Knowable by way of negative evidence (none exists)So if one atheist claims that it is knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
Not knowable by way of positive evidence (none exists)And other claims that it is not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
No, both are consistent with (none exists). Both are rational for different reasons.It then follows that at least one of the claims is false, thus without evidence and as such irrational.
Yes. But it’s also rational to claim there’s no positive evidence for the non-existence of gods.Give it up, it is rational not to claim the existence of gods, because there is no positive evidence for the existence of gods,
Give an example of an irrational version of reasoning leading to be an atheist.but from there doesn't follow that all versions of reasoning leading to be an atheist are rational.
Yes, but not as per the example above. There's no such thing as a flawlessly rational person.PS ynot, atheism is not irrational, but some atheists are as per the example above.
ETA - In case some are unwilling or unable to “read between the lines” and “join a few dots”, (none exists) means (no positive evidence for the existence or non-existence of any god exists).
Last edited: