Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Which is why I suggested that you don't really need the first I.


Well the sentence does not make sense without that first "I". You cannot credibly write or say "thinks, therefore I am" ... because that instantly raises the question of who or what is claimed to be doing the said "thinking" ... what is it that is supposed to be doing anything called "thinking"?

If the statement was something more like "I seem to exist, because I seem to experience thoughts about my own existence", then that might be OK ... but that's only an implication saying we do seem to exist (it's not a statement claiming literal proof). Or perhaps he could have said "I think, therefore that seems to prove I exist" ... it may "seem to", but it's not specifically showing an actual proof, is it! (I'll leave that without a question mark).

But philosophical statements from Descartes or any philosopher are irrelevant in any of this. Philosophy is no longer the way we determine what is likely to be the true explanation for anything we detect or experience as apparent “reality” in this universe. It's been superseded by science (for overwhelming reasons that are now really far beyond any credible argument from philosophers). But you will not find any serious scientists claiming that we can literally prove anything in science (or in anything else), at least not for what we detect as apparent “reality” (as opposed to (say) a proof in maths … but where even in pure maths, there is afaik almost always an implied assumption somewhere in the calculations/reasoning).
 
It is possible to leave out the I, which is what I did.
But you are right about science having gone beyond that a long time ago. Science dels with real things and isn't really concerned with whether real things are real.
 
When Descartes says he “thinks”, did he already start by saying “I”? If he starts by saying “I … do anything”, then he is beginning with the assumption of his own existence. He is first saying that he does exist, and then after that he proceeds to say that he does something called “thinking”. In that statement, as it's phrased, he begins by first assuming that he does indeed exist.

But I'm also almost the last person here to suggest that perhaps none of us exist or that reality does not exist. I'm just saying that it's not really a proof of the actual physical existence of humans, for anyone or anything to produce the phrase “I think, therefore I am”. Above you just say that it “implies' that people do exist … well we don't need Descartes merely for an implication … everything mankind has ever done or detected about everything in this universe, very strongly supports the obvious conclusion that of course we all exist (so did everything else on the planet before any humans ever evolved).

Yes, "cogito". (The first-person singular pronoun is implied in Latin. Similar to Spanish: soy, estoy)
Mybe this can help:



But if everything is to be doubted, how can the Meditator know the cogito? A number of readings have been given to understand this step. One is to read it as an intuition rather than an inference, as something that comes all at once, in a flash. Another reading interprets the cogito as a performative utterance, where the utterance itself is what confirms its truth. That is, I could not say "I exist" if I did not exist or if I did not think, and so the act of saying it is what makes it true. Thus, I can only affirm my own existence (not anybody else's) and I can only do so in the present tense: I cannot say "I thought, therefore I was/am."

It should be noted that the cogito only works for thought. I cannot say, "I walk, therefore I am," since I can doubt I am walking. The reason I cannot doubt that I am thinking is that doubt itself is a form of thought. (From : http://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/meditations/section3/page/2/)
​

And this:

Dans cette première connaissance, il ne se rencontre rien qu’une claire et distincte perception de ce que je connais (René Descartes: Méditations métaphysiques, III. Traduction française du duc de Luynes (1647 )​
(“In this first knowledge [the cogito], there is nothing but a clear and distinct perception of what I know” (Personal translation; bold letters are mine)).​
 
Last edited:
I think it corresponds to what I was saying in post 485.

But the translation with a first person singular pronoun still seems to be correct:

Verb[edit]
cōgitō (present infinitive cōgitāre, perfect active cōgitāvī, supine cōgitātum); first conjugation
1. I think quotations ▼
2. I consider, ponder
Wiktionary


It reminds me of a weird experience I had twenty years ago, during the Xmas holidays of 1998-99:
I had arrived in Havana in the evening, and the next morning I was with a group of Danes taking first salsa and then Afro-Cuban folkloric dance lessons. We started by walking across a field to the extremely beautiful buildings of La ENA, Escuela Nacional de Artes. (I think that some of the buildings seen in Game of Thrones were inspired by the marvellous architecture of la ENA.)

However, since it was my first time in Cuba, I wasn't familiar with the conditions and expected to be able to buy bottled water, but there wasn't any, and since we'd been warned against drinking tap water, I had four hours of dancing with nothing to drink and temperatures rising.
So far nothing weird, but then I probably had a minor heat stroke or something like that. I don't know. I've never asked a professional. But consciousness closed down.
I found myself standing, leaning forwards, slightly bent over with my hands on my knees, eyes closed, and I didn't know where I was, who I was or even what I was. I didn't know my name or even that I had one. My best analogy is a computer that's been turned off and is rebooting.
As the senses returned to me, the only thing that really concerned me was the location, not my identity. I could hear voices, and they sounded like at a gym, and based on that I very slowly began to figure out/remember where I was, and for some reason I didn't dare open my eyes until I knew that.

It's the only time in my life that I remember a brief moment of having no knowledge at all. (Or maybe having no access to any knowledge.) And the question I asked myself was in no way Cartesian! Nor was it existential. But even so, I still knew that I was, but that was the only thing.

I have no idea how I had somehow managed to remain standing, but apparently the sense of balance doesn't rely 100% on consciousness.
 
Last edited:
So:
Strong: There is evidence that there are no gods.
Weak: It is unknown if there are any gods.

The 2 are in contradiction to each other, so one of the positions is irrational.


Actually those two statements do not contradict one-another.

The first statement just claims there is evidence to show that these gods (whoever they are?) do not really exist. But evidence against gods is only a indication that the belief may well be false/untrue. The evidence is not a proof that the gods cannot possibly exist … so to that extent we cannot say we “know” they don't exist … all we can say is that the evidence appears to be against it.

But that's exactly what your second statement also says! It just says we do not know if any such gods really exist … they might do, even though the evidence is said to be against it.

You would only have a contradiction if your two statements said something like -

1. We have proved that no gods exist.
2. It is unknown whether any gods exist.

But of course the problem there, is that the first statement is false, because we have not “proved” that no gods exist.

However, all of that is just an example of your use of language being mistaken. It doesn't really get as far as what any of us ought to rationally believe as the evidence for or against God (or any similar gods in other religions).
 
You have something of an obsession with Trump it seems - must be something you can take for that.:D

Seriously though this is a very poor form of argument. The - "Oh yes that other guy does that too and he's a jerk so you must be a jerk also." one.
I’m not even sure if it was meant as an insult or compliment given many people would like to be called “Very Trump like”. If it had been “Very Helmuth Nyborg like” at least the message would’ve been less ambiguous (talk about obsession).

To put it another way . . .
Very Trump-like!
Thanks! I didn't know you liked, respected and admired Trump.
 
Last edited:
I think it corresponds to what I was saying in post 485.

I think so.

Descartes' cogito illustrates only the impossibility of obtain an absolute certitude outside of formal sciences... and the own existence as thinking Ego. No room for anymore.

Of course, many other knowledge can be almost absolute, but they are sadly irrelevant for the capital concerns of the human being. Boiling water hurts. The moon is a satellite of the earth, and so on.
 
You have something of an obsession with Trump it seems - must be something you can take for that.:D
Seriously though this is a very poor form of argument. The - "Oh yes that other guy does that too and he's a jerk so you must be a jerk also." one.

I’m not even sure if it was meant as an insult or compliment given many people would like to be called “Very Trump like”. If it had been “Very Helmuth Nyborg like” at least the message would’ve been less ambiguous (talk about obsession).
To put it another way . . .
Thanks! I didn't know you liked, respected and admired Trump.


And the two of you have now reduced yourselves to the only thing you're good at. Very Trump-like.
 
You would only have a contradiction if your two statements said something like -

1. We have proved that no gods exist.
2. It is unknown whether any gods exist.

But of course the problem there, is that the first statement is false, because we have not “proved” that no gods exist.

However, all of that is just an example of your use of language being mistaken. It doesn't really get as far as what any of us ought to rationally believe as the evidence for or against God (or any similar gods in other religions).

It depends on the meaning you give to the word "prove". If it has an absolute sense, no one has actually proved that any god exists.

However, there are arguments against the existence of a multitude of particular gods. Some, because they are contradictory —good, omnipotent, omniscient and etc., you know. Others because the things they claim to have done are false.
This is already some sort of test.

Moreover, the supporters of the existence of gods have tried to find proof of their existence for some millennia and have failed again and again. Since the one who has to prove that something exists is the one who affirm this existence, this resounding failure is something of a test.

Therefore, I believe it can be said that we have some proof that the gods do not exist. And much more this or that particular god.
There is reason to be an atheist —or "gnostic atheist", if you like this denomination better.
 
Here's an interesting question:

Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?

Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?
 
Some atheists are not sure there are no gods because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are no gods.

Some atheists are sure there are no gods because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are gods.

Different people have different perspectives. So what?

No atheists are atheists because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are no gods.

All* atheists are atheists because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are gods.

Atheism is neither a belief nor a philosophy.

* This post assumes we aren't talking about default-atheists.
 
Last edited:
Some atheists are not sure there are no gods because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are no gods.

Some atheists are sure there are no gods because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are gods.

Different people have different perspectives. So what?

No atheists are atheists because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are no gods.

All* atheists are atheists because there is no empirical evidence to prove there are gods.

Atheism is neither a belief nor a philosophy.
* This post assumes we aren't talking about default-atheists.

Well, I like how you are able to speak on behalf of all atheists.
To me as a atheist, my atheism is a belief and a part of my philosophy. Now of course that makes me irrational as an atheist, because you speak with truth about atheism. I am irrational, because my atheism is a belief and a part of my philosophy.
But you are also irrational, because you against evidence assume that all forms of atheism are rational and since mine is irrational, your claim that atheism is neither a belief nor a philosophy is not rational. That is so because your claim amounts to a contradiction. For all forms of atheism none are neither a belief nor a philosophy, yet mine is a belief and a philosophy.

So we are both irrational about atheism.

With regard
 
Here's an interesting question:

Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?

Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?
It's not that interesting of a question. If a big fraction of the population believed in Garage Dragons, you'd find a bunch of deconverts unwilling to rule them out completely either.

Can you say there is definitely no garage dragons?
 
Here's an interesting question:

Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?

Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?

Nope - agnosticism means that you believe in principle that there is no way to know if god exists, atheism is stating you do not believe in a particular god.

It gets a tad confusing because some people want to use the word god without defining it and as such any question about "it" becomes meaningless. Or they use it to refer to the set of gods in human religions, which since many of those gods have contradictory definitions means that they an't all exist.

I for instance can state with absolute certainty that the the god the RCC states exists does not exist. I can say that because the RCC provides a well described definition of what they mean by god.

Without a definition of "god" any question about "its" existence simply becomes:

Do you believe in XCVBNMHGFRT?​

Which you would of course rightly respond with "I don't know what XCVBNMHGFRT means" rather than saying you don't or you do believe in XCVBNMHGFRT.

"Theism" and "Atheism" mean nothing unless you define the god they are meant to refer to.
 
Here's an interesting question:

Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?

Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?


Well first of all agnosticism is not (or should not be) merely the position of saying “we don't know whether or not there are gods”, because none of us truly know whether God (e.g. the Christian God, or any similar supernatural gods) could possibly exist. If we did really claim to “know”, then that is a claim of literal certainty, and that means you must be able to produce a complete proof … and of course nobody has ever produced any such total proof either way.

But secondly “hard atheism” only expresses the belief or opinion that the claimed gods do not exist … atheism is a belief or opinion, which is almost always based on reasoning such as that which we can draw from everything now discovered and explained by modern science.

And I apologise for repeatedly raising science (though I certainly should not have to apologise for it), but that really is the overwhelming reason why, unlike 500 years ago and more, most atheists today do not believe that God exists (many atheists may not even realise that science is a huge part of their reason for disbelief, but I think it's obvious that science is central to their atheism, and that they are just not thinking clearly about the real reasons why they think the evidence is so strongly against such Gods).

But on the wider question of whether any of us are “reasoned” into atheism, or even "reasoned" into or out of theism, the obvious answer is surely that of course, as adults at least, we always think we have good reasons for whatever we believe to be true (or even, good reasons, for sitting on the fence about it, e.g. as in the usual case of people who say they are agnostics). It's perhaps slightly different for young children, e.g. if they have been brought up in religious homes (or been persuaded by schools that begin the school day with prayers to God and have more-or-less compulsory weekly lessons in RE/RI/whatever), in which case they may believe in God without ever having thought about it much in any sort of objectively “reasoned” way (i.e. they just accept what adults tell them, without a great deal of thought or debate about it).
 
Well first of all agnosticism is not (or should not be) merely the position of saying “we don't know whether or not there are gods”, because none of us truly know whether God (e.g. the Christian God, or any similar supernatural gods) could possibly exist. If we did really claim to “know”, then that is a claim of literal certainty, and that means you must be able to produce a complete proof … and of course nobody has ever produced any such total proof either way.

Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not. Then again, if you choose to disappear down that rabbit hole, then you can only really say that you believe that you know anything at all. But that was solipsim lies.

But, yes, agnosticism is the position that we don't (or can't) know whether or not God(s) exist(s). Richard Dawkins is an agnostic. That doesn't make him any less of an atheist.
 
Perhaps it could be put as believing that you know whether God(s) exist(s) or not. Then again, if you choose to disappear down that rabbit hole, then you can only really say that you believe that you know anything at all. But that was solipsim lies.


If you only "believe" that you know something, then that is only a belief ... it's a belief in which you might be right or wrong. And that is 100% different from anyone claiming to actually know something as a literally certain unarguable fact ... if they say that, then they are claiming it's a fact for everyone (not merely for their own belief or opinion ... "facts" are not personal to individuals ... a "fact" is universal for everyone and everything).



But, yes, agnosticism is the position that we don't (or can't) know whether or not God(s) exist(s). Richard Dawkins is an agnostic. That doesn't make him any less of an atheist.


On YouTube there is a debate in which someone told Dawkins that, because in his book Dawkins said he was "a 6.9 out of 7 on the scale of disbelief”, that meant he was an agnostic, and Dawkins said something like "oh, OK, then technically I am an agnostic" ... well actually he should not have accepted that so readily, because it's wrong lol! ... as is extremely well known, Dawkins always says that he does not believe in God (but as someone who knows something about science, he always accepts that he cannot be absolutely certain that no such God could possibly exist ... he cannot prove the God does not exist), and hence has always correctly described himself as an "Atheist" … that was (and still is) the correct description - Dawkins does not believe the God exists. And that makes him an atheist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom