Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I would say, "the reason ... is irrational."
So what? Does that make the person any less an atheist?

But what do I know. English isn't my first language ...
That's okay, I will attempt to "read between your lines" and "join up some of your dots". Perhaps you might care to do the same for me?
 
Last edited:
If others do what they define as being "good things", but you define those things as being "bad things", does it still not matter to you, and is their motivation of no interest to you?
Obviously :rolleyes: I am using a standard, culturally-accepted definition of "good". If someone does something that I think is good (feeding the hungry, rescuing the kitten, kicking the habit, which I think most of us agree on) then I don't care why they did that thing.

This, I think, would be completely obvious to anyone who doesn't have a preconceived idea of what they think I am saying, or an a priori motivation to disagree with me. I'm actually a little surprised that I have to explain this.

Yeah, no, actually I'm not even remotely surprised.
 
Well I noticed that there was only 5 minutes between your initial and repeated requests. Do you always expect such prompt attention?


No, that depends. In this case it is an ongoing discussion where you're busy contradicting yourself so forgive me for asking again: Who are they? And why do you claim that I'm speaking on their behalf?!

In post 529, you accused me of speaking on behalf of other people.

When asked (post 531) who these imaginary "other people" were, you (post 533) said that they were "The "they" in my (ynot's) post that you (dann) quoted."

However, in the post that I quoted the "they" were all atheists!
The only thing that defines people as atheists, and is common to all atheists, is that they aren’t theists. Why people are atheists is irrelevant. Whether one type of atheist is more or less rational than another doesn’t make one any more or less an atheist than the other. So what if the reason some are atheists isn't rational? It doesn’t make atheism irrational.


When I asked again (post 536) "And who are the "they" in your post?", you answered: "The "they" are the "those" that spend time endlessly debating whether or not the reasons some people are atheists are irrational. Why do you think they do it?"

So what you're saying is that the people you define as atheists are the ones who spend time endlessly debating whether or not the reasons some people are atheists are irrational. And somehow I speak on their behalf. And that is from the guy who resorts to condescension as his default debating tool.

Forgive me, but I don't have the patience required for irrational arguments like this! This is like trying to argue with Donald Trump!
 
Last edited:
How do you know that? No such society has ever existed.


Based on how (some) atheists embrace all kinds of Nazi ideology, it's hard to imagine that a whole society of them would be a bulwark against fascism.
On the other hand, since a large majority of people would only give up religion in the kind of society where people didn't need religion, I would also find it hard to imagine that fascism stood a chance of appealing much to people.
And you're right, of course, that no such society ever existed so empirical evidence would be hard to come by. :)

ETA: I'd probably prefer a deeply religious anti-fascist Christian to a fascist atheist any time! :)
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure that "science" does not lead to the inevitable conclusion that even the fact of your own existence is beyond certainty.


Well, there is the problem with your statement straight away (i.e. the highlighted bit) - science does not claim to produce any actual "fact" in the literal sense of complete "certainty" ... so science is not making (and does not need to make) any claims of saying the existence of anything (inc. ourselves) is a matter of 100% certainty.

As I tried to explain above - science does not claim to establish certainty, and it really does not need to do that. We just deal with whatever we detect as the apparent "facts" of existence for anything, and if we are lucky, i.e. in the best cases, we can construct a "Theory" to explain the existence of those things ... but it's not actually a "proof" ... science is not claiming to prove things as a matter of absolute certainty.

That does not mean we cannot be extremely confident about such theories as QM (QFT), Relativity, Evolution, or of course the apparently obvious "fact" of our own existence. It just means that we have learned (mainly through science & maths) to avoid unnecessarily claiming that we have established something as a literal certainty when we cannot actually prove it to be a 100% certainty.
 
Well, kellyb said "something like Nazism", not "Nazism", and that was in response to a conversation I was having in which I stated that ideologies which can cause people to kill do not require a religious component, and cited Hitler's irreligiosity as one example. If people prefer, Lennisit-Marxist Communist regimes are an easier fit.

The point isn't whether or not a truly atheistic society has ever existed, it's whether religious ideologies are different to ideologies which don't have a religious component in their ability to inspire people to kill for them. I would suggest that there is little evidence that they are, and that the question is complicated by the incorporation of religion into most aspects of life, particularly in the past. An example of the latter is the Church and Islam's role in the early development of science and mathematics - does this imply that religion is particularly prone to supporting science and mathematics? Or is it a product of how embedded in everyday life religion was when science and mathematics were in their infancy?
 
Or not. I think you have a dangerous habit of playing white or red, even or odd.
Nuance, please.

Okay, Aristotle: "The most certain of all basic principles is that contradictory propositions are not true simultaneously."

It is known that there are no gods.
It is not known that there no gods.

We can rewrite it to a contradiction: It is knowable and not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
So if one atheist claims that it is knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god. And other claims that it is not knowable if there are gods in any sense or not, including any versions of a creator god.
It then follows that at least one of the claims is false, thus without evidence and as such irrational.

Give it up, it is rational not to claim the existence of gods, because there is no positive evidence for the existence of gods, but from there doesn't follow that all versions of reasoning leading to be an atheist are rational.

With regard

PS ynot, atheism is not irrational, but some atheists are as per the example above.
 
So:
Strong: There is evidence that there are no gods.
Weak: It is unknown if there are any gods.

The 2 are in contradiction to each other, so one of the positions is irrational.

Taking a different tack to others - I don't think there is a contradiction there. You can have evidence for something without knowing whether or not it's true.

That's how science works - you form a hypothesis and try to disprove it. If you fail to disprove it, then that's evidence that your hypothesis is correct. That doesn't mean that your hypothesis is correct. It's not immediately declared a fact. No, more evidence is gathered and you (and other people) try to find other ways to disprove it. The more people fail to disprove it, the more evidence there is that it's correct. But it's only when there's a sizeable body of evidence that supports it that it's considered a theory - and even the most well-supported theory has the unspoken caveat that it can be overturned by enough new contradictory evidence.

It's perfectly reasonable to be aware of evidence that there are no gods, and yet not know whether or not there are any gods.
 
Last edited:
Taking a different tack to others - I don't think there is a contradiction there. You can have evidence for something without knowing whether or not it's true.

That's how science works - you form a hypothesis and try to disprove it. If you fail to disprove it, then that's evidence that your hypothesis is correct. That doesn't mean that your hypothesis is correct. It's not immediately declared a fact. No, more evidence is gathered and you (and other people) try to find other ways to disprove it. The more people fail to disprove it, the more evidence there is that it's correct. But it's only when there's a sizeable body of evidence that supports it that it's considered a theory - and even the most well-supported theory has the unspoken caveat that it can be overturned by enough new contradictory evidence.

It's perfectly reasonable to be aware of evidence that there are no gods, and yet not know whether or not there are any gods.

We enter epistemology and metaphysics now. :) Do you want to proceed?

With regards
 
No we're not.
...

Since we now are going to enter cognitive relativism in connection with some form of subjectivity, we might as well stop.
It goes like this:
Me: This is about metaphysics and epistemology.
You: No, it is not.
Me: Yes, it is.

The only way you can explain us both including our individual cognition within reality is through the use of cognitive relativism in connection with some form of subjectivity and combine that with a limit for how evidence works in regards to metaphysics and epistemology.

With regard
 
The only way you can explain us both including our individual cognition within reality is through the use of cognitive relativism in connection with some form of subjectivity and combine that with a limit for how evidence works in regards to metaphysics and epistemology.

That wasn't the subject of our discussion.
 
That wasn't the subject of our discussion.

Yes, it was. Is there a difference between knowledge and evidence? How do those two tie into what we can say about reality? What is reality? What does having reality independently of the mind mean?

In those questions we have cognitive relativity, subjectivity, epistemology and metaphysics tied together. :)

With regard
 
Yes, it was.

No, it wasn't.

Is there a difference between knowledge and evidence?

Yes. I explained the difference. That difference is one of the foundations of the scientific method, and the scientific method is provably effective.

How do those two tie into what we can say about reality? What is reality? What does having reality independently of the mind mean?

None of these things are relevant to the discussion we were having, which was whether there's a contradiction in there being evidence for the non-existence of gods and not knowing that there are no gods. I explained why there is not. If you disagree, then you can address what I said.

The place to start would be in either explaining how I'm wrong about the scientific method, or providing evidence that the scientific method is ineffective. The latter might be a hard sell while using a computer, though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom