Ban circumcision in San Fran???

<snip>


Religion is about defining an in-group through a set of rules.

That is true about any group formed by people.

Those that do not obey the rules are to be cast out, discriminated against, tortured and often killed.

Well, the group's rewards for joining up and the group's acts of shunning do vary.

(Below quoted out of order)
Religion isn't about charity, love and peace.

Well, sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't. I'm not well versed on the subject but I know that organized religion has been responsible for many things that have benefited communities and people in general (not just their own fellow members of the same religion).

IIRC, the Unitarian church in the USA did a lot of abolitionist work and helped run the underground railroad before the Civil War.

Religous groups often do fund hospitals and run soup kitchens and similar sorts of things.

There's no doubt that they also have been responsible for wars and Inquisitions.

But I think its only fair to recognize the good along with the bad and even horrible.

What I like about religious organizations is that they offers a framework for people to interact outside of family and commerce. And I'm agnostic.

Whether organized religion has offered a net benefit or horror to humanity and what is available to replace it with instead would be a good topic for another thread, IMHO. I don't think I have enough knowledge to contribute to it in a significant way, but if anyone wanted to start it, I would read it with great interest. (Hint, hint :) )
 
Now that Thunder has bowed out to lick his wounds, I'd be interested to know if anyone is still supporting the circumcision of male infants. In particular, I'd be interested to know if anyone is supporting the procedure when it is not required by a particular religion.

And if so, why?

Rolfe.
I only support circumcision when required for medical reasons.
Given that there are reputable sources indicating ~200 deaths per year due to complications from non-medically mandated circumcisions in the USA alone I can see no reason to support or condone it.
 
Last edited:
Citation?
Certainly.
The Thymos study (2010) suggests 117. More coverage here. This study covered only the neonatal period and would exclude deaths from complications, such as infections, which would be likely to manifest later.
Baker's study (1979, available in part here) suggested 229
Gellis (American Journal of Diseases of Children DEC1978, available here) suggested that deaths form complications from circumcision outnumbered those from penile cancer.
John Brunetti (NY City Child Services) estimated 200 deaths pa in the US. [presentation at the 'Early Head Start' annual conference 2001]
Bollinger (in 'Death and the New Penis') examines a number of sources and suggests ~100 deaths pa.

Non-USA.
Gairdnder (BMJ DEC1949, available here) suggested 16-19 deaths pa in the UK in the late 1940s. Extrapolation would support 120-150pa in the US today.
 
San Franciscans may end up not having the chance to vote on this

San Francisco Superior Court Judge Loretta Giorgi on Wednesday issued a tentative ruling saying the ballot measure to ban circumcision must be withdrawn, calling it "expressly preempted" by state law.

She said the California Business and Professions Code prohibits local regulation of medical procedures. She goes on to write that it "serves no legitimate purpose" for an illegal measure to remain on the ballot and ordered elections chief John Arntz to remove it.

The ruling is tentative, and Giorgi is scheduled to hold a hearing on the matter today at 9:30 a.m. But observers say it is very unlikely that she'll change her mind considering the vehemence of her initial ruling.

San Francisco Chronicle
 
What is this, projection of your own extremism? Why yes, it is.

Cutting off a bit of functional anatomy because:

1) An old book told me
or
2) A crank in the 19th century convinced a lot of Americans it cured masturbation, and it became traditional.

That is extremism.
 
Cutting off a bit of functional anatomy because:

1) An old book told me
or
2) A crank in the 19th century convinced a lot of Americans it cured masturbation, and it became traditional.

That is extremism.
Meh, what are a few hundred dead children when god tells you to do something.
 
Well, I am booked in to have a circumcision on the 21st March (I am 44) :( It is not my first choice to have the procedure, but my Urologist has recommended I go ahead with it so heh ho.

I will fortunately be having an anaesthetic rather than just having some beardy robe wearer slicing it off for me which is a great relief.

The potential side effects listed include infection, loss of sensation, scarring and more so I can't imagine why someone would have this done to themselves voluntarily (or more incredibly their babies :eek:), but there are (and ever will be) a lot of fools out there.
 
Well, I am booked in to have a circumcision on the 21st March (I am 44) :( It is not my first choice to have the procedure, but my Urologist has recommended I go ahead with it so heh ho.

I will fortunately be having an anaesthetic rather than just having some beardy robe wearer slicing it off for me which is a great relief.

The potential side effects listed include infection, loss of sensation, scarring and more so I can't imagine why someone would have this done to themselves voluntarily (or more incredibly their babies :eek:), but there are (and ever will be) a lot of fools out there.
I don't know why you have to have it done, but there is the option of only cutting part of it off. Unfortunately most doctors are ignorant of this, but you might want to inform yourself about it. (I can't provide any links, I got this info from the old RDF forum, which since has been deleted.)
 
Thanks for the advice, its coming off coz it is tight and pretty uncomfortable, particularly when standing to attention (it not me).

There is apparently also an option where they make a cut to loosen it up (like cutting a v in it) but my consulant says that while this would do the trick it isn't a very attractive solution, and only generally used on older patients where the cosmetic appearance is less of an issue.
 
Thanks for the advice, its coming off coz it is tight and pretty uncomfortable, particularly when standing to attention (it not me).

There is apparently also an option where they make a cut to loosen it up (like cutting a v in it) but my consulant says that while this would do the trick it isn't a very attractive solution, and only generally used on older patients where the cosmetic appearance is less of an issue.


Ouch!

Good luck, dude.

When I had to have surgery on my clavicle, right before they put me under anesthesia they gave me a magic marker to mark the shoulder that needed working on.

The idea that this might be important was not reassuring, but I suppose every little bit helps.

Maybe you should ask for one so that that you can make sure they don't remove more than they ought to.

:eek:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom