Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
What does the gnostic atheist know for sure, that the agnostic atheist doesn't know for sure? Not that I am asking you specifically for an answer, but for anyone who feels they fall into either category.

If atheism is based on naturalism, then both the gnostic atheist and the agnostic atheist are on the same philosophical footing when analysing the data. So why the difference? Is it possible to reason one group into the other? What data would they use? Or is it all down to opinions?
 
The only form of evidence that something doesn’t exist is the complete lack of evidence that it does exist. This applies to all things not just imaginary gods. If we can’t conclude gods don’t exist then we can’t conclude anything doesn’t exist. This leaves the door open to the fantasy world of “anything is possible, nothing is impossible”.

Not if you have evidence that contradicts what is meant to exist, in such cases you know it doesn't exist. So a simplistic example in the vein of this thread: Zeus is a god that lives in a palace on Mt. Olympus, there is no such palace therefore we know Zeus doesn't exist.
 
What does the gnostic atheist know for sure, that the agnostic atheist doesn't know for sure? Not that I am asking you specifically for an answer, but for anyone who feels they fall into either category.

If atheism is based on naturalism, then both the gnostic atheist and the agnostic atheist are on the same philosophical footing when analysing the data. So why the difference? Is it possible to reason one group into the other? What data would they use? Or is it all down to opinions?

It's down to understanding what you are saying and agreeing on definitions.
 
What does the gnostic atheist know for sure, that the agnostic atheist doesn't know for sure? Not that I am asking you specifically for an answer, but for anyone who feels they fall into either category.

If atheism is based on naturalism, then both the gnostic atheist and the agnostic atheist are on the same philosophical footing when analysing the data. So why the difference? Is it possible to reason one group into the other? What data would they use? Or is it all down to opinions?

I will try to answer.
As an agnostic as it is tied to naturalism, I consider reason, logic and evidence limited processes just as my ability to run.
So to say that I run means that if I have mobility I can run on a firm surface up to a certain speed, i.e. that running is limited. I treat reason, logic and evidence in the same manner, they are something I do, processes, and they are limited.

So let us play everything. :)
Is gravity everything? No, it is a part of reality and it is not everything.
Are words everything? No, they are a part of reality and not everything.
Is reason everything? No, it is a part of reality and not everything.
So reason is limited process and I can't reason everything, because I can't do everything using reason.
The same with logic and evidence.

As a skeptic, I accept I can't do a lot of processes in the sense of everything. So as a process I can't know what reality is independently of my mind as it is in itself. Thus I can't know if there is a god or if I am a Boltzmann brain.
So I believe that e.g. that the computer screen I am looking at right now is there as the computer screen independently of my mind, but I don't know that. That is naturalism as a belief. I believe that reality independently of my mind is as it appears to me in my mind and thus I don't believe in the supernatural nor that I am a Boltzmann brain.
But I don't know that, because that is not how knowledge, reason, logic and evidence works.

But the way I see it, is that gnostic atheists use the word know differently than me, because in practice they claim something I can't replicate. I.e. they use the word know in a way I can't and to me they in effect do something subjective. They think there is no god and then act as if their thinking is what causes there to be no god. In a sense they are doing a form of magical thinking, because they claim in effect a causality that is not there.
But now we are inside metaphysics, ontology and epistemology rolled up in, what requires training to understand.
I.e. it requires training to learn to catch, hold and examine ones own cognition and not just to take it for granted.

With regard
 
...snip.

As I said, the definition would be "people who believe they know if God exists".

Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Agnostic theist: I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists.

It's pointless and silly to say that these words are meaningless because some of the people speaking them are wrong about matters of fact.



People can hold more than one opinion on a subject, and those opinions can have nuance. Whether you find that concept too complicated or not is irrelevant.

Which god?
 
Sure, but just because I might believe and claim it to be a fact that the Earth is flat, does not mean that I have any validity to my claim of "fact". IOW - of course religious people do believe God is a certainty (i.e. a "fact"), but they are wrong if they say it actually IS a "fact/certainty" ... because they cannot actually prove it to be true ... and if they cannot prove it then they have not established that it is actually a fact.

And the same same goes for you and I as atheists ... we can't prove God does not exist ... so I'm not therefore going to be loose with my use of language/thinking and start claiming it to be a fact that God does not exist (and nor does it become a fact if I merely add the word "belief" to phrase it by saying "I believe it's a fact" that he does not exist" ... that's still just a belief (the word "fact" is actually redundant/misplaced in any phrase like that).
What's your take on garage dragons?
 
I'm not sure how adding "in principle" adds anything to the definition. But I didn't want to make this a discussion about definitions. Using the definitions from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Explicit weak/negative/soft atheists... reject or eschew belief that any deities exist without actually asserting that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Implicit weak/negative atheists... would include people (such as young children and some agnostics) who do not believe in a deity but have not explicitly rejected such belief.



Given that both are coming from a position of (presumably) empiricism, how is it that some people believe that the existence of God (or if you like, a super-natural creator) is unknowable, while others -- the hard atheists -- assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement? What is the disconnect? How can one, say, be reasoned out of agnosticism into hard atheism?



The problem there is entirely to do with the use of language and the way some people have chosen to define terms like atheism and agnosticism.

Those definitions, i.e. the ones you quote above, whilst very common in modern dictionaries, are completely unscientific, because they keep stating that people must "know" things, when actually none of us know whether God exists. The only excuse I can think of for dictionaries writing erroneous definitions like that, is that the editors do not realise that we cannot actually “know” things in that sense of things certainly existing or certainly not existing (such as God).

The position is entirely simple, and it's the one that afaik actually applies to real people in practice (i.e. almost everyone) - (1) theists believe that their god exists. They may say it's a certainty, but that's a worthless claim, because they are not able to prove any such certainty (in fact very far from it). Or (2) atheists are people who do not believe the claimed god/God exists. That again is only a belief or opinion (though it's typically supported by a great deal of very strong evidence). In between you have people (“agnostics”) who have no strong opinion or belief either way. They are just not sure what to believe about God.

But lastly – it's blindingly obvious how anyone can be reasoned out of agnosticism into atheism. It happens when they are presented with information and evidence that persuades them that the God almost certainly never existed. They might equally be persuaded into theism, if they are presented with information (true or false) which convinces them that the God actually does exist.
 
Thanks Tommy. I've reordered your response slightly.

But now we are inside metaphysics, ontology and epistemology rolled up in, what requires training to understand.
Certainly, atheism is associated with metaphysical naturalism/philosophical naturalism. So it is making a metaphysical statement of some sort. I'm not sure if that is the case with agnosticism, since I'm not sure if it needs to make a metaphysical statement at all. But if they are both rooted in metaphysical naturalism, as I've said earlier, I wonder whether one can be reasoned from agnosticism to a hard atheism, using the same set of data.

But the way I see it, is that gnostic atheists use the word know differently than me, because in practice they claim something I can't replicate. I.e. they use the word know in a way I can't and to me they in effect do something subjective.
But if you believe in metaphysical naturalism, wouldn't you "know" that there are no divine beings? The very belief by definition excludes the possibility of a metaphysical being. So what is the agnostic saying? That metaphysical naturalism is not necessarily a valid position? If so, why? And can someone be reasoned out of one position into the other?
 
What does the gnostic atheist know for sure, that the agnostic atheist doesn't know for sure?

As far as s/he is concerned - that God does not exist.

If atheism is based on naturalism, then both the gnostic atheist and the agnostic atheist are on the same philosophical footing when analysing the data.

And if faith is based on faith, then the gnostic and agnostic theists are also on the same philosophical footing when coming to their conclusions.

As it is, not all atheism is based on naturalism. My grandfather was a Catholic, until he was the only survivor of his unit in WWII. After that he was an atheist for the next 70s years. I wouldn't say that his atheism was based on naturalism, or the logical impossibility of God, or anything like that, but a more visceral "if God does exist, then how could something like this happen?" both about the specifics of seeing all his friends die around him, and with the generalities of the horrors he saw in the war.

So why the difference?

Different people are different.
 
But lastly – it's blindingly obvious how anyone can be reasoned out of agnosticism into atheism. It happens when they are presented with information and evidence that persuades them that the God almost certainly never existed.
Well, yes of course. But is that information out there now for the agnostic? If the information is objective and based in empiricism, why are there agnostics? Is it just a matter of making them aware of that information?

And if the information is not out there, why are there hard atheists? Why aren't they agnostics, if the information isn't there? Or is it subjective, a matter of opinion? If so, then why claim agnosticism and/or atheism is based in empiricism?
 
Well, yes of course. But is that information out there now for the agnostic? If the information is objective and based in empiricism, why are there agnostics? Is it just a matter of making them aware of that information?

And if the information is not out there, why are there hard atheists? Why aren't they agnostics, if the information isn't there? Or is it subjective, a matter of opinion? If so, then why claim agnosticism and/or atheism is based in empiricism?

Because for most people it doesn't make any difference - the agnostic and the atheist don't believe in any of the god (of the religions that have a god or gods).

I suspect that many agnostics use the word "god" without defining it, and when your definition of "god" isn't defined of course you can't say "god does not exist", it goes back to what I said earlier.

Let me ask you a question:

Do you believe XCVBNMHGFRT exists?

What is your answer? Do you believe that XCVBNMHGFRT exists or could/might exist?
 
As it is, not all atheism is based on naturalism. My grandfather was a Catholic, until he was the only survivor of his unit in WWII. After that he was an atheist for the next 70s years. I wouldn't say that his atheism was based on naturalism, or the logical impossibility of God, or anything like that, but a more visceral "if God does exist, then how could something like this happen?" both about the specifics of seeing all his friends die around him, and with the generalities of the horrors he saw in the war.
Definitely. I think many people become agnostics/atheists (and theists of course) through some kind of metaphysical argument rather than empirical data.

Different people are different.
So the difference between agnostics and hard atheists is subjective? They look at the same empirical data but come to different conclusions? Or is it, as per your grandfather's experience, that some are convinced through metaphysical arguments while others aren't?
 
Which god?

I think that's a different question for atheists and theists, and an irrelevant one for gnostics and agnostics, although still different for theists and atheists.

For the former, atheists disbelieve in all gods, while it will vary for individual theists. Perhaps they believe in a Judeo-Christian God (or, at least, one of the versions, and probably one tailored to their own individual preference), or perhaps they believe in a specific pantheon. Perhaps they even believe that all gods are ultimately the same god and therefore believe in some way in the gods of all religions.

For agnostic theists, I can't think of an instance in which it would be logical to assume that they would say "I'm certain that the God of the Bible exists, I'm certain that Zeus doesn't exist, but Ra might", although it would be silly to rule it out entirely as there are a lot of people in the world with a lot of different, ofttimes very silly, beliefs. For agnostic atheists I'd say that most would have to concede the possibility that any god could exist, but would be likely to give each equal (very, very slim) weight. But I'm also sure that there are, for example, atheists who are starting to find themselves being persuaded by the idea that, say, Allah really exists, but who wouldn't give the time of day to the thought that Odin does. So they'd be agnostic about a particular god.

As with all such things, there will be a huge number of variation in people's individual beliefs because the world is so large with such a large population and every single individual in this world is, indeed, an individual.

I was using "God" as a shorthand in my post above because I was becoming tired of typing out "god(s) exist(s)", rather than just "God exists".
 
Those definitions, i.e. the ones you quote above, whilst very common in modern dictionaries, are completely unscientific, because they keep stating that people must "know" things, when actually none of us know whether God exists.

Language isn't science. Neither is belief.
 
So the difference between agnostics and hard atheists is subjective? They look at the same empirical data but come to different conclusions? Or is it, as per your grandfather's experience, that some are convinced through metaphysical arguments while others aren't?

Both. Different people are different. Some people, when presented with the same data will come to the same conclusions. Some people, when presented with the same data will come to different conclusions. And, of course, not everybody will be presented with the same data.
 
Because for most people it doesn't make any difference - the agnostic and the atheist don't believe in any of the god (of the religions that have a god or gods).

I suspect that many agnostics use the word "god" without defining it, and when your definition of "god" isn't defined of course you can't say "god does not exist", it goes back to what I said earlier.
I gave the definitions from Wiki, and my questions are based around those definitions.

Let me ask you a question:

Do you believe XCVBNMHGFRT exists?

What is your answer? Do you believe that XCVBNMHGFRT exists or could/might exist?
Darat, I understand what you are saying: the question is meaningless without a definition. But I gave the definitions for agnosticism and hard atheism earlier. If you disagree with those definitions, or believe a definition is not possible, perhaps best to end our discussion here. :thumbsup:
 
Both. Different people are different. Some people, when presented with the same data will come to the same conclusions. Some people, when presented with the same data will come to different conclusions. And, of course, not everybody will be presented with the same data.
Yes, but that is usually when the data is not complete. No-one argues over the circumference of the earth, for example, because we have the data to make a definitive conclusion. Anyway, that's not really an argument against what you wrote. I agree it is both. To move between agnosticism and hard atheism would require additional empirical evidence (if it becomes available) as well as some kind of metaphysical one.
 
Last edited:
The only form of evidence that something doesn’t exist is the complete lack of evidence that it does exist. This applies to all things not just imaginary gods. If we can’t conclude gods don’t exist then we can’t conclude anything doesn’t exist. This leaves the door open to the fantasy world of “anything is possible, nothing is impossible”.


There is actually another quite huge class of evidence against the existence of God, and it's very obvious & very persuasive. Namely - there is now overwhelming evidence to show that the entire idea of the Christian God (Yahweh) was invented by ordinary people around the region of Palestine circa.1400 BC. It was an idea invented from all sorts of earlier beliefs about other gods in Persian, Egyptian, Greek culture. Where all of those gods, inc. God/Yaweh, were originally just attempts to explain the cause of the world and explain various events that everyone experienced in their daily lives.

Those were all things (questions) which at the time were of great practical importance to everyone. Things like drought and famine, thunder and lightening, storms & floods, earthquakes, volcanoes, fatal or serious diseases, the stars in the sky, even life and death itself ... all those things impacted directly on the daily lives of evertone. But they were things that no mortal human could control (though many kings and queens believed they were so special that they had powers over nature, and tried to command the rains to stop, or command the winds to blow ... others, religious preachers, thought their devout piety would allow them to influence God or to hear Gods messages, such that they could make “prophesy” of what God was about to do (e.g. send his Son Jesus to Earth) or what revenge he would take upon un-believers (often of course they thought God had instructed them to take their own revenge against unbelievers) …

… but now when we look back at all of that early religious writing, inc. from times long before Christianity (e.g. even on stone tablets and various effigies and statues etc. from early Greek, Egyptian, Persian religions), we can tell very clearly that these were superstitions which arose from attempts to understand how the world around them worked, attempts to get answers to all those questions which so greatly affected their daily lives. Often of course they also became ways of proclaiming power over other people.

But the evidence for that, as the origin of all those religious beliefs, is actually overwhelming. All of those religions began in that way. They all began as misguided uneducated attempts to understand and control the world around them.

The point of course is - that is very strong evidence against God. Because it shows that none of those early people ever had any real evidence for any gods. All they actually had was a world of pre-scientific ignorance in which they were trying (a) to make sense of the world and trying to think of explanations and answers for everything, and (b) using that process also to gain power and control over others and to force others to be subservient or even to worship you as a gifted proclaimer for God.
 
Thanks Tommy. I've reordered your response slightly.


Certainly, atheism is associated with metaphysical naturalism/philosophical naturalism. So it is making a metaphysical statement of some sort. I'm not sure if that is the case with agnosticism, since I'm not sure if it needs to make a metaphysical statement at all. But if they are both rooted in metaphysical naturalism, as I've said earlier, I wonder whether one can be reasoned from agnosticism to a hard atheism, using the same set of data.

Well, you will get the answer below. There is a variant of naturalism you have overlooked. :)


But if you believe in metaphysical naturalism, wouldn't you "know" that there are no divine beings? The very belief by definition excludes the possibility of a metaphysical being. So what is the agnostic saying? That metaphysical naturalism is not necessarily a valid position? If so, why? And can someone be reasoned out of one position into the other?

So what is it? This variant of naturalism? It is methodological naturalism. I don't know that naturalism is true nor can I prove it. I use it in how I explain reality. I don't use the supernatural, because it works for me to use methodological naturalism. But from the fact that I use methodological naturalism doesn't follow that reality is natural nor supernatural nor that I am a Boltzmann brain or not. It tells you, how I reason; i.e. what I believe. I believe that reality is natural.

Here is what the strong position can't do. We share that we are an effect caused by the rest of reality; i.e. reality independent of the mind. But I don't claim that I know what reality is independent of the mind, because I don't have access to reality as independent of the mind.
The strong position claims that, but when you check what it entails, it always boils down to this: Someone to the effect of - it doesn't make sense to me that reality could be different independently of my mind as compared as it appears to me, therefore I disregard that possibility as irrelevant and claim that I know that metaphysical naturalism.
But the problem is this:
  • Reality as it appears to me causes me to experience reality as it appears.
  • Reality not as it appears to me causes me to experience reality as it appears.
For these two possibilities you can't tell which one is correct, because you only have the same effect to go by: Reality whatever it is independent of my mind causes me to experience the following effect: I experience through my mind and I can only tell how I experience through my mind.

  • Objective in the metaphysical sense: Having reality independent of the mind.
  • Epistemology: Experience through the mind.
  • Metaphysical epistemology: Not experiencing through the mind so as to know what reality is independently of the mind.
I can't do the last one. To me that is not possible.
I am not a metaphysical solipsist, I am an epistemological solipsist. I only experience through my mind, hence epistemological solipsism, but not metaphysical solipsism.
I don't do metaphysics other that the thing in itself (Kant). For the rest I state what I believe: I believe in the natural world, hence methodological naturalism.

In practice I then believe that you and I exist in a natural world, but since I am a skeptic, I don't believe in metaphysical knowledge beyond that what ever the rest of reality is, it has reality independently of my mind. I stop there and don't claim knowledge beyond that. No philosophical naturalism, dualism or idealism. I state what I believe in: Methodological naturalism.

With regard
 
Last edited:
I think it corresponds to what I was saying in post 485.

But the translation with a first person singular pronoun still seems to be correct:




It reminds me of a weird experience I had twenty years ago, during the Xmas holidays of 1998-99:
I had arrived in Havana in the evening, and the next morning I was with a group of Danes taking first salsa and then Afro-Cuban folkloric dance lessons. We started by walking across a field to the extremely beautiful buildings of La ENA, Escuela Nacional de Artes. (I think that some of the buildings seen in Game of Thrones were inspired by the marvellous architecture of la ENA.)

However, since it was my first time in Cuba, I wasn't familiar with the conditions and expected to be able to buy bottled water, but there wasn't any, and since we'd been warned against drinking tap water, I had four hours of dancing with nothing to drink and temperatures rising.
So far nothing weird, but then I probably had a minor heat stroke or something like that. I don't know. I've never asked a professional. But consciousness closed down.
I found myself standing, leaning forwards, slightly bent over with my hands on my knees, eyes closed, and I didn't know where I was, who I was or even what I was. I didn't know my name or even that I had one. My best analogy is a computer that's been turned off and is rebooting.
As the senses returned to me, the only thing that really concerned me was the location, not my identity. I could hear voices, and they sounded like at a gym, and based on that I very slowly began to figure out/remember where I was, and for some reason I didn't dare open my eyes until I knew that.

It's the only time in my life that I remember a brief moment of having no knowledge at all. (Or maybe having no access to any knowledge.) And the question I asked myself was in no way Cartesian! Nor was it existential. But even so, I still knew that I was, but that was the only thing.

I have no idea how I had somehow managed to remain standing, but apparently the sense of balance doesn't rely 100% on consciousness.


Question : This was a long time ago. What was your mental outlook about these things back then?

I found your anecdote extremely interesting, as well as, in an odd way, moving. You know, much like some Jesus-worshipper might find moving accounts of Jesus apparently having actually manifested himself, wounds and all, to some fellow Jesus-worshipper. That sort of thing does happen, and when it does, it is generally explained by simple suggestibility : I was wondering if the same can be said for your perception of your consciousness “re-booting”.

I may not have expressed this very well, but you know what I’m driving at, right? Back in the period you mention, were these concepts of consciousness that are being discussed in this thread, were they at all familiar to you? Did this re-booting analogy pop up in your mind, then, directly/primarily as a result of your perception and experience, or might it simply have been suggestibility basis your thoughts around this?

(For instance I myself, back then, probably hadn’t really even heard of or read about, and hadn’t even begun to think of, any/all of these things that are being talked of here. So if I would have had some perception of myself “re-booting”, back then, then it couldn’t possibly have been just suggestibility as far as I am concerned : it would have been bona fide direct experience of this consciousness-rebooting thing. And I don’t think I’ve heard anyone else speak of this in quite this way.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom