Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

You don't believe in reincarnation, right yrreg?

What sort of evidence would it take to get you to change your mind?

Why shouldn't an atheist require that kind of evidence to believe in the "quintessential god"?

Why don't you?
 
Ask yourself whether you dare to write in such ways in an essay type examination, if you at least have any minimal concern for the sacrifices your parents have to endure to put you through college.

This is not an essay, and we need some humor to endure your not too bright pontification.

Perhaps you should read up on all the ways people have failed to prove god´s existence over the last 2000 years. That would give you an idea of the problem and where not to start.
In science it is called knowing the subject.
 
Yrreg, you were supposed to report back with evidence of god´s existence.

Instead you are just stalling with word salat.
Please get to the point.

(No, nescafe, you do not get the MDC.)

:(

But my daughter needs a college fund!
 
Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.

​
And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

Re-grow the severed arm of a church organist who lost his/hers.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.

And miss all the fun?

And here is my latest enlarged enumeration of the ways of non-thinking atheists should avoid, if they want to show mankind that they can engage in constructive exchange of ideas with people who are not atheists like themselves, i.e, atheists themselves who engage in non-thinking ways of writing and talking.

1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.
​

Age-ist!
2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

Can't slip anything by you, can we?


3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.

Somebody's mind is in the gutter.

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.

OK. I'll stick with the wacky rules. Mark 7:10 - Because Moses said, 'Honor your father and your mother,' and 'Whoever curses his father or mother must certainly be put to death.'

5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.

What kind of person would call you such things? I am aghast!

6. Phobia of self-incrimination non-thinking, for example, unreasonable and unintelligent resistance against producing any definition of God for fear of implicating themselves as God-believers.

Einstein and I agree with you on this one.

7. Off on a tangent non-thinking, for example, bringing up a sports event when the topic is about God’s existence.

Bears lost! Alas...Chicago mourns again. Oops....sorry!

8. Tsunami non-thinking, by bringing in so many gods when the most current God believed in by learned theists is enough and best to focus on.

The most current? Are you expecting a new one any time soon?

​
And here is one test for atheists to realize that they are into non-thinking ways of writing:
Ask yourself whether you dare to write in such ways in an essay type examination, if you at least have any minimal concern for the sacrifices your parents have to endure to put you through college.
​

Mommy and Daddy sent you to school? I paid for my own, thank you very much. And as for writing skills, let's diagram that last sentence of yours. Or let's not.


So, if you think that I am neglecting your messages here, it can be because you are not relevant to the topic here, or you are engaged in non-thinking ways of writing.

I will not be ignored!!!!

Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.

Right back at ya, brother!
 
This is not an essay, and we need some humor to endure your not too bright pontification.

Perhaps you should read up on all the ways people have failed to prove god´s existence over the last 2000 years. That would give you an idea of the problem and where not to start.
In science it is called knowing the subject.

I just want to assert that I put my SELF through college twice-- no help from parents... I have a Masters of Science degree... and I put myself partially through law school too before dropping out. (One of the reasons I dropped out is due to arguments like those of yrreg-- I don't feel "right" spinning the truth I want out of the facts that are-- while peppering my spiel with manipulative pedantic semantics. It reminds me too much of religion.)

I think my writing surpasses that of yrreg and that whatever expenses his parents endured to put him through college may have been for naught. I, for one, am tired of that particular insult and request that he tries to think of new ones if he wishes to have any respect from me.
 
Last edited:
Learn to think in terms of quintessences.

[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.​


Since I didn't know off hand what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understood to be the quintessential concept of God, I had to do a little research. I assumed that these people would be no different than theists in any other profession but I wanted to avoid assumptions and deal with evidence.

Theistic Scientists:













I didn't get around to researching the philosophers and artists yet. I will do that as time permits.

One thing I noticed about theistic scientists is that they seem to have the same conception of God, more or less, as most of the Christians I know. (e.g. all-loving, merciful, had a son who came to earth, performed miracles, was sacrificed for the remission of sin, rose from the dead and ascended into Heaven, dictated sacred scripture through prophets which is to be viewed as the ultimate "truth," etc.)






"God is an existent entity independent of man's mind" is a somewhat wordy way of saying "God exists." This statement is pretty much the definition of theism. I doubt you'll find many theists that will disagree with it. Nor will you find many atheists that would disagree that this is what most theists believe.



You must keep in mind if you do some real thinking, that if you ask these people, theistic scientists, philosophers, artists, what is their quintessential concept of God, prescinding ( look up that word prescinding because someone here thought it is not any current English term ) God's dealings with Jews and then Christians and then Muslims, they will tell you:

Of course the quintessential concept of God is:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


Please, Phase Inverter, acquire the skill and habit of thinking in terms of quintessences.


By the way what is your idea of an empirical testing for the ascertainment of entities existing outside man's mind as also entities inside man's mind?


That goes also for atheists here who otherwise love to engage in non-thinking ways of talking and writing.




Yrreg
 
Jeez, it sure takes a lot of pedantic self-aggrandizing psychobabble to keep oneself believing that faith makes one a deep thinker and moral example!

Arrogance thy name is yrreg.
 
I'm thinking.

There is irony in trying to describe what it is one doesn't believe in.

I'm curious about the 'edge' between theist and atheist. I see an outlook that might be described as both.

An honest and objective scientist may feel the awe of the whole shebang of reality, which is really quite astounding, and choose to see it as a whole; maybe even give it a simple name. Such a person might even be moved on occasion, to drop to their knees in front of extreme natural beauty and wonder, and to give thanks, to the whole shebang, as if it existed; as if your thanks counted for anything.

That gets pretty close to theism, as does a fondness for the big bang. That initial singularity may as well be god, as far as i'm concerned. Why not?

One's abstract effection for the singularity is no more religious or irrational than a mathematician's fondness for a certain string of numbers.

As per good/bad god-no-god, who cares? Overall, the combo of good and bad is good.
So, it is good that we are percievers of this amazing reality.

A science geek with the above feelings might be considered more spiritual than a fundamentalist christian; certainly closer to god, even while being an atheist.
 
Just give us the same evidence that would make you believe in the invisible entities you deny the existence of yrreg.

How hard is that?

Surely, something other than brain-washing (indoctrination) has made you believe this crap load of stuff you believe. Do you have any evidence for ANY of your assertions???

--you know, just the same type of evidence you'd require for all the things you deny.
 
Last edited:
[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.​






You must keep in mind if you do some real thinking, that if you ask these people, theistic scientists, philosophers, artists, what is their quintessential concept of God, prescinding ( look up that word prescinding because someone here thought it is not any current English term ) God's dealings with Jews and then Christians and then Muslims, they will tell you:

Of course the quintessential concept of God is:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


Please, Phase Inverter, acquire the skill and habit of thinking in terms of quintessences.


By the way what is your idea of an empirical testing for the ascertainment of entities existing outside man's mind as also entities inside man's mind?


That goes also for atheists here who otherwise love to engage in non-thinking ways of talking and writing.




Yrreg

All right, then, since we've changed the subject, and have decided not to discuss the original point of what quintessential idea of God is shared by theist thinkers, but simply to speak of what you have decided, let us continue.

I contend that God as defined by you cannot be reliably detected or characterized by empirical means. Even if it were possible to detect in some way the presence of a divinity in the universe (which has not happened), the speculation that such divinity is the creator of the universe would still be far beyond the ability of any empirical test. The best possible result would be if such a God were to demonstrate his presence and power in a manner and extent so obvious and testable that it would be reasonable to extrapolate from that empirical evidence that he is capable of the job, or that his own account of the event is reliable. This has never happened.

If such a God were both existent and empirically testable, we would not have this discussion now. All reasonable people would be theists, and only people who cannot admit the obvious, the Yrregs, DOC's and Radrooks of the atheist camp if you will, would still be denying the demonstrable existence and character of God.

In case you had not noticed, this is not the current state of affairs. I do not think that it is terribly important to slice the discussion of empirical testing for God more finely. Any possibility, any instance of empirical testing for God would be an accomplishment of staggering importance in the history of the world. It has not happened. If you think it could be done better, then it's your job to figure out a better way. I'm satisfied that no empirical test for the existence of God is possible, a position shared by many theists, which is why they use the word "faith" to describe their relationship with God.
 
So God is my dog? Or maybe a sycamore? Or a penguin? I like penguins.
They are all existent entities and are all independent of man's mind. Along with any other animal and/or plant you care to name. ...

If you really want me to define god, then I choose the Invisible Pink Unicorn.
She is invisible, pink, a unicorn, and all-powerful. And frequently bad-tempered.
...
You will note that I did not mention that the IPU is the creator of uncertainty and the rapturer of socks. Because these are not things that define her. They are things she does.
italics added.

Wow! I am stunned! Since I have had socks randomly disappear for my entire life, I think I need to reconsider my Pastafarianism and contemplate the IPU's majesty.

My daughter is irresistably attracted to stuffed animal unicorns, especially those that are white with pink manes and tails. Could this mean that she, with her child's openness to the Divine, is recognizing the shadow of the IPU?

Moved, Miss Kitt

PS I like penguins, too!
 
You want us to talk to theists, we get it. Sadly the use of long words will not make you sound any smarter, and your re-use of them just makes you look insane. You remind me of that one crazy guy that goes up and down hollywood putting up the "King George was arrested by the FBI" stickers everywhere. Most here can understand where theists are coming from because most of us started out theistic. I understand the emotional connections, the fear of doubt, the desire to think of things as simple matter of black or white. We had to grow out of those mindsets. Maybe it's you who have to get a better understanding of us. When you have the bravery to doubt and reason on your own, try to walk in our shoes.
 
Last edited:
We can do tests on the whole shebang of reality, and consider it as God, without succumbing to irrational beliefs. A good atheist could be a very devout theist, by upgrading the definition of God to include the whole of what we can observe and verify scientificly.

Far as I know, no religion has the corner on the definition of God.
I think its high-time to ponder a God for atheists.

(tax breaks, if nothing else)
 
Please, atheists, abstain from all such non-thinking ways if you want at least in the USA people to not hold you to be the most distrusted minority in the USA.*




Yrreg


*But no, I am not any US citizen but a student examining atheists, and I find atheists in the US to be most absorbing for an engrossing and delightful examination, to probe into their of atheist mind and heart.

Even British atheist writers find US atheists a rich market for their print output.

​
You are not studying anything. You are preaching.

You cannot study the atheist mind and heart as a group anymore than you can study all theists as a single mind and heart. The variation in reasoning and ideas is greater than you think it is within both atheist and theistic realms of thought.

You also understand very, very little about people in the US.

Find a trash bin and dump the stereotypes you are clinging too. Then, maybe, you might really learn something.
 
Haha, gotcha for not thinking or being engaged in non-thinking.

[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.​


-------------------


So, you think or non-think that just because you got through college on your own, without parental financial support, therefore you are entitled to engage in all the non-thinking ways of talking and writing here, that is one very glaring example of non-thinking.


I will not speak for myself, but I know someone who looks back at me when I look in the mirror, who left home at the age of 17 and got to study abroad on full scholarship away from his home country, without one cent from family and home, but on my own good use of reason and intelligence.

------------------

You know guys, when you talk and write you must already have it in your repertory of mental skills for reason and intelligence to accompany and screen your words all the time, so that you don't say things like because you finished college on your own you can already engage in non-thinking ways of talking and writing.


That is also the trouble with atheists, because they enjoy the gift of free will, they can already choose to wilfully deny God's existence and engage in all manners of non-thinking to keep themselves self-smug that they are freed of God.

-------------------


Anyway, at least do some correct or constructive thinking, what are you in favor of that is good and true aside from hollering all the time that you don't accept the existence of God?

Ah yes, you say you got all your ideas of what is good and true that happen to parallel what theists also hold to be good and true, not because of God but due to chaos operating by accident.

In which case how come you can still write and spell correctly most of the time here, if chaos is your god and chance or accident is the way chaos works, and you are submerged in chaos and bound under accident all the time and everywhere -- unless you also imagine that there are moments and scenes where chaos and accident do not prevail and you are there, but why the privilege of exemption when everything is chaos and accident everywhere and all the time?

That is one very mind-self-annihilating way of thinking, erh, non-thinking.


Incidentally, when you have some non-chaotic and non-accident sane moments, and do some genuine thinking, can you see that chaos and accident are concepts from your limited brain, but with God there is no chaos and no accident, only vertical and horizontal transcendental order, which the Greeks call cosmos.


--------------------


Please, now go back to think about what is empirical testing, which you atheists insist on for at least considering the possibility of God's existence.


And if you get the impression that I am pontificating, go and do likewise but don't engage in all eight and still more coming ways of atheists' non-thinking, when they talk and write in re God's existence or non-existence.





Yrreg
 
Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.

There are so many problems with this one statement alone. First, you're in no position to be chastising others for wasting time and bandwidth when you started numerous threads consisting of the same repetitive nonsense copy-pasted over. Second, you're in no position to dictate what opinions people are and are not allowed to express; if you're allowed to post your beliefs, so can everyone else. This forum is not your private property. Third, if people aren't responding the way you would like them to, then it should occur to you somewhere down the line that maybe it's because of the way you address them. Copy-pasting your list of strawmen is not going to get your arguments taken seriously. If you hate atheists so much, then there's no need for you to interact with them.
 
Your mind is not acquainted with the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.

I suspect you are either being flippant or are indeed a naive mind.

I will no longer read any messages from you in this thread.

No, I am not putting you on ignore, just that when I come across your messages here I will not read them, because as I said you are either being flippant or a mind that is indeed naive not constructively fruitful to engage with.


Shall we have a smile together just the same, before I start not giving you any further attention in this thread, okay?

But I do encourage you to engage your mental resources in looking up the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists and read them, to come up with what your more constructive mind can distill to be their quintessential concept of God.

Perhaps you could look up the phrase "condescending prick".

Or just take Fiona's posts as outstanding examples of courtesy and thoughtfulness even while disagreeing with what someone else said.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom