but they would still say they think there is a 10% chance that the God does not exist (so they are tending towards theism, but still quite undecided) ... at the opposite end of the scale, you would have "agnostics" up to around 10% God-belief, i.e. they say they feel 90% confident that he does not exist, but they still have a significant doubt about it (10% doubt), so they would not quite go as far as saying they are atheist.

But the point of putting it in that numerical type of way, is only to emphasise that there are really only two different positions, i.e. theists at one end of any scale vs atheists at the opposite end of that scale … and what we really mean by “agnostics”, or what we should really mean by “agnostic”, is that they are people whose opinions come in around the middle region of that scale, such they would not claim a very strong belief in either direction (they are undecided).

But there is really no need to keep trying to define new terms like “hard atheism”, or “extra hard atheism”, or how about “extra extra hard atheism”, or you could have “weak cautionary provisional theism”, or maybe “loose disconnected vague but only fairly vague notional anti-intellectual hybrid agnosticism”. All that really exists are people on that scale of belief, from a feeling of complete certainty in God at one end, to a feeling of complete certainty in no God at the other end … and with the rest of the people in-between (but take note – that is emphatically NOT the same as saying those people at the extreme ends ARE “certain” that the God does or does not exist … what it says is that they feel “certain” in their own minds, and that "feeling" is an opinion or belief … that cannot be a claim of universal fact or certainty for everyone).
 
Last edited:
The joke, when I read this about 100% certain and that some claim that is not possible, then they who claim is not possible, they are 100% certain that 100% certain claims are not possible.
That one is as old as skepticism in the western culture and goes to shown the difference in skepticism: Dogmatic skeptics are 100% certain that 100% certain knowledge is not possible and those skeptic, who value non-judgement.

BTW I am a dogmatic skeptic in some cases. :)

With regard
 
You'll have to wait a while. You're making things difficult. I will first need to consult my lawyer and my tax advisor. :rolleyes:

It's up to you whether or not you bother answering the questions you were asked.

You've been quick to criticise any system other than Dawkins, but you have been unable to answer criticisms of his system or say why it is superior to others. It's entirely up to you whether you want to correct that situation. It's also entirely up to you whether you feel you need to get outside input in order to do so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom