Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Here's an interesting question:

Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?

Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?

Before a stupid battle starts because each of us understand the word "atheism" in a different way, I would try to fix the content of GDon's question, which I find really interesting.

The baron of H claims that there is definitely no gods.

Mr. J.H claims that he doesn't know whether or not there are gods.

Why some people (call them baronites) agree with the baron of H. and other (let call them heichites) agree with Mr. J.H.?

My answer:
I see two possibilities:
Either baronites and heichites don't agree about facts or they don't agree about what is a justified belief. I supose that the usual disagreement resides in the latter option.
 
Before a stupid battle starts because each of us understand the word "atheism" in a different way, I would try to fix the content of GDon's question, which I find really interesting.

The baron of H claims that there is definitely no gods.

Mr. J.H claims that he doesn't know whether or not there are gods.

Why some people (call them baronites) agree with the baron of H. and other (let call them heichites) agree with Mr. J.H.?

My answer:
I see two possibilities:
Either baronites and heichites don't agree about facts or they don't agree about what is a justified belief. I supose that the usual disagreement resides in the latter option.

Yeah, my money is also on justified beliefs.
 
Well, I like how you are able to speak on behalf of all atheists.
To me as a atheist, my atheism is a belief and a part of my philosophy. Now of course that makes me irrational as an atheist, because you speak with truth about atheism. I am irrational, because my atheism is a belief and a part of my philosophy.
But you are also irrational, because you against evidence assume that all forms of atheism are rational and since mine is irrational, your claim that atheism is neither a belief nor a philosophy is not rational. That is so because your claim amounts to a contradiction. For all forms of atheism none are neither a belief nor a philosophy, yet mine is a belief and a philosophy.

So we are both irrational about atheism.

With regard
The part of my post you hilited and apparently responded to “speaks on behalf of” atheisM, not atheisTs.

Atheism is no more atheists than science is scientists. That you self-identify as an irrational-atheist with belief and philosophy doesn’t make atheism a belief or philosophy. Claiming atheism is rational isn’t claiming atheists are rational.

Your post is entirely constructed with poor English language reading and comprehension skills and conflation straw. As such it has no validity.
 
Last edited:
The part of my post you hilited and apparently responded to “speaks on behalf of” atheisM, not atheisTs.

Atheism is no more atheists than science is scientists. That you self-identify as an irrational-atheist with belief and philosophy doesn’t make atheism a belief or philosophy. Claiming atheism is rational isn’t claiming atheists are rational.

Your post is entirely constructed with poor English language reading and comprehension skills and conflation straw. As such it has no validity.

There is no atheism nor science without atheists nor scientists.

There would be gravity without humans and there has been gravity without humans. There can't be atheism without atheists and there can't science without scientists. Both are cases of human behavior.

As to the highlight, it follows that you are not rational, just because you are an atheists, right? So while theism is irrational, it then follows that theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists, right?

So repeat after me: Atheists aren't rational, just because they are atheists and theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists!
Can you do that, please?

With regard
 
Nope - agnosticism means that you believe in principle that there is no way to know if god exists, atheism is stating you do not believe in a particular god.
I'm not sure how adding "in principle" adds anything to the definition. But I didn't want to make this a discussion about definitions. Using the definitions from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Explicit weak/negative/soft atheists... reject or eschew belief that any deities exist without actually asserting that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Implicit weak/negative atheists... would include people (such as young children and some agnostics) who do not believe in a deity but have not explicitly rejected such belief.


Given that both are coming from a position of (presumably) empiricism, how is it that some people believe that the existence of God (or if you like, a super-natural creator) is unknowable, while others -- the hard atheists -- assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement? What is the disconnect? How can one, say, be reasoned out of agnosticism into hard atheism?
 
Originally Posted by dann
Very Trump-like!

You have something of an obsession with Trump it seems - must be something you can take for that.:D

Seriously though this is a very poor form of argument. The - "Oh yes that other guy does that too and he's a jerk so you must be a jerk also." one.

I’m not even sure if it was meant as an insult or compliment given many people would like to be called “Very Trump like”. If it had been “Very Helmuth Nyborg like” at least the message would’ve been less ambiguous (talk about obsession).

To put it another way . . .

Thanks! I didn't know you liked, respected and admired Trump.

Hey you may have something there ynot! Perhaps what this Helmuth Nyborg dude is on about is happening already and Denmark is dumbing down, so we have a groundswell of support for Trump in the country.
 
There is no atheism nor science without atheists nor scientists.

There would be gravity without humans and there has been gravity without humans. There can't be atheism without atheists and there can't science without scientists. Both are cases of human behavior.

As to the highlight, it follows that you are not rational, just because you are an atheists, right? So while theism is irrational, it then follows that theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists, right?

So repeat after me: Atheists aren't rational, just because they are atheists and theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists!
Can you do that, please?

With regard

Believing in a god for which there is no proof is irrational, so to that extent theists are irrational. But that doesn't mean they are always irrational; they may live normal lives apart from that.

Atheists are rational for not believing in god, but may be irrational in other aspects of their lives. Most people are not entirely rational at all times.
 
There is no atheism nor science without atheists nor scientists.

There would be gravity without humans and there has been gravity without humans. There can't be atheism without atheists and there can't science without scientists. Both are cases of human behavior.

As to the highlight, it follows that you are not rational, just because you are an atheists, right? So while theism is irrational, it then follows that theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists, right?

So repeat after me: Atheists aren't rational, just because they are atheists and theists aren't irrational, just because they are theists!
Can you do that, please?

With regard
You continue to conflate "atheism" and "atheist".

You also continue to misunderstand, misquote and misinterpret my words (willfully so perhaps). I’ve never said or even implied that atheists are rational per se, just because they’re atheists, and theists are irrational per se, just because they’re theists. I’ve said that atheism is rational and theism is irrational. Atheists are therefore rational for not being theists, and theists are therefore irrational for being theists. Stop telling lies about what I’m saying in a dishonest and pathetic attempt to score points.

But I made a mistake in posting “Claiming atheism is rational isn’t claiming atheists are rational “. I should’ve (meant to have) posted “Claiming atheism isn’t a belief or philosophy isn’t claiming atheists (or theists) don’t have beliefs and philosophies about atheism“, which would have been more appropriate to our current debate.
 
Last edited:
Believing in a god for which there is no proof is irrational, so to that extent theists are irrational. But that doesn't mean they are always irrational; they may live normal lives apart from that.

Atheists are rational for not believing in god, but may be irrational in other aspects of their lives. Most people are not entirely rational at all times.
Exactly! And I've never said anything different.
 
Last edited:
Hey you may have something there ynot! Perhaps what this Helmuth Nyborg dude is on about is happening already and Denmark is dumbing down, so we have a groundswell of support for Trump in the country.
How "very Helmuth Nyborg like" of you to say that ;)
 
And I apologise for repeatedly raising science (though I certainly should not have to apologise for it), but that really is the overwhelming reason why, unlike 500 years ago and more, most atheists today do not believe that God exists...
Using the definitions I give just above: Does science support agnosticism or hard atheism, or both, or neither?
 
Well first of all agnosticism is not (or should not be) merely the position of saying “we don't know whether or not there are gods”, because none of us truly know whether God (e.g. the Christian God, or any similar supernatural gods) could possibly exist. If we did really claim to “know”, then that is a claim of literal certainty, and that means you must be able to produce a complete proof … and of course nobody has ever produced any such total proof either way.

But secondly “hard atheism” only expresses the belief or opinion that the claimed gods do not exist … atheism is a belief or opinion, which is almost always based on reasoning such as that which we can draw from everything now discovered and explained by modern science.

And I apologise for repeatedly raising science (though I certainly should not have to apologise for it), but that really is the overwhelming reason why, unlike 500 years ago and more, most atheists today do not believe that God exists (many atheists may not even realise that science is a huge part of their reason for disbelief, but I think it's obvious that science is central to their atheism, and that they are just not thinking clearly about the real reasons why they think the evidence is so strongly against such Gods).

But on the wider question of whether any of us are “reasoned” into atheism, or even "reasoned" into or out of theism, the obvious answer is surely that of course, as adults at least, we always think we have good reasons for whatever we believe to be true (or even, good reasons, for sitting on the fence about it, e.g. as in the usual case of people who say they are agnostics). It's perhaps slightly different for young children, e.g. if they have been brought up in religious homes (or been persuaded by schools that begin the school day with prayers to God and have more-or-less compulsory weekly lessons in RE/RI/whatever), in which case they may believe in God without ever having thought about it much in any sort of objectively “reasoned” way (i.e. they just accept what adults tell them, without a great deal of thought or debate about it).


I share your apparent frustration in having to define atheism and agnosticism over and over. To me atheism is purely a lack of belief in any kind of deity and that's it.

Perhaps the problem lies in the definition of the deity believed or not believed in so I have created a new thread - "Define the God(s) you Believe/Disbelieve in." where this can be discussed.
 
I share your apparent frustration in having to define atheism and agnosticism over and over. To me atheism is purely a lack of belief in any kind of deity and that's it.

Perhaps the problem lies in the definition of the deity believed or not believed in so I have created a new thread - "Define the God(s) you Believe/Disbelieve in." where this can be discussed.
Anyone that isn't a theist is an atheist. It's that simple.
 
Last edited:
If you only "believe" that you know something, then that is only a belief ... it's a belief in which you might be right or wrong. And that is 100% different from anyone claiming to actually know something as a literally certain unarguable fact ... if they say that, then they are claiming it's a fact for everyone (not merely for their own belief or opinion ... "facts" are not personal to individuals ... a "fact" is universal for everyone and everything).

You're right that facts are facts, but what each individual believes to be a fact may be different. True believers really do think it's a fact that God exists. They think it's true for everybody. You may think they're wrong. I know I do. But that doesn't mean to say that they don't think it's a fact.

If you're going to restrict the word "agnostic" not to what people think are facts, but what the facts actually are, then either everybody is an agnostic or nobody is, because either God exists or he doesn't. Clearly that's not only not what the word means, but it's also entirely useless as a term.

Basically, in the simplest terms, atheism/theism is whether or not you think god(s) exist(s), and agnosticism/gnosticism is whether or not you think you can know this with absolute certainty.

Dawkins does not believe the God exists. And that makes him an atheist.

Yes, he is an atheist agnostic.
 
Agnostic-atheists conclude that complete lack of empirical evidence means we can’t say if gods exists or not (as we do with things yet to be possibly discovered).

Gnostic-atheists conclude that complete lack of empirical evidence means we can say if gods exists or not (as we do with extinct species).

Trouble with classifying gods as being “things yet to be possibly discovered” is that according to all current knowledge gained from all current empirical evidence, gods are not even possibly possible. At least we know extinct species once existed and could therefore possibly still exist somewhere, or possibly exist again somehow.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure how adding "in principle" adds anything to the definition. But I didn't want to make this a discussion about definitions. Using the definitions from Wiki:

Agnosticism: the view that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable.

Atheism: Explicit strong/positive/hard atheists... assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Explicit weak/negative/soft atheists... reject or eschew belief that any deities exist without actually asserting that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement. Implicit weak/negative atheists... would include people (such as young children and some agnostics) who do not believe in a deity but have not explicitly rejected such belief.


Given that both are coming from a position of (presumably) empiricism, how is it that some people believe that the existence of God (or if you like, a super-natural creator) is unknowable, while others -- the hard atheists -- assert that "at least one deity exists" is a false statement? What is the disconnect? How can one, say, be reasoned out of agnosticism into hard atheism?

Does this help you?:


In an absolute sense no one has actually proved that any god exists.

However, there are arguments against the existence of a multitude of particular gods. Some, because they are contradictory —good, omnipotent, omniscient and etc., you know. Others because the things they claim to have done are false.
This is already some sort of test.

Moreover, the supporters of the existence of gods have tried to find proof of their existence for some millennia and have failed again and again. Since the one who has to prove that something exists is the one who affirm this existence, this resounding failure is kind of like a test.

Therefore, I believe it can be said that we have some proof that the gods do not exist. And much more this or that particular god.

There is reason to be a "hard"(?) atheist —or "gnostic atheist", according other denominations.
 
Last edited:
Using the definitions I give just above: Does science support agnosticism or hard atheism, or both, or neither?

Science has not proven that any god exists, but over time it has given explanations of facts that were considered proof of the existence of the supernatural. In other words, religions withdraw in front of science. And this is something of a test against theism.
 
Agnostic-atheists conclude that complete lack of empirical evidence means we can’t say if gods exists or not (as we do with things yet to be possibly discovered).

Gnostic-atheists conclude that complete lack of empirical evidence means we can say if gods exists or not (as we do with extinct species).

Trouble with classifying gods as being “things yet to be possibly discovered” is that according to all current knowledge gained from all current empirical evidence, gods are not even possibly possible. At least we know extinct species once existed and could therefore possibly still exist somewhere, or possibly exist again somehow.

Your argument is clever, but it has a problem: theists claim that at least one god currently exists. Not that it has existed in the past or may exist in the future, like the species you mention. It is somewhat different because the existence of something currently existing must be proven now.
 
Does this help you?:

In an absolute sense no one has actually proved that any god exists.

However, there are arguments against the existence of a multitude of particular gods. Some, because they are contradictory —good, omnipotent, omniscient and etc., you know. Others because the things they claim to have done are false.
This is already some sort of test.
Then, after the tests have been completed, what is more likely to fit the evidence? Agnosticism or hard atheism? Or neither?

As I wrote above, both can't be correct, and both are coming from a perspective of empiricism. So which one is incorrect, based on the data that we have available?

There is reason to be a "hard"(?) atheist —or "gnostic atheist", according other denominations.
Okay. So is agnosticism less likely to be valid than hard atheism (as defined by the definitions I gave above)?
 
Your argument is clever, but it has a problem: theists claim that at least one god currently exists. Not that it has existed in the past or may exist in the future, like the species you mention. It is somewhat different because the existence of something currently existing must be proven now.
Well it might be a problem if my argument was about theists, but it was specifically about types of atheists.

However - Don’t know what weird theists you know, but all the theists I know claim their god is eternal (always did exist, always will exists and currently does exist). Never met a theist that claims their god only exists currently. Never met a theist that claims their god is extinct either, if that’s what you mean.

I’m puzzled by your post. Is there something I’m missing you could explain differently to help me out?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom