Ban circumcision in San Fran???

How do you know that Rolfe isn't Jewish like me, and thus feels free to level this charge?

GB

I don't give a damn if he's Jewish or not. What he said was offensive. You don't get a pass on being offensive just because you can claim that you're only being offensive to your own group. That's exactly the sort of identity politics logic which leads to this sort of problem in the first place.
 
What a bunch of wild eyed zealotry. The foreskin is the appendix of the penis. I got rid of mine as an adult and never regretted it. Arguing against circumcision of babies is one thing, but outlawing it--that is just an outrage.

I don't think abortion should be illegal either, but I'll bet most of...um...let me put it another way:

I see a lot of pro-life zealots here arguing for the rights of the uncut.

Yeah, I just compared foreskins to fetuses so you could see yourselves from the other side of the fence. How d'ya like them apples?
 
But, did I see you acknowledging, or discussing? I don't think so.

So the hell what? How does that justify what you said? It doesn't.

And Thunder, despite his trawl back through his posts, only cherry-picked points he wanted to address.

Thunder is Thunder. He's never been particularly logical or consistent. This is not news. But again, so the hell what? Are you trying to argue that you were somehow justified in writing something offensive because he deserved to be offended? You've let Thunder exasperate you, and I sympathize (believe me I do), but you've also let your own brain shut down when trying to slam him.

I pointed out that when people with Thunder's outlook get into a position of authority in the medical profession (and in politics), they tend to promote these views.

Yet you didn't label them as doctors who share Thunder's opinions. You labeled them Jews. Which makes it look a hell of a lot like what you're complaining about is Jews getting too much influence. Can you honestly be that blind about how you sound? You're smarter than that, Rolfe. Or you can be, if you choose to.

You think you get a free pass to do what you like, because anyone who points out the evil in what you are doing can be vilified as anti-Semitic. Well, not here you don't.

If "you" is referring to me personally, then you're way off base. And if it's not, well, let me remind you that I never criticized your posts as antisemitic until you stopped talking about circumcision and started talking about The JewsTM.
 
Russell Crowe recently called circumcision "barbaric and stupid", "who are you to correct nature? Is it real that GOD requires a donation of foreskin? Babies are perfect." He responded to some of the backlash, and calling people "morons" before he took it down and also his pro-choice opinions on abortion, he apologised for "causing distress" and that others interpreted it as "mocking the rituals and traditions of others".

Sucks that he laid down and removed it.
 
What a bunch of wild eyed zealotry. The foreskin is the appendix of the penis. I got rid of mine as an adult and never regretted it. Arguing against circumcision of babies is one thing, but outlawing it--that is just an outrage.

I don't think abortion should be illegal either, but I'll bet most of...um...let me put it another way:

I see a lot of pro-life zealots here arguing for the rights of the uncut.

Yeah, I just compared foreskins to fetuses so you could see yourselves from the other side of the fence. How d'ya like them apples?

Please provide evidence that "a lot" of people on this thread are "pro-life."

I'm happy that you're happy with your mutilated penis, particularly as you consented to have it done as an adult. :)

I'm sorry, but the majority of the people on this thread think it's an outrage to chop off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

GB
 
I don't give a damn if he's Jewish or not. What he said was offensive. You don't get a pass on being offensive just because you can claim that you're only being offensive to your own group. That's exactly the sort of identity politics logic which leads to this sort of problem in the first place.

Yes! I'm glad to see that your faulty view of logic hasn't changed. :)


GB
 
What a bunch of wild eyed zealotry. The foreskin is the appendix of the penis. I got rid of mine as an adult and never regretted it. Arguing against circumcision of babies is one thing, but outlawing it--that is just an outrage.

I don't think abortion should be illegal either, but I'll bet most of...um...let me put it another way:

I see a lot of pro-life zealots here arguing for the rights of the uncut.

Yeah, I just compared foreskins to fetuses so you could see yourselves from the other side of the fence. How d'ya like them apples?

No one is saying circumcision should be outlawed. When someone reaches the age of majority they should be allowed to make the decision to have a circumcision if they wish. Just as you did. The question is whether or not parents have the right to take away such a choice by giving their children a circumcision when they aren't old enough to make any kind of decision at all.

Most people here think it is a pointless, pain-inducing surgery with little to no health benefits which may well be outweighed by the health risks.

As you are using the appendix as an analogy, we could ask whether you would be in favour of having parents take their children to hospital and asking for their children's appendices to be removed. I wouldn't favour such a thing unless they already had to have surgery. It would be creating unnecessary risks to have children's appendices taken out despite the fact there are obvious health benefits to having no appendix.
 
I don't have too much of an opinion about this but I can't really say that I am upset that I was circumcised.
 
What a bunch of wild eyed zealotry. The foreskin is the appendix of the penis.

That's an interesting analogy as research into the potential functions of the appendix is on going: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/10/071008102334.htm it's probably not as 'useless' as was popularly believed. Can you live without it? Clearly, should it be routinely removed, clearly not.

I got rid of mine as an adult and never regretted it.

Which is fine, no one would have prevented you from doing that but all men should have had the dignity of that choice, I doubt most would make it. That is all that is being argued in the proposed law and here.

Arguing against circumcision of babies is one thing, but outlawing it--that is just an outrage.

You need to read more closely because that is exactly what is being proposed, a ban on circumcision of minors without medical need. Once you're 18, or what ever age they decide, you're free to cut, pierce, or decorate as you see fit. And this is what nearly all posters have agreed with, I don't think there is a single post which supports an outright ban.
 
I don't give a damn if he's Jewish or not. What he said was offensive. You don't get a pass on being offensive just because you can claim that you're only being offensive to your own group. That's exactly the sort of identity politics logic which leads to this sort of problem in the first place.


If you'd been with this thread from the beginning, you might have noticed that I joined in originally to challenge Nihilianth's claim that banning infant circumcision was anti-Christian, because Christians circumcise for religious reasons. As a Christian, I knew he was talking poppycock.

Rolfe.
 
So the hell what? How does that justify what you said? It doesn't.


I don't think that what I said requires justification. I think it was a perfectly rational observation. I merely note that you said not a word until you thought you could bully me down with your wild accusations of anti-Semitism, then you charged in with all guns blazing.

Thunder is Thunder. He's never been particularly logical or consistent. This is not news. But again, so the hell what? Are you trying to argue that you were somehow justified in writing something offensive because he deserved to be offended? You've let Thunder exasperate you, and I sympathize (believe me I do), but you've also let your own brain shut down when trying to slam him.


I think you've completely lost it. You're so far gone in the victim mentality, the conviction that Jewish people are always right in what they do and that if anyone criticises them then this may be dismissed and vilified as anti-Semitic, that you can't see how irrational you're being.

Yet you didn't label them as doctors who share Thunder's opinions. You labeled them Jews. Which makes it look a hell of a lot like what you're complaining about is Jews getting too much influence. Can you honestly be that blind about how you sound? You're smarter than that, Rolfe. Or you can be, if you choose to.


I didn't "label" anyone as anything. I said that when these medical committees sit around to discuss these things, there are often one or two senior members who are Jewish, and have Thunder's outlook. They forcefully articulate their point of view. What should happen of course is that contrary views are aired and a rational discussion takes place, and consensus best practice emerges. But in this situation the contrary voices fall silent, for fear of being labelled anti-Semitic.

And in fact you have provided as perfect an illustration of this as anyone could wish for.

If "you" is referring to me personally, then you're way off base. And if it's not, well, let me remind you that I never criticized your posts as antisemitic until you stopped talking about circumcision and started talking about The JewsTM.


I didn't stop talking about circumcision. I'm still talking about it. However, Thunder started posting these weasel-worded medical recommendations that sound exactly like similar recommendations that can be found from the same bodies endorsing alternative medicine practices. It's the same thing. It's not politically correct to criticise homoeopathy, so the contrary voices wriggle a bit and sit on their hands, and the nut-case view is endorsed.

No group, race or individual gets a free pass to do what they like, child abuse or animal abuse or anything else, simply because they have a persecution complex.

Rolfe.
 
What a bunch of wild eyed zealotry. The foreskin is the appendix of the penis. I got rid of mine as an adult and never regretted it. Arguing against circumcision of babies is one thing, but outlawing it--that is just an outrage.

I don't think abortion should be illegal either, but I'll bet most of...um...let me put it another way:

I see a lot of pro-life zealots here arguing for the rights of the uncut.

Yeah, I just compared foreskins to fetuses so you could see yourselves from the other side of the fence. How d'ya like them apples?


What are you smoking? If you wanted to be circumcised as an adult, that was your choice and good luck to you. Why do you want to deprive other people of that choice?

What on earth does this have to do with abortion, either? Has anybody in this thread suggested abortion should be illegal? Who is seeing whom from the other side of what fence?

If there's any parallel at all, I think it would be in the area of a person's right to choose what happens to their own body. So, as I support a woman's right to choose to terminate a pregnancy, I support an adult man's right to choose to keep his foreskin (or indeed to remove it) as he sees fit.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
It's strange, really. I never thought much about circumcision until this thread started. I knew it was a practice carried out by my Jewish friends, but it wasn't exactly a hot topic of conversation, so I tended to assume it was something so minor it wasn't really controversial. I do recall some meaning looks and innuendo being exchanged between two male friends who for some reason had not realised each other was Jewish until that moment, but I couldn't really access the sub-text.

At the same time I'm a passionate advocate of humane treatment of animals, and I teach a class on the subject of animal mutilations as part of an animal husbandry course. I teach that farmers must constantly re-examine what they do, and ensure that mutilations that are not absolutely essential are discontinued, that procedures are as minimal as possible, and that they are carried out as humanely as possible. I also point out that standards change as society's view changes, and there is a history of procedures which were once seen as perfectly acceptable being progressively outlawed.

So where does circumcision lie on that scale? Frankly I was horrified when I read the details of the surgical procedure, and the pain levels exhibited by the baby. It is absolutely impossible that that would be allowed in animal husbandry. It makes castration look entirely benign, quite honestly. If this were animals having this done to them with no robust evidence of overwhelming benefit to counterbalance the pain and the mutilation, it would be banned.

Rolfe.
 
I don't think that what I said requires justification. I think it was a perfectly rational observation. I merely note that you said not a word until you thought you could bully me down with your wild accusations of anti-Semitism, then you charged in with all guns blazing.

Oh please. The fact of the matter is that I don't even care much about circumcision in and of itself. I didn't jump in before because I'm not even really interested in whether you oppose circumcision or not.

I think you've completely lost it. You're so far gone in the victim mentality

Your biases are showing. I don't consider myself a victim, because I'm not. You, however, ARE complaining about being a victim.

I didn't "label" anyone as anything. I said that when these medical committees sit around to discuss these things, there are often one or two senior members who are Jewish, and have Thunder's outlook. They forcefully articulate their point of view. What should happen of course is that contrary views are aired and a rational discussion takes place, and consensus best practice emerges. But in this situation the contrary voices fall silent, for fear of being labelled anti-Semitic.

And in fact you have provided as perfect an illustration of this as anyone could wish for.

Yeah, no. What you're saying is that people will get labeled as being antisemitic just for opposing circumcision. But that's not why I attacked you, is it? No, it isn't. I've repeatedly pointed that out to you, yet you persist in telling what is essentially a lie about what happened here.

I didn't stop talking about circumcision. I'm still talking about it. However, Thunder started posting these weasel-worded medical recommendations that sound exactly like similar recommendations that can be found from the same bodies endorsing alternative medicine practices. It's the same thing.

Then call him out on that. You don't need to even mention religion to do so.
 
Ziggurat, I think you're being hasty in ascribing anti-semitism to Rolfe here. Now, I can't argue that she is right or wrong in what she says, but it boils down to this:

Special interest group A approves of practice X.

People not part of special interest group A disagree or are neutral with regards to practice X

Normally, opposing viewpoints are supplied and practice X is decided to be either useful, or not useful/harmful.

However, in this case, special interest group A have a history of being repressed and practice X is considered to be very important to them, so no one outside of this group voices an opinion because they think they will be accused of bigotry against group A rather than disgust at horrible practice X.

That special interest group A is jews is totally irrelevant. It could be any minority, particularly one with a history of being repressed. If it were a christian practice, or a hindu practice I imagine that a similar form of pressure could and might be used, and even if it isn't the fear of such a label might well make those who would speak out kow-tow to the minority group. Think of how many times a religious group has complained that a claim that disputes their own bias is somehow an attack on the religion.

Some Jewish groups do throw anti-semitism around where it isn't needed or warranted at times, although again, Rolfe might be totally wrong about the perceived pressure. She was talking about the non-Jewish doctors imagining cries of anti-semitism rather than the Jewish doctors actively using the term afterall.
 
Last edited:
They were being polite to you. Or kind. Or something.

You're hearing it now. A circumcised penis is a poor, scarred, naked thing, and I can only pity their owners.

Rolfe.

How much pity are we talking here? :p
 
Interestingly, the BMA is much less mealy mouthed about circumcision for medical purposes:


http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...cision2006.jsp#Circumcisionformedicalpurposes

So circumcision should only be used for medical purposes as a very last resort and is very rarely indicated. But if the parents just want it done for no medical reason.... well that's just fine.
:rolleyes:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/jul/11/doctors-urge-circumcision-on-nhs

NHS urged to offer circumcisions to avoid botched operations

Senior doctors have called for male circumcision to be offered by the NHS amid fears that unregulated operations are leading to serious injuries among Muslim boys.

A number of public health specialists have urged the health service to overturn its ban on such operations after an investigation into circumcisions performed at an Islamic school in Oxford found that 13 out of 32 boys who had the procedure – at an average age of six – ended up with medical problems.

Three endured what a new research paper describes as "incomplete circumcision" at the hands of an overseas-qualified doctor who only had six months of basic surgical training. They also ended up with urethral scarring or a haematoma – a build up of blood that results from internal bleeding – or both. Six had to be treated in hospital for complications related to their circumcision, and two had to undergo the procedure for a second time. Ten of the 13 needed to take a course of antibiotics.

Writing in the UK Faculty of Public Health's Journal of Public Health, the study's co-authors, Dr Karthikeyan Paranthaman and two fellow public health doctors in Oxford, concluded: "This incident highlights the harm associated with circumcision in young children by unregulated operators due to lack of compliance with best surgical and infection control guidance. There is an urgent need for commissioning circumcision services for religious reasons in the NHS."

...

Rather than having us contribute to this barbarism, how about being blunt with the parents? E.g., tell them that they are both deluded and cruel to do that to a child to appease their sadistic bastard of a God and they should be ashamed of themselves?
 
Another query - is it still standard practice in Jewish traditional circumcision rites for the mohel to suck the blood off the penis post-circ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom