Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420


Posted by yrreg

Posted by yrreg
So, would you like to tell us, atheists here who are sincerely interested in exchange of ideas, what you know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2008 c.e., now going to 2009 c.e.?


Yrreg
​

So, would you like to tell us, atheists here who are sincerely interested in exchange of ideas, what you know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2008 c.e., now going to 2009 c.e.?

Without going into your bad habit of non-thinking tergiversative ways?



Yrreg

​

So, would you like to tell us, atheists here who are sincerely interested in exchange of ideas, what you know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2008 c.e., now going to 2009 c.e.?

Without going into your bad habit of non-thinking tergiversative ways?


I guess not.


Anyway, this is what I think is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists:

God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.


What do you say to that?


If you disagree, then please produce your own account of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists.

So that at least we can together for a start work out a mutually accepted concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists.

And from that point get into a constructive exchange of ideas on God and no God.


----------------

Here is another of your non-thinking ways in web forums and in web writing:

Name-calling people who want to exchange ideas with you on God or no God, like calling them fundies, trolls, IDiots.

Please abstain from such unconstructive ways of exchanging ideas with people who like to hear from you your reasonable and intelligent thoughts on God or no God.




Yrreg


Just in case there are atheists here who are non-tergiversative on the one hand, and sincere and interested on the other to engage with me on exchange of ideas in regard to the existence of God or non-existence of God, let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.

Keep in mind for your own security in the embrace of your atheistic worldview that in so undertaking this mutual task: you are not in any way committing yourselves to the admission that there exists God.

What we want to do is to arrive at a concept of God acceptable to both you and me, so that we can get some constructive exchange of ideas on the existence of God or His non-existence.

----------------

Here, I will get started.


Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.




Yrreg
 
I don't know why I'm bothering, given your track record of completely ignoring all replies to your threads here and on IIDB, but no, I don't accept your statement "God is an existent entity independent of man's mind".

Do you accept my statement God is an entity existing only in man's imagination ?
 
Or mine? God is an explanatory concept which does not explain anything?
 
God is an existent entity entirely dependent on man's mind and action.


I am trying to get you to come up with what you know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


Please try again.




Or you believe that your statement is what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God?


In which case, I suggest that you just read this thread but dispense yourself from writing messages here, because you would not be constructively engaged here.




Yrreg
 
I am trying to get you to come up with what you know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.
There's a lot of different, condradictory ones. That one, in my mind, is the most likely to be true.

Or you believe that your statement is what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God?
At least one.
 
Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.
I would agree that that is what theist take as basic understanding.

I don´t see how that will help you understand that atheist don´t belive in any god.

Are you asking "what exatly is it you don´t belive in?"
or "please define the (to atheists) nonexisting god?"
 
Last edited:
Just in case there are atheists here who are non-tergiversative on the one hand,
We get it already. You found a big word in your thesaurus that you think makes your posts sound more intelligent, despite the fact that you have demonstrated an utter lack of understanding of its definition, and clumsy simpleminded vernacular constitutes the remainder of your claims. It's not very hard to catch when someone is doing this. Give it up already and just use the word "equivocate." It's got the same number of syllables, so I don't see what your complaint is.

and sincere and interested on the other to engage with me on exchange of ideas in regard to the existence of God or non-existence of God, let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.
I see you still haven't figured this out and are waiting for someone else to define it for you. Not the concept of God, I mean the term "exchange of ideas."

Keep in mind for your own security in the embrace of your atheistic worldview that in so undertaking this mutual task: you are not in any way committing yourselves to the admission that there exists God.
Aww, but then who am I supposed to hate while we're having this discussion?

What we want to do is to arrive at a concept of God acceptable to both you and me, so that we can get some constructive exchange of ideas on the existence of God or His non-existence.
Let me jump several steps ahead and warn you that if you were keeping the teleological or cosmological arguments in reserve as proof for God in order to shout, "Gotcha!" (though I can't imagine why you'd ever want to do that) that house of cards has long since been blown down.

Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​
So-- theists believe in God? That's got to be the newsflash of the century.

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​
It doesn't help if your proposed definition contradicts what you said immediately before it. Nice try sneaking that in though.

If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.




Yrreg
Or you could just save some trouble, run away, and start a new topic whining about how atheists didn't answer the way you wanted them to. Though again, I can't imagine why you'd ever want to do that. :rolleyes:
 
Yrreg, it would behoove you to actually engage with the people who are responding to your threads.

No atheist would ever agree with your statement, as it is the opposite of what they believe. An agnostic would say "there's no way to know."

There is no quintessential concept of god, just as there is no quintessential concept of the boogy man. (Or is that boogieman, or bogey man, or boogie woogie, or oogie boogie...)
 
Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.




Yrreg

No. I do not accept this statement.

I can conceive no equivalent statement in which we might find agreement.

You believe in the existence of an entity, which existence you cannot prove.

I do not believe in the existence of that entity, which non-existence I cannot prove.

At best, the only compromise we two can reach is your concession that the entity might not exist, and mine that it might.

I am willing to grant my concession. Are you willing to grant yours?
 
Last edited:
I am trying to get you to come up with what you know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


Please try again.

Well why don't you answer your own question so we can discuss it. Nobody here reads minds.
 
Just in case there are atheists here who are non-tergiversative on the one hand, and sincere and interested on the other to engage with me on exchange of ideas in regard to the existence of God or non-existence of God

There are SOME theists I might be interested in exchanging such ideas with. YOU already aptly demonstrated total unwillingness to exchange ideas, or to even hear anything that does not fit your preconceptions. Especially your (utterly wrong) preconceptions of how atheists think.

So the answer is no.
 
Please read the OP carefully.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.

Go and find out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God.


When you have come to the quintessential concept of God from these theistic people, then bring the concept up in this thread.




Yrreg
 
WARNING! The following post contains humor which might confuse Gerry:


Tergiversate.

Cast:
Dave - boss
Bruce - Williams

[Set in office. Bruce knocks on the door.]

Dave: Come in.

Bruce: I came as soon as I ascertained you needed to see me, sir.

Dave: Sit down, Williams.

Bruce: [sits] What is it, sir?

Dave: There have been some complaints about your use of language on the docks.

Bruce: If this is about yesterday, sir, yes I did use a few blue words, a few cuss words, but as soon as I ascertained that the mix up had been corrected --

Dave: Noo, Williams, it's not your swearing that I'm getting complaints about; it's the fact that use the word "ascertain" too much.

Bruce: Really?

Dave: Yes, apparently you use it an average of two to three- hundred times, daily.

Bruce: Well, I do, but so...other...few words...fit.

Dave: Well, it's driving the men crazy.

Bruce: Who's complaining, sir? Is it Sanchez?

Dave: Noo, it's not Sanchez. It's--it's the older men, the ones nearing retirement.

Bruce: Sir, I ascertain that these men are just jealous of my command of the...English...uh language.

Dave: Well, perhaps. But, I suggest just to keep things running smoothly down at the docks that you humor me by limiting yourself to these four work-related phrases: [reads them off a paper] "Good morning fellas; Hand me that thing; Boy, this work's hard; Guys, break's over".

Bruce: Sir, I ascertain--

Dave: Ah.

Bruce: -- that it's their problem. They're just jealous of me. It's my right to ascertain things. You should talk to them about their being upset about my...ascertaination.

Dave: Look, I was young once; and, whatever you do in the privacy of your home, with your good lady wife, well that's your business. But, when it starts to slow work down on the docks, then it becomes my business.

Bruce: I ascertain--

Dave: If you don't back off that word, you'll be looking for a new job -- comprendez-vous?

Bruce: I...asc--

Dave: Unh-uh.

Bruce: ah--

Dave: Mmm-mm.

Bruce: ah--

Dave: Nn-nn.

Bruce: Asc--

Dave: N-nuh-no.

Bruce: Asc -- asc--

Dave: Nooo-no-no-no.

Bruce: I asc--

Dave: Mm-mm-mm-mm.

Bruce: Cer--

Dave: No.

Bruce: tuh--

Dave: Uh-uh. "Good morning fellas; hand me that thing; boy, this work's hard; guys, break's over".

Bruce: I asc--

[Dave shoves the paper in his face. Bruce grabs it with disgust.]

Bruce: [pouting] Boy, this work's hard.

Dave: There ya go! Good boy! Now, get the hell out of my office.

[Bruce gets up to go.]

Dave: Glad we had the chance to delineate our little problem.

[Twinkley music sounds out the word "delineate" dances around the screen.]

Bruce: [to himself, trying the word out] Duh-lynn-e-ate. Duh-lynn-e-ate... Sir, I promise I'll never use that...other word ever again. [to himself] Duh-lynn-e-ate.

[Dave eyes him skeptically, as Bruce continues trying the word.]
 
Last edited:
Please read the OP carefully.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.

Go and find out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God.


When you have come to the quintessential concept of God from these theistic people, then bring the concept up in this thread.




Yrreg

Do your own research Yrreg. If and when you have a topic to discuss then please feel free to set it out and give us your ideas about it
 
Yrreg. Please listen. It doesn't matter what definition you arrive at, atheists do not believe in any god.

You can define your god however you wish, it won't make any difference. Atheists don't believe that any god exists.
 
Man, this is a go-nowhere thread if I've ever seen one. This chap's only motive is to prop-up his personal belief system. Humoring him is a gratuitous pastime at best. D
 
Please read the OP carefully.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.

Go and find out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God.


When you have come to the quintessential concept of God from these theistic people, then bring the concept up in this thread.

Yrreg

After many, many years of asking religious people this sort of question, I find that, after the attempts at purported logical explanation, are refuted, the claim is that I must find belief.

The trouble is that all the religions believe in many different and contradictory things with the same degree of self-satisfied seriousness. See my sig.

:pigsfly:pigsfly:pigsfly:pigsfly:pigsfly
 
Please read the OP carefully.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.

Go and find out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God.


When you have come to the quintessential concept of God from these theistic people, then bring the concept up in this thread.




Yrreg

Why would atheists care what theists' quintessential concept of your god is?

What is your quintessential concept of the Invisible Pink Unicorn that you are angry at and deny the existence of?

Why do you keep starting new threads, fleeing old ones that are EXACTLY THE SAME THING?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom