Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

I'm not a baseball fan, so I had never heard of a "breaking ball" until now. The idea that a pitch could be thrown to suddenly break out of it's normal arc or flight path at some point sounds incredibly wooish to me.

What would explain this sudden break? It sounds like you would have to use a rigged ball, or... magic? I would need to see high speed footage of this actually happening. Preferably from multiple angles, with some sort of measurement points in the background.

Imagine the strong resistance that this(the idea that these are just curveballs) will receive in the baseball community.

-Batters find it easier to swallow the idea that they missed the mythical "breaking ball", than a conventional throw.

-Pitchers who believe they have been throwing this awesome pitch for years.

-Fans who will be disappointed that some of the magic has been taken out of their game, or won't want to feel foolish that they believed in something that wasn't quite right.
 
I wonder how these tests were conducted. Every pitcher's breaking ball is unique. Watching from various outside perspectives (multiple TV angles, multiple seating sight lines at stadiums, watching from various fielding positions including catching, pitching/catching myself with no batter in the box), it surely seems that pitches break differently, even for the same pitcher. That's one heck of an optical illusion, but I can provisionally accept this research if it took into account the almost infinite grips, arm speeds, arm angles, spin angle and velocity, pitch angle and velocity, etc. of real-time baseball.

How about the slider? that pitch often appears to follow the parabolic arc described for the breaking ball. Does that pitch actually go straight then? The point is, many pitchers throw a pitch which follows a smooth arc to the naked eye. Why don't those pitches fool the eye as well?

Watch Roy Halladay on Saturday night. Every pitch he throws appears to have very late movement. Watch Tim Lincecum in the same game. His stuff doesn't appear to break as late, but he employs some incredible deception in his delivery which makes his pitches extremely difficult for a batter to track. Halladay challenges the batter more directly and does not employ much deception - he says here it is, in the strike zone, hit it if you can. They can't. Why do his pitches appear to break so much later than almost every other pitcher in baseball?

Inquiring minds want to know.
 
I'm not a baseball fan, so I had never heard of a "breaking ball" until now. The idea that a pitch could be thrown to suddenly break out of it's normal arc or flight path at some point sounds incredibly wooish to me.

What would explain this sudden break? It sounds like you would have to use a rigged ball, or... magic? I would need to see high speed footage of this actually happening. Preferably from multiple angles, with some sort of measurement points in the background.

Imagine the strong resistance that this(the idea that these are just curveballs) will receive in the baseball community.

-Batters find it easier to swallow the idea that they missed the mythical "breaking ball", than a conventional throw.

-Pitchers who believe they have been throwing this awesome pitch for years.

-Fans who will be disappointed that some of the magic has been taken out of their game, or won't want to feel foolish that they believed in something that wasn't quite right.

No offense, but if you ever stood in the batters box against a capable breaking ball pitcher, you would understand why freaks of hand-eye coordination with world class physical talent will swear to you that a Roy Halladay pitch breaks late. If the pitch actually follows a smooth arc, it is beyond human capability to visually pick that up in the batters box. Pitchers who do not have the capability to create that optical illusion don't make it to the majors, unless they throw a 100 MPH fastball, or a killer slider.

It flat out will never matter what the actual movement is. No amount of experimental evidence will enable a human being to discern otherwise.
 
Conversations like this always remind me of the immortal Dizzy Dean. When told of scientific evidence that a breaking ball doesn't break (the thought back then - 80+ years ago - was that it was completely an optical illusion, and the ball traveled in a straight line) - Dizzy said "You tell that scientist feller that he can stand behind that tree over there and I'll whump him with an optical illusion".

I've seen 15 year olds throw breaking balls and hit bottles set up behind trees from 60 feet away. One could hit a bottle placed behind and several feet over on the far side of the tree; the ball would appear to bystanders to wrap around the tree.
 
I'm also curious to know what the physics of a legitimate breaking ball would be.

The only variation I can see possible would be the actual curve of the parabola, and at what point along the arc the batter was located.
 
A baseball loses over 10% of its speed on the way to the plate, but very little of its spin, so although the curve is smooth, it is slightly sharper near the end.
 
Conversations like this always remind me of the immortal Dizzy Dean. When told of scientific evidence that a breaking ball doesn't break (the thought back then - 80+ years ago - was that it was completely an optical illusion, and the ball traveled in a straight line) - Dizzy said "You tell that scientist feller that he can stand behind that tree over there and I'll whump him with an optical illusion".

That makes no sense. Had these scientists never played wiffle ball or table tennis? The curves there are so extreme as to be undeniable. Even for tennis the effect of spin is quite clear. Obviously the effect would be less for a baseball, but there is no reason to think it would be zero.
 
I'm not a baseball fan, so I had never heard of a "breaking ball" until now. The idea that a pitch could be thrown to suddenly break out of it's normal arc or flight path at some point sounds incredibly wooish to me.

What would explain this sudden break? It sounds like you would have to use a rigged ball, or... magic? I would need to see high speed footage of this actually happening. Preferably from multiple angles, with some sort of measurement points in the background.

Imagine the strong resistance that this(the idea that these are just curveballs) will receive in the baseball community.

-Batters find it easier to swallow the idea that they missed the mythical "breaking ball", than a conventional throw.

-Pitchers who believe they have been throwing this awesome pitch for years.

-Fans who will be disappointed that some of the magic has been taken out of their game, or won't want to feel foolish that they believed in something that wasn't quite right.

You people need to go to a game. And learn to use Google. The physics of the breaking ball have been studied to death.

http://webusers.npl.illinois.edu/~a-nathan/pob/index.html
 
A baseball loses over 10% of its speed on the way to the plate, but very little of its spin, so although the curve is smooth, it is slightly sharper near the end.

But that is expected and not exactly what i read people are claiming. It sounds to me there is a sort of jump down, or even UP, right at the end before the batting, and that is how I read the claim. Naturally I might be totally misreading.
 
This conversation has been going on for 100 years. It occurs to me that maybe some of the most repected hitters in the games history - Ruth, Dimaggio, Williams, Hornsby, etc. - maybe they could discern the actual trajectory to a more precise degree than the other 10's of thousands of professionals who have played the game. One thing is for certain - the best hitters in the game can pick up the spin/lack of spin of the ball, its trajectory and relative velocity, and process that information to arrive at the balls final location in relation to the leading edge of the plate, in 2 tenths of a second or less.
 
I'm certain that baseballs obey the laws of physics. Just as cricket balls, tennis balls and table-tennis balls do, all of which curve in flight for different reasons.

That a heavily spinning ball might curve more dramatically as it slows wouldn't surprise me. Nor the claim that there's an element of optical illusion to it.

I would have thought that film could settle the matter.
 
Last edited:
Then why do some curve balls appear to break and not others?

I'm not a baseball fan, so I had never heard of a "breaking ball" until now. The idea that a pitch could be thrown to suddenly break out of it's normal arc or flight path at some point sounds incredibly wooish to me.

Why does a bowling ball hug the line until the very end, when it suddenly hooks? Can the same thing happen to a ball in the air?

(I'm not arguing, just asking. Physics and higher level math were my weakest classes in school.)
 
That makes no sense. Had these scientists never played wiffle ball or table tennis? The curves there are so extreme as to be undeniable. Even for tennis the effect of spin is quite clear. Obviously the effect would be less for a baseball, but there is no reason to think it would be zero.

I didn't do the experiment, and I wasn't there when the results were related to Dizzy. It's just a story that a true baseball fan would appreciate and chuckle over. I doubt if the "scientist" claimed the curve was zero, just negligible in relation to the optical illusion perceived. Dizzy was essentially saying that the curve can be tennis or table tennis comparable, and he proved it. Wiffle balls are something else - I could throw a wiffle ball that dipped, rose, and dipped again on the way to the plate (or appeared to). I could throw a wiffle ball which curved 30 yards. Those holes were magic.
 
Last edited:
Why does a bowling ball hug the line until the very end, when it suddenly hooks?
Do they, though? I can imagine that as the ball gets closer to the pins, you see the relative horizontal movement more clearly, making it appear to curve more as it gets closer.

If it really does happen, then I'm reminded of trying to take off in a car when you are in snow or ice. If you step hard on the gas, you just sit there and spin. You have to apply power very slowly and evenly for the tires to grab and not break free. I'm imagining a bowling ball thrown with too much spin to grab the lane effectively. As it travels down the lane and loses spin due to friction, it eventually slows enough to grip the lane and curve.

As should be obvious - I'm speculating wildly, and making no claims.
 
Let me throw another "curve ball" into the discussion - the knuckle ball. The knuckle ball, when thrown properly (which about 12 pitchers have been able to do in the history of the game) floats to the plate like a butterfly, boobing and weaving in a completely unpredictable manner. The few pitchers able to throw a knuckler for a strike could pitch well into their 40's and were often unhittable.

Is a knuckler an optical illusion?
 
Do they, though? I can imagine that as the ball gets closer to the pins, you see the relative horizontal movement more clearly, making it appear to curve more as it gets closer.

If it really does happen, then I'm reminded of trying to take off in a car when you are in snow or ice. If you step hard on the gas, you just sit there and spin. You have to apply power very slowly and evenly for the tires to grab and not break free. I'm imagining a bowling ball thrown with too much spin to grab the lane effectively. As it travels down the lane and loses spin due to friction, it eventually slows enough to grip the lane and curve.

As should be obvious - I'm speculating wildly, and making no claims.

One would think that a ball in contact with the ground would be able to curve easily.

ETA: what I mean is, I can "roll" a baseball with backspin and make it stop its forward motion and reverse itself on the proper surface. So the physics of a bowling ball's spin and a thrown baseball's would very different.
 
Last edited:
Why does a bowling ball hug the line until the very end, when it suddenly hooks? Can the same thing happen to a ball in the air?

Because it's skidding across the lane early on. At the end it slows enough to gain traction. Cars behave pretty much the same way on slippery surfaces - too many revs driving on snow may give less traction than less revs.

edit: cross-posted, and agree with Roger :)
 
Last edited:
It does not take that long watching the game before you can tell the difference between a fastball, a cut fastball, a curve, a slurve, a slider, a screwball, etc. from almost anywhere in the park.

As you said before, this is obvious in bullpen sessions without a batter, and also obvious when a batter simply takes a pitch.

I can understand the argument in this form: the quality of a curveball may be heavily dependent on the batter's perspective. This would explain why two identical curveballs in all respects (speed, spin, amount of curve) appear completely different when thrown by (1) someone in highschool and (2) Pedro Martinez. The first curveball is preceeded by an 80mph fastball with no movement, the latter by a 95mph fastball that tails. Even if Pedro throws a crappy, for him, curveball, the difference between it and what came before may make it look much more daunting than than the high-schooler's.

MLB has uses technology to track the speed and movement of every pitch:

http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20071002&content_id=2245402&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb

We can literally obtain raw data for every single pitch thrown in a baseball game. While I understand the argument in the OP, it's just not true that a curveball ONLY moves based on the batter's perspective.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom