Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I gave the definitions from Wiki, and my questions are based around those definitions.


Darat, I understand what you are saying: the question is meaningless without a definition. But I gave the definitions for agnosticism and hard atheism earlier. If you disagree with those definitions, or believe a definition is not possible, perhaps best to end our discussion here. :thumbsup:

Slight bit of confusion here - it is the definition for the word "god" I was talking about, the definition for atheism and agnosticism you gave did not define that word.
 
Well, you will get the answer below. There is a variant of naturalism you have overlooked. :)

So what is it? This variant of naturalism? It is methodological naturalism. I don't know that naturalism is true nor can I prove it. I use it in how I explain reality. I don't use the supernatural, because it works for me to use methodological naturalism...

In practice I then believe that you and I exist in a natural world, but since I am a skeptic, I don't believe in metaphysical knowledge beyond that what ever the rest of reality is, it has reality independently of my mind. I stop there and don't claim knowledge beyond that. No philosophical naturalism, dualism or idealism. I state what I believe in: Methodological naturalism.
Methodological naturalism is the principle of modern-day science. I don't know if one 'believes' in it so much as one practices it. But it makes no statement about the metaphysical, other than implicitly ignoring it, since it sits outside the realm of naturalism.

Saying you don't believe in metaphysical knowledge is making a metaphysical statement. That's metaphysical naturalism, not methodological naturalism.
 
Any fool can believe in any idea, and any fool can disbelieve any idea - there's no honor or skill in either being a believer, or being a disbeliever.
It's not even particularly interesting.
Beliefs are essentially 'models', where a models is never 100% correct, but has some utility. Believing in invisible dragons has limited utility, believing in a Christian God (may) have more utility.
Regarding the nature of reality, in most cultures today, the most common belief is 'materialism', the belief that reality is this stuff called matter, and that matter exists in time and space. Materialism is a belief, a model with high predictive power.
But it is still a belief.
For me, the only definition of atheist that is interesting is: one who has rejected all beliefs (regarding the nature of reality) - including Materialism.
 
Any fool can believe in any idea, and any fool can disbelieve any idea - there's no honor or skill in either being a believer, or being a disbeliever.
It's not even particularly interesting.
Beliefs are essentially 'models', where a models is never 100% correct, but has some utility. Believing in invisible dragons has limited utility, believing in a Christian God (may) have more utility.
Regarding the nature of reality, in most cultures today, the most common belief is 'materialism', the belief that reality is this stuff called matter, and that matter exists in time and space. Materialism is a belief, a model with high predictive power.
But it is still a belief.
For me, the only definition of atheist that is interesting is: one who has rejected all beliefs (regarding the nature of reality) - including Materialism.
Any fool can arbitrarily make up a definition of atheist and be interested in their own belief that's it's a valid definition. There's no honor or skill in being an interested believer in one's own invalid definition of atheist.
 
Last edited:
I share your apparent frustration in having to define atheism and agnosticism over and over. To me atheism is purely a lack of belief in any kind of deity and that's it.
It's great that you have your definition which is logically consistent and that you hold to for good reasons. However you do have to acknowledge that other people use different definitions of those words, which are also logically consistent and that they hold to for good reasons, and that can be a source of misunderstanding. We struggle for a common language with which to communicate our philosophies.
 
It's great that you have your definition which is logically consistent and that you hold to for good reasons. However you do have to acknowledge that other people use different definitions of those words, which are also logically consistent and that they hold to for good reasons, and that can be a source of misunderstanding. We struggle for a common language with which to communicate our philosophies.

The old "you can put whatever meaning you like on a word" crap. So a word, even as simple as the word atheist, is tripped over. If people just put whatever meaning they like on words, how are we going to have any sort of productive discussion?

Anyway here it is from IanS, put as simply as it can be, for those with challenged comprehension.


The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist". It means someone who does not believe in the existence of religious gods.

But regardless of what anyone can dig up from dictionary definitions etc., what in practice is universally meant by the term 'atheist", is that the person does not believe in the existence of the claimed religious God.

.........
 
Not if you have evidence that contradicts what is meant to exist, in such cases you know it doesn't exist. So a simplistic example in the vein of this thread: Zeus is a god that lives in a palace on Mt. Olympus, there is no such palace therefore we know Zeus doesn't exist.

There are propositions that can be refuted. "Linda is home and waiting for your call." Others cannot be refuted: "Somewhere in the world there is an invisible dwarf who lives under a stone". God is like the little dwarf. If there is no evidence in favour, it is justified that we believe that it does not exist.

This is one reason -not only- to believe that God doesn't exist. (I.e, to be atheist and not agnostic).
 
As I said, the definition would be "people who believe they know if God exists".

Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Agnostic theist: I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists.

Your classification is too stark. Between absolute certainty and absolute insecurity there should be some intermediate degree at least. Not all believers and unbelievers are so drastic. For example: see Dawkins' seven degrees: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_of_theistic_probability#Dawkins'_formulation
 
What does the gnostic atheist know for sure, that the agnostic atheist doesn't know for sure? Not that I am asking you specifically for an answer, but for anyone who feels they fall into either category.

If atheism is based on naturalism, then both the gnostic atheist and the agnostic atheist are on the same philosophical footing when analysing the data. So why the difference? Is it possible to reason one group into the other? What data would they use? Or is it all down to opinions?

I don't understand your first question. How can we discuss the issue without going into both sides reasons?

To the second: They are different justified opinions. I believe that the difference is not in the data but in how they are interpreted.
 
Last edited:
The problem there is entirely to do with the use of language and the way some people have chosen to define terms like atheism and agnosticism.

Those definitions, i.e. the ones you quote above, whilst very common in modern dictionaries, are completely unscientific(...)
Of course, these dictionaries are not dictionaries of science. It is you who is in a mistake. If you want a scientific definition you have to go to a dictionary of science. Your problem is that you wouldn’t find the word “God” in such a dictionary. There is a very simple explanation: the problem of God is not a scientific one. It is a philosophical problem that has not any scientific solution.
If you want the philosophical definition of atheism you should go to a dictionary of philosophy.

The position is entirely simple, and it's the one that afaik actually applies to real people in practice (i.e. almost everyone) - (1) theists believe that their god exists. They may say it's a certainty, but that's a worthless claim, because they are not able to prove any such certainty (in fact very far from it). Or (2) atheists are people who do not believe the claimed god/God exists. That again is only a belief or opinion (though it's typically supported by a great deal of very strong evidence). In between you have people (“agnostics”) who have no strong opinion or belief either way. They are just not sure what to believe about God.

But lastly – it's blindingly obvious how anyone can be reasoned out of agnosticism into atheism. It happens when they are presented with information and evidence that persuades them that the God almost certainly never existed. They might equally be persuaded into theism, if they are presented with information (true or false) which convinces them that the God actually does exist.

I have crossed out their opinions on the subject. A good definition does not include opinions. That is not to say that I disagree with your views on this commentary. I am, even if it needs some nuance: see my comment #670.
 
Last edited:
Definitely. I think many people become agnostics/atheists (and theists of course) through some kind of metaphysical argument rather than empirical data.


So the difference between agnostics and hard atheists is subjective? They look at the same empirical data but come to different conclusions? Or is it, as per your grandfather's experience, that some are convinced through metaphysical arguments while others aren't?

What a mania of yours! Between metaphysics and science and between absolute certainty and absolute subjectivity there are degrees! If you put the question in black and white terms, you will end up justifying anything.
 
Any fool can arbitrarily make up a definition of atheist and be interested in their own belief that's it's a valid definition. There's no honor or skill in being an interested believer in one's own invalid definition of atheist.

Definitions are common or particular, suitable or inconvenient, clear or confuse... There are not "authentic" or "true" definitions. A madman's definitiion can be a good definition, even if his belief is crazy.
 
Last edited:
Definitions are common or particular, suitable or inconvenient, clear or confuse... There are not "authentic" or "true" definitions. A madman's definitiion can be a good definition, even if his belief is crazy.
The definition of a word is a statement of the exact meaning of that word. An atheist is specifically a person that doesn’t have a belief in a god or gods (rejects beliefs in gods, if that makes you happier). Any valid and meaningful definition of “atheist” has to therefore contain reference to belief in gods.

A definition that defines “atheist” as being “one who has rejected all beliefs”, would mean a person that doesn’t believe in Santa, Tooth Fairy, dragons and the like would be an atheist. Is that a “good definition” of “atheist”?
 
There are propositions that can be refuted. "Linda is home and waiting for your call." Others cannot be refuted: "Somewhere in the world there is an invisible dwarf who lives under a stone". God is like the little dwarf. If there is no evidence in favour, it is justified that we believe that it does not exist.

This is one reason -not only- to believe that God doesn't exist. (I.e, to be atheist and not agnostic).

Nope - or rather nope to the gods that people actually believe exist in their religions.

Sure you can create a new definition for the word "god" and start using that - it just wouldn't be the god - for example - that the RCC says exists so causing confusion.

I say sticking to the definitions that those that claim "god/s" exists is the only sensible way you can define an atheist.

If you replace "god" with your definition all you are actually saying is that "Something may exist" - which is rather weak sauce.
 
The definition of a word is a statement of the exact meaning of that word.

And what authority decides "the exact meaning of that word"?
The meaning of a word is how it is used, especially by a particular community. Different communities of speakers may use the same word differently, so there may be different "exact meanings".
 
Your classification is too stark. Between absolute certainty and absolute insecurity there should be some intermediate degree at least. Not all believers and unbelievers are so drastic. For example: see Dawkins' seven degrees: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_of_theistic_probability#Dawkins'_formulation

...what is "too stark" about "I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong" or "I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong"?
 
As I said, the definition would be "people who believe they know if God exists".

Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Agnostic theist: I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists.

It's pointless and silly to say that these words are meaningless because some of the people speaking them are wrong about matters of fact.


What is “pointless and silly" is people trying to create definitions describing people as “atheist agnostic weak semi-hard softening on Tuesdays impressionist partial unbelievers” etc. All that really exists are people who either believe in God, or else who do not believe it, but with a large group in-between who have no strong belief either way.

But anyone called a “gnostic theist” who says to quote you “I know for sure that God does not exist.” is simply wrong and is wasting everyones time debating it … because if he truly “knows”, meaning he is claiming literal certainty”, then he has to produce his unassailable proof … where is that proof?? And the exact same has to be said for the equally erroneous mistaken claim of “Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists”.
 
Last edited:
Nope - or rather nope to the gods that people actually believe exist in their religions.

Sure you can create a new definition for the word "god" and start using that - it just wouldn't be the god - for example - that the RCC says exists so causing confusion.

I say sticking to the definitions that those that claim "god/s" exists is the only sensible way you can define an atheist.

If you replace "god" with your definition all you are actually saying is that "Something may exist" - which is rather weak sauce.

Indeed, there can be confusion if you do not notice that you are using the word in a different way than those that are hearing it. This is the classic entanglement of the forums with the term "atheism". Once the confusion has been cleared up, the only thing that can be done is to stop talking about the word and attend to the facts. Or agree on a common meaning. This solution is often hampered because the speakers insist that their meaning is "exact" or "true". This is where the verbal mess begins.

NOTE: To say that X exists is not to define X. It is to affirm an existence of fact that will not change because we change the name of the fact.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom