Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

I've always understood a breaking ball to be a curveball that hooks sharply as it nears the plate.

From what I'm hearing on this thread, deceleration + spin is a possible reason for a sharpening of the curve.

But the article also proposes a mechanism for an optical illusion which makes the ball appear, to the batter, to break more sharply than it actually does.

I think that's an accurate reading of the situation.

When they first started showing the pitch-trackers in MLB games I was surprised at how little curveballs actually moved. I would have sworn that a guy like Clayton Kershaw for the Dodgers had a curve that broke two feet. But there was the pitch tracker saying it was more like 5 inches.

Between curveballs, the spin will separate a good one from a bad one. What this research helps explain is why all curveballs, regardless of quality, appear to break more than they actually do. It's intersting.
 
This is an interesting article, but, really, all it is saying is that the batter has an additional perceptual disadvantage at judging the path of the ball. Very good hitters overcome this to an extent, but ultimately, they have to learn to lay off pitches that they can't hit.

Here's a quote from Ted Williams from The Science of Hitting on the subject of good vs. bad pitches:

''I have said that a good hitter can hit a pitch that is over the plate three times better than a great hitter with a questionable ball in a tough spot. Pitchers still make enough mistakes to give you some in your happy zone. But the greatest hitter living can't hit bad balls good."

Good pitchers know how use that perception problem to make you swing at bad pitches.

ETA: Maybe one of the reasons Ted Williams was such a good hitter was his outstanding vision. Maybe his central vision area was wider than average or something.
 
Last edited:
breaking ball: a pitch that suddenly curves sharply as it reaches the plate, having curved gradually or not at all prior to the "break.

I've never heard this - I've always thought that a "breaking ball" was just one that has a vertical drop more than the batter would expect, and the pitcher does this with a combination of slower speed and topspin. It's mostly the slower speed that has the effect.

I never knew that some people thought that a breaking pitch would have a somewhat abrupt change in its motion.



That appears to be unanimous amongst those studying the physics of pitching - a thrown ( not thrown sidearm) baseball cannot rise - but it often appears to rise.
I have hit golf balls that I'm pretty positive do actually rise - that is, the path near the beginning is concave upwards. The times that I've done this have been crappy hits from an elevated tee, where the initial trajectory is slightly sloping downwards but the backspin causes it to level out and rise.



Him: "You know, it's tough to pitch on the coast, the ball really carries."
Me: "Really? That's surprising. We'll be right at sea level. The ball really carries in places like Denver, with thin air and no humidity.
At the same pressure and temperature, humidity actually decreases air drag. That's because at the same pressure and temperature, a given volume of air will have a set number of molecules. Humid air has some of the nitrogen and oxygen molecules replaced by water molecules, and water molecules are significantly lighter than either nitrogen or oxygen.
 
If you listen to hockey color commentators, you will occasionally hear about the defenseman who has a "heavy" slap shot. Apparently, moving pucks have linear velocity, angular velocity, and "heaviness".
I always took that to mean that they lean into the shot a little more than average and/or that they put more bend in the stick prior to letting it snap, not that there is anything literally heavy about the shot. I'm pretty sure it's just a figure of speech. Now, if we could just get them to stop saying, when discussing charging penalties, that "he left his feet" (when they mean "his feet left the ice"). And they all do it. :mad:
 
Let me throw another "curve ball" into the discussion - the knuckle ball. The knuckle ball, when thrown properly (which about 12 pitchers have been able to do in the history of the game) floats to the plate like a butterfly, boobing and weaving in a completely unpredictable manner. The few pitchers able to throw a knuckler for a strike could pitch well into their 40's and were often unhittable.

Is a knuckler an optical illusion?

My understanding is that a knuckle ball is a ball thrown with no spin. These balls would be more influenced by atmospheric affects so they will wobble more than a ball with spin. It's the same as a bullet shot from a rifled barrel as opposed to a smooth bore barrel. This also explains why most pitchers can't throw accurate knuckle balls , it's a lot harder to shoot a smooth bore accurately than a rifle.


ETA: Apparently it also causes vortices around the stitching which makes it tumble unpredictably.
 
Last edited:
I always took that to mean that they lean into the shot a little more than average and/or that they put more bend in the stick prior to letting it snap, not that there is anything literally heavy about the shot. I'm pretty sure it's just a figure of speech. Now, if we could just get them to stop saying, when discussing charging penalties, that "he left his feet" (when they mean "his feet left the ice"). And they all do it. :mad:

I have heard it more than once in the context of "his shot may not be as hard as some others, but it is a heavy shot" - inbuing the puck with a hitherto unknown physical property.
 
At the same pressure and temperature, humidity actually decreases air drag. That's because at the same pressure and temperature, a given volume of air will have a set number of molecules. Humid air has some of the nitrogen and oxygen molecules replaced by water molecules, and water molecules are significantly lighter than either nitrogen or oxygen.

True, but the extreme dryness of Denver, to be specific, effects the balls in such a way that they become more elastic:

Prior to the 2002 baseball season, studies determined that it was more the dry air rather than thin air which contributed to the more frequent home runs. It was found that baseballs stored in drier air are harder and therefore more elastic to the impact of the bat. A room-sized humidor was installed in which to store the baseballs, and since its introduction the number of home runs at Coors Field has decreased and is now nearly the same as other parks.[4]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coors_Field

It's a counterintuitive result.

I'm not sure if I knew that at the time I discussed the Pacific's gravity with my less than brilliant teammate, but the thin air was definitely legendary for its positive effect on hitters.
 
Last edited:
Do they, though? I can imagine that as the ball gets closer to the pins, you see the relative horizontal movement more clearly, making it appear to curve more as it gets closer.

If it really does happen, then I'm reminded of trying to take off in a car when you are in snow or ice. If you step hard on the gas, you just sit there and spin. You have to apply power very slowly and evenly for the tires to grab and not break free. I'm imagining a bowling ball thrown with too much spin to grab the lane effectively. As it travels down the lane and loses spin due to friction, it eventually slows enough to grip the lane and curve.

As should be obvious - I'm speculating wildly, and making no claims.

I have bowled a lot particularly when I was younger. So my first thought was of course it hugs the line then curves in. But then thinking about it and visualizing the curve of the ball I realized no it doesn't really. What happens is that you release the ball near the middle of the lane then is travels outward at an angle and kisses the gutter for a few feet then sharply curves inward towards the pins. It basically travels in a classic parabolic arc with the center of the arc being x degrees off center to the lane.
 
Like so many arguments, this one seems arise over the meaning of a word, in this case: "break." All bb players and fans are aware that curve balls break. They just do, okay. This means the ball follows a curve that does not follow the expected parabola. it does not mean there is a break in the continuity in the ball's trajectory. No thrown ball follows a perfect parabolic path because the speed of the ball is not constant throughout it's flight. If you want to see an extreme example, watch the trajectory of a badminton bird. You will see a smooth curve at the beginning followed by a very rapid drop towards the end. A curve ball does exactly the same thing, only not as extreme and without the feathers.
 
Like so many arguments, this one seems arise over the meaning of a word, in this case: "break." All bb players and fans are aware that curve balls break. They just do, okay. This means the ball follows a curve that does not follow the expected parabola. it does not mean there is a break in the continuity in the ball's trajectory. No thrown ball follows a perfect parabolic path because the speed of the ball is not constant throughout it's flight. If you want to see an extreme example, watch the trajectory of a badminton bird. You will see a smooth curve at the beginning followed by a very rapid drop towards the end. A curve ball does exactly the same thing, only not as extreme and without the feathers.

That is a parabola.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parabola
 
True, but the extreme dryness of Denver, to be specific, effects the balls in such a way that they become more elastic:


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coors_Field

It's a counterintuitive result.

I'm not sure if I knew that at the time I discussed the Pacific's gravity with my less than brilliant teammate, but the thin air was definitely legendary for its positive effect on hitters.

Regarding the humidors for balls, the Diamondbacks management team is debating whether to install one at Chase Field.
 
No, a badminton birdie starts off fast, then quickly slows down laterally.

Which is a parabola.


ETA. Look at the graphic in the link. Particularly at the bottom portion.
 
Last edited:
So one big misconception in this thread seems to be exactly what a parabola is. And if I had better graphic skills I would draw it out. But one thing a parabola is not is a smooth curve. It is a curve from zero to infinity.
 
I have bowled a lot particularly when I was younger. So my first thought was of course it hugs the line then curves in. But then thinking about it and visualizing the curve of the ball I realized no it doesn't really. What happens is that you release the ball near the middle of the lane then is travels outward at an angle and kisses the gutter for a few feet then sharply curves inward towards the pins. It basically travels in a classic parabolic arc with the center of the arc being x degrees off center to the lane.

A bowling ball actually hooks. The first 2/3 of the lane is coated with oil. There's a slight curve as it approaches the gutter because the spin is just slipping on the oil. Once it hits the drier wood, the spin kicks in and it hooks sharply. The trajectory is not symmetrical, which I believe is a requirement of a parabola. The ball itself is not a perfect sphere internally, which also plays a part in how it behaves.
 
A bowling ball actually hooks. The first 2/3 of the lane is coated with oil. There's a slight curve as it approaches the gutter because the spin is just slipping on the oil. Once it hits the drier wood, the spin kicks in and it hooks sharply. The trajectory is not symmetrical, which I believe is a requirement of a parabola. The ball itself is not a perfect sphere internally, which also plays a part in how it behaves.

Good to know. I wan't aware only the first part of the lane lane was coated. I did know that the ball isn't symmetrical because of the holes. Which of course is how you can spin the ball by snapping upwards of your approach. If you want some real fun when bowling try using a 8 lb. kids ball and palming it.
 
Which is a parabola.


ETA. Look at the graphic in the link. Particularly at the bottom portion.
Objects in a gravitational field with no air friction travel in a parabola. The more air friction, the less like a parabola it is. A shuttlecock is an extreme example of this.
 
Objects in a gravitational field with no air friction travel in a parabola. The more air friction, the less like a parabola it is. A shuttlecock is an extreme example of this.
I want to get the next part in but I was partly wrong and I apologize for insisting I was right.
A parabola is a conic section. Any conic section. The classic parabola is x squared=y. But you can also have x=y squared or x cubed=y squared. This is what I mean by not understanding what a parabola is. A parabola is a conic section. Wait for this after the break.

Okay I was wrong air friction is a factor in determining whether or or not it is a parabola. So would air resistance cause an elipse, that's a lot like a parabola but with two focci.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom