Baseball News: Breaking ball caused by batter (not pitcher)

I'm not a baseball fan, so I had never heard of a "breaking ball" until now. The idea that a pitch could be thrown to suddenly break out of it's normal arc or flight path at some point sounds incredibly wooish to me.

What would explain this sudden break? It sounds like you would have to use a rigged ball, or... magic? I would need to see high speed footage of this actually happening. Preferably from multiple angles, with some sort of measurement points in the background.

Baseballs curve for the same reason that wings on airplanes create lift.

If a curveball is woo, then you should be terrified every time you board an airplane.
 
One would think that a ball in contact with the ground would be able to curve easily.
Have you ever bowled? If you throw a ball with no spin whatsoever, it starts by just skidding, and then eventually starts rolling. But it's a gradual process - lanes are pretty slick relative to the ball's surface.

Oh, another thought. Performance of the ball depends on how the lane is waxed. If there is more grip at the pins than at the rest of the lane, it will hook more nearer the pins.
 
Because it's skidding across the lane early on. At the end it slows enough to gain traction. Cars behave pretty much the same way on slippery surfaces - too many revs driving on snow may give less traction than less revs.

edit: cross-posted, and agree with Roger :)

Ah. That explains why I can't make a bowling ball do that. I can't throw them hard enough to make them skid in the first place.

I don't think I'm likely to ever average much over 120.
 
Baseballs curve for the same reason that wings on airplanes create lift.

If a curveball is woo, then you should be terrified every time you board an airplane.
He said "break" not "curve". They are not synonyms.

Since others are using confusing language:
curve ball: a pitch that follows a smooth, symmetric curve as it approaches the plate:
breaking ball: a pitch that suddenly curves sharply as it reaches the plate, having curved gradually or not at all prior to the "break".

There is ample physics explaining the former, not so much for the latter.
 
He said "break" not "curve". They are not synonyms.

Since others are using confusing language:
curve ball: a pitch that follows a smooth, symmetric curve as it approaches the plate:
breaking ball: a pitch that suddenly curves sharply as it reaches the plate, having curved gradually or not at all prior to the "break".

There is ample physics explaining the former, not so much for the latter.

"Break" is just term for a curveball that appears to move quicker. This is also easily explainable with physics.

A ball spinning faster will create more pressure differential than one spinning slowing (holding the overall velocity constant). "Break" is just the colloquial term to describe the tighter spinning ball.

Just out of curiosity, when a pitcher is just throwing a bullpen session, what criteria do you think is employed to judge a quality curveball from a poor one? Is it just purely random?

If the pitcher, catcher, and pitching coach identify a quality curveball, then when thrown in a game, said curveball is more difficult to hit, what feature are all parties observing?

Now, if the claim is just that a curveball moves less and more slowly than people think, I don't disagree, but this whole discussion seems be created by scrutinizing a casual, non-specific word, "break," with scientific intensity.
 
Last edited:
Baseballs curve for the same reason that wings on airplanes create lift.

If a curveball is woo, then you should be terrified every time you board an airplane.

I understand why curveballs can be thrown.

I do not understand how you could throw a curveball that suddenly "breaks" at some point and deviates wildly out of its arc.
 
Have you ever bowled? If you throw a ball with no spin whatsoever, it starts by just skidding, and then eventually starts rolling. But it's a gradual process - lanes are pretty slick relative to the ball's surface.

Oh, another thought. Performance of the ball depends on how the lane is waxed. If there is more grip at the pins than at the rest of the lane, it will hook more nearer the pins.

I'm actually agreeing with you, I just don't think it can be related to a baseball curve in any meaningful way.
 
I understand why curveballs can be thrown.

I do not understand how you could throw a curveball that suddenly "breaks" at some point and deviates wildly out of its arc.

That's just an optical illusion. Same thing with a "rising" fastball.

That being said, the reason some fastballs appear to rise while others don't has to do with the velocity of said pitch.

Likewise, the "sharp breaking" curveballs are differentiated from "rolling" curveballs by actual physical properties, namely the speed and direction of the spin as well as the velocity of the pitch.
 
Last edited:
"Break" is just term for a curveball that appears to move quicker. This is also easily explainable with physics.

A ball spinning faster will create more pressure differential than one spinning slowing (holding the overall velocity constant). "Break" is just the colloquial term to describe the tighter spinning ball.

Just out of curiosity, when a pitcher is just throwing a bullpen session, what criteria do you think is employed to judge a quality curveball from a poor one? Is it just purely random?

If the pitcher, catcher, and pitching coach identify a quality curveball, then when thrown in a game, said curveball is more difficult to hit, what feature are all parties observing?

Now, if the claim is just that a curveball moves less and more slowly than people think, I don't disagree, but this whole discussion seems be created by scrutinizing a casual, non-specific word, "break," with scientific intensity.

I don't disagree with what you are saying about curveballs; it all seems very reasonable. The article in the OP however was about something very different, and it would seem from some google searching that both fans AND players believe in these throws that can suddenly deviate at the last moment from their arc.
 
That's just an optical illusion. Same thing with a "rising" fastball.

That appears to be unanimous amongst those studying the physics of pitching - a thrown ( not thrown sidearm) baseball cannot rise - but it often appears to rise. So here is an optical illusion that all - players, coaches, researchers - agree is an optical illusion. Doesn't stop batters from swinging and missing at the optical illusion, though.
 
That's just an optical illusion. Same thing with a "rising" fastball.

That being said, the reason some fastballs appear to rise while others don't has to do with the velocity of said pitch.

Likewise, the "sharp breaking" curveballs are differentiated from "rolling" curveballs by actual physical properties, namely the speed and direction of the spin as well as the velocity of the pitch.

We are in agreement then, I was only arguing against the idea that the ball actually does in reality what the illusion portrays.
 
I don't disagree with what you are saying about curveballs; it all seems very reasonable. The article in the OP however was about something very different, and it would seem from some google searching that both fans AND players believe in these throws that can suddenly deviate at the last moment from their arc.

Well, pointing out the ways sports fans and especially the dullards playing and coaching the games make mistakes in their understanding of physics is sort of shooting fish in the barrell. I say this as someone who played baseball in the Big12.

Here was an exchange I had with a fellow pitcher as we were flying to the West Coast for a series:

Him: "You know, it's tough to pitch on the coast, the ball really carries."
Me: "Really? That's surprising. We'll be right at sea level. The ball really carries in places like Denver, with thin air and no humidity. Why does the ball carry on the coast?"
Him: "Because the ocean has so much gravity."

Now, he was not unusually stupid for a ballplayer. Coaches are ex-ballplayers. Managers are ex-ballplayers.

There's a whole lot of dumb in that population.
 
Ah. That explains why I can't make a bowling ball do that. I can't throw them hard enough to make them skid in the first place.

I don't think I'm likely to ever average much over 120.

Don't give up. I used to average around 150 just by bowling straight (tho, at a slight angle across the lane). Bowling a hook is an advantage if you can do it well.

Now, how can I divert this thread into the magnificent mysteries of cricketing swing, cut and spin ? Not to mention the dreaded reverse swing :D
 
Well, pointing out the ways sports fans and especially the dullards playing and coaching the games make mistakes in their understanding of physics is sort of shooting fish in the barrell. I say this as someone who played baseball in the Big12.
Ah, no. You didn't read the study, I think. The issue is not that the players are dullards in this case, the issue is that there is an optical illusion causing this effect.

From the link in the OP:
"The curveball does curve, but the curve has been measured and shown to be gradual," Shapiro said. "It's always going to follow a parabolic path. But from a hitter's point of view, an approaching ball can appear to break, drop or do a whole range of unusual behaviors."

That is what we are addressing. If you don't find it particularly interesting that somebody conducted a scientific study to figure out what causes this misperception, fine, but don't accuse us of being woo, please.
 
That is what we are addressing. If you don't find it particularly interesting that somebody conducted a scientific study to figure out what causes this misperception, fine, but don't accuse us of being woo, please.

First of all, I don't remember accusing anyone on this thread of "being woo," but if I gave that impression, my apologies.

Second, I agree that the article is interesting in its findings, but the structure of the piece is misdirected. If the conceit was, "here's why curveballs appear to move more than they actually do," then I would have no criticism.

The aspect of the work that I find misdirected is their claim that curveballs don't "break." As I said, this is just a colloquialism meant to distinguish good curveballs from bad ones. Focusing the article on dispelling this "myth" is just subjecting a vague, casual term to scientific scrutiny. They even acknowledge this, perhaps unintentionally:

"A little terminology: to many batters and pitchers, a break is a deviation from the relatively straight path of a fastball. In that sense, all curveballs break."

Ok, then I guess they do break. But to set up the conceit, let's say "break" means "to violate the laws of physics," then point out that curveballs do not, in fact, violate the laws of physics.

In other words, interesting article, good findings, silly conceit.
 
Last edited:
Well, pointing out the ways sports fans and especially the dullards playing and coaching the games make mistakes in their understanding of physics is sort of shooting fish in the barrell. I say this as someone who played baseball in the Big12.

Here was an exchange I had with a fellow pitcher as we were flying to the West Coast for a series:

Him: "You know, it's tough to pitch on the coast, the ball really carries."
Me: "Really? That's surprising. We'll be right at sea level. The ball really carries in places like Denver, with thin air and no humidity. Why does the ball carry on the coast?"
Him: "Because the ocean has so much gravity."

Now, he was not unusually stupid for a ballplayer. Coaches are ex-ballplayers. Managers are ex-ballplayers.

There's a whole lot of dumb in that population.

If you listen to hockey color commentators, you will occasionally hear about the defenseman who has a "heavy" slap shot. Apparently, moving pucks have linear velocity, angular velocity, and "heaviness".
 
I don't disagree with what you are saying about curveballs; it all seems very reasonable. The article in the OP however was about something very different, and it would seem from some google searching that both fans AND players believe in these throws that can suddenly deviate at the last moment from their arc.

How about this: the curve described by the path of the ball has no discontinuity. The radius of curvature may change, but there are no "kinks".
 
First of all, I don't remember accusing anyone on this thread of "being woo," but if I gave that impression, my apologies.

Second, I agree that the article is interesting in its findings, but the structure of the piece is misdirected. If the conceit was, "here's why curveballs appear to move more than they actually do," then I would have no criticism.

The aspect of the work that I find misdirected is their claim that curveballs don't "break." As I said, this is just a colloquialism meant to distinguish good curveballs from bad ones. Focusing the article on dispelling this "myth" is just subjecting a vague, casual term to scientific scrutiny. They even acknowledge this, perhaps unintentionally:

"A little terminology: to many batters and pitchers, a break is a deviation from the relatively straight path of a fastball. In that sense, all curveballs break."

Ok, then I guess they do break. But to set up the conceit, let's say "break" means "to violate the laws of physics," then point out that curveballs do not, in fact, violate the laws of physics.

In other words, interesting article, good findings, silly conceit.
I accept your definition.

If you google breaking ball, you get your definition - a term that collects various pitches such as curve ball or a slider.

However, if you google 'break sharply', you get tons of claims of sudden curves right at the plate. For example, here is one from the New York Times.

I don't see anything in the article that I found misleading - it was apparent (to me) that they were talking about sudden departures from a smooth, curved path. I can see where if you are used to using 'break' to mean any kind of pitch with a curve that you might read it differently.
 
"A little terminology: to many batters and pitchers, a break is a deviation from the relatively straight path of a fastball. In that sense, all curveballs break."

I've always understood a breaking ball to be a curveball that hooks sharply as it nears the plate.

From what I'm hearing on this thread, deceleration + spin is a possible reason for a sharpening of the curve.

But the article also proposes a mechanism for an optical illusion which makes the ball appear, to the batter, to break more sharply than it actually does.
 
I don't see anything in the article that I found misleading - it was apparent (to me) that they were talking about sudden departures from a smooth, curved path. I can see where if you are used to using 'break' to mean any kind of pitch with a curve that you might read it differently.

Fair enough. I've always understood the "break" in a curveball or slider to be the difference in movement between two balls on the same path with the same velocity, one with backspin, like a fastball, the other with top spin or some horizontal spin.

The fact that some people involved in baseball imagine voodoo, magical behavior to certain pitches isn't really surprising, nor do we need sophisticated analysis of the human eye to reject their nonsense. Perhaps I was oversensitive to that having spent so much time around it. I think the work in the OP stands on its own without having to drudge up some fabled nonsense in baseball lore to argue against.

My Grandad's favorite book when he was young was The Shortstop by Zane Grey:

http://www.fantasticfiction.co.uk/g/zane-grey/shortstop.htm

One of the more entertaining scenes was when the main character throws a curveball in a game while barnstorming in the country. They accuse him of witchcraft and run him out of town. These myths have been around for a while, and distressingly, they haven't really changed that much since 1909.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom