Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Well I am non-tergiversative and sincere. Fortunately I fail on the interested part. You might be able to inspire some interest if you didn't cherry pick your responses and pretend the valid ones didn't exist.

Wait... Bummer, maybe I am interested in yrreg. His sentence structure and generalizations reminds me of... something. I have some studying to do.
 
Hey Yrreg, here's another definition of God for you to factor in, since after all, you did ask atheists to define your God for you.

God is the Great Dick Lover in the sky. The weight of evidence is behind this definition, since it's all right there in the Bible, therefore I win.

God....made....stuff. All the stuff. That's God. The Stuffmaker.



Rather makes him sound like a roll of Mentos, doesn't it? God: the Stuffmaker!



Ooooh! If you put God in Diet Coke, does he make huge jets of carbonated foam shoot up into the air?

That would at least be interesting.

Well of course. Just change the lyrics to the commercial jingle and you get this. Creepy how well it fits, innit?


It doesn't matter what comes, stuff goes better in life,

With Godly stuff and full of Life!

Nothing gets to you, stayin stuff, stayin cool,

With Godly stuff and full of LIFE!

Stuff goes better, Godly stuffness,

Stuff goes better with Godly stuff and full of life!

--God, The Stuff Maker!
 
To be fair, Shalamar, Yrreg is not a typical religious person: few are as insulting and few are as arrogant -in fact for a christian humility is part of the imitation of Christ, as I understand it, and pride is a sin. Let us not judge religion by this kind of thing.

thanks, now I have to recallibrate my sarcasm meter...........:)
 
Last edited:
Let's see how my post did!

Here they are again, the non-thinking ways of atheists:


1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.​

I stuck to Yahweh of the Bible. Ding!

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.​

Stuck to the Bible, ding!

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.​

Ding!

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.
​

Stuck to the Bible, ding!


5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.​

Ding!

6. All other kinds and degrees of non-thinking resorted to by atheists to skirt the issue (I will classify them under descriptive names as I come across them next time).​

Yrreg



Wow! My post cleared this bar easily, 6-0!
 
So let's see if you "win" the "honor" of a reply.

My posts delivered and I'm still waiting the "intelligent discussion" promised. Sadly, being the skeptic that I am, I have little hope that it will be forthcoming.
 
To be fair, Shalamar, Yrreg is not a typical religious person: few are as insulting and few are as arrogant -in fact for a christian humility is part of the imitation of Christ, as I understand it, and pride is a sin. Let us not judge religion by this kind of thing.
I agree, but I'm afraid that recent threads by other theists put me in mind of that old "Beyond the Fringe" sketch about the coal miner who wished he could have been a judge: "I'm not saying there's a load of riffraff down the mines, I'm not saying that - I'm just saying there's a load of riffraff down my mine!"
 
Wow! My post cleared this bar easily, 6-0!


My posts delivered and I'm still waiting the "intelligent discussion" promised. Sadly, being the skeptic that I am, I have little hope that it will be forthcoming.


In post #90 I proved, at least tentatively, using the system of logic proposed right here in this thread by yrreg himself (making it pertinent and on topic), that he is a non-thinking person, lacking in reason and intelligence. I mean, as if that wasn't already obvious.
 
I thought I was in full compliance with the yregg programme so far. Appears not! Ive been left dangling. No response at all. Best go fishing.


Please do some real thinking on what is an empirical test for ascertaining the existence of something like God.

I am myself doing some serious thinking about empirical testing for ascertaining the existence of things outside man's mind.

So far I have learned that empirical means in the present context of man's knowledge about God or no God, having to do with man's experience.



What do you think are the organs of man's experiences by which man gets to know realities outside his mind and also inside his mind?

----------------


For the sake of mutual collaboration in the exchange of ideas about God or no God, please don't continue in a flippant fashion, that is not conducive to constructive and productive thinking.

This does not mean that you cannot mention penis and vagina and anus as organs of man's experiences, by which man gets to know realities outside man's mind and also realities inside man's mind.


Just that your heart and mind must be ordered toward thinking without distractions, by not indulging in what I already enumerated earlier, ways of non-thinking by atheists who don't want to do serious thinking.

One way of atheists, another one, of non-thinking is to go off a tangent away from the topic at hand, for example, bringing up some sports event when the topic here is about the existence or non-existence of God.




Yrreg
 
...let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.


Since I didn't know off hand what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understood to be the quintessential concept of God, I had to do a little research. I assumed that these people would be no different than theists in any other profession but I wanted to avoid assumptions and deal with evidence.

Theistic Scientists:
Blaise Pascal said:
The God of Christians is not a God who is simply the author of mathematical truths, or of the order of the elements; that is the view of heathens and Epicureans. He is not merely a God who exercises His providence over the life and fortunes of men, to bestow on those who worship Him a long and happy life. That was the portion of the Jews. But the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob, the God of Christians, is a God of love and comfort, a God who fills the soul and heart of those whom He possesses, a God who makes them conscious of their inward wretchedness, and His infinite mercy, who unites Himself to their inmost soul, who fills it with humility and joy, with confidence and love, who renders them incapable of any other end than Himself

Robert Boyle said:
Christ's passion, His death, His resurrection and ascension, and all of those wonderful works which He did during His stay upon earth, in order to confirm mankind in the belief of His being God as well as man.

Sir Isaac Newton said:
There are more sure marks of authenticity in the Bible than in any profane history

Sir William Herschel said:
All human discoveries seem to be made only for the purpose of confirming more and more the Truths contained in the Sacred Scriptures

Michael Faraday said:
The Bible, and it alone, with nothing added to it nor taken away from it by man, is the sole and sufficient guide for each individual, at all times and in all circumstances…For faith in the divinity and work of Christ is the gift of God, and the evidence of this faith is obedience to the commandment of Christ.

Sir Joseph Lister said:
I am a believer in the fundamental doctrines of Christianity


I didn't get around to researching the philosophers and artists yet. I will do that as time permits.

One thing I noticed about theistic scientists is that they seem to have the same conception of God, more or less, as most of the Christians I know. (e.g. all-loving, merciful, had a son who came to earth, performed miracles, was sacrificed for the remission of sin, rose from the dead and ascended into Heaven, dictated sacred scripture through prophets which is to be viewed as the ultimate "truth," etc.)


Here, I will get started.

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.



"God is an existent entity independent of man's mind" is a somewhat wordy way of saying "God exists." This statement is pretty much the definition of theism. I doubt you'll find many theists that will disagree with it. Nor will you find many atheists that would disagree that this is what most theists believe.
 
What do you think are the organs of man's experiences by which man gets to know realities outside his mind and also inside his mind?
Oh great. Is yrreg now going to try the Malerin technique or hurling out solipcistic/idealistic/dualistic BS in order to justify this "there is no evidence of god because evidence is all in the mind" argument.

For the sake of mutual collaboration in the exchange of ideas about God or no God, please don't continue in a flippant fashion, that is not conducive to constructive and productive thinking.
You first.
This does not mean that you cannot mention penis and vagina and anus as organs of man's experiences, by which man gets to know realities outside man's mind and also realities inside man's mind.
There is no reality inside of man's mind. They are called hallucinations and delusions.
Just that your heart and mind must be ordered toward thinking without distractions, by not indulging in what I already enumerated earlier, ways of non-thinking by atheists who don't want to do serious thinking.
That is one of the most hypocritical statements I have read in some time. Great job.
One way of atheists, another one, of non-thinking is to go off a tangent away from the topic at hand, for example, bringing up some sports event when the topic here is about the existence or non-existence of God.
Still waiting for you to define your god and to provide evidence for it.
 
Please do some real thinking on what is an empirical test for ascertaining the existence of something like God.

I am myself doing some serious thinking about empirical testing for ascertaining the existence of things outside man's mind.

So far I have learned that empirical means in the present context of man's knowledge about God or no God, having to do with man's experience.



What do you think are the organs of man's experiences by which man gets to know realities outside his mind and also inside his mind?

----------------


For the sake of mutual collaboration in the exchange of ideas about God or no God, please don't continue in a flippant fashion, that is not conducive to constructive and productive thinking.

This does not mean that you cannot mention penis and vagina and anus as organs of man's experiences, by which man gets to know realities outside man's mind and also realities inside man's mind.


Just that your heart and mind must be ordered toward thinking without distractions, by not indulging in what I already enumerated earlier, ways of non-thinking by atheists who don't want to do serious thinking.

One way of atheists, another one, of non-thinking is to go off a tangent away from the topic at hand, for example, bringing up some sports event when the topic here is about the existence or non-existence of God.




Yrreg

Yrreg, are you reading posts in an alternate universe? Why can't you respond to posts that are actually on the subject with responses that have some relationship to the subject? You accuse others of going off on a tangent, but you cannot seem to concentrate long enough to remember what the thread is about.
 
I would accept any evidence for any ways we can know things exist--usually this involves data or measurement or testing of some sort if the thing proposed is invisible-- like atoms, or magnetism, or wind, or mental illness, or music.

What would it take you to believe in sprites that insert ideas into your mind for their enjoyment and yours? Can you provide the type of evidence that would convince you that such sprites exist if they did, indeed, exist? Why wouldn't we expect as much of the "quintessential god"? (I take it that you deny the existence of sprites the same way I deny the existence of the "quintessential god".)
 
Last edited:
If you want an answer that coincided with your prejudices I will give you a fairly common definition of the Christian god.

Male
All-knowing
All-powerful
All-good
Eternal
​

You left out...

Really good-looking
Hung like a unicorn
A fan of "The Hills"
 
My concept of God and I am now into empirical testing of God.

Yrreg, "What is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists?" cannot be answered, or even approached, until this question is answered:

Which theology are you referring to?


If you have not read this earlier post from me, please read it now, here reproduced below and be guided accordingly.


Posted by Wowbagger
Posted by yrreg
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.
​
If you are asking atheists if that is the essence of God that they don't believe in, I would say that covers part of it.

But, I also think atheists will deny God exists, no matter how you define God.

We can discover certain things that exist independent of man's mind. Whenever there is independent verification of empirical findings, in science, that is usually what is happening.

If you think God exists, independently of man's mind, what sort of tests can you come up with, to test for His existence?
​

Yes, for myself I see the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists to be:


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​

If atheists also know this quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, then we have already atheists and me here a common accepted idea of God.



Quote:
But, I also think atheists will deny God exists, no matter how you define God.
​

At least they are knowledgeable about what they deny to be existing, instead of just saying that they don’t have to give any ideas at all of what they are denying because it does not have any existence for them.

Which I must tell them is most contrary to reason and intelligence on their part, and it is also one non-thinking way with atheists -– which I might call the phobia of self-incrimination.



Quote:
We can discover certain things that exist independent of man's mind. Whenever there is independent verification of empirical findings, in science, that is usually what is happening.
​

I like to ask atheists what exactly they mean by empirical verification of existing things, by which empirical verification God is supposedly from their part not susceptible to, and therefore the conclusion is that God does not exist?



Quote:
If you think God exists, independently of man's mind, what sort of tests can you come up with, to test for His existence?
​

You mean empirical tests?


I have to do some thinking, not that I have no tests for God’s existence of the empirical kinds, but I have to think of the ways to best expound what tests can be applied to God that can be empirical or even better than empirical ones, and which also produce certitude in man’s mind.

--------------------

Addressing atheists here who are not into non-thinking ways of exchanging ideas on God or no God:

Do you agree to the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists as expressed in the following statement:


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​

And do you agree to the task on the part of theists to validate the existence of God by empirical tests?


I will have to do some thinking about empirical tests for the validation of existence of things like God.




Thanks, Wowbagger, for your constructive exchange of ideas here.



And please, atheists here, when you are asked to give your ideas of God Which you deny to be existent, you are not being reasonable and intelligent in insisting that you don't have to define God which you don't believe to be existing.

That is one more non-thinking way with your kind of attitude in discussions with people who really want to find out how you think and how you feel as to come to the conclusion that there is no God.

That way of non-thinking which is another one to my list of non-thinking ways atheists engage in is what I might call phobia of self-incrimination.


And for atheists who are really sincere in the exchange of ideas about God, please be informed that I have already time and again stated my concept of God as:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​

And as per suggestion of Wowbagger, I am now into the serious thinking about empirical testing of God's existence.

If you care to do also some really genuine serious constructive and productive thinking, dwell on what exactly is an empirical test by which God must be susceptible to in order that His existence can be established to the satisfaction of atheists.




Here are two more non-thinking ways of atheists in web forums and also in web writings generally:

>> Off a tangent non-thinking, for example bringing in a sports event when the topic is about God's existence.

>> Tsunami non-thinking, for example, bringing in so many gods of so many and usually no longer current religions and earlier peoples, past civilizations and cultures, so as to drown any constructive and productive exchange of ideas in focusing on the most current concept of God among learned theists.




Please, atheists, abstain from all such non-thinking ways if you want at least in the USA people to not hold you to be the most distrusted minority in the USA.*




Yrreg


*But no, I am not any US citizen but a student examining atheists, and I find atheists in the US to be most absorbing for an engrossing and delightful examination, to probe into their of atheist mind and heart.

Even British atheist writers find US atheists a rich market for their print output.

​
 
Yrreg, you were supposed to report back with evidence of god´s existence.

Instead you are just stalling with word salat.
Please get to the point.

(No, nescafe, you do not get the MDC.)
 
We're the most distrusted minority because of bigots like you and your indoctrinators--not because we are less trust-worthy.

In fact atheists have at least one claim to trust that theists don't have-- they don't claim "special knowledge" or access to "divine truths". They are far less likely to engage in the dishonest confirmation bias necessary for all people to believe their woo is true. They acknowledge that wishing something were so or "believing in it" doesn't make it so. They are also far less likely to confuse fact with conjecture and far less likely to judge others as they imagine themselves humble and "thinking".

So give us the evidence you would require for the invisible entities you deny! That's fair.

By what reason do you dismiss gods of the past and yet still believe in the one you refer to as the "quintessential god"? You deny these gods.... you deny sprites... just as we deny your "quintessential god" and your assertions that it is we who are "non-thinking". Why don't you try giving us the same evidence that would convince you of the things YOU deny.

What could be more fair than that. What would it take to get you to believe that sprites are the ones planting ideas and thoughts in your head?
 
I read that the palms are not strong enough, and the nails have to go through the wrists.

So much for stigmata miracles.
 
Latest list of non-thinking ways indulged in by atheists.

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.

​

And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.


And here is my latest enlarged enumeration of the ways of non-thinking atheists should avoid, if they want to show mankind that they can engage in constructive exchange of ideas with people who are not atheists like themselves, i.e, atheists themselves who engage in non-thinking ways of writing and talking.



1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.

5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.

6. Phobia of self-incrimination non-thinking, for example, unreasonable and unintelligent resistance against producing any definition of God for fear of implicating themselves as God-believers.

7. Off on a tangent non-thinking, for example, bringing up a sports event when the topic is about God’s existence.

8. Tsunami non-thinking, by bringing in so many gods when the most current God believed in by learned theists is enough and best to focus on.

​

And here is one test for atheists to realize that they are into non-thinking ways of writing:

Ask yourself whether you dare to write in such ways in an essay type examination, if you at least have any minimal concern for the sacrifices your parents have to endure to put you through college.​



So, if you think that I am neglecting your messages here, it can be because you are not relevant to the topic here, or you are engaged in non-thinking ways of writing.


Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.





Yrreg
 
I'm pretty sure that's an exact replica of the statue my church had when I was a kid.

I'm not sure it's a good idea to have kids staring at that all the time...


ETA
I see yrreg posted as I was writing this...,

(I'm pretty sure that's an exact replica of a post he made earlier.)


Anyhow yrreg, --just give us the evidence you'd require to believe in the invisible entities you deny the existence of.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom