My belief in the results of the scientific testing of psi. I mean, why do they try to establish a group effect (ie. Global Consciousness Project) when it hasn't even been firmly established in individuals yet!
They need to show that if person A scores high on a psi test, then next time this same person A gets tested he/she will score high again, or scores highly more often than low and can keep doing this. That is what it means for someone to have psi. Not persons A, B, C, ..., Z score poorly on average, but then when we combine their scores they collectively scored poor enough, but above zero, to be statistically significant.
In some psi literature they mistakengly use the analogy of a baseball player, and that the player will not hit a homerun everytime, but we know homeruns exist, so while psi may not manifest all the time, it does sometimes. Well, we know the bat exists, know the field exists, and know that there is video of baseball players actually hitting homeruns when they play this physical sport called baseball. Not to mention we have pure physical explanation for a bat hitting and propelling a ball- we don't need to use statistics here to establish the phenomena of homeruns. The players also DO hit home runs over and over during the homerun derby. With psi, we don't know it happens in individuals.
The parapsychology papers sometimes mention there were some "superstars", but then never seem to want to simply focus on testing those superstars. If they did, it would probably be like being in a room of 1,000 people and have them each flip a coin. A person is 'out' when they flip a head. The people left at the end say 10 flips are those who have psi. Of course, we'd expect these people to be different each time, which is why I fear they don't focus on testing the superstars, and instead go for more nebulous group effects.