Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Oh please. The fact of the matter is that I don't even care much about circumcision in and of itself. I didn't jump in before because I'm not even really interested in whether you oppose circumcision or not.


You're only concerned that nobody should point out that a lot of the support for circumcision, including Thunder's, is explicitly Jewish religious woo.

Your biases are showing. I don't consider myself a victim, because I'm not. You, however, ARE complaining about being a victim.


Your attitude that nobody is allowed to criticise any specifically Jewish practice while mentioning that it is a Jewish practice and defended because it is Jewish religious woo, is classic victim-role-adoption.

Yeah, no. What you're saying is that people will get labeled as being antisemitic just for opposing circumcision. But that's not why I attacked you, is it? No, it isn't. I've repeatedly pointed that out to you, yet you persist in telling what is essentially a lie about what happened here.


No, people get labelled as anti-Semitic for pointing out that some of the most vociferous proponents of the practice are Jewish, and their support is because they support Jewish religious woo.

If anyone was lying, it was you and Thunder, for claiming that I had portrayed the Jewish doctors as threatening. I said nothing of the sort. The vilification comes generally from third parties like yourself. Exactly as you are doing now.

Then call him out on that. You don't need to even mention religion to do so.


Don't be silly. I'm suggesting that Jewish doctors (and maybe Moslem ones too, let's not be exclusive here) speak up forcefully in favour of endorsing infant circumcision, and others are inhibited from putting forward the contrary view for fear of being labelled anti-Semitic (and probably anti-Islam too). And so we get these mealy-mouthed weasel-worded policies about communities and parental choice, instead of telling it like it is.

It's a bit difficult to discuss this without mentioning religion. It's good to see that a number of medical bodies have not gone down this route though, good for them

Rolfe.
 
You're only concerned that nobody should point out that a lot of the support for circumcision, including Thunder's, is explicitly Jewish religious woo.

Obviously not, since the post of yours I responded to wasn't about religious practices. It was about doctors, and their medical recommendations. You claimed that their recommendations were tainted by religion, but my objection to your post had absolutely nothing to do with any criticism of a religious justification. Because there was no such criticism within your post.
 
In regard to link in the OP, which seems to forgotten in the amongst all the claims of anti-Semitism, just how do the backers of this initiative think this ban will work if it passes (I don't think it will)?

Will the police or a new anti-circumcision government agency monitor the birth of Jewish boys then 8 days later have a stakeout at the parents house, looking for a mohel?

When has banning something that was previously legal ever convined folks to stop doing that activity?
 
Obviously not, since the post of yours I responded to wasn't about religious practices. It was about doctors, and their medical recommendations. You claimed that their recommendations were tainted by religion, but my objection to your post had absolutely nothing to do with any criticism of a religious justification. Because there was no such criticism within your post.

Do you believe conflict of interest exists and influences people's decisions?

If so, how does a belief that circumcision is harmless (if not beneficial) and required by God not a conflict of interest when making recommendations about infant circumcision?

Medicine is littered with examples of the prejudice and racism of doctors and medical researchers influencing medical science.

IMO, if a group has to use God to justify swinging their arms so far they punch others in the face, they've lost the argument and their opinion should be ignored.
 
In regard to link in the OP, which seems to forgotten in the amongst all the claims of anti-Semitism, just how do the backers of this initiative think this ban will work if it passes (I don't think it will)?

Will the police or a new anti-circumcision government agency monitor the birth of Jewish boys then 8 days later have a stakeout at the parents house, looking for a mohel?

When has banning something that was previously legal ever convined folks to stop doing that activity?

Slavery hasn't ceased to exist because the civilised countries of the world have made it illegal, therefore we should not bother sending mohel's to prison for physically assaulting infants and children.
 
Slavery hasn't ceased to exist because the civilised countries of the world have made it illegal, therefore we should not bother sending mohel's to prison for physically assaulting infants and children.

The passing of this ban will not stop even one religious-based circumcision, it will just go underground (maybe, I just can't see this being enforced even if it does pass). The solution here is not banning circumcision, it's educating the non-religious public about it, after all, most circumcisions in the U.S. are not done for religious reasons.
 
The passing of this ban will not stop even one religious-based circumcision, it will just go underground (maybe, I just can't see this being enforced even if it does pass). The solution here is not banning circumcision, it's educating the non-religious public about it, after all, most circumcisions in the U.S. are not done for religious reasons.

One could reasonably ask the same question about the FGM ban? How is it policed, how is it handled? But the fact here is that this initiative isn't expected to pass. It's been done largely as a way to educate and bring attention to an important issue. Circumcision is a practice which thrives in silence and hopefully the ban will get people thinking.
 
Last edited:
Do you believe conflict of interest exists and influences people's decisions?

If so, how does a belief that circumcision is harmless (if not beneficial) and required by God not a conflict of interest when making recommendations about infant circumcision?

"Conflict of interest" is the wrong term. The word for what you describe is "bias". But if you really want to open up that can of worms, if you really want to probe people's secret motivations rather than the merits of their statements, then the conclusion that opposition to circumcision is influenced by antisemitism is unavoidable. We have far more direct evidence of that than for Rolfe's allegations against doctors.

Medicine is littered with examples of the prejudice and racism of doctors and medical researchers influencing medical science.

True. But that cuts more than one way (no pun intended).

IMO, if a group has to use God to justify swinging their arms so far they punch others in the face, they've lost the argument and their opinion should be ignored.

I see no reference to religious scripture in any of the medical association statements at issue here.
 
Religion is the Golf club from hell:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jan/11/chief-rabbi-donor-cards?INTCMP=ILCNETTXT3487

In classical Jewish law – halacha – a person is dead if their heart stops beating. But some rabbis around the world have adopted brain death as an acceptable definition, even if the heart and lungs are kept working artificially. Organs recovered under these conditions, when the blood is still flowing, are more suitable for transplant use.

The chief rabbi has said he and his rabbinical court, the London Beth Din, reject the legal and medical definition of death. They have ruled that organs from Jews may only be removed for transplant at the point of cardiorespiratory failure. This position could mean that Jews opt out of organ donation in order to stay within their faith's legal parameters. It also appears to contradict an earlier official pledge of support featured on the NHS Blood and Transplant website.

In a statement the chief rabbi said: "There is a view that brain stem death is an acceptable halachic criterion in the determination of death. However it is the considered opinion of the London Beth Din that in halacha cardiorespiratory death is definitive."

Why should anyone care what this bloke thinks is the correct interpretation of Jewish club rules when they're deciding what to with their dead relative's body? It's none of his *********** business.

Why should his opinion make people of his club feel bad for doing something good?
 
One could reasonably ask the same question about the FGM ban? How is it policed, how is it handled?

I don't think that ban is policed at all, mostly because it happens to girls at different ages.

But the fact here is that this initiative isn't expected to pass. It's been done largely as a way to educate and bring attention to an important issue. Circumcision is a practice which thrives in silence and hopefully the ban will get people thinking.

Horrible way to "educate" people.
 
Why should anyone care what this bloke thinks is the correct interpretation of Jewish club rules when they're deciding what to with their dead relative's body?

So is this thread now officially about all the terrible things that Jews do? Or are we still trying to keep the conversation at least related to circumcision?
 
Horrible way to "educate" people.

It got everyone here talking didn't it? It's made the main stream news didn't it? Perhaps educate isn't quite the right word; perhaps raise the issue in a public way that forces people to take notice.
 
"Conflict of interest" is the wrong term.

No, it's not. It's a conflict of interest because a Jewish (or Muslim) person has an interest in circumcision of males continuing to be legal.

The word for what you describe is "bias". But if you really want to open up that can of worms, if you really want to probe people's secret motivations rather than the merits of their statements, then the conclusion that opposition to circumcision is influenced by antisemitism is unavoidable. We have far more direct evidence of that than for Rolfe's allegations against doctors.

Some people's opposition to circumcision may be influenced by antisemitism. So what? Don't you think you better have a substantial body of evidence before you start flashing that card around?

<snip>

I see no reference to religious scripture in any of the medical association statements at issue here.

Of course you don't. What you see is the APA's recommendations flipping when Edgar Schoen get's on the panel reviewing circumcision and flipping back when he's booted off.

Jewish and Muslim people should not be involved on panels which issue medical recommendations on circumcision because their interest is in circumcision continuing to be legal.
 
It got everyone here talking didn't it? It's made the main stream news didn't it? Perhaps educate isn't quite the right word; perhaps raise the issue in a public way that forces people to take notice.

But did it put the anti-circumcision people in a good light? I don't think so. They have come off as bullying, anti-religious promotors of the nanny state.
 
So is this thread now officially about all the terrible things that Jews religious authorities do? Or are we still trying to keep the conversation at least related to circumcision?

That's better.

It was off topic, but provided as another example of religion poking its nose in where it should not.

What Jews and Muslims think about circumcision being made illegal should be discounted, just as the views of the tobacco industry about smoking bans should be ignored.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom