Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Some people's opposition to circumcision may be influenced by antisemitism. So what? Don't you think you better have a substantial body of evidence before you start flashing that card around?

The thought occurred to me pages ago.

Jewish and Muslim people should not be involved on panels which issue medical recommendations on circumcision because their interest is in circumcision continuing to be legal.

Yup, Jews can't be trusted. :rolleyes:
 
Do you think a Muslim or Jewish doctor or nurse could give professional advice to a patient or a parent that goes against their religious beliefs?

Sure, most religions allow their followers to be hypocrites. However, I think it's far more likely people's beliefs will influence the advice they provide when the issue is a core tenet of their religion.
 
Another query - is it still standard practice in Jewish traditional circumcision rites for the mohel to suck the blood off the penis post-circ?

I have attended two brits and, AFAIK, that was not done. The first one I went to everyone in attendance was Orthodox Jewish and the men and women were separated so I couldn't really see what was going on. I wasn't aware of this practice back than (it was the 1970s), but I think I would have noticed if the mohel had bent over the baby. :eye-poppi

The second one I went to -- this was definitely NOT done.

Apparently there are three parts to a brit and the last part involves drawing away the blood from underneath the skin to prevent post operational complications. Apparently the Talmud does not specify how that has to be done. More info at these links:


Short and to the point:
http://www.askmoses.com/en/article/...-mohel-suck-the-blood-after-circumcision.html

More wordy and doesn't make it clear when alternate ways of suctioning the blood away from the wound started being implemented:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brit_milah#Metzitzah_technique

AH, I'm glad you brought up the 3rd and final part of the brit because it shows that what people think they know about brits itsn't always true and that the tradition is not as inflexible and unchangeable as some people, including many Jews, think.

And that may apply to the entire brit ceremony as well. If you read the entire wiki link, it seems very likely that the brit ceremony as its carried out now is a far more extreme procedure than it was originally.

That being the case, why couldn't the brit go back to being a less severe medical procedure? Or perhaps even done away with?

The film director of the movie I had recommended upthread believes that the Jewish tradition is strong and flexible enough to come up with a new type of covenant ceremony ... if more Jews started actually thinking about this topic and looking back into the traditions again.

Movie link (NOT SAFE FOR WORK):
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/The_Film.html

Links for Question and Answer sessions that occurred in various parts of the world after public viewings of this film:
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/Q&A.html

This one has the option of youtube captions:
Sunday: September 9th, 2007 The Gene Siskel Film Center: Chicago (at the bottom of the web page)

and this one has pretty decent sound:
Tuesday: March 25, 2008 JCC of the Upper West Side of Manhattan: NY

you can hear the actual questions from the audience fairly clearly unlike some of the other videos.

What I like about this documentary is that the film director treats everyone with respect, even the ones that he very much disagrees with. He does his best to let everyone do their best to make their case. While, as he puts it, he is most interested on how to handle conflicts between religious tradition and modern day ethics and sensibilities -- he does cover other sides of this area also such as medical issues and foreskin functions.

As a result this is probably the most convincing presentation that I have seen anywhere that circumcision is a truly bad idea.

Most people don't think about circumcision. At one point the number of circumcisions done in the USA was so high that it had reached a critical mass. As a result most people probably continued to have this done to their sons without thinking about it because obviously it must be something good for their sons, otherwise why would it be such a common procedure?

Slowly that started to change in nonreligious circles, and one of the director's goal is to encourage people to start thinking critically about this in Jewish circles as well, even in the more traditional Jewish circles. In one of the filmed Q&A sessions he says he believes that the Jewish tradition is flexible enough to phase the brit ceremony out -- but the first step is to get people to actually think about it. (I'm rephrasing what he said in my own words of course, I don't recall what he said exactly word for word.)

This is a difficult area to get Jews to think about. Many believe that if they don't continue this practice they will cut themselves off from the community of Jews, this is especially true in Orthodox Jewish circles. That makes the stakes so high that it removes personal choice from the equation. Here's a testimonial on the director's web site that seems to show that perhaps this barrier can be breached ... IF enough people start thinking about it and become willing to discuss it.

Hi Eli,

I just wanted to drop you a note to say thank you. My parents, my wife, and I watched "Cut" and it affected my parents deeply. My mother, who was vehemently for circumcision, now believes that we should not circumcise. My mother gave me a tearful apology on Mother's Day for giving us a hard time. My father, who was even more vehemently for circumcision, now says that if he had to make the decision today, it would be extremely difficult and he doesn't know what he would decide. My wife and I are totally shocked that my parents could change their mind so quickly.

My parents are being much more warm around my wife and me. Everyone feels as if a terrible burden has been lifted. The family crisis had ended!!

We all believe that "Cut" is extremely well done and is the single greatest resource on Jewish circumcision in the world...

Thank you for your kindness in sending us the film. You really rescued my family.


Warm regards,

xxxx xxxxx (x's are my edit)

The people in the documentary and the Q&As videos are much more eloquent than I, so again -- I really recommend watching it.
 
Last edited:
Correct. So is murder and theft and various other things which some people choose to indulge in.

Exactly my point. The government banning something doesn't make people stop doing it. So what again was your argument regarding slavery?
 
Last edited:
Exactly my point. The government banning something doesn't make people stop doing it. So what again was your argument regarding slavery?


It was suggested that infant circumcision should not be made illegal because making things illegal doesn't stop people doing it
Slavery was made illegal in the US and it is not practised now. It was made illegal.
 
But did it put the anti-circumcision people in a good light? I don't think so. They have come off as bullying, anti-religious promotors of the nanny state.

Considering the baggage that the act carries, even when not being performed for religious reasons, there was probably no way to avoid that. Any suggested restriction would probably have been met with the same vitriol. How would you have written the law? Would you have even proposed a law, if not what different approach might you have tried?
 
Not allowing cutting off bits of babies is a nanny state?

Not that I agree with it but if you read any of the coverage on this issue, particularly in the US, they do make that charge; along with calling those who support it anti-semitic.
 
Exactly my point. The government banning something doesn't make people stop doing it. So what again was your argument regarding slavery?
I think that it might be an example of the fallacy of the perfect solution.
 
You're only concerned that nobody should point out that a lot of the support for circumcision, including Thunder's, is explicitly Jewish religious woo.




Your attitude that nobody is allowed to criticise any specifically Jewish practice while mentioning that it is a Jewish practice and defended because it is Jewish religious woo, is classic victim-role-adoption.




No, people get labelled as anti-Semitic for pointing out that some of the most vociferous proponents of the practice are Jewish, and their support is because they support Jewish religious woo.

If anyone was lying, it was you and Thunder, for claiming that I had portrayed the Jewish doctors as threatening. I said nothing of the sort. The vilification comes generally from third parties like yourself. Exactly as you are doing now.




Don't be silly. I'm suggesting that Jewish doctors (and maybe Moslem ones too, let's not be exclusive here) speak up forcefully in favour of endorsing infant circumcision, and others are inhibited from putting forward the contrary view for fear of being labelled anti-Semitic (and probably anti-Islam too). And so we get these mealy-mouthed weasel-worded policies about communities and parental choice, instead of telling it like it is.

It's a bit difficult to discuss this without mentioning religion. It's good to see that a number of medical bodies have not gone down this route though, good for them

Rolfe.

Don't mind Ziggurat. He sometimes has a little trouble with context. ;)


GB
 
The film director of the movie I had recommended upthread believes that the Jewish tradition is strong and flexible enough to come up with a new type of covenant ceremony ... if more Jews started actually thinking about this topic and looking back into the traditions again.

Movie link (NOT SAFE FOR WORK):
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/The_Film.html

Links for Question and Answer sessions that occurred in various parts of the world after public viewings of this film:
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/Q%26A.html

This one has the option of youtube captions:
Sunday: September 9th, 2007 The Gene Siskel Film Center: Chicago (at the bottom of the web page)

and this one has pretty decent sound:
Tuesday: March 25, 2008 JCC of the Upper West Side of Manhattan: NY

you can hear the actual questions from the audience fairly clearly unlike some of the other videos.

What I like about this documentary is that the film director treats everyone with respect, even the ones that he very much disagrees with. He does his best to let everyone do their best to make their case. While, as he puts it, he is most interested on how to handle conflicts between religious tradition and modern day ethics and sensibilities -- he does cover other sides of this area also such as medical issues and foreskin functions.

As a result this is probably the most convincing presentation that I have seen anywhere that circumcision is a truly bad idea.


Watched it last night, and it was very interesting. It clarified something I had suspected but didn't quite understand, which is the keratinisation of the glans penis.

As a vet, I understand that this "foreskin" thing is in fact the prepuce, and of course every male animal has a prepuce into which the penis is retracted. What emerges is pink, glistening and moist, and really quite fragile. In particular, it needs the prepuce to keep it moist, prevent drying, and maintain the surface epithelium. I wondered how any male animal could do without this organ, without the penis becoming severely damaged. It seems the human glans penis reacts to constant exposure by this keratinisation reaction, leaving it dry and with a thickened, sometimes rather cracked epithelium, but somehow it survives without actually falling off.

I found I had most respect for the contributors who admitted that there was no medical benefit to circumcision, and that it was in fact rather harmful, but they did it anyway because of the covenant with Abraham. One contributor made quite a moving point about how the father was in a sense entrusting or even sacrificing his son's manhood, his hope for future generations, to the covenant. He compared it to Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac, because he believed God was commanding him to do it. I might vehemently disapprove of this, but it is an argument which is intellectually honest and which can command respect.

What I found so dishonest about Thunder's approach was his constant rationalisation of the procedure as conferring benefits, and at times insisting that he was advocating it because of these benefits, and not because of "religious woo". Admit it's a religious act carried out in spite of a degree of harm, and the discussion can proceed.

I think this admission clarifies a lot in relation to the social circumcision that seems so widespread in the USA. That seems all to be predicated on the assumption that the procedure is medically beneficial. (And I still retreat in bafflement from that assertion - how can amputation of the healthy neonatal prepuce possibly have medical benefits? It's insane.) If Jewish proponents of the practice were to admit to the real reason it's carried out within Judaism, rather than perpetuating the myths of medical benefit, then the entire debate would be a great deal clearer.

As an aside, I found the scenes of the babies in white dresses being taken to the synagogue for the procedure quite surreal. Of course I have attended at such ceremionies many times, and participated three four times (oops, forgot to mention the first time I participated, and I even have a certificate to prove it...). Sometimes the babies cry, too (well they do if I have to hold them!). But for a welcome ceremony to bring the baby into the family of its religious community to centre around a pretty serious surgical operation - er, what? It certainly makes the covenant extraordinarily serious, but part of me was shouting, oh for goodness sake, splash a few drops of water on the poor thing and be done with it.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

This is a difficult area to get Jews to think about. Many believe that if they don't continue this practice they will cut themselves off from the community of Jews, this is especially true in Orthodox Jewish circles. That makes the stakes so high that it removes personal choice from the equation.

<snip>

This is why I find all religion disgusting. At the core of religion is control and hatred, which is probably why the religious are so often bedfellows with cruel and psychotic despots.
 
It was suggested that infant circumcision should not be made illegal because making things illegal doesn't stop people doing it
Slavery was made illegal in the US and it is not practised now. It was made illegal.

Slavery didn't end in the south because a law (in the U.S. an amendment) was passed. It ended because the south was destroyed. They had no way to continue on with that economic/political/social system.
 
Last edited:
Not allowing cutting off bits of babies is a nanny state?

Yes, when those who do cut off bits of babies don't see anything wrong in it. Why, in this case, does those pushing this issue think that the government can just legislate away practices ingrained in certain religions as scared and for the larger part of society is just routine?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom