Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.
Yrreg

Please don't post here then either.

And I'll do what I like thank you.

I'll make sure that means I'm wasting forum and peoples time ok?

don't like it? There's the door.
 
Yrreg, you are a most exasperating poster, and I do not understand why you are so unwilling to engage. Yes, I believe that most theists would agree with your "quintessential concept of God" - that God exists as an entity independent of the human mind. But I am completely blank on why that should be an issue. To me, it seems merely a tautology, so I'm not sure why you're even asking our opinion on that fact. Are you leading us somewhere? If so, please proceed.
 
Yrreg, you are a most exasperating poster, and I do not understand why you are so unwilling to engage.
Oh, Yrreg wants to engage, but doesn't seem to have an opinion thats worth engaging with..............

Yes, I believe that most theists would agree with your "quintessential concept of God" - that God exists as an entity independent of the human mind. But I am completely blank on why that should be an issue.
Don't fret, your temporary blankness is a gift to spare you from more torture.;)

I'm trying for permanent blankness, so I read all of yrreg's post(s) before I go to bed each night..........:boggled:
To me, it seems merely a tautology, so I'm not sure why you're even asking our opinion on that fact. Are you leading us somewhere? If so, please proceed.

Lead?
Up the garden path, more likely..........:p
 
Yrreg, "What is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists?" cannot be answered, or even approached, until this question is answered:

Which theology are you referring to?


Even if yrreg deigns to address this essential question, his past performance leads me to believe that he will dismiss it as "tergiversative".
 
Posted by yrreg
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.
​

If you are asking atheists if that is the essence of God that they don't believe in, I would say that covers part of it.

But, I also think atheists will deny God exists, no matter how you define God.

We can discover certain things that exist independent of man's mind. Whenever there is independent verification of empirical findings, in science, that is usually what is happening.

If you think God exists, independently of man's mind, what sort of tests can you come up with, to test for His existence?


Yes, for myself I see the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists to be:


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​

If atheists also know this quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, then we have already atheists and me here a common accepted idea of God.


But, I also think atheists will deny God exists, no matter how you define God.


At least they are knowledgeable about what they deny to be existing, instead of just saying that they don’t have to give any ideas at all of what they are denying because it does not have any existence for them.

Which I must tell them is most contrary to reason and intelligence on their part, and it is also one non-thinking way with atheists -– which I might call the phobia of self-incrimination.


We can discover certain things that exist independent of man's mind. Whenever there is independent verification of empirical findings, in science, that is usually what is happening.


I like to ask atheists what exactly they mean by empirical verification of existing things, by which empirical verification God is supposedly from their part not susceptible to, and therefore the conclusion is that God does not exist?


If you think God exists, independently of man's mind, what sort of tests can you come up with, to test for His existence?


You mean empirical tests?


I have to do some thinking, not that I have no tests for God’s existence of the empirical kinds, but I have to think of the ways to best expound what tests can be applied to God that can be empirical or even better than empirical ones, and which also produce certitude in man’s mind.

--------------------

Addressing atheists here who are not into non-thinking ways of exchanging ideas on God or no God:

Do you agree to the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists as expressed in the following statement:


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​

And do you agree to the task on the part of theists to validate the existence of God by empirical tests?


I will have to do some thinking about empirical tests for the validation of existence of things like God.




Thanks, Wowbagger, for your constructive exchange of ideas here.



And please, atheists here, when you are asked to give your ideas of God Which you deny to be existent, you are not being reasonable and intelligent in insisting that you don't have to define God which you don't believe to be existing.

That is one more non-thinking way with your kind of attitude in discussions with people who really want to find out how you think and how you feel as to come to the conclusion that there is no God.

That way of non-thinking which is another one to my list of non-thinking ways atheists engage in is what I might call phobia of self-incrimination.




Yrreg
 
And please, atheists here, when you are asked to give your ideas of God Which you deny to be existent, you are not being reasonable and intelligent in insisting that you don't have to define God which you don't believe to be existing.
What!??

Stop right there. Why are we being unreasonable? Please elucidate why we should have to clearly define what we don't believe in?

It's not only the Christian god we don't believe in, yrreg. It's also the Hindu gods, the Norse gods, the Greek gods, and yes - we don't even believe in the Flying Spaghetti Monster the way you believe in the Christian god. So no matter what the definition of God, we don't believe in it. You can play around with definitions all you like, but if you're defining any kind of metaphysical or paranormal or divine entity, then you're defining something we atheists don't believe in.

Playing around with a single definition is pointless, since we don't believe in any definition of "god".
 
And please, atheists here, when you are asked to give your ideas of God Which you deny to be existent, you are not being reasonable and intelligent in insisting that you don't have to define God which you don't believe to be existing.
Yrreg

One day I'll have that in my signature line.

Your definition of being reasonable and intelligent sucks too.

Got any more big words? tervigwhateveritwas was great, I really enjoyed that.
 
Did as you asked. Im waiting for the next step. Please dont toy with me, the suspense is unbearable.
 
Here is another non-thinking way with atheists.

Here is another way of non-thinking atheists indulge in, I call it the phobia of self-incrimination; it consists in refusing to give any concepts of God which you deny to be existing.

You can put it in No. 6 below in the quoted enumeration, as No. 6(a).

As I mentioned in the thread on Atheists and sexual libertinism, please abstain from non-thinking ways of interacting with people who want to hear from you your ideas of God or no God.

Here they are again, the non-thinking ways of atheists:


1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.

5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.

6. All other kinds and degrees of non-thinking resorted to by atheists to skirt the issue (I will classify them under descriptive names as I come across them next time).

​


I will not give any time and attention to your messages as soon as I sense that you are into such kinds of non-thinking.

Here is how you will know in case you are not aware that you are into any or all of the ways of non-thinking common among atheists in atheist web forums or web writings:

Ask yourself whether you dare to write in such ways in an essay type examination, if you at least have any minimal concern for the sacrifices your parents have to endure to put you through college.​



So, if you think that I am neglecting your messages here, it can be because you are not relevant to the topic here, or you are engaged in non-thinking ways of writing.


Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.


In the meantime I am off to do some thinking on the best ways and means, and in the most simple plain language I can master, how to test God's existence by empirical ways and means.


And you atheists also do some serious real thinking -- no, not non-thinking -- about empirical testing for the existence of things like God.




Yrreg
 
Arthwollipot,

Oh you non-thinker!:rolleyes:

This whole thing is pointless while Yrreg refuses to engage others constructively.
 
Last edited:
And please, atheists here, when you are asked to give your ideas of God Which you deny to be existent, you are not being reasonable and intelligent in insisting that you don't have to define God which you don't believe to be existing.


If that is the case, yrreg, then you are not being reasonable and intelligent if you don't define all the gods that you don't believe in.
 
Here is another way of non-thinking atheists indulge in, I call it the phobia of self-incrimination; it consists in refusing to give any concepts of God which you deny to be existing.

You can put it in No. 6 below in the quoted enumeration, as No. 6(a).




In the meantime I am off to do some thinking on the best ways and means, and in the most simple plain language I can master, how to test God's existence by empirical ways and means.


And you atheists also do some serious real thinking -- no, not non-thinking -- about empirical testing for the existence of things like God.




Yrreg
It will be a cold day in hell when you can provide empirical evidence of god.:jaw-dropp
 
In the meantime I am off to do some thinking on the best ways and means, and in the most simple plain language I can master, how to test God's existence by empirical ways and means.

I am amaced that no other theist have throught of that in the last 2000 years, that is, proving god´s existence. :D

Great idea Yrreg, I am sure you can come up with something over the weekend.
 
I thought I was in full compliance with the yregg programme so far. Appears not! Ive been left dangling. No response at all. Best go fishing.
 
Yrreg said:
At least they are knowledgeable about what they deny to be existing, instead of just saying that they don’t have to give any ideas at all of what they are denying because it does not have any existence for them.

This is your fundamental error, I think.

Most atheists have a good idea of what they do not believe in: they do not believe in ANY of the various conceptions of god which mankind has proposed. You are less knowledgeable then they, Yrreg: they understand that there is no one definition/description of God which is the "essence" of the idea. You clearly think there is and you mention theist philosophers and scientists and artists: but these do not agree either. So why don't you mention particular theists you believe have outlined a conception of God which you can accept: I am sure people will be happy to start from there. It is completely pointless to ask people to define your god for you: if you do not know him no-one can. And in fact this is a familiar tactic from the religious: they like to leave god vague so they cannot be challenged on particular aspects: it is not we who are not thinking: it is you. One cannot have a discussion about "god" without defining the term and there is no agreed definition at all. So we have nothing to talk about.

Another reason people ask you for your own conception is that we are more courteous than you: we do not assume we know what you believe. You might try that some time - it is really helpful in discussion and it tends to avoid the kind of insults you have repeatedly offered in your various threads, as well as moving things forward more constructively. So do your research and tell us what god you would like to discuss: it is clear that you do not understand that all gods are alike to atheists and you think that raising older gods is in some way flippant or irrelevant: it isn't. Odin and Zeus are raised because there were people who believed in those gods just as surely as you believe in yours.

You imply that they did but do so no longer because our understanding of the nature of god has improved: good. What you need to do is to show how those older notions were demonstrated to be inadequate. This is how knowledge advances: a hypothesis is adopted and then later other evidence/knowledge comes along which fits the fact better and so it is abandoned in favour of a new one. Your various posts suggest you think this has happened in the context of religion: so show us how. Demonstrate the facts/evidence/logic which makes one god more likely than several: show why the process of reducing the numbers should stop at one rather than none. That would be a good start to a conversation and might clear away some of the debris which litters your threads

It would also be helpful if you stopped being so rude
 
1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

Note to self, add Jehova, Jeebus, Holy Ghost too Its all Retrogressive non-thinking after all.
But I won't say that here cos I've got to argue about nothing, and hell, you can't get a bigger nothing than the crackpot dogma of my god. (remember to delete that bit when I post it up)

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.
Translation I don't have the wit about me to realise what analogy, metaphor or parable and any other minor nuance of language actually means.

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.
Translation
I divide all responses into "upper" or "lower" class arguments, so I can avoid addressing the issues behind those comments because I don't have a clue. I don't have an absolute to measure the values against either, so I can shift the goalposts when I please to evade any real impression of giving straight answers.
4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.
Translation
I've attended and passed Radrooks "biblical literacy test".
5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.
Translation
Because I probably can't figure out what the heck those descriptions mean.
Especially when aimed at myself.
6. All other kinds and degrees of non-thinking resorted to by atheists to skirt the issue (I will classify them under descriptive names as I come across them next time).
Translation And just to cover all the bases that I might not have thought of, cos these atheists are tricky I'll put this "get out of jail free" card in so as to call "foul" as often as I like if I can't answer the issue at hand.
I will not give any time and attention to your messages as soon as I sense that you are into such kinds of non-thinking.
Translation And after all that I'll ignore you anyway, even if you have a point I might remotely understand, just in case I get it wrong.


Thats how it looks to me.
 
Last edited:
I agree that the statement in the OP may very well be the worldview of some christian theists.

No, I do not believe in such an entity.

Now what?
 
Here is another way of non-thinking atheists indulge in, I call it the phobia of self-incrimination; it consists in refusing to give any concepts of God which you deny to be existing.
I could give the concepts of god in which I don't believe, but it would be such a long list it would probably crash the entire forum.

Instead, I will simply state;

Whichever definition of god you or any other person care to propose, however quintessential, I don't believe in it.
 
I agree that the statement in the OP may very well be the worldview of some christian theists.

No, I do not believe in such an entity.

Now what?

You'll probably get ignored......................................................:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom