Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

So if one atheist claims that it is knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
Knowable by way of negative evidence (none exists)

And other claims that it is not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
Not knowable by way of positive evidence (none exists)

It then follows that at least one of the claims is false, thus without evidence and as such irrational.
No, both are consistent with (none exists). Both are rational for different reasons.

Give it up, it is rational not to claim the existence of gods, because there is no positive evidence for the existence of gods,
Yes. But it’s also rational to claim there’s no positive evidence for the non-existence of gods.

but from there doesn't follow that all versions of reasoning leading to be an atheist are rational.
Give an example of an irrational version of reasoning leading to be an atheist.

PS ynot, atheism is not irrational, but some atheists are as per the example above.
Yes, but not as per the example above. There's no such thing as a flawlessly rational person.

ETA - In case some are unwilling or unable to “read between the lines” and “join a few dots”, (none exists) means (no positive evidence for the existence or non-existence of any god exists).
 
Last edited:
It doesn't matter. The "they" are obviously the "other people".

However - The "they" are the "those" that spend time endlessly debating whether or not the reasons some people are atheists are irrational. Why do you think they do it?

I experience you as being annoyingly arrogant. Perhaps it's a cultural divide thing?


This seems an almost endless squabble you are having with dann and I can appreciate your frustration.

When you build an argument suggesting this may be as a result of that, it is only reasonable to expect others to give some thought to your structured reasoning, and respond in a thoughtful manner. What we often get however, is the sort of immature retort of "But look at that guy over there".

Then we have others making a blanket claim that Hitler, (and hence the Nazis despite having belt buckles inscribed with the words - 'Gott Mit Uns' (God Is With Us)), was anti religious as if this were a given. This is presented as an argument for the suggestion, a nazi regime would thrive in an atheist society. When evidence is presented, showing Hitler's religiosity is ambiguous, the chant goes on unabated.
 
This seems an almost endless squabble you are having with dann and I can appreciate your frustration.

When you build an argument suggesting this may be as a result of that, it is only reasonable to expect others to give some thought to your structured reasoning, and respond in a thoughtful manner. What we often get however, is the sort of immature retort of "But look at that guy over there".

Then we have others making a blanket claim that Hitler, (and hence the Nazis despite having belt buckles inscribed with the words - 'Gott Mit Uns' (God Is With Us)), was anti religious as if this were a given. This is presented as an argument for the suggestion, a nazi regime would thrive in an atheist society. When evidence is presented, showing Hitler's religiosity is ambiguous, the chant goes on unabated.
It's not endless because we've ended it (at least I have). It sometimes gets to a point where continuing is pointless.

Never mind Hitler, apparently Helmuth Nyborg is the current "evil atheist". Spread the word and save the world!
 
Last edited:
This is presented as an argument for the suggestion, a nazi regime would thrive in an atheist society.

No it wasn't. That's twice now you've argued a straw-man version of what I said, and that's despite me having explained what I was saying twice.

When evidence is presented, showing Hitler's religiosity is ambiguous, the chant goes on unabated.

The evidence you presented was a wikipedia page. What are the very first two sentences on that wikipedia page?

Adolf Hitler's religious beliefs have been a matter of debate; the wide consensus of historians consider him to have been irreligious, anti-Christian, anti-clerical and scientistic.[1] In light of evidence such as his fierce criticism and vocal rejection of the tenets of Christianity,[2] numerous private statements to confidants denouncing Christianity as a harmful superstition,[1] and his strenuous efforts to reduce the influence and independence of Christianity in Germany after he came to power, Hitler's major academic biographers conclude that he was irreligious and an opponent of Christianity.

That is what I said. That you want to paint "the wide consensus of historians" as "ambiguous", and attempted to back that up by quote-mining your source is dishonest, and you shouldn't be astounded when such a transparent tactic doesn't make for a convincing argument.

And you see fit to lecture other people on rationality. Honestly. Just try to take a step back and ask yourself what you're actually trying to accomplish.
 
No it wasn't. That's twice now you've argued a straw-man version of what I said, and that's despite me having explained what I was saying twice.

Yes calling in the "Straw-man" claim is a sure fire winner. I have some difficulty with a number of your "explanations" unfortunately.


The evidence you presented was a wikipedia page. What are the very first two sentences on that wikipedia page?

Oh, so I should defer my understanding of the actual words of Hitler, in favour of someone elses opinion of where he was at?

Here is something else to look at regarding Hitlers religiosity. A number of quotes of Hitlers words on the subject are contained therein.

https://michaelsherlockauthor.wordp...is-not-great-how-religion-poisons-everything/


That is what I said. That you want to paint "the wide consensus of historians" as "ambiguous", and attempted to back that up by quote-mining your source is dishonest, and you shouldn't be astounded when such a transparent tactic doesn't make for a convincing argument.

And you see fit to lecture other people on rationality. Honestly. Just try to take a step back and ask yourself what you're actually trying to accomplish.

Getting a little testy here aren't we? This is as much as I can glean from this little tirade.
 
But that's actually not the same as saying "I think, therefore I am", and then claiming those words to be a proof that you (as the human writer/thinker) must exist. That's not a proof, because it actually begins by assuming that you do exist ...
I'm just grazing on this thread, not up to speed on the controversies, but I've had the same feeling about Descartes for decades. Even in Latin (which I don't know) you start with a first-person conjugation, so though it doesn't include the word "I" the verb form does the same job.
 
Yes calling in the "Straw-man" claim is a sure fire winner.

No, it just happens to be true.

Tell you what, if you think I have at any point made the argument that Nazism would thrive in an atheist society, then please quote me doing so. I'll happily apologise and concede you're right and I'm wrong.

I have some difficulty with a number of your "explanations" unfortunately.

And yet rather than address them you pretend I've said something else.

Oh, so I should defer my understanding of the actual words of Hitler, in favour of someone elses opinion of where he was at?

You're ignoring the private statements he made to friends and colleagues and his actual actions against the Christian Church in favour of believing the propaganda he said in public while trying to get elected or immediately afterwards.

Here is something else to look at regarding Hitlers religiosity. A number of quotes of Hitlers words on the subject are contained therein.

https://michaelsherlockauthor.wordp...is-not-great-how-religion-poisons-everything/

Quotes, again, from public speeches and Mein Kampf.

How about, instead, we go with what Goebbels had to say on the matter?

Goebbels noted long discussions about the Vatican and Christianity, and wrote: "The Fuhrer is a fierce opponent of all that humbug". - The Goebbels Diaries 1939–41

Or, if Goebbels isn't enough of a primary source for you, how about Hitler himself?

"The dogma of Christianity gets worn away before the advances of science. Religion will have to make more and more concessions. Gradually the myths crumble. All that's left is to prove that in nature there is no frontier between the organic and the inorganic. When understanding of the universe has become widespread, when the majority of men know that the stars are not sources of light but worlds, perhaps inhabited worlds like ours, then the Christian doctrine will be convicted of absurdity."

"Christianity is the prototype of Bolshevism: the mobillization by the Jew of the masses of slaves with the object of undermining society."

"Science cannot lie, for it's always striving, according to the momentary state of knowledge, to deduce what is true. When it makes a mistake, it does so in good faith. It's Christianity that's the liar."

- Hitler's Table Talk

Getting a little testy here aren't we? This is as much as I can glean from this little tirade.

Sure, that's all that's there, if you ignore my quoting of your source saying that "the wide consensus of historians" supports what I've been saying and contradicts what you've been saying. I can't imagine why you'd want to ignore that.
 
Last edited:
Actually, you know what? I think this is pointless. It's always pointless with you. Anybody who will quote-mine his own source because it contradicts him (while deliberately not including a link to that source), anybody who ignores what I've said about Lenin-Marxist Communism in favour of pursuing a pointless and trivial side-niggle about Hitler which is irrelevant to what I'm actually saying, anybody who consistently and continually argues in bad faith, just isn't worth the time and effort.

I will not engage with you again. I hope you eventually find whatever form of comfort it is you're looking for from these kinds of threads.
 
Actually, you know what? I think this is pointless. It's always pointless with you. Anybody who will quote-mine his own source because it contradicts him (while deliberately not including a link to that source), anybody who ignores what I've said about Lenin-Marxist Communism in favour of pursuing a pointless and trivial side-niggle about Hitler which is irrelevant to what I'm actually saying, anybody who consistently and continually argues in bad faith, just isn't worth the time and effort.

I will not engage with you again. I hope you eventually find whatever form of comfort it is you're looking for from these kinds of threads.


Ok, out with a flounce it is.
 
The contradiction in terms that I see is this one:

How can you say that it "remains to be seen" when you know that it has already been seen to be untrue?!

I have already mentioned the Danish atheist Helmuth Nyborg and his Nazi friends:

“It remains to be seen” was more of a rhetorical question. Clearly there have been Nazis and fascist atheists. However, perhaps someone would like to argue that the problem is not human nature, but that it is a kind of perversion. Not I.

But the problem was posed here in relation to an entire or predominantly atheistic society. This society has never existed in history.

However, Hitler and Mussolini, as well as other fascist dictators of the time, were very interested in the power of religion to control the masses. Their parties had many para-religious rites and they flirted with some forms of theism. The idea of a secular religion - if I may say so - was in the mindset of social sciences since Durkheim and others. In my opinion that is what it is: an unacceptable oxymoron.
 
Christians don't have to be any more irrational than atheists. Sure, their Christianity isn't rational, but the rest of the time they may be much more rational than many atheists.
And a similar thing can be said about atheists..
Your logical mistake: the idea that God exists is always irrational. Some atheists maintain irrationally that God does not exist. Universal is not particular.

"The rest time" is too vague. I need to get more precision about when and under what circumstances a theist can be more racional than an unbeliever.
 
Last edited:
Okay, Aristotle: "The most certain of all basic principles is that contradictory propositions are not true simultaneously."

It is known that there are no gods.
It is not known that there no gods.

We can rewrite it to a contradiction: It is knowable and not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
So if one atheist claims that it is knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god. And other claims that it is not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
It then follows that at least one of the claims is false, thus without evidence and as such irrational.

Give it up, it is rational not to claim the existence of gods, because there is no positive evidence for the existence of gods, but from there doesn't follow that all versions of reasoning leading to be an atheist are rational.
Aristotle was speaking of a logical-metaphysical reasoning in which only two values of truth are possible: true or false.
In philosophy there are many intermediate values of evidence. For example, Russell said that sometimes he was inclined toward atheism (knowing that God doesn't exist) and sometimes toward agnosticism (not to believe that God exists).

I would say I am an atheist because I have reason to believe that God does not exist. Some are strong and some are less strong. But I am open to debate because agnosticism also seems to have its reasons. I have nothing to debate with a fideist, except the consequences of his belief.
 
Then we have others making a blanket claim that Hitler, (and hence the Nazis despite having belt buckles inscribed with the words - 'Gott Mit Uns' (God Is With Us)), was anti religious as if this were a given. This is presented as an argument for the suggestion, a nazi regime would thrive in an atheist society. When evidence is presented, showing Hitler's religiosity is ambiguous, the chant goes on unabated.

The concordat with the Catholic Church was not exactly anti-Christian. Or the tacit or express support of other majority faiths in Germany. What the Allies reproached to the Pope and other religions was that they had many believers among the Nazis themselves and that they did nothing to take them off the Nazi party. (Note the consequences of the churches' explicit opposition to the elimination of mentally handicapped people. The Nazis stopped the program immediately). What the Nazis wanted was for the churches not to interfere in their affairs, as Jehovah's Witnesses did. If they limited themselves to go to mass, Hitler had nothing against them The difference between papal politics respect Nazism and Stalinism is illuminating.

This is why you cannot speculate about an hypothetical Nazi-atheistic society. This has never existed. Nowhere near.
 
Last edited:
I'm just grazing on this thread, not up to speed on the controversies, but I've had the same feeling about Descartes for decades. Even in Latin (which I don't know) you start with a first-person conjugation, so though it doesn't include the word "I" the verb form does the same job.


Which is why I suggested that you don't really need the first I.
 
Last edited:
Your logical mistake: the idea that God exists is always irrational. Some atheists maintain irrationally that God does not exist. Universal is not particular.

"The rest time" is too vague. I need to get more precision about when and under what circumstances a theist can be more racional than an unbeliever.


Your logical mistake is that you pretend that theists think theistically 24-7. They don't. And that atheists are being rational 24-7. They aren't. The circumstances under which a theist not only can be but actually is more rational than an unbeliever are whenever the theist thinks rationally and the atheist doesn't. It's as simple as that, and it doesn't require very particular circumstances.
However, that some circumstances are more conducive to rational thinking than others has been mentioned a couple of times above (and below: my sig line).
 
Last edited:
“It remains to be seen” was more of a rhetorical question. Clearly there have been Nazis and fascist atheists.


Martin Bormann was one of them. I've already mentioned Helmuth Nyborg.

However, perhaps someone would like to argue that the problem is not human nature, but that it is a kind of perversion. Not I.


The problem isn't human nature. I doubt that there is such a thing. In the case of Nazis, the problem is fascist (and nationalistic/patriotic) 'nature' (and there's nothing natural about that).

But the problem was posed here in relation to an entire or predominantly atheistic society. This society has never existed in history.


Nobody seems to disagree that there's never been a real atheist nation.

However, Hitler and Mussolini, as well as other fascist dictators of the time, were very interested in the power of religion to control the masses. Their parties had many para-religious rites and they flirted with some forms of theism.


They more than flirted with Christianity! Wiki:
Hitler argued against secular schools, stating: "Secular schools can never be tolerated because such schools have no religious instruction, and a general moral instruction without a religious foundation is built on air; consequently, all character training and religion must be derived from faith."

And Christians were welcome as members of the NSDAP even though some of the party leaders were opposed to the existing churches:
Although the broader membership of the Nazi Party after 1933 came to include many Catholics and Protestants, aggressive anti-Church radicals like Joseph Goebbels, Martin Bormann, and Heinrich Himmler saw the kirchenkampf campaign against the Churches as a priority concern, and anti-church and anticlerical sentiments were strong among grassroots party activists.
(...)
In public speeches, he (Hitler) portrayed himself and the Nazi movement as faithful Christians.[37][38] In 1928 Hitler said in a speech: "We tolerate no one in our ranks who attacks the ideas of Christianity ... in fact our movement is Christian."
As a measure in the struggle for power against the influence of the churches (Kirchenkampf) the Nazis tried to establish a "third denomination" called positive Christianity, aiming to replace the established churches to reduce their influence.
Wiki - National Socialist attitudes to Christianity

The Nazi persecution of atheists appears to have been mainly directed at left-wing atheists, i.e. in line with the consistent Nazi persecution of communists:
Adolf Hitler banned left-wing atheist and freethought groups and regularly spoke against the "atheistic" or "godless movement." Indeed, Nazi Germany is a depressingly common example, with Reductio ad Hitlerum (wrongly, and thus ironically) used against atheists to associate them with Nazism. That being said, it was more because Hitler hated communism rather than anything else. Atheists that were members of the Nazi party (such as Martin Bormann ) could still get great careers under the Nazi regime. According to propaganda officer Goebbels, Hitler hated Christianity as well and sought to eradicate it. So Hitler has no place on either side of the spectrum. The SS oath denounced atheism as well, and the organization forbade atheists from joining.
Rational Wiki

But Martin Bormann joined the SS in 1937 so they seem to have distinguished between 'good' (= Nazi) and 'bad' (= Commie) atheists!
 
Last edited:
No, that is not what it actually just says. It actually says that "I think", which implies that there's something, a 'first-person narrator', doing the thinking = I exist (or am).


When Descartes says he “thinks”, did he already start by saying “I”? If he starts by saying “I … do anything”, then he is beginning with the assumption of his own existence. He is first saying that he does exist, and then after that he proceeds to say that he does something called “thinking”. In that statement, as it's phrased, he begins by first assuming that he does indeed exist.

But I'm also almost the last person here to suggest that perhaps none of us exist or that reality does not exist. I'm just saying that it's not really a proof of the actual physical existence of humans, for anyone or anything to produce the phrase “I think, therefore I am”. Above you just say that it “implies' that people do exist … well we don't need Descartes merely for an implication … everything mankind has ever done or detected about everything in this universe, very strongly supports the obvious conclusion that of course we all exist (so did everything else on the planet before any humans ever evolved).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom