Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Is it to difficult to just scroll up and read what I posted already?

Just answer the question.

Why do you think that folks have agreed that an in-door smoking ban is a good idea? Where did you think that information came from, the government?

So do you think that folks would have stopped smoking en masse the day the ban came in if it weren't for the ban? And this would have been the result of education? No, they stopped smoking because it was banned.


Drinking wasn't a deep-seated religious conviction when it was banned in the U.S. during Prohibition, yet it was pursued in many backroom during that time period. You know that full well.

The problem of people drinking in backrooms was that it funded and increased organized crime. If it were just people secretly drinking illegally then I doubt many would have cared. It also was clearly a major loss of revenue for the legitimate economy. Do you think a ban on circumcision will give rise to an underground mafia of circumcisers? No. Of course not. Instead the numbers of people getting circumcised will decrease.
 
Legislation hasn't stopped either of these practices. Only education will. Folks have to understand why these things are wrong, it won't work if government just demands they be stopped.

By that logic we should allow Sharia law to be practiced, and Satanists to chop off bits of non-consenting persons' anatomies; which we don't, contrary to popular opinion of the Lunatic Fringe.


GB
 
How do you know this? There will always be people who break the law but that doesn't make it not worth having. The fact that there was a law provided a mechanism to convict that man and send him to prison. It could provide the girl a mechanism to pursue civil action in the future. How is that not worth having?

Alt+F4 doesn't believe in laws apparently, just "education." I wonder if Alty has been reading too much Ayn Rand lately? ;)


GB
 
Watched it last night, and it was very interesting. It clarified something I had suspected but didn't quite understand, which is the keratinisation of the glans penis.

As a vet, I understand that this "foreskin" thing is in fact the prepuce, and of course every male animal has a prepuce into which the penis is retracted. What emerges is pink, glistening and moist, and really quite fragile. In particular, it needs the prepuce to keep it moist, prevent drying, and maintain the surface epithelium. I wondered how any male animal could do without this organ, without the penis becoming severely damaged. It seems the human glans penis reacts to constant exposure by this keratinisation reaction, leaving it dry and with a thickened, sometimes rather cracked epithelium, but somehow it survives without actually falling off.

Thanks for posting this Rolfe. IMHO, your explanation complements one of the scenes in the documentary beautifully.

I have read that in the Victorian times, mid to late 1800s, circumcision started becoming a more widely accepted practice because it made the penis less sensitive. Apparently Victorians believed that masturbation was bad and that circumcision would help stop it. :rolleyes: And even before the Victorian times it was known that a side effect of circumcision was to make the penis less sensitive. One of my teachers happened to mention that in passing when I was a high school student and at the time I just didn't take him seriously. It was mentioned as an aside during a class discussing one of the brits mentioned in the Torah, and I guess I thought the reduction in sensation must be really slight, because if it wasn't -- well, who would do that to so many baby boys? Both Jewish and non-Jewish baby boys as circumcision at the time was an extremely common procedure in the American Midwest.

So, until I thought about this issue more critically a few years ago, I had never taken seriously what I had heard and read about the effects of circumcision. But the movie and your comments really bring it home. The movie director in one of his Q&A videos said that most Americans have a double standard when it comes to circumcision. They usually think that female circumcision is worse than it is and that male circumcision is not as bad as it actually is. In reality, its the reverse and the difference between those circumcisions are not as great as most people think it is.

I suppose another reason that I never took these comments at face value is because when one thinks about what is actually being done -- its really shocking that "nice" regular folks from every walk of life are doing this so nonchalantly every day to tiny newborns. But, if the trend continues and circumcision continues to be performed on fewer and fewer babies -- I suppose that one day it will commonly be looked upon with the same type of amazement, horror and disconnect (for lack of a better word) that many people now look upon the ancient practice of foot binding in China. I say disconnect because I don't think that most people can understand how anyone could have ever thought that it was a good idea to bind up their daughters' feet, permanently, while they were still toddlers.


I found I had most respect for the contributors who admitted that there was no medical benefit to circumcision, and that it was in fact rather harmful, but they did it anyway because of the covenant with Abraham. One contributor made quite a moving point about how the father was in a sense entrusting or even sacrificing his son's manhood, his hope for future generations, to the covenant. He compared it to Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac, because he believed God was commanding him to do it. I might vehemently disapprove of this, but it is an argument which is intellectually honest and which can command respect.

I mostly agree, it seemed that all of the participants were sincere and making an attempt to be intellectually honest. However, as the film director says in another one of the Q&A videos, it is discouraging to see how easily scientific studies can be twisted by well meaning people. The film director thinks that the practice of circumcision is proof that it can be hard for even scientific people to be objective ... despite their knowledge of the scientific method and use of double blind studies. But when looking at the history of circumcision it becomes apparent that those tools must not always be implemented well. How else to explain why the same medical procedure was blessed as a godsend for widely different issues depending upon the decade? Circumcision has been described as the cure or prevention for masturbation, syphilis, UTIs, penile and cervix cancer, HIV, and more. You can always tell what the hot issue was in any particular decade by seeing what malady circumcision was supposedly preventing at the time. If that wasn't tragic, it would be hilarious.

We do disagree on a small point thought. I would say that the participants in the film were clarifying that the Judaic tradition never claimed that circumcision had any health benefits and that it was always only suppose to be done because it was a commandment -- and not for any other reason. I think it can be confusing that after circumcision became popular outside of Jewish circles in some English speaking countries, that some Jewish individuals basically said (including my mother ;) ) .. hey, isn't this nice ... modern scientists and doctors are now saying that this ancient commandment also has health benefits! Isn't that great? But that is not the same as saying that these alleged health reasons are the reasons why Jewish males are circumcised. The only reason they are circumcised, according to Jewish tradition, is because that's the commandment. You can't admit that the tradition doesn't say something that it never said, however you can clarify the point.


<snip>

Admit

uh ... clarify ;) that

it's a religious act carried out in spite of a degree of harm, and the discussion can proceed.

I think this admission clarifies a lot in relation to the social circumcision that seems so widespread in the USA. That seems all to be predicated on the assumption that the procedure is medically beneficial. (And I still retreat in bafflement from that assertion - how can amputation of the healthy neonatal prepuce possibly have medical benefits? It's insane.) If Jewish proponents of the practice were to admit to the real reason it's carried out within Judaism, rather than perpetuating the myths of medical benefit, then the entire debate would be a great deal clearer.

As mentioned already, my understanding is that Jewish proponents of the practice (at least the ones knowledgeable about their religion's history and traditions) have always stated that the only reason the commandment is done is because its a commandment.

Now if a wider understanding of that helps make the debate clearer, I'm all for it.

For various bizarre and political reasons many people of many faiths have asserted that circumcision had health benefits and should be done for that reason, mainly starting from the Victorian Era. I obviously disagree with them. And I think it would help make the debate clearer if it was better known that circumcision first started getting wider social acceptance outside of Jewish circles because its new proponents believed that masturbation was bad and that circumcision would stop it! :rolleyes: If more people knew that, it would probably go a long way to help make clear how silly and misguided circumcision is.

<snip>

but part of me was shouting, oh for goodness sake, splash a few drops of water on the poor thing and be done with it.

Or have a shalom brit :) -- a Jewish welcoming ceremony without a circumcision. :)
 
Last edited:
Like Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pot, Castro and Jong-Il? :rolleyes:

You must be a Christian. The above is a favoured fallacious tactic of Christians to tar Atheists with.

Stalin, Mao, Pot, and Jong Il, didn't kill a bunch of people in the name of Atheism; they were Class Warfare Revolutionaries. As opposed to Christians and other Theists who always use their religion to justify their wars, mass murders and inquisitions.

Putting Castro into the mix suggests that his regime committed mass murder, which no-one really accuses him of because there is no evidence to suggest otherwise.

Hitler was a Christian, a Catholic Austrian who got cozy with German Lutherans. The Holocaust was essentially the biggest pogrom in history. Anyone who doubts this should read Mein Kampf.

I'm tired of people using Religion to excuse barbaric acts. Which is why I, a Jew, support the Circumcision Ban.


GB
 
This is why I find all religion disgusting. At the core of religion is control and hatred, which is probably why the religious are so often bedfellows with cruel and psychotic despots.

That's not fair. He's just hating religion because religion causes people to hate. I mean, religion even made HIM hate, and he's not even religious! That's how bad it is!

I dunno. He implied I hated him because I support independence for Scotland, and that was only a couple of weeks after we'd had dinner together. Now it seems I also hate him because I'm a Christian.

Funny, I thought he was a really nice guy too. Was it something I said?

Rolfe.

:eye-poppi

Seriously, I think organized religions have been both beneficial and harmful. Just like most things, sometimes we get it right and sometimes we don't.
 
The only reason they are circumcised, according to Jewish tradition, is because that's the commandment. You can't admit that the tradition doesn't say something that it never said, however you can clarify the point.

As mentioned already, my understanding is that Jewish proponents of the practice (at least the ones knowledgeable about their religion's history and traditions) have always stated that the only reason the commandment is done is because its a commandment.

For various bizarre and political reasons many people of many faiths have asserted that circumcision had health benefits and should be done for that reason, mainly starting from the Victorian Era. ....


Thanks for that interesting and informative post.

I can understand why, once circumcision had become "popular" outwith the Jewish tradition, and then non-Jews started with the retro-justification regarding prevention of all these ills, that Jews would also take that on board and run with it. It does make it more difficult to make the counter-arguments though, when you have a group of people not simply asserting that it's a religious commandment, but also that it's a beneficial intervention. This was where Thunder was coming from of course. Arguments designed to clarify that it is not a beneficial intervention get caught up in the "anti-Semitism!" allegations, and more heat than light is generated.

To say to boys, no this isn't a good thing we did to you, it's a sacrifice that was made on your behalf to enter you into the covenant of Abraham, would be a lot more honest it seems to me.

We do the same thing to babies of course. "Though little children do not understand these things, yet is the promise also to them. They are the heirs of the covenant of grace...." The difference is, of course, all we do at that point is drip some water on their foreheads. If they decide in later life to repudiate it all and march off muttering "superstitious woo", then nothing irreversible has happened.

I don't know whether this is something Jewish thinkers need to take on board these days, but it could be set to become a bigger human rights issue in the future.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Folks, please remember to address the topic. Posts that are only about other members are ad hominems, even if not particularly insulting.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Folks, please remember to address the topic. Posts that are only about other members are ad hominems, even if not particularly insulting.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky

Looking back through the posts on this page, it appears that I was the only one to have done this.

My Bad. :o

GB
 
Thanks for that interesting and informative post.

I can understand why, once circumcision had become "popular" outwith the Jewish tradition, and then non-Jews started with the retro-justification regarding prevention of all these ills, that Jews would also take that on board and run with it.

Well, some Jews and some non-Jews. Jewish people are not identical clones. Obviously, there's a lot of individuality and variation within the Jewish faith -- I think we've seen that among the few Jewish posters here at the JREF and also from the relevant links in a variety of threads here at the forums over the years. And of course there's a lot of individuality and variation among non-Jews also. ;)

It does make it more difficult to make the counter-arguments though, when you have a group of people not simply asserting that it's a religious commandment, but also that it's a beneficial intervention.

Apparently there are some Jews that are saying, "Oh and by the way there are health benefits to circumcision also." The female reform rabbi in the movie was one example. So what? People should get their medical information from doctors and scientists ( in relevant fields, of course), not rabbis. Just like if one needs legal advice they should get it from lawyers, not medical doctors.

The best way to clear up incorrect information about the health effects of circumcision is to provide accurate information with proper citations from relevant sources. Most rabbis don't have medical degrees so aren't in a position to provide it. So, I don't think it's difficult at all to successfully make counter-arguments providing accurate information about the health effects of circumcision. ETA: Also in the documentary, the film maker interviewed an anti-circ activist. When asked how he handled the religious aspect of circumcision, he said he didn't. He only dealt with the health effects and said its his policy not to discuss the religious aspects of circumcision. Most circumcisions in the USA are not done for religious reasons, so I think his approach makes a lot of sense. FWIW, most varieties of Judaism have demonstrated over the centuries that it has a way of adapting to medical and scientific advances, and changing social mores. I think it will continue to do so, albeit slowly.

This was where Thunder was coming from of course.
I haven't found Thunder to be an honest debater so I usually didn't read his posts. I gather I didn't miss out on any insightful comments or good tidbits of information by skipping over them in this thread. :)

<snip>


I don't know whether this is something Jewish thinkers need to take on board these days, but it could be set to become a bigger human rights issue in the future.

Rolfe.

Judaism got started during the Bronze Age and has managed to continue to change over the centuries so that it remained relevant to enough people so that it has continued to exist in a variety of many different flavors. I suspect it will continue to do so. It may continue to take a long time, but I do believe that it will continue to adapt as it has in the past.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if changing the vocabulary typically used to discuss circumcision would have an impact in the debate?

For example:

amputation vs. circumcision
intact vs. uncircumcised


Perhaps a different word for foreskin? Some people seem to still consider it to be an unimportant piece of skin. Would using the word "sheath" do a better job of getting the point across that it has important functions, including a protective one? Feel free to suggest another word if you like.

If my understanding is correct, while circumcision became popular in English speaking countries starting in Victorian times ... it did not in other Western countries. So perhaps the word they use in their languages to mean "foreskin" did a better job of conveying the meaning of what it actually is and does???
 
So perhaps the word they use in their languages to mean "foreskin" did a better job of conveying the meaning of what it actually is and does???

The Norwegian word for foreskin translates directly into foreskin. Likewise, the Norwegian word for circumcision translated directly into circumcision.
 
The Norwegian word for foreskin translates directly into foreskin. Likewise, the Norwegian word for circumcision translated directly into circumcision.


Well, so much for that idea then! Thanks for answering the question.
 
Excellent posts, Kaylee.

Medically, the organ is the prepuce. In other animals, it's known as the sheath in the vernacular, so I think you're in the right ball park.

Rolfe.
 
Like Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pot, Castro and Jong-Il? :rolleyes:

Thanks for providing the standard reply. You will of course note that those leaders turned political ideologies into virtual religions. However, I was thinking more along the lines of this:

Anti-Judaic attitudes developed from the early years of Christianity and persisted over the ensuing centuries, driven by numerous factors including theological differences, competition between Church and Synagogue, the Christian drive for converts,[1] misunderstanding of Jewish beliefs and practices, and Jewish hostility toward Christians.

These attitudes persisted in Christian preaching, art and popular teaching of contempt for Jews over the centuries. In many Christian countries, it led to civil and political discrimination against Jews, legal disabilities, and in some instances to physical attacks on Jews which occasionally ended in emigration, expulsion, and even death.

Religion isn't about charity, love and peace. Religion is about defining an in-group through a set of rules. Those that do not obey the rules are to be cast out, discriminated against, tortured and often killed.

Having parents hack off a piece of their child's flesh as an act of faith is a method used to strengthen both feelings of in-group membership and the otherness of out-groups.
 
Thanks for providing the standard reply. You will of course note that those leaders turned political ideologies into virtual religions. However, I was thinking more along the lines of this:



Religion isn't about charity, love and peace. Religion is about defining an in-group through a set of rules. Those that do not obey the rules are to be cast out, discriminated against, tortured and often killed.

Having parents hack off a piece of their child's flesh as an act of faith is a method used to strengthen both feelings of in-group membership and the otherness of out-groups.

Ironically, Conservative Christians, Conservative Muslims, and Conservative Jews are allying and circling their wagons to fight off the Hordes of "Atheist" Secularism and Human Rights. Nothing unites religions generally at odds with each other like the whiff of Atheism. :rolleyes:

It all comes down to the opposition of the conservative Theist point of view that Religious Freedom trumps Human Rights, and the Secularist point of view that Human Rights trumps Religious Freedom.

GB
 
Excellent posts, Kaylee.

Aw, shucks. Thanks. :p

Medically, the organ is the prepuce. In other animals, it's known as the sheath in the vernacular, so I think you're in the right ball park.

Rolfe.

If people started calling the foreskin the prepuce in everyday language, I think the occurrence of partial penile amputation would increase. J/J, but uh, maybe not.



Great debate folks, its been fun!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom