Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Come on, guys. Let's talk about the organs of experience that detect non-existent entities.

Personally, my duodenum tingles everytime a leprechaun is near. And my pancreas throbs to the beat of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony when the Invisible Pink Unicorn trots by.
 
I'd be glad to give up my identity as an atheist is there was any evidence for a deity (or deities.) Just ordinary evidence... probably the kind that it would take for yrreg to believe in an invisible immeasurable entity he currently denies the existence of.
 
Hmm. Let me see. The organs that allow us to know that something exists outside of our minds.

How about eyes? I see something, it appears separate from me. Ears? I hear sounds that I did not make. I can touch, taste and smell things that aren't me.

Is that what you're asking for, yrreg?
 
Come on, guys. Let's talk about the organs of experience that detect non-existent entities.

Personally, my duodenum tingles everytime a leprechaun is near. And my pancreas throbs to the beat of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony when the Invisible Pink Unicorn trots by.

Mine too!!
 
Yrreg, what organs of experience do you use to detect your god but deny reincarnation?

How do you distinguish ghosts from demons? How do you distinguish your quintessential god from the non quintessential ones that people have believed in?

Maybe if you were a little more forthcoming, we could make sense of whatever it is you are asking for. Certainly, you've used an "organ of experience" to discern these things, right?
 
Yrreg,

Your OP was as broad as the Pacific Ocean. How dare you tell people what is allowable to post and which is not. You may have "created" this thread but you are not it's "god".
 
Maybe we need to simplify a part of the question. I don't know why I keep beating my head against the wall hoping for civil and intelligent discourse, but I will try this one more time:

Yrreg: let us stipulate for the moment that your working definition of God is agreeable, and work with it. Let us further stipulate, as a thought exercise, that somehow or other, it is possible empirically to detect the existence of a divine entity in the universe. We need not specify which organs of perception, real or imagined, would be required for this, nor even what as-yet undiscovered means one might use to be sure that the entity perceived is indeed divine. Let us just, for the sake of discussion, imagine that it is so, and that rational people could be persuaded empirically that it is so.

I still maintain that it would not be possible, in any way, empirically to determine that the divinity you perceive is the divinity you define as the creator of the universe. Your only possible knowledge of that would be by testimony and authority, or by logical inference.

Right. There you have it. That is my last attempt at a civil response to what started out purporting to be a discussion about the epistemological problem of knowing God. Do you care to discuss this?
 
I'm sure I often smell things that I at least say aren't me.

Stop tergiversating! It is well known that the quintessential principle of flatuence, as established by philosophers, scientists, and artists in 2008 C.E., is "whoever smelt it, dealt it." I would like to discuss this quintessential principle. If any of you are sincerely interested in such a discussion, please pull my finger.

Please do not derail this thread with non-thinking comments like "whoever denied it, supplied it."
 
Yrreg,

Your OP was as broad as the Pacific Ocean. How dare you tell people what is allowable to post and which is not. You may have "created" this thread but you are not it's "god".



by what organ are you perceiving that yrreg is not this thread's god?
 
Last edited:
Stop tergiversating! It is well known that the quintessential principle of flatuence, as established by philosophers, scientists, and artists in 2008 C.E., is "whoever smelt it, dealt it." I would like to discuss this quintessential principle. If any of you are sincerely interested in such a discussion, please pull my finger.

Please do not derail this thread with non-thinking comments like "whoever denied it, supplied it."

I would just like to add: "one smart fellow, he felt smart" (said 3 times out-loud in rapid succession.)
 
It's difficult to consider any 'quintessential' definition of 'God', seeing as how so many theists have differing (and even contradictory) definitions of God. The most one could extract is that God is/was a Superior Being. Certainly, we need not bring up 'hoary Gods' such as Thor or Zeus to acknowledge that theological experts with some non-Christian backgrounds see God/god as a being with greater than human powers, but less than omnipotence. Modern pagans hold belief in many such deities. Likewise, not all theists are going to acknowledge that God 'created' everything. In fact, a handful of modern theologists even subscribe to the concept that the biblical God (OT version) was, in fact, merely one of a pantheon (which, in early Judaism, he was)... meaning that while God may have created the Earth, he may not have had a hand in much else. Or, that the OT God may simply have been the one of several who chose the Jews as his own people - leaving the other peoples of Earth to other members of his family.

Then, of course, we have to cope with theists who define God in terms of abstractions of concept - the 'if a person behaves as if it's real, it's real enough' notion. Of course, such a God concept is of little use to most theists, but not all.

Without going deeper into it, asking what the LCD of theistic definition is when referring to God is tantamount to asking them what Christianity is. There are just too many possible definitions. And to embrace a singular definition, such as the one yrreg embraces, is to discard a significant portion of countering definitions.

Meanwhile, the atheist position is relatively clear. They refuse to believe in any deific concept for which some level of quality, empirical proof is absent. They also refuse to accept as deific god-concepts which are insignificant. For example, of what significance is it to define God as a purple lemon? Certainly, such a 'god' is irrelevant (although somewhat interesting) in terms of deity.

There is a concept of God I, personally, find oddly compelling... that God was the creator of the Universe - which died in its creation. Where does that place the argument between theists and atheists? Of course, such a being is unworthy of worship - or, more specifically, such a deity is incapable of appreciating or needing such worship - and I doubt many theists would be willing to entertain such a notion. Likewise, the deist concept, that a Creator exists who is utterly unconcerned with the activities on this tiny, insignificant speck of Creation, meets a similar fate - yet this concept, as well, is still held by many. Our founding fathers were rather fond of the concept.

So it really is insignificant to bother with whatever 'quintessential' god concept theists may hold when discussing the existence or non-existence of God with atheists. I would suggest it is better to simply define your own terms of what God means, and then try to have a reasonable discussion with atheists as to their belief or non-belief in your own concept - or, if applicable, their reasons for not worshipping the god-concept you expound.

yrreg, of course, is free to ignore this post as he sees fit.
 
Ugh!!! EVERYONE! Please stop replying to yrreg!!! You're only drowning perfectly good threads under with pulling up his perfectly pointless ones!!! He keeps making more and more! Just stop giving him attention, please! D:

Think of all the other great threads there are on here. Think of the neglect those poor threads are feeling from all the attention you are giving this poor misguided sap! Yes, I'm guilty of giving attention too! But in the time I've been reading his threads, I've relized how pointless they are. No matter how many times you tell the child to stay out of the cookie jar, he'll go back if he wants to. He won't understand why he can't have a cookie now. (bad example, I know)

Nevertheless, my point stands true. You're wasting posts by responding to his. And if you've been reading his other threads I won't have to elaborate any more on this subject.
 
God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.

oh really?
where can i find the evidence proving that?
and how did "he" do that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom