Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

A few years ago I noticed a division in my thinking. Back then I was Catholic. I started noticing that the church was taking up positions that just didn't make sense to me. Pres. Bush (who I strongly disagree with) was spouting religious none sense in his speeches and the faithful were eating it up. I realized that even what I found entertaining was counter to religion. I had always been a fan a comedians and realized that my favorites were to ones that were critical of religion (Lenny Bruce, George Carlin, Bill Maher, David Cross, etc). [OPERAIDER'S NOTE: If you have not heard of David Cross, you need to go to Border's and get It's Not Funny and Shut Up You F%&$ing Baby] I eventually found that I was completely skeptical of the paranormal with the single exception of a belief in God. I then saw P&T's episode on the bible, and heard David Cross quote some lines from it, and realized that in all the years that I was a Catholic I had never actually read the Bible. So I read it and here I am today, completely cured off.
 
Jambo - I actually did the exact opposite of most of you , instead of going from belief to scepticism I went from scepticism to belief
I'm some what confused by this comment. I could have swore that you had told me that you had become interested in the paranormal at a very young age? That doesn't seem to leave you much time to be skeptical. I've also noticed some people making reference to that fact that you are still fairly young. I believe someone said your in your teens. This seems to leave even less time for you to have been skeptical.

P.S. Please note that I am in no way trying to look down on him for being young. Jambo, please correct me if I'm wrong above.
 
Since as far back as I can remember, I wanted there to be magic in the world. As a very young child, I watched "The Magic Land of Alakazaam", a children's show that featured a magician (and his assistant Nonny Darnell in a sequined suit :eek: ) and it never dawned upon me that when they sold their "magic kit" that it was just stage magic for kids. I attended church and believed in God and Jesus, but that didn't stop me from believing in seances and UFO's. I read "The Search for Bridey Murphy" and "Chariots of the Gods" with awe and belief. I studied astrology and knew all the signs and what they meant. I bought a Ouiji board and shoved the planchette around with my eyes squinted (just giving the spirits a bit of a boost.) There was not a single thing I didn't believe in.

Or did I? I wonder if maybe my mania for magic (and comic book superheroes) didn't stem from my desperate wish for there to be magic in the world. Any kind of magic. I was willing to give magic the benefit of the doubt in every case, but dang it, magic kept dropping the ball. I never got a spirit to do anything significant in a seance. I never got to where I could pick people's zodiac signs reliably. I never met an alien (though I did see a UFO - long story).

So it was with great reluctance that I adopted skepticism as a default position. I wanted to be a starry-eyed believer, but I had just been let down too many times.

But I haven't given up. I really want someone to win the Randi challenge so there can be magic in the world. But I'm not giving them a free pass. If they're real, they have to prove it and show me it can work reliably. I've been burned too many times. I won't get fooled again.
 
jambo372 said:
I actually did the exact opposite of most of you , instead of going from belief to scepticism I went from scepticism to belief .
That really interesting! So what made you make the switch? I certainly am interested in knowing.
 
jambo372 said:
I actually did the exact opposite of most of you , instead of going from belief to scepticism I went from scepticism to belief .

From looking over the few posts citing this statement it seems there is a unanimous desire to hear about this revelation. I doubt we would understand or follow the route you did, but we would like to hear about your personal experience.

I don't think I believe in wierd things, if any of you out there suspect me of something of that nature please, please tell me so I can correct my mental compass. By definition a blind spot is difficult to spot from the inside, we all have them, i'm sure. They may not be obvious, but rest assured they are there.




Swallow, Monica, swallow. Not on the rug. Not on the rug. Oh damn.
 
Yes, I used to be a Van Daniken-ite; ancient astronauts? UFO roads in Peru? Atlantis, built by (then destroyed by) aliens? Seemed reasonable...

Then a VERY attractive girl in school one day asked me why I believed in them, and if I ever looked up any alternate theories or reasons concerning them. I looked, and Lo! was blinded by the Light O' Truth.

Now, I leave the ancient astronaut stuff to STARGATE.
 
HarryKeogh said:
I took some Scientology courses and did some auditing.
Used to waste 50 bucks a week at the chiropractor
Used to put vitamin E on cuts to prevent scars from forming.
used to swear by ketogenic diets
Then the internet came and a world of info and research was at my fingertips.
The Internet REDUCED the number of flaky beliefs you had?
There's always one who's got to be different.
 
I had the usual childhood religious beliefs until I outgrew them, but the thing that makes me cringe is my former belief, as an intelligent adult, in OBEs / astral projection. This was brought on by an intense and rather terrifying episode of what I now know was sleep paralysis, followed by a classic case of confirmation bias: I had an experience that I couldn't explain, and the only thing I had heard of that vaguely resembled it was OBEs. So I started reading about them, and was amazed at how many people had had them, and how many of them sounded exactly like my experience... so therefore they must be true and that must be what happened to me.

The only part of my story that isn't an utter cliché is that when I stumbled, by dumb luck, upon an article about something I had never heard of called "sleep paralysis" (and then looked up a bunch more info on it), my belief in OBEs didn't cause me to reject what was obviously the more rational and likely explanation. In fact I was relieved as hell to learn that these episodes (of which I'd had a couple more by that point) were all in my head.

Looking back at that experience is what caused me to start examining the process of belief, both in myself and in people at large, and eventually led me to skepticism, atheism, and this site.
 
Re: another alternative

billydkid said:
I am neither of those things. I am a skeptic who didn't specifically disbelieve nutty things. Now I do.
If you didn't specifically believe them, then you are one of the non-ex-flaky minority, and may vote accordingly. After all, there must be a zillion nutty beliefs and religions out there which I don't "specifically disbelieve" because I've barely heard of them.
 
Well to be honest there are certain aspects of the paranormal I've never believed in and still don't . There are other things I thought to be nonsense originally - I didn't believe in telekinesis until I saw demonstrations of it by Uri Geller, Jean Pierre Girard & Nina Kulagina , I then stopped believing in Geller but retained belief in Nina Kulagina.
I was undecided about spiritualism & mediumship but began believing when I was amazed by a medium . Once I took a sceptical friend to a spiritualist sitting, he sat next to me in the service and then the medium came to me and he was chalk white at the accuracy of what the medium told me - he converted to belief on the spot . I also believe in spirits because I have saw things a few times myself and a medium actually told me that she knew about it .
 
jambo372 said:
Well to be honest there are certain aspects of the paranormal I've never believed in and still don't . There are other things I thought to be nonsense originally - I didn't believe in telekinesis until I saw demonstrations of it by Uri Geller, Jean Pierre Girard & Nina Kulagina , I then stopped believing in Geller but retained belief in Nina Kulagina.
I was undecided about spiritualism & mediumship but began believing when I was amazed by a medium . Once I took a sceptical friend to a spiritualist sitting, he sat next to me in the service and then the medium came to me and he was chalk white at the accuracy of what the medium told me - he converted to belief on the spot . I also believe in spirits because I have saw things a few times myself and a medium actually told me that she knew about it .
You believed in some, but then you stopped when you got other evidence? Then you started believing in others?

I hate to say this, Jambo, but you sound like you are a sucker for any purveyor of plausible bullshift. Where were you when I was selling encyclopedias?
 
Jambo, I'm very curious, what did Nina Kulagina do to covince you that Geller didn't?

As for mediumship, while I obviously don't know any of the details about what you experienced, I can tell you that stories exactly like your brief description -- amazingly accurate, unknowable information and skeptics turned to believers on the spot -- are the very stuff that fraudulent mediums' careers are made of. If you're genuinely interested in exploring the topic from a rational angle, there are two books I would highly recommend to you: The Psychic Mafia by M. Lamar Keene, which is a tell-all confession by a reformed fraudulent medium; and The Full Facts Book of Cold Reading by Ian Rowland, which is a step-by-step guide on how to make yourself look like you're receiving accurate psychic impressions when, in reality, you're doing nothing of the sort. It's not cheap, but is well worth the asking price.
 
Uri Geller was proved fraudulent. Nina Kulagina was tested by various investigators over a period of at least 10 years and no investigator has ever found a fitting rational explanation for her experiments & demonstrations. That's why I still believe in her and not Geller.
You would have to see the medium to know what I was talking about.
I couldn't think of a rational explanation, it didn't really fit with cold/hot reading.
 
You would have to see the medium to know what I was talking about.
I couldn't think of a rational explanation, it didn't really fit with cold/hot reading.
Well I'm sure we could think of some rational explanations.
However, despite repeated requests, you refuse to provide any details about your reading. Is it because you are worried we may be able to find perfectly rational and mundane explanations?

I would be extremely interested to hear what a reader could say/do that wouldn't fit in to hot/cold reading.

But this just sounds like a usual - "You had to be there" kind of claim.

Until we hear more details then this isn't even anecdotal evidence. You are digging in your heels on this one jambo and don't even want to see alternate possibilities.


And for the last time there are several rational explanations for Nina - none of which are now, sadly, testable. We won't ever know either way now, but claiming there is no way it was anything other than psychic power is just completely untrue. You invest far too much of your personal belief in this one controversial case.
Geller was a trickster and, had he passed away years ago, we may still be debating his 'abilities' However, because he has done the same stuff over and over and very publicly, it has given everyone a chance to look more closely and repeatedly at his performance and see the trickery.

How you can't even entertain the possibility that the same MAY have happened with Nina is something I find hard to understand.
 
I see a way of solving this debate,get Jambo372's medium to contact Nina and have her perform some telekinesis via the spirit world.Now that would be impressive!!;)
 
As I recall, conjurors viewing films of Kalliguna's manipulations were of the opinion that she used such simple tricks as concealed magnets and super-fine thread.
I believe Randi spoke of this in one of his books.
The Skeptic's Dictionary has no article listed.
 
My experience is broadly similar to MRC_Hans'.

Some stuff was easier to reject than others: I was pretty well agnostic at seven or eight years old, but thought von Daniken interesting when I was thirteen- possibly because he appeared to be questioning dogmatic orthodoxy himself. Like others, I simply found myself questioning his evidence. And if he was right, then Velikovsky had to be wrong. Turns out they both were.
Two important points about von Daniken:-
1.There was nothing intrinsically impossible in his notion of ETs visiting Earth in the distant past. (I still don't consider this a particularly woo-woo claim, merely an improbable and unproven one).
2. Von Daniken's evidence was there to be studied and questioned and found wanting. I believe his early stuff was genuinely misinterpreted, the late stuff cynically false. Realising this was a valuable experience for me - and it appears for others.

nb-I too am a big SF buff and have been since I was about ten.
Learning to tell fact from fiction is a skill that should be taught in primary school.
 
Mojo said:
I suspect that the other 27% are kidding themselves.
Nope! :)

Usual childhood of sporadic church attendance, but Australia is a skeptical/cynical nation at heart, and it starts at an early age. So we are, in the main, hard-bitten skeptics from a young age - you only need to see the acerbic wording that I, AUP, Manifesto, reprise and other Aussies write to realise that.

Of course I, like billions of others, hope for many things to come true - an end to world hunger, a permanent cure for our droughts, etc, etc - but that's not really woo-woo thinking. Woo-woo thinking would be trying to achieve these things by praying to an ancient Palestinian soothsayer! :)

So, yes, I'm a skeptic, but no, I never believed in wierd things.
 
Kitty Chan said:
It doesnt seem available on dvd either :(

Hey pick your brain if you dont mind what was the show with the guy that did inventions or what have you in the shed in his backyard? He had a sidekick called Rex?? I liked that one too, ring any bells??
Was it a British show with Dave Brubeck's "Take Five" as the theme song? Sounds like "The Secret Life of Machines".

I really liked that show, too.

washing_machines_small.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom