Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

In soccer, there is a physical theory that does lead to a breaking ball. If you hit a ball hard enough you get into a turbulent air flow regime that has lower drag and is a poor region for getting a curve. If you hit the ball slower, the ball has higher drag coefficent and also curves from the spin affect more.

To get the magic breaking affect, you hit the ball a bit harder that the transition between these two air flow regions. The ball starts with low drag and almost no bend, however as it slow and goes through the transition region it will pick up both curve and more drag causing an unnatural curve. So the theory goes.

I don't know how that changes when you add stitching to a ball, as in a baseball.

Walt
 
I have bowled a lot particularly when I was younger. So my first thought was of course it hugs the line then curves in. But then thinking about it and visualizing the curve of the ball I realized no it doesn't really. What happens is that you release the ball near the middle of the lane then is travels outward at an angle and kisses the gutter for a few feet then sharply curves inward towards the pins. It basically travels in a classic parabolic arc with the center of the arc being x degrees off center to the lane.

Nope :)

Watch 'The biggest hook you will see in bowling' ... no way this is a symmetrical curve

 
Good to know. I wan't aware only the first part of the lane lane was coated. I did know that the ball isn't symmetrical because of the holes. Which of course is how you can spin the ball by snapping upwards of your approach. If you want some real fun when bowling try using a 8 lb. kids ball and palming it.

If you think rocket surgery is hard, try designing bowling balls. :D It's not just the finger holes. The core itself is not a consistent density. You can see some designs here: http://www.madehow.com/Volume-4/Bowling-Ball.html
 
Nope :)

Watch 'The biggest hook you will see in bowling' ... no way this is a symmetrical curve


Thanks but I already got it. Bowlings way easier to understand cause it's in two planes instead of three like baseball.

I may need to take that back. (Just watched the video) How is that not parabolic curve? Going to look again but right now I don't see it.
 
Last edited:
So without having any data on the curvature of the ball all I have to got on is the video and my perception of it. I see nothing to show that that doesn't conform to this type of curve.


220px-Parabola.svg.png


I could be wrong.
V
 
Just wanted to point out for a little fun that the reason they are those little dots on the approach and the little arrows down the lane is so you can curve the ball correctly. Also if you don't bowl a lot but want to get a good score 150 or above get the heaviest ball you can handle and throw it a hard as you can in the cap between the first two pins.
 
Just wanted to point out for a little fun that the reason they are those little dots on the approach and the little arrows down the lane is so you can curve the ball correctly. Also if you don't bowl a lot but want to get a good score 150 or above get the heaviest ball you can handle and throw it a hard as you can in the cap between the first two pins.

This is how I bowl :)
 
It is a curve from zero to infinity.
No. That illustration is just one example of a parabola. Only a small subset have the property you cite.

A parabola is a conic section. Any conic section. The classic parabola is x squared=y. But you can also have x=y squared or x cubed=y squared.
No. That wiki article you cited has the general formula for a parabola. Any formula including cubes (or any other higher power) is not a parabola or even a conic section.

Okay I was wrong air friction is a factor in determining whether or or not it is a parabola. So would air resistance cause an elipse, that's a lot like a parabola but with two focci.
No. Including air friction is the analysis of a baseball, shuttlecock or any other throw object introduces a nonlinear term into the equation of motion which means the resultant trajectory is not described by any conic section.
 
I have to say, I'm shocked at what a difference that makes.
After the Houston Astrodome was built a question arose as to the effect of the air conditioning on home runs. I was lucky enough to be involved in the study of that question. It was fun. When the stadium was inactive we did some field work to roughly determine the effects of turning on the air conditioning in terms of air flow. Then some simple modeling showed that the currents induced by the running of the air conditioning could affect the distance the ball could travel by over 4 feet. I found that to be counter intuitive.
 
No. That wiki article you cited has the general formula for a parabola. Any formula including cubes (or any other higher power) is not a parabola or even a conic section.

I wasn't talking about cubes I was talking about taking a number to the power of 3. But trying to figure out a rational answer of x to the third power= y to the second power makes my head hurt so I'll leave if alone.
 
God, I love this place! A total geekout on a baseball question. Which is exactly what I was looking forward to.

Why couldn't all you people have been in my high school?
 
No, they don't.

But baseball trajectories HAVE start and endpoints.

So I wrote out this big long response agreeing with you then disagreeing with you so basically I'm really not sure about how baseballs fly. I saw earlier that somebody posted a bunch of data on flight data on baseballs. Would somebody be willing to make a graphic of the data? What I have a hard time with is not seeing the flight as a parabolic arc. While a I understand air resistance is a factor over a distance of 60 feet in a stadium that is a minimal factor.



And in this I could just be talking out of my ass
V
 
While I understand the argument in the OP, it's just not true that a curveball ONLY moves based on the batter's perspective.

Not to single out Trane, but how many posts in this thread thought the OP was talking about curve-balls and not what it was actually talking about*

In fact the OP clearly discusses how curve-balls are real, but many people post like it said the opposite.

*The OP is only saying that a pitch (refereed to in the OP as breaking) that makes a distinct angle change at a specific point in space is an optical illusion. NOT that curve-balls are an optical illusion.

Then you have the posts confusing that with how a curve is more distinct as the pitch reaches the plate because of the loss of velocity.....
 
Last edited:
So I wrote out this big long response agreeing with you then disagreeing with you so basically I'm really not sure about how baseballs fly. I saw earlier that somebody posted a bunch of data on flight data on baseballs. Would somebody be willing to make a graphic of the data? What I have a hard time with is not seeing the flight as a parabolic arc. While a I understand air resistance is a factor over a distance of 60 feet in a stadium that is a minimal factor.



And in this I could just be talking out of my ass
V

So reading some more I realize what I might visualizing are actually hyperbolic arcs and no parabolic arcs. The problem I have is one the math goes beyond planar I just get lost. So once again


I could just be talking out of my ass
V
 
Two things:
1) Didn't Adair make this point in his Physics of Baseball report back in the 80s? (and it ended up a book in the early 90s - I have it somewhere). He noted that a curve ball had a regular path and there was nothing sharp about it. He just didn't make a big deal over it.

2) The "rising fastball is an optical illusion" line is kind of true, kind of not. It's not really an optical illusion. It is more of, "We are used to seeing a ball drop by x, and that is what we have in our mind as a normal, straight fastball. This fastball doesn't drop as much, which means it arrives higher than we expect it to arrive for a straight fastball." When you've been conditioned to see as many pitches from a pitching machine, and have it in your head that those pitches are coming straight (not falling), than pitches that don't fall as much are interpreted as rising.

3) What about wiffle balls?
 
Just in regard to the opening post, there is another sport (in addition to football and 10-pin bowling) in which a swinging (i.e. breaking) ball is commonplace, and that sport is cricket, where in-swing, out-swing, and now reverse swing bowling is routine.

I don't know of any instance where the swing of a base-ball is compared to the swing of a cricket ball (here again the "lateness" of the swing gives the most dangerous deliveries). It seems likely that in cricket, where a ball is used for some 400-500 deliveries, and the bowler works on the ball by rubbing one side, the arcs would be much greater. (Note that the "break" of a cricket ball is something different, this is the change in direction of a ball after it bounces on the pitch).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom