Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

If you have no idea of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists, please take the time to read on them, just enough to have an adequate acquaintance with what you can sum up to be the quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, namely, theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.
There is no quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists. They do not universally agree on anything.

This is a statement I will accept:
There is a label, "God".
​
If you ask me what I know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists, here is my statement:

God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​
That is what I take to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.
Well, here's some news: A lot of them disagree with you.
 
But lets, for the sake of argument, agree that god is "the creator of heaven and earth and everything".

(Which is funny to me-- because heaven doesn't exist and earth is not even a grain of sand in comparison to the universe... but we'll go with it.)

Yes, for the sake of argument yrreg, I deny that there is a creator of "everything". I deny all invisible immeasurable forms of consciousness whether they create planets or not.

I deny them because I can't tell such things from the absence of such things. That is something this atheist denies. I'm sure most atheists will agree that they deny the existence of such entities anywhere EXCEPT the minds of humans.

So carry on with your sermon... or whatever you hoped to prove, preach, or "discuss" here. Rest assured, I'm perfectly comfortable denying the god as you've describe him. I'm as comfortable denying him as you are in denying the existence of fairies, unicorns (mentioned in the bible you know), and Xenu. I feel the same way about the god you describe as any invisible entity you would deny the existence of.
 
In answer to the title of this thread:

No.

And apparently, neither are you.

Here's a quarter, sonny. Call back when you're ready to talk, rather than preach.

Beanbag
 
Yrreg, I think to avoid confusion it would be helpful to start right off by acknowledging that two separate things can addressed without overlap: What god is and what god is defined as.

Your first statement here could be taken an assertion of God's existence, rather than an attempt to define what we mean when we use the term.

This subject has come up before on this forum, and been pretty well argued to death, but I don't think you'll find a truly uniform, dependably unarguable consensus among even theist philosophers and other sages about all the essential attributes of God. About the best you can do is to come up with a definition suitable for general use, a definition that can be assumed to be what we mean when we use the word "God" without further qualification or modification, in informal discourse. If you were writing philosophy or theology, you'd be expected to state specifically what we mean by the word, or defer to a specific doctrine that defines it, before discussing it.

I will admit that it has been some time since I read extensively in the works of theistic philosophers and theologians, but I have done so in the past. My take on this question is that there is no "quintessential concept of God" that is more than a rough vernacular definition, unless and until we define it further for the instance in which we're using it.

When we use the vernacular term "God," (as differentiated from "a god," "gods," etc.) I would say that unless otherwise specified, we can be assumed to mean an entity external to ourselves which is credited with the creation of everything that is, except for itself. Most of the time we could add that that entity is assumed to be supernatural or transcendent, and to have created the universe intentionally.

Of course, saying this carries with it no suggestion that such an entity either exists, or is capable of existing, either ontologically or logically.

All of which raises the big question: so what? If you want to speak of God or of anything else, all you need to do is say "When I use the term, I mean this and this and this," and then say your piece. In other discussions, you've been extremely reluctant to clarify your terms. Now you seem to be inviting us to define them for you, and making snarky comments when we do. Cui bono?
 
If we were to attempt to describe the typical Christian god-concept most of us grew up with, it would probably be something like:

  1. Name: Yahweh
  2. Age: Countably infinite
  3. Activity: Nothing for a countably infinite period of time.
  4. Activity: Create things that are not himself, not counting the waters of chaos, which apparently existed prior to starting to create stuff.
  5. Activity: Create Earth, life, stars, sun, other planets, and so on.
  6. Activity: Tempts humans, knowing they will fail.
  7. Activity: Sentences those who fail to hard time, hard labor, and death.
  8. Activity: Sentences the descendents of those who fail to the same fate.
  9. Activity: Kills everyone on Earth except 6 people, including millions of wicked, wicked babies, who cried in terror while drowning.
  10. Activity: Self-incarnates as a mortal, who is then executed as a rabble-rouser.
  11. Activity: Tells those who believe it that they will be resurrected into bliss if they believe it without proof.
  12. Activity: Tells those who disbelieve it without proof that they'll be resurrected and tortured indefinitely, so badly they'll wail and gnash their teeth.
  13. Activity: Never fears death, himself.
  14. Activity: Never fears pain, himself.
  15. Activity: Never fears terror or torture or loss of a loved one, himself.
  16. Activity: Is never told to believe in a higher god without proof or he'll be tossed into super-Hell.


Note to theists and philosophers: Just because you made people doesn't grant you license to terrorize them.
 
Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


Yrreg

Yes, that's what I deny the existence of. I deny that to the same extent that you deny the corollary statement:
God does not exist independent of man's mind.​

Does that help you? Now do you know exactly what I deny the existence of? And it really doesn't include just gods-- but all the invisible immeasurable entities that have been claimed to exist independent of man's mind. Yes, ALL of them. I deny them all equally. I deny them to the same extent that you deny the corollary. How's that? Moreover, I concur that the majority of theists that you refer to accepts what you have written in bold--they believe that god exists independent of human minds. Is that enough fodder for the discussion you supposedly want to have? I don't know how I could be more clear or less tergiva-whatever. I'm sure that most atheists would agree that they deny (don't believe in?) any gods that exist outside the human imagination.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, "What is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists?" cannot be answered, or even approached, until this question is answered:

Which theology are you referring to?
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, "What is the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists?" cannot be answered, or even approached, until this question is answered:

Which theology are you referring to?

I bet it's not Hindu!
 
If you have no idea of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists, please take the time to read on them, just enough to have an adequate acquaintance with what you can sum up to be the quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, namely, theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


Please don't bring up at this point of the thread your own thoughts about God and no God; later we might go into your thoughts.


First, as I say in the OP, I am inviting you to share with me your knowledge of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you ask me what I know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists, here is my statement:


God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


That is what I take to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.





Yrreg

I did what you asked, I read up on theistic scientists, theistic philosophers and theistic artists and can confirm that;

they, and you define god as "god is the creator of heaven and earth and everything".

What is my next mission, I'm all eager here.
 
Last edited:
So, yrreg, you have 2 people here who agree that most theists believe in a god that created everything and exists independent of human thought.

We don't believe in such a god. We deny that such god exists.

Now what?
 
Please read the OP carefully.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.

Yrreg

What possible benefit could there be for me to do extensive research on the details of your fantasy? You think I should expend that much effort just to humor you?

Get over yourself.
 
Your mind is not acquainted with the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.
Translation
I'm just going to consider you beneath my level of education. Stay there.
I suspect you are either being flippant or are indeed a naive mind.
Translation I'm not going to take you seriously because I can't answer any of your queries, to hide my ignorance...
I will no longer read any messages from you in this thread.
Translation
And because I can't answer your questions , and am too lazy and stupid to think for myself, I am going to ignore you.
No, I am not putting you on ignore, just that when I come across your messages here I will not read them, because as I said you are either being flippant or a mind that is indeed naive not constructively fruitful to engage with.
Rince repeat, rince repeat. Next verse.
Shall we have a smile together just the same, before I start not giving you any further attention in this thread, okay?
Translation
Idle threats, and let's just smile as if we agree to make me look good, while I try and find some way of wriggling out some more of actually answering any questions or admitting I might be wrong.

But I do encourage you to engage your mental resources in looking up the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists and read them, to come up with what your more constructive mind can distill to be their quintessential concept of God.
Yrreg

TranslationDo your own research cos I can't really find any and I'll use big words to make me sound like I know what I'm talking about when I don't. You are not being constructive, although condesendingly enough I know you can do it. You just need to believe.:)
 
Last edited:
I'd say that an atheist could entertain the notion of an overall consciousness that is not visable. It needn't be god, though it could be, in which case a person entertaining such an idea would cross over into the theist realm.

Consider the sheer quantity of invisable data that 'exists' at any given time from all the wireless transmissions. It makes the notion of an 'immaterial' consciousness more digestable. I think an atheist could accept the Gaia hypothesis without believing in god, for instance.
 
As I mentioned in the thread on Atheists and sexual libertinism, please abstain from non-thinking ways of interacting with people who want to hear from you your ideas of God or no God.

Here they are again, the non-thinking ways of atheists:


1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.

5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.

6. All other kinds and degrees of non-thinking resorted to by atheists to skirt the issue (I will classify them under descriptive names as I come across them next time).

​


I will not give any time and attention to your messages as soon as I sense that you are into such kinds of non-thinking.

Here is how you will know in case you are not aware that you are into any or all of the ways of non-thinking common among atheists in atheist web forums or web writings:

Ask yourself whether you dare to write in such ways in an essay type examination, if you at least have any minimal concern for the sacrifices your parents have to endure to put you through college.​



So, if you think that I am neglecting your messages here, it can be because you are not relevant to the topic here, or you are engaged in non-thinking ways of writing.


Please don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.





Yrreg
 
Look, yrreg, you have 3 people who agree on your "quintissential" god who don't believe in that god...

I don't think you are going to find anyone who agrees with your pedantic and silly characterization of "non-thinking" since the majority of people here seem to think more clearly than you from my perspective. Labeling something and repeating it does not make it so. We don't consider you a role model nor a teacher since you have presented no evidence that you have anything to offer in the area.

However, at least 3 people have agreed to your provisional assertions that were supposedly necessary for you to begin whatever discussion you wanted to have. So begin. Stop with the judgmental insults and present whatever positive evidence you have for whatever point you are trying to make.

Or consider yourself fodder for our amusement.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg,

I have seen some patronising posters in my time here, but you take the cake. Anyone who does not debate according to your worldview is defined as non-thinking. Grow up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom