So the hell what? How does that justify what you said? It doesn't.
I don't think that what I said requires justification. I think it was a perfectly rational observation. I merely note that you said not a word until you thought you could bully me down with your wild accusations of anti-Semitism, then you charged in with all guns blazing.
Thunder is Thunder. He's never been particularly logical or consistent. This is not news. But again, so the hell what? Are you trying to argue that you were somehow justified in writing something offensive because he deserved to be offended? You've let Thunder exasperate you, and I sympathize (believe me I do), but you've also let your own brain shut down when trying to slam him.
I think you've completely lost it. You're so far gone in the victim mentality, the conviction that Jewish people are always right in what they do and that if anyone criticises them then this may be dismissed and vilified as anti-Semitic, that you can't see how irrational you're being.
Yet you didn't label them as doctors who share Thunder's opinions. You labeled them Jews. Which makes it look a hell of a lot like what you're complaining about is Jews getting too much influence. Can you honestly be that blind about how you sound? You're smarter than that, Rolfe. Or you can be, if you choose to.
I didn't "label" anyone as anything. I said that when these medical committees sit around to discuss these things, there are often one or two senior members who are Jewish, and have Thunder's outlook. They forcefully articulate their point of view. What should happen of course is that contrary views are aired and a rational discussion takes place, and consensus best practice emerges. But in this situation the contrary voices fall silent, for fear of being labelled anti-Semitic.
And in fact you have provided as perfect an illustration of this as anyone could wish for.
If "you" is referring to me personally, then you're way off base. And if it's not, well, let me remind you that I never criticized your posts as antisemitic until you stopped talking about circumcision and started talking about The JewsTM.
I didn't stop talking about circumcision. I'm still talking about it. However, Thunder started posting these weasel-worded medical recommendations that sound
exactly like similar recommendations that can be found from the same bodies endorsing alternative medicine practices. It's the same thing. It's not politically correct to criticise homoeopathy, so the contrary voices wriggle a bit and sit on their hands, and the nut-case view is endorsed.
No group, race or individual gets a free pass to do what they like, child abuse or animal abuse or anything else, simply because they have a persecution complex.
Rolfe.