Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Science has not proven that any god exists, but over time it has given explanations of facts that were considered proof of the existence of the supernatural. In other words, religions withdraw in front of science. And this is something of a test against theism.
No, that is nonsense. I know it gets repeated on these forums, but it doesn't make any sense. The discoveries of science have increased generation after generation. Think of what we knew a generation ago, compared to a generation before that, etc.

If "religions withdraw in front of science", then a graph should show a steady withdrawal of religion against science over the last, say, 10 generations. Instead, all we get are a few big confrontations -- evolution and heliocentrism -- and that's about it.

Science has increased our knowledge tremendously over the last 25 years. What has science made religion withdraw from in that period? Very little AFAIK.
 
On YouTube there is a debate in which someone told Dawkins that, because in his book Dawkins said he was "a 6.9 out of 7 on the scale of disbelief”, that meant he was an agnostic, and Dawkins said something like "oh, OK, then technically I am an agnostic" ... well actually he should not have accepted that so readily, because it's wrong lol! ... as is extremely well known, Dawkins always says that he does not believe in God (but as someone who knows something about science, he always accepts that he cannot be absolutely certain that no such God could possibly exist ... he cannot prove the God does not exist), and hence has always correctly described himself as an "Atheist" … that was (and still is) the correct description - Dawkins does not believe the God exists. And that makes him an atheist.

I don't know what year is the debate you mention, but in 2006, in your book The God Delusion, Dawkins defines agnosticism as the belief that the existence of God is as likely as his non-existence. Atheism is defined as the belief that the non-existence of God is improbable or certain "as surely as a theist believes in God". He considers himself an atheist (in high degree) because he believes that God's inexistence is highly unlikely. Cf. p. 73 and 128.
 
No, that is nonsense. I know it gets repeated on these forums, but it doesn't make any sense. The discoveries of science have increased generation after generation. Think of what we knew a generation ago, compared to a generation before that, etc.

If "religions withdraw in front of science", then a graph should show a steady withdrawal of religion against science over the last, say, 10 generations. Instead, all we get are a few big confrontations -- evolution and heliocentrism -- and that's about it.

Science has increased our knowledge tremendously over the last 25 years. What has science made religion withdraw from in that period? Very little AFAIK.

I wasn't thinking about the last few generations. But still, from Galileo to the present day, many scientific theories were condemned by the churches before they had to bow their heads. For example, mathematics, atomism, abandonment of final causes, biological classifications, geology, blood circulation, universal gravitation, etc.
True, apart from some recalcitrant sects, churches' opposition to science is at a minimum.
 
However - Don’t know what weird theists you know, but all the theists I know claim their god is eternal (always did exist, always will exists and currently does exist). Never met a theist that claims their god only exists currently. Never met a theist that claims their god is extinct either, if that’s what you mean.

Of course. God is not a diplodocus. Don't you see the difference?
I don't see what you don't see about my clarification.
Don't worry about it. It doesn't look serious.
 
I'm not sure how adding "in principle" adds anything to the definition. But I didn't want to make this a discussion about definitions. Using the definitions from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Explicit weak/negative/soft atheists... reject or eschew belief that any deities exist without actually asserting that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Implicit weak/negative atheists... would include people (such as young children and some agnostics) who do not believe in a deity but have not explicitly rejected such belief.


Given that both are coming from a position of (presumably) empiricism, how is it that some people believe that the existence of God (or if you like, a super-natural creator) is unknowable, while others -- the hard atheists -- assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement? What is the disconnect? How can one, say, be reasoned out of agnosticism into hard atheism?
Unknowable and unknown are very, very different things.

However one explanation is as I touched on I. E. that people mean different things by the word god.
 
I share your apparent frustration in having to define atheism and agnosticism over and over. To me atheism is purely a lack of belief in any kind of deity and that's it.

Perhaps the problem lies in the definition of the deity believed or not believed in so I have created a new thread - "Define the God(s) you Believe/Disbelieve in." where this can be discussed.
This why I think a better way to define atheism is by the question "which God do you believe in?"
 
I don't get the point.
You don’t get the point that I agree with you that agnostic-atheism is less likely to be valid than gnostic-atheism (what some people call hard/strong-atheism)? :confused: So my response to your "Yes" post was (Yes) By a country mile and then some! I didn't include the (Yes), but surely that was obviously implied.
 
Last edited:
Of course. God is not a diplodocus. Don't you see the difference?
I don't see what you don't see about my clarification.
Don't worry about it. It doesn't look serious.
It’s not that I don’t see the difference, it’s that I don’t see the relevance.

My post was purely an argument that agnostic-atheism is less likely to be valid than gnostic-atheism. “Extinct species” was only introduced to demonstrate a “real world” example of rationally concluding that something doesn’t exist due of the lack of empirical evidence. It certainly wasn’t intended to draw any parallel between extinct species and gods, and it truly puzzles me that you seem to thing it did.

My post also points out that it’s even more rational to conclude gods don’t exist than it is to conclude extinct species don’t exist, because there’s never been any empirical evidence gods ever have existed, or even could possibly exist.

Is any of that hard to read and comprehend?
 
Last edited:
This why I think a better way to define atheism is by the question "which God do you believe in?"


Yes a good question and not so easy to answer. My take on this, (after discussion with many theists), is the god they believe in is something conjured up in their own minds, to satisfy their own needs.
 
Using the definitions I give just above: Does science support agnosticism or hard atheism, or both, or neither?


Well that definition (one which has been discussed here many times before) is imho wrong. It's a worthless definition if says it's defining an individual who does not know if God exists ... because none of us truly "know" - theists don't know, and neither do atheists ...

... if you do know for sure that God exists, then it means you must be able to produce a literal "proof" of that existence (or similarly if an atheists says he "knows" God does not exist) ... but it's really not possible for any of us to actually produce a proof like that ... for all of us, theist, atheist (or so-called "agnostic") it can only ever be a matter of our individual belief ... as a Christian you believe he does exist (presumably?), and as an atheist I think he does not (for all the quite obvious evidential reasons that I've mentioned so many times) ... but in the end it can only be a matter of our personal belief (unless and until anyone does show an absolute proof).

As for science "supporting" hard atheism - science, is an academic subject made up of millions of professional people. The individuals have all sorts of opinions and beliefs (about anything), including some who believe God exists, others who would say they have no strong view (and they might say they are "agnostic"), and probably a majority who over the last 100-150 years have increasingly accepted that God probably does not exist (and that he is rather obviously a creation of peoples imagination from biblical times when people really had no better explanation for how the world around them real worked).

If your question is really to ask whether or not core science (i.e. physics, chemistry, biology and most of maths) is compatible with a supernatural creator of the universe who produces miracles etc., then the answer is "No", that is not compatible with what we have now learned from those core areas of fundamental scientific research (i.e. the areas which have established the "theories" upon which all of science rests).
 
Last edited:
The only form of evidence that something doesn’t exist is the complete lack of evidence that it does exist. This applies to all things not just imaginary gods. If we can’t conclude gods don’t exist then we can’t conclude anything doesn’t exist. This leaves the door open to the fantasy world of “anything is possible, nothing is impossible”.
 
You're right that facts are facts, but what each individual believes to be a fact may be different. True believers really do think it's a fact that God exists. They think it's true for everybody. You may think they're wrong. I know I do. But that doesn't mean to say that they don't think it's a fact.


Sure, but just because I might believe and claim it to be a fact that the Earth is flat, does not mean that I have any validity to my claim of "fact". IOW - of course religious people do believe God is a certainty (i.e. a "fact"), but they are wrong if they say it actually IS a "fact/certainty" ... because they cannot actually prove it to be true ... and if they cannot prove it then they have not established that it is actually a fact.

And the same same goes for you and I as atheists ... we can't prove God does not exist ... so I'm not therefore going to be loose with my use of language/thinking and start claiming it to be a fact that God does not exist (and nor does it become a fact if I merely add the word "belief" to phrase it by saying "I believe it's a fact" that he does not exist" ... that's still just a belief (the word "fact" is actually redundant/misplaced in any phrase like that).



If you're going to restrict the word "agnostic" not to what people think are facts, but what the facts actually are, then either everybody is an agnostic or nobody is, because either God exists or he doesn't. Clearly that's not only not what the word means, but it's also entirely useless as a term.


Well the word "agnostic" would just become meaningless with that sort of definition that says "agnostics are people who do not know if God exists". That's a completely meaningless and mistaken definition (yes, I do know it's in all the dictionaries lol :D).

What agnostic should mean, and some dictionaries also give this as the definition, and what I think almost everyone in normal society thinks of as "agnostic" (or certainly what in my experience people in the UK meant in the past), was/is that they understood the term to mean someone who was not sure of their beliefs where God was concerned. That is; the person thinks there is a reasonable chance that God does exist, but they also think there is a similarly reasonable chance that he does not exist ...

... at any given time in their lives, an "agnostic" like that might lean more strongly to one side or the other, but still without ever getting to the point of thinking he almost certainly does exist, at which point they would become a theist ... or conversely if they get as far as thinking he almost certainly does not exist, then they have become an atheist. But like everyone else, their views can, and do, change.


Basically, in the simplest terms, atheism/theism is whether or not you think god(s) exist(s), and agnosticism/gnosticism is whether or not you think you can know this with absolute certainty.


Yes, he is an atheist agnostic.


Well, see what I say above about that. Richard Dawkins is an atheist - because he does not believe God exists. All the other attempts to define things like "hard atheism" or "agnostic atheism" etc., just seem to be frivolous self-indulgent attempts to complicate in dictionaries and religious debates, what is actually a very simple concept of belief or otherwise in God.
 
Last edited:
No, that is nonsense. I know it gets repeated on these forums, but it doesn't make any sense. The discoveries of science have increased generation after generation. Think of what we knew a generation ago, compared to a generation before that, etc.

If "religions withdraw in front of science", then a graph should show a steady withdrawal of religion against science over the last, say, 10 generations. Instead, all we get are a few big confrontations -- evolution and heliocentrism -- and that's about it.

Science has increased our knowledge tremendously over the last 25 years. What has science made religion withdraw from in that period? Very little AFAIK.


I suspect that what David meant (and what I would certainly say about it), is that every time science discovered anything and gave a very complete & quite unarguable explanation, then religion and the Church leadership eventually had to accept the science and drop it's earlier claims where it had previously said that such things were all due to God. IOW it's what we have come to call the "God of the gaps" performance from the Church, whereby every time science explains something, the earlier religious belief/answer has to be abandoned (though uniquely, religions like the Chrsitian church and Pope etc., typically take hundreds of years to admit that they were wrong).

That's really turned out to be true for all of the many millions of things that science has now discovered and explained. And in all those millions of things, not once has it ever turned out that the explanation is the one previously claimed by religion. But the most obvious example, as I of course pointed out to you before, is the discovery of evolution ...

... the fact that humans were not created, but instead evolved from earlier apes (those earlier apes evolved from quite different earlier animals of all types ... going right back to primitive plants etc.), really destroys the very basis upon which religions like Christianity were built. They were built entirely on the ancient belief that a superhuman God must have created humans and placed them on Earth ... and further, it was the basis of that belief that humans were special and unique in being the deliberate and entire aim and purpose of God's will ... that is, the belief that this was God's specific purpose to create humans.

Well, that's now known to be wrong, isn't it!? ... the answer is "Yes", it definitely is wrong. God most definitely did not make any humans at all. And that really does destroy the entire basis of why the religion was created in the first place (despite all sorts of disingenuous and deceptive attempts by church leaders to change what the religion had originally claimed as the divine truth of God's creation).
 
Sure, but just because I might believe and claim it to be a fact that the Earth is flat, does not mean that I have any validity to my claim of "fact". IOW - of course religious people do believe God is a certainty (i.e. a "fact"), but they are wrong if they say it actually IS a "fact/certainty" ... because they cannot actually prove it to be true ... and if they cannot prove it then they have not established that it is actually a fact.

And the same same goes for you and I as atheists ... we can't prove God does not exist ... so I'm not therefore going to be loose with my use of language/thinking and start claiming it to be a fact that God does not exist (and nor does it become a fact if I merely add the word "belief" to phrase it by saying "I believe it's a fact" that he does not exist" ... that's still just a belief (the word "fact" is actually redundant/misplaced in any phrase like that).

None of this changes what the word means.

Well the word "agnostic" would just become meaningless with that sort of definition that says "agnostics are people who do not know if God exists". That's a completely meaningless and mistaken definition (yes, I do know it's in all the dictionaries lol :D).

As I said, the definition would be "people who believe they know if God exists".

Gnostic atheist: I know for sure that God does not exist.
Agnostic atheist: I don't think God exists, but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Agnostic theist: I believe God exists , but I have to concede the possibility I may be wrong.
Gnostic theist: I know for sure that God exists.

It's pointless and silly to say that these words are meaningless because some of the people speaking them are wrong about matters of fact.

Well, see what I say above about that. Richard Dawkins is an atheist - because he does not believe God exists. All the other attempts to define things like "hard atheism" or "agnostic atheism" etc., just seem to be frivolous self-indulgent attempts to complicate in dictionaries and religious debates, what is actually a very simple concept of belief or otherwise in God.

People can hold more than one opinion on a subject, and those opinions can have nuance. Whether you find that concept too complicated or not is irrelevant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom