Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

A parabola is a conic section. Any conic section.

Just to add to the maths education here, this part is wrong as well. Yes, a parabola is a conic section, but there are other non-parabola conic sections - ellipses and hyperbolas (I have no idea what the plural of hyperbola is, I keep wanting to call them hyperbole). Circles are sometimes included as well, but they're really just special cases of ellipses. See here.
 
While we're wandering onto discussion of tenpin bowling ...

Back in the 60's I bowled in a minor league for a year or two. Started as a novice and improved (they used a handicap system, so being a poor bowler wasn't the end of the world). Using my reliable straight-ball technique I got up around 140-150 average. Pretty much gave up bowling after that. OK so far...

Nearly 40 years later I found myself bowling every few weeks with some students I was working with. I found I was scoring 150ish reliably from the outset, and improved my old pb of 187 to 223.

And there seemed to be far fewer of the horrendous splits that a straight-ball so easily produces.

What happened in those intervening years to make the game so much easier?

Lane quality/uniformity and especially ball design.
 
OK. I have to ask : is there any baseball video of those jumping ball ?
I keep hearing a lot of theory, but not much evidence.

Or did i miss a link hidden in any of the above post ?

There are plenty of videos of curve balls. Here's one:




The optical illusion that the study talks about is best viewed from the batter's point of view. The illusion is what changes the curve from a smooth sweep to what appears to be a sharp turn.

Two of the better pitchers in the National League will be squaring off in the NLCS tomorrow, Tim Lincecum and Roy Halladay. There should be quite a few wicked curves (as well as scientifically inaccurate commentary) thrown during the game.:D
 
Thanks for the video. But we seem to speak all of a different things. A curve ball, however sharply decending due to friction , turbulence, spin, is still describing a curve and (in absence of any sudden wind blow) has only a smooth trajectory, and a rate of vertical motion change more or less constant over the short trajectory.

But the description I keep reading from break ball jumping up and down decidely speak of a non smooth "a jump" in the trajectory.

So I have got the feeling that people speaks of two different things. Curve trajectory aren't new and exist in different type of sport, heck including golf. But it does not seem to be what the break-jump is about.

So I am asking any proponent that a break-jump happens, do anybody have any video evidence.

Otherwise I will simply start thinking those break ball don't exists, and they are *only* an optical illusion.
 
So I am asking any proponent that a break-jump happens, do anybody have any video evidence.

I don't think anyone in this thread is arguing that such a thing exists.

I'm sure there's a MLB forum somewhere with someone dense enough to defend the voodoo position.
 
I don't think anyone in this thread is arguing that such a thing exists.

I'm sure there's a MLB forum somewhere with someone dense enough to defend the voodoo position.

Yeah :). Foudn a few actualy randomly googling.

I thought the same was spoken here but I was obviously mistaken. Will not be the first time nor the last.
 
Thanks for the video. But we seem to speak all of a different things. A curve ball, however sharply decending due to friction , turbulence, spin, is still describing a curve and (in absence of any sudden wind blow) has only a smooth trajectory, and a rate of vertical motion change more or less constant over the short trajectory.

But the description I keep reading from break ball jumping up and down decidely speak of a non smooth "a jump" in the trajectory.

So I have got the feeling that people speaks of two different things. Curve trajectory aren't new and exist in different type of sport, heck including golf. But it does not seem to be what the break-jump is about.

So I am asking any proponent that a break-jump happens, do anybody have any video evidence.

Otherwise I will simply start thinking those break ball don't exists, and they are *only* an optical illusion.

Essentially what many are saying is that it appears to the batter like a "big jump", and that some pitchers, such as Halladay in tomorrow nights NLCS, throw a breaking ball that *always* looks like it breaks sharper and later than almost any other pitcher.

In effect, batters cannot judge whether his breaking ball is going to be a (straight) fastball or a breaking pitch until it is too late to adjust their swing. For some reason batters cannot perceive the "smooth trajectory" of his curve ball - they see a straight trajectory and then a sharp break at the last fractional second.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the video. But we seem to speak all of a different things. A curve ball, however sharply decending due to friction , turbulence, spin, is still describing a curve and (in absence of any sudden wind blow) has only a smooth trajectory, and a rate of vertical motion change more or less constant over the short trajectory.

But the description I keep reading from break ball jumping up and down decidely speak of a non smooth "a jump" in the trajectory.

So I have got the feeling that people speaks of two different things. Curve trajectory aren't new and exist in different type of sport, heck including golf. But it does not seem to be what the break-jump is about.

So I am asking any proponent that a break-jump happens, do anybody have any video evidence.

Otherwise I will simply start thinking those break ball don't exists, and they are *only* an optical illusion.

Here's a quote from the study:
Even though the differences between foveal and peripheral resolution are large, these differences do not usually disrupt our perception of seamless visual space. Here we examine a motion stimulus in which the shift from foveal to peripheral viewing creates a dramatic spatial/temporal discontinuity.

The batter perceives the curve as greater/sharper than it is because of the shift in focus. You can see, by the example in the video, that the curve, while dramatic, is not as sharp as TV commentators and baseball raconteurs would have you believe.

There's no doubt that curveballs curve, though.

ETA: I see I was beaten to the punch (or swing).
 
Last edited:
CurtC -

A golf ball will rise due to its spin. A baseball can and will rise due to spin as well; I've been told it would take about 10,000 rpms to make it happen.... Which is something that a pitcher can't impart on the ball.
 
I would think that if the ball is spinning too fast, the rotation would just be a blur and the optical illusion would not be present. I'm not sure at what point that would happen though, and if it would be in the range of spin speed for normal pitches. If it is, a pitch with less curve might be harder to hit in some sense.

Also, I would assume that for a ball that is dirty on one side, the effect would be more obvious.
 
I would think that if the ball is spinning too fast, the rotation would just be a blur and the optical illusion would not be present. I'm not sure at what point that would happen though, and if it would be in the range of spin speed for normal pitches. If it is, a pitch with less curve might be harder to hit in some sense.

Also, I would assume that for a ball that is dirty on one side, the effect would be more obvious.

Your premise is why I used the word supposedly. I'm convinced that there's an optical illusion of some sort. I'm just not sure how to describe or replicate it.

As yet another aside, the worst thing about curve balls in little league was that we had to deal with pitchers perfecting their craft. Sometimes you'd stay in there figuring it was a curve, but it wouldn't break. Ouch!

As a sophomore in high school I got to face a pitcher (senior) who went into the minors. It was funny when he threw his fastball. I saw him do his wind-up, then I heard the ball hit the catcher's mitt. Talk about an optical illusion - he made the damn thing disappear.
 
CurtC -

A golf ball will rise due to its spin. A baseball can and will rise due to spin as well; I've been told it would take about 10,000 rpms to make it happen.... Which is something that a pitcher can't impart on the ball.

Finally,

It is not that a rising fast ball is impossible, only impossible for a human to throw one.

The optical illusion idea probably comes from a viewers ability to determine how much spin, and what plane the spin is in, that the pitcher has put on the ball.

As far as I know, the plane of the spin of the baseball is the difference between sliders, curves and screwballs.

A ball with spin is not going to follow a parabola, it is going to be a more complex curve than that but still a smooth curve none the less.

Or it could be a parabolic trajectory, just not one with axis of symmetry in line with the center of the earth. Now that would confuse a hitter or two.

The more spin on the ball the more it will drop compared to a ball with no spin.

Tennis player hit topspin for that very reason. Hit flat and hard 3 foot over the net, the ball is out. Hit with topspin and just as hard and the ball is in.
 
Okay I now understand that a parabola cannot be x to the third=y. Because I went ahead and graphed it. If somebody had bothered to show the graph earlier in the discussion I would have understood the argument easier.
 
Somehow I don't think that's the answer he was expecting. I read his earlier post as "So you're telling me that 2x2x2=8 is a cube? What kind of idiotic thing to say is that?"

What I was trying to say without a measurement it is not a CUBE is is cubing a number. So 2 x 2 x 2 =2 cubed =8. Where as 2 meters x 2 meters x 2 meters = 8 meters cubed or a 2 meter CUBE.

And yes you are right that was what I was trying to say as well
 
Last edited:
No. That wiki article you cited has the general formula for a parabola. Any formula including cubes (or any other higher power) is not a parabola or even a conic section.

Which of course I have now graphed for myself and realized you were right. But you couldn't bother doing that.
 
I would think that if the ball is spinning too fast, the rotation would just be a blur...

Have you ever noticed, that if a spinning baseball is on its way to you, the point on the ball with the axis of rotation will appear as a red dot? It's the blur of the red stitching staying in a constant small area, but the stitching around the spinning equator part of the ball will be too blurred to make out.

I've heard that batters (consciously or unconsciously) use the location of this dot to gauge what kind of pitch it is.




In effect, batters cannot judge whether his breaking ball is going to be a (straight) fastball or a breaking pitch until it is too late to adjust their swing. For some reason batters cannot perceive the "smooth trajectory" of his curve ball - they see a straight trajectory and then a sharp break at the last fractional second.
I think that some people don't realize how hard it is to hit a pitch thrown by a professional pitcher. A fastball is in the air for less than half a second, and a batter has to decide whether to swing early enough to have time to get his bat around, so he has to decide whether to swing by the time the ball has come about halfway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom