Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Guess Yrreg will be back as soon as he has come up with evidence of god´s existence.
 
It is evidence, Toke, but not as we know it....







Well ok, I lied. It isn't :D
 
I guess that's the last we'll see of him then.

Sadly, no -- he will be back with some word salad he will call "evidence" shortly. We might even get a new Pes Oir Amsus story!

Hey, Yrreg, what about atheist buddhists?
 
Sadly, no -- he will be back with some word salad he will call "evidence" shortly. We might even get a new Pes Oir Amsus story!

I found this????

What is mind? Mind is not matter.
What is matter? Never mind!
 
How about

People who believe in God(s) think he/she/they is/are jolly important (to varying degrees) and on the whole try to keep on the their good side (except when they don't).
 
Yrreg, "What is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists?" cannot be answered, or even approached, until this question is answered:

Which theology are you referring to?
 
At least they are knowledgeable about what they deny to be existing, instead of just saying that they don’t have to give any ideas at all of what they are denying because it does not have any existence for them.

Which I must tell them is most contrary to reason and intelligence on their part, and it is also one non-thinking way with atheists -– which I might call the phobia of self-incrimination.


Okay, yrreg, please list and define all things for which you deny the existence. Everything. Don't just say you don't have to define them because, to you, they don't exist. According to your logic (and I use the word "logic" very loosely here), that would run contrary to reason and intelligence, and would make you, by your definition, a non-thinking person and demonstrate that you have, again by your own terms, a phobia of self-incrimination.

So are you a non-thinking person, lacking in reason and intelligence, or are you prepared to list and define all things, everything, for which you do not accept the existence?
 
So, Yrreg, I addressed your question politely with what I think is the problem with attempting to pin down the "quintessential" attributes of God, as opposed to a working definition. You seem to have plenty of time to make non-specific responses in which you make general assertions that people are not worth responding to. How about a dialogue here on the actual subject of your thread?

We are talking about whether or not we can say what God is, and whether or not there is agreement by theists on the definition, are we not? I contend that although we can probably agree on a working definition for ordinary conversation, such a definition is not specific enough to be useful in a theological discourse without clarification. In other words, if you want to debate about God in any useful way, you need to do your own job of saying what you mean when you use the word, or refer back to some other person or religious doctrine which does that job.

Care to comment?
 
How about this:

The God I don't believe in is NOT the 100 foot tall bearded man in the sky that watches over us. The God i don't believe in is more subtle and sophisticated.
 
"And don't tell me God works in mysterious ways," Yossarian continued [...] "There's nothing mysterious about it, He's not working at all. He's playing. Or else He's forgotten all about us. That's the kind of God you people talk about, a country bumpkin, a clumsy, bungling, brainless, conceited, uncouth hayseed. Good God, how much reverence can you have for a Supreme Being who finds it necessary to include such phenomena as phlegm and tooth decay in His divine system of Creation? What in the world was running through that warped, evil, scatological mind of His when He robbed old people of the power to control their bowel movements? Why in the world did He ever create pain?"
 
As I mentioned in the thread on Atheists and sexual libertinism, please abstain from non-thinking ways of interacting with people who want to hear from you your ideas of God or no God.

Here they are again, the non-thinking ways of atheists:


1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

​
bolding mine



Wait...

YOU ask US to give a definition of god as we perceive philosophers etc. to define it.

And then, when you get an answer, you disregard it because it's not the Christian god you prefer?

You are a hypocrite.


I chose the Invisible Pink Unicorn for a reason: It's self-contradictory. Much like a goodly number of other gods that are being or have been worshiped around the world. Call it a "representative example".


The trouble is (and which you don't seem to understand) is that there are thousands, if not millions, of different interpretations of "gods".
And Thor, and Krisha, and Zeus, and what-have-you are all interpretations of "gods".
It is damned-near impossible to know which one you are referring to.



Here is another way of non-thinking atheists indulge in, I call it the phobia of self-incrimination; it consists in refusing to give any concepts of God which you deny to be existing.


Because there are so freaking many of them.

Every theist I have talked to will have a slightly different take on it. As I've pointed out before, this allows you to disregard any definition you don't like by simply saying "that's not the god I believe in". This is why I have been pressing you for a definition of the god you believe in. Not a resume, a definition. Its it male or female? Is it omniscient, omnibenevolent, omnipresent and/or omnipotent?



But fine.

If you want an answer that coincided with your prejudices I will give you a fairly common definition of the Christian god.


Male
All-knowing
All-powerful
All-good
Eternal​


And I will immediately say that this god does not exist. Note that this in in contrast to saying I don't believe in it.

Why?
Because it is self-contradictory.


But you now have a definition from me that agrees with your preconceptions. So you can't prance around and complain that we aren't giving you the answers you wanted.



By the way: Do you believe in the Invisible Pink Unicorn?

No?

Then understand this: your lack of belief in the IPU (or Zeus, or Thor, or Krishna, etc) is exactly the same as an atheists lack of belief in the IPU (or Zeus, or Thor, or Krishna, etc) or your god.


It's not that we secretly know god exists, and deny it so we can masturbate.
It's not that we secretly know god exists, and deny it so we can misbehave.


It's that we don't believe in it. Full-stop.
Exactly the same as you not believing in the IPU (et-al).


Do you agree that it would be rude of me to assert that the reason you don't believe in, say, Vishnu, is because you are too attached to material goods (Karma) and want to ignore the necessity of removing that attachment (a necessary condition for reaching the next plane of existence)?
 
Last edited:
Just in case there are atheists here who are non-tergiversative on the one hand, and sincere and interested on the other to engage with me on exchange of ideas in regard to the existence of God or non-existence of God, let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.

Keep in mind for your own security in the embrace of your atheistic worldview that in so undertaking this mutual task: you are not in any way committing yourselves to the admission that there exists God.

What we want to do is to arrive at a concept of God acceptable to both you and me, so that we can get some constructive exchange of ideas on the existence of God or His non-existence.

----------------

Here, I will get started.


Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.




Yrreg
Gods somewhere between a Cosmic Muffin and a Hairy Thunderer.
 
Its a trick.

Yrreg wants atheists to 'define' god as he defines it. Its a 'gotcha' moment so he can say: "Ha! You do believe in my god! You angry atheist you!"

But he is throwing out, and igoring any 'description' of god that doesn't fit in his worldview, and instead stoops to 'non-thinking'. In other words: If he ignores it, then it doesn't exist.

Yrreg is a fine example of why I dislike religion more and more.
 
To be fair, Shalamar, Yrreg is not a typical religious person: few are as insulting and few are as arrogant -in fact for a christian humility is part of the imitation of Christ, as I understand it, and pride is a sin. Let us not judge religion by this kind of thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom