Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

Which of course I have now graphed for myself and realized you were right. But you couldn't bother doing that.

And you apparently couldn't be bothered reading Wikipedia articles, using Google, reading a basic maths textbook, or listening to anything anyone said. It's not like polynomials are some kind of obscure, arcane secrets, they're extremely basic maths taught to children barely into their teens, and it's not exactly hard to find out information about them if you're interested. But despite that, you insisted on arguing with people over something you must have known that you didn't actually understand. Don't blame others for your own laziness.
 
Where as 2 meters x 2 meters x 2 meters = 8 meters cubed ......

Nooooooooooo. It's 8 cubic metres.

8 metres cubed is friggin' hundreds of cubic metres ;)
 
Last edited:
As a sophomore in high school I got to face a pitcher (senior) who went into the minors. It was funny when he threw his fastball. I saw him do his wind-up, then I heard the ball hit the catcher's mitt. Talk about an optical illusion - he made the damn thing disappear.

Apparently your experience isn't uncommon...

Jonah Leher, in How We Decide, reports that major-league batters potentially make decisions about a pitch long before it has left the pitcher's hand. A typical pitch takes something like .35 seconds to reach home plate, it takes .25 seconds for a a batter to engage muscles in a swing, leaving .1 second for a decision. Leher explains why even these estimates are generous. Google "how we decide baseball pitches" and you can see this section of his book.
 
I have heard it more than once in the context of "his shot may not be as hard as some others, but it is a heavy shot" - inbuing the puck with a hitherto unknown physical property.
I see what you mean. You're right; some commentators seem to suggest that a player's shot, even though slower in speed, somehow has more force behind it as if it were self-propelled or suddenly quadrupled in mass.
 
I see what you mean. You're right; some commentators seem to suggest that a player's shot, even though slower in speed, somehow has more force behind it as if it were self-propelled or suddenly quadrupled in mass.

Cricket commentators say similar things about some bowlers, that they bowl a heavy ball. I've yet to find a sensible explanation of what this might mean in physics terms, but I do know what they're trying to say.
 
Cricket commentators say similar things about some bowlers, that they bowl a heavy ball. I've yet to find a sensible explanation of what this might mean in physics terms, but I do know what they're trying to say.

Probably something to do with height and angle of delivery, digging in and getting action off the pitch (i.e. the turf, for our non-cricketing friends) . Ball speed through the air might equate Malcolm Marshall with Michael Holding (say) but they certainly bowled 'differently'.

Otherwise ... :confused:
 
Probably something to do with height and angle of delivery, digging in and getting action off the pitch (i.e. the turf, for our non-cricketing friends) . Ball speed through the air might equate Malcolm Marshall with Michael Holding (say) but they certainly bowled 'differently'.

Otherwise ... :confused:

Possibly this refers to the degree of "bounce" off the pitch; the ability of the ball to rear off a good length. Joel Garner (and Glen McGrath) were yards slower than Holding or Marshall, yet their height enabled a very spiteful bounce that got good batsmen out. (Garner in particular was regarded as the most "dangerous" of the West Indians quicks - not only was he the bowler most likely to get a man out, he was most likely to injure someone when the batsman misjudged how high the ball would rear; mind you, Michael Holding was not a short man).

The bounce off the pitch is also important for slow bowlers, regardless of whether the ball deviated or not through the air or off the pitch.
 
And you apparently couldn't be bothered reading Wikipedia articles, using Google, reading a basic maths textbook, or listening to anything anyone said. It's not like polynomials are some kind of obscure, arcane secrets, they're extremely basic maths taught to children barely into their teens, and it's not exactly hard to find out information about them if you're interested. But despite that, you insisted on arguing with people over something you must have known that you didn't actually understand. Don't blame others for your own laziness.

So I say I was wrong and get attacked for saying I was wrong by a mod that's really nice. And my own laziness I studied all this when I was younger but it's not like it's part of my daily life. So maybe somebody could have bothered to actually to explain it instead of saying UHUH your wrong. Which I have still not seen an explanation why I'm wrong. Yes I am but why am I.
 
Last edited:
a mod that's really nice.

Why thank you.

So maybe somebody could have bothered to actually to explain it instead of saying UHUH your wrong.

Someone did bother to explain it. The fact remains that you are complaining about people not bothering to do things, when the whole exchange is the result of you not bothering to spend a minute or two actually learning about the subject you are trying to argue about. It's hardly an attack to point out that that is lazy.

Which I have still not seen an explanation why I'm wrong. Yes I am but why am I.

It has been explained multiple times. You are wrong because the definitions of the terms you use are not the correct ones. By definition parabolas are a subset of conic sections, therefore it is wrong to claim all conic sections are parabolas. By definition a parabola has the equation
ff5f9c68cfa28896e8a9dabcf3b7f067.png
* therefore it is wrong to claim that a parabola can have a cubic term. That really is all there is to it. These terms mean specific things, and how you used them was wrong. OK, technically this is how you are wrong. I cannot answer why you are wrong, since a couple of minutes with Google or Wikipedia should be enough to prevent someone from making these mistakes.

*From Wikimedia.
 
Baseballs curve for the same reason that wings on airplanes create lift.

If a curveball is woo, then you should be terrified every time you board an airplane.

An airplane's wings create lift by deflecting air downwards in combination with enough forward speed that the upward force of the deflected air on the underside of the wing is equal to or greater than the downward pull of gravity. As baseballs do not have wings, they cannot operate by the same principle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom