Yrreg -- In your latest long post (# 137) I see you have again re-stated the basic disconnect between your view of atheism, and atheists' view of atheism:
That is also the trouble with atheists, because they enjoy the gift of free will, they can already choose to wilfully[sic] deny God's existence and engage in all manners of non-thinking to keep themselves self-smug that they are freed of God.
Atheism is not willfully denying God's existance, any more than not believing in the Tooth Fairy is "willfully denying" that the Tooth Fairy exists. It's an absense of belief, not a willful denial of what is believed.
When a person gets a cancer diagnosis, but doesn't get any further medical treatment because, they say, "I'll be fine" -- that is an example of denial. When a woman ignores that her granddaughter has disappeared, that cadaver dogs found body scent in her daughter's car trunk, and believes that the missing baby will turn up somewhere, because the daughter's contradictary statements about what happened when the child vanished must be true--that's denial.
When someone says, "Look, there's no evidence of a Tooth Fairy, and in fact my Mom and Dad admit that when I was a kid, they put money under my pillow because they thought believing in the Fairy was a fun thing for me," -- that's simply acknowledging that there is no evidence for, and ample reasons against, belief in an-provable purely spiritual entity. Not believing in gods works exactly the same way.
I don't believe in poltergeists;I don't believe in the Tooth Fairy; I don't believe in the Easter Bunny; I don't believe in Vishnu the Destroyer; I don't believe in the Sidhe; I don't believe in brownies, pixies, or sprites; I don't believe in ghosts; I don't believe in demons, or angels, or gods. I just plain don't believe in things that defy the rules of physics, chemistry, biology, and epistemology. The list of what I don't believe in keeps expanding as more unlikely claims come in. I don't believe in reiki (sp?), or Touch Therapy, or homeopathy, or the Elders of Zion.
I need evidence; and not just evidence that someone else believes, but evidence that stands on its own. I don't willfully deny something when I say that there's no evidence (or insufficient evidence) of it. I just keep my mind uncluttered by the legions of myths that mankind has made, and is making daily. (Check out the Mars Civilization people, if you want to see mythmaking in action.)
I hope you take a few minutes to truly look at what I said, Yrreg. It's the thing that stands between you and meaningful exchanges with the atheists, here and elsewhere, that would like to share a discussion. We don't tell you what you believe, we trust you to know that and tell us--as is relevant to the discussion--what you think. Please do us the same courtesy.
Regards, Miss Kitt
That is also the trouble with atheists, because they enjoy the gift of free will, they can already choose to wilfully[sic] deny God's existence and engage in all manners of non-thinking to keep themselves self-smug that they are freed of God.
Atheism is not willfully denying God's existance, any more than not believing in the Tooth Fairy is "willfully denying" that the Tooth Fairy exists. It's an absense of belief, not a willful denial of what is believed.
When a person gets a cancer diagnosis, but doesn't get any further medical treatment because, they say, "I'll be fine" -- that is an example of denial. When a woman ignores that her granddaughter has disappeared, that cadaver dogs found body scent in her daughter's car trunk, and believes that the missing baby will turn up somewhere, because the daughter's contradictary statements about what happened when the child vanished must be true--that's denial.
When someone says, "Look, there's no evidence of a Tooth Fairy, and in fact my Mom and Dad admit that when I was a kid, they put money under my pillow because they thought believing in the Fairy was a fun thing for me," -- that's simply acknowledging that there is no evidence for, and ample reasons against, belief in an-provable purely spiritual entity. Not believing in gods works exactly the same way.
I don't believe in poltergeists;I don't believe in the Tooth Fairy; I don't believe in the Easter Bunny; I don't believe in Vishnu the Destroyer; I don't believe in the Sidhe; I don't believe in brownies, pixies, or sprites; I don't believe in ghosts; I don't believe in demons, or angels, or gods. I just plain don't believe in things that defy the rules of physics, chemistry, biology, and epistemology. The list of what I don't believe in keeps expanding as more unlikely claims come in. I don't believe in reiki (sp?), or Touch Therapy, or homeopathy, or the Elders of Zion.
I need evidence; and not just evidence that someone else believes, but evidence that stands on its own. I don't willfully deny something when I say that there's no evidence (or insufficient evidence) of it. I just keep my mind uncluttered by the legions of myths that mankind has made, and is making daily. (Check out the Mars Civilization people, if you want to see mythmaking in action.)
I hope you take a few minutes to truly look at what I said, Yrreg. It's the thing that stands between you and meaningful exchanges with the atheists, here and elsewhere, that would like to share a discussion. We don't tell you what you believe, we trust you to know that and tell us--as is relevant to the discussion--what you think. Please do us the same courtesy.
Regards, Miss Kitt