Ban circumcision in San Fran???

This is why I find all religion disgusting. At the core of religion is control and hatred, which is probably why the religious are so often bedfellows with cruel and psychotic despots.

Like Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pot, Castro and Jong-Il? :rolleyes:
 
Like Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pot, Castro and Jong-Il? :rolleyes:

That's not fair. He's just hating religion because religion causes people to hate. I mean, religion even made HIM hate, and he's not even religious! That's how bad it is!
 
Yes, when those who do cut off bits of babies don't see anything wrong in it. Why, in this case, does those pushing this issue think that the government can just legislate away practices ingrained in certain religions as scared and for the larger part of society is just routine?


So you think all legislation prohibiting FGM should be abolished?

Mormons should be allowed multiple, underage wives?

Rolfe.
 
That's not fair. He's just hating religion because religion causes people to hate. I mean, religion even made HIM hate, and he's not even religious! That's how bad it is!


I dunno. He implied I hated him because I support independence for Scotland, and that was only a couple of weeks after we'd had dinner together. Now it seems I also hate him because I'm a Christian.

Funny, I thought he was a really nice guy too. Was it something I said?

Rolfe.
 
So you think all legislation prohibiting FGM should be abolished?

Mormons should be allowed multiple, underage wives?

Rolfe.

Legislation hasn't stopped either of these practices. Only education will. Folks have to understand why these things are wrong, it won't work if government just demands they be stopped.
 
Last edited:
Slavery didn't end in the south because a law (in the U.S. an amendment) was passed. It ended because the south was destroyed. They had no way to continue on with that economic/political/social system.

So, the amendment was redundant? Nobody would have continued to hold slaves? I doubt that.
Making it illegal, or in some other way 'not allowed' was a powerful influence.
Similarly if it were illegal to circumcise baby boys: certainly some people would continue to do it, just as some continue to murder and steal, but it would be a powerful influence.
 
Legislation hasn't stopped either of these practices. Only education will. Folks have to understand why these things are wrong, it won't work if government just demands they be stopped.


Legislation doesn't stop murder, or robbery, or rape, either. You reckon it has no role at all in reducing the incidence of these things?

Rolfe.
 
Legislation doesn't stop murder, or robbery, or rape, either. You reckon it has no role at all in reducing the incidence of these things?

Rolfe.

The vast majority of people don't commit murder, robbery or rape because they already understand those things are wrong. Circumcision is not considered wrong by the majority of the population. It's either seen as required by a religion or as a common (no big deal) procedure that most every American male has done.

Do you really think a legal ban against circumcision will work when most people don't think it's wrong to begin with?
 
Yes, when those who do cut off bits of babies don't see anything wrong in it. Why, in this case, does those pushing this issue think that the government can just legislate away practices ingrained in certain religions as scared and for the larger part of society is just routine?

We protect girls with such laws, why should we presume that boys shouldn't enjoy the same protection?
 
Legislation hasn't stopped either of these practices. Only education will. Folks have to understand why these things are wrong, it won't work if government just demands they be stopped.

Is your argument actually that all rules and laws are superfluous and that the only thing that stops people doing things we don't like is to educate?

This is clearly, clearly wrong.

I don't know if you've ever been to a pub but British and Irish pubs used to be thick with cigarette smoke until an "unenforcable ban" came in in both countries. Smoking disappeared overnight much to even my surprise.

Now, FGM may not be completely eradicated through banning but it is probably far lower than it would be if FGM were legal in the US and the UK. Male circumcision would also drop off - I expect - even if it isn't eradicated and if that happens the ban will probably be a good thing.

And, as others have said, if this ban only starts people wondering why they found circumcision acceptable in the first place and can think of no good reason then that too will be a success.
 
So, the amendment was redundant? Nobody would have continued to hold slaves? I doubt that.
Making it illegal, or in some other way 'not allowed' was a powerful influence.
Similarly if it were illegal to circumcise baby boys: certainly some people would continue to do it, just as some continue to murder and steal, but it would be a powerful influence.

Perhaps for a different thread, but do you really think that it was the 13th Amendment, and not the destruction of the south in the Civil War that ended slavery?

How much of a "powerful influence" was the 18th Amendment in ending alcohol in the U.S.? How much of a "powerful influence" has there been in ending slavery worldwide when it still occurs, despite being illegal everywhere in the world (ok, maybe not Somalia).
 
We protect girls with such laws, why should we presume that boys shouldn't enjoy the same protection?

Oh we do? We have the laws, just how are girls being protected? Who is investigating/prosecuting these crimes? How many persons in the U.S. have been convicted of FGM?

Stop kidding yourself, laws aren't the answer, education is.
 
Oh we do? We have the laws, just how are girls being protected? Who is investigating/prosecuting these crimes? How many persons in the U.S. have been convicted of FGM?

Stop kidding yourself, laws aren't the answer, education is.

I am not sure, I've read at least a few. However, if you're caught, you are in a heap of legal trouble.
 
Is your argument actually that all rules and laws are superfluous and that the only thing that stops people doing things we don't like is to educate?

Scroll up for my answer.

I don't know if you've ever been to a pub but British and Irish pubs used to be thick with cigarette smoke until an "unenforcable ban" came in in both countries. Smoking disappeared overnight much to even my surprise.

Are your really trying to make an argument comparing the banning of indoor smoking vs. the banning of circumcision?

Now, FGM may not be completely eradicated through banning but it is probably far lower than it would be if FGM were legal in the US and the UK. Male circumcision would also drop off - I expect - even if it isn't eradicated and if that happens the ban will probably be a good thing.

Evidence?

And, as others have said, if this ban only starts people wondering why they found circumcision acceptable in the first place and can think of no good reason then that too will be a success.


And they won't
 
I am not sure, I've read at least a few. However, if you're caught, you are in a heap of legal trouble.

As far as I know, there has been one.

Last November, Khalid Adem, an Ethiopian immigrant living in Atlanta, received a 10-year prison sentence for cutting off the clitoris of his 2-year-old daughter. (He pleaded innocent, accusing the girl's mother, his ex-wife, of orchestrating the cutting.) The case, hailed as the first conviction for female genital mutilation (FGM) in the United States, has renewed attention to the practice a decade after federal legislation was passed to ban it.
 
As far as I know, there has been one.

I was looking for that one too, thought it was in the Carolinas; but there you go. And you can be sure that if discovered others would follow. So why should boys not be given the same protection?
 
Scroll up for my answer.

Is a "Yes" or "No" too difficult?


Are your really trying to make an argument comparing the banning of indoor smoking vs. the banning of circumcision?

Yes. You are making an argument comparing slavery to male circumcision and trying to show that in the case of slavery the ban has been useless because after all, slavery still exists. Your argument clearly seems to be that banning things that were legal is useless and only education works when it comes to changing people's behaviour. I disagree and was showing a clear-cut example where that is clearly not true.

Evidence?

The evidence is a simple application of common sense. Most people don't have their children circumcised because of any deep-seated religious conviction. If it were illegal they wouldn't pursue backroom circumcisions. You know that full well.



And they won't

What is this sentence fragment for? What does it mean?
 
I was looking for that one too, thought it was in the Carolinas; but there you go. And you can be sure that if discovered others would follow. So why should boys not be given the same protection?

This legal protection doesn't seem to have protected girls, why would you think it would protect boys? Both kinds of genital mutilation are not being prevented by legislation.
 
Is a "Yes" or "No" too difficult?

Is it to difficult to just scroll up and read what I posted already?

Yes. You are making an argument comparing slavery to male circumcision and trying to show that in the case of slavery the ban has been useless because after all, slavery still exists. Your argument clearly seems to be that banning things that were legal is useless and only education works when it comes to changing people's behaviour. I disagree and was showing a clear-cut example where that is clearly not true.

Why do you think that folks have agreed that an in-door smoking ban is a good idea? Where did you think that information came from, the government?

The evidence is a simple application of common sense. Most people don't have their children circumcised because of any deep-seated religious conviction. If it were illegal they wouldn't pursue backroom circumcisions. You know that full well.

Drinking wasn't a deep-seated religious conviction when it was banned in the U.S. during Prohibition, yet it was pursued in many backroom during that time period. You know that full well.
 
This legal protection doesn't seem to have protected girls, why would you think it would protect boys? Both kinds of genital mutilation are not being prevented by legislation.

How do you know this? There will always be people who break the law but that doesn't make it not worth having. The fact that there was a law provided a mechanism to convict that man and send him to prison. It could provide the girl a mechanism to pursue civil action in the future. How is that not worth having?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom