Are you a sceptic who used to Believe Weird Things?

The thing that led me to the JREF was a half-remembered news item which I saw on TV as a child. I recalled a bearded magician (though I had mistakenly thought it was David Berglas ) who had a prize for proof of the paranormal. The subject came up in an internet forum and I thought I'd better do some reading on the subject before shooting my mouth off.

I found my way here, and have been shooting off ever since!
 
I have voted for not having believed weird things, although I was a believing christian when child. However, from the moment I grew up to have an independent mind I seem to have been a skeptic, and my christian beliefs evaporated all by themselves.
 
As a teenager, I was heavily into subjects like The Bermuda Triangle, the Loch Ness Monster, Bigfoot, UFOs (to some extent), mostly all of the so-called "Unexplained Phenomena." Like Phrost, I was a big fan of "In Search Of." It wasn't so much that I believed in these things, but that I held out hope that eventually science would solve these "mysteries," and that we would have rational, scientific explanations for what was really going on. Well as years--no--decades went by and still nothing, I gradually realized that there weren't even any mysteries to be solved in the first place. It was all just a lot of words and air.
 
Surely there should be a choice for "I am a skeptic who still believes in weird things." Is there no one on this forum who believes in Quantum Mechanics or the Continuum Hypothesis?

Seriously, though. "Weird" is in the eye (and vocabulary) of the beholder; a lot of the beliefs that most of us take quite seriously will be considered "weird" by others. Most importantly, "skeptic" does not mean "disbeliever." It's quite possible to believe something without evidence, while still searching (critically) for that evidence.
 
I used to talk about psychic powers, but, to be honest, I was lying about my belief. I knew what I was saying was a load of carp, but I guess I wanted to fit in. Those "beliefs" vanished suddenly when I quit lying to myself, they also took my belief in god when they left.
 
My belief in the results of the scientific testing of psi. I mean, why do they try to establish a group effect (ie. Global Consciousness Project) when it hasn't even been firmly established in individuals yet!

They need to show that if person A scores high on a psi test, then next time this same person A gets tested he/she will score high again, or scores highly more often than low and can keep doing this. That is what it means for someone to have psi. Not persons A, B, C, ..., Z score poorly on average, but then when we combine their scores they collectively scored poor enough, but above zero, to be statistically significant.

In some psi literature they mistakengly use the analogy of a baseball player, and that the player will not hit a homerun everytime, but we know homeruns exist, so while psi may not manifest all the time, it does sometimes. Well, we know the bat exists, know the field exists, and know that there is video of baseball players actually hitting homeruns when they play this physical sport called baseball. Not to mention we have pure physical explanation for a bat hitting and propelling a ball- we don't need to use statistics here to establish the phenomena of homeruns. The players also DO hit home runs over and over during the homerun derby. With psi, we don't know it happens in individuals.

The parapsychology papers sometimes mention there were some "superstars", but then never seem to want to simply focus on testing those superstars. If they did, it would probably be like being in a room of 1,000 people and have them each flip a coin. A person is 'out' when they flip a head. The people left at the end say 10 flips are those who have psi. Of course, we'd expect these people to be different each time, which is why I fear they don't focus on testing the superstars, and instead go for more nebulous group effects.
 
Besides being a Mormon and all the weird beliefs that entails, I used to be heavily into conspiracy theories. I used to quite firmly believe that JFK was killed as the result of a government conspiracy and that certain groups were manipulating world events. I also beleived in UFO's to an extent (and the requisite government cover up, of course)

I mentioned in another thread how my atheism came as a result of questioning things, realizing that certain things about God and as a result gradually coming to the realization that I didn't beleive in God. My backing away from conspiracy theories and UFO's was along the same lines. The more I really thought about them (as opposed to just accepting whatever I read in things I read) and the more questions I asked, the less sense things made and eventually, I slowly backed away from those beliefs.

I still have an interest in those things, though. The world of UFO's, aliens and shady government agents is a fun one. Only now, it shows up in my writing and fiction is where those sort of things belong.
 
So is anyone other than me willing to admit that he or she still has at least one weird belief?

The only superstition I still maintain is that it is bad luck to say the words, "Things couldn't possibly get worse."
 
So far, it looks like the former flakes have it. What a bunch we turn out to be. I keep wondering why Aussie Skeptic doesn't turn up and flame us all. Or perhaps he has his own little story to tell. Do let us know... was there ever a time when Aussie Skeptic did a WOO-ing go, with a rolly-polly gammon and spinach?

If anyone sees him, tell him I'm taking his name in vain, would you?
 
Confession Time

Yep, I used to believe in the following woo woo stuff, mostly in my teen years. Bigfoot, Noah's Ark-I watched the documentaries about the people that planned expiditions to find the thing, Ghosts-I thought I had a few paranormal experiences myself, but they could be explained rationally, The Historicity of the Bible-I was a Fundy at one time, forgive me, UFOs and I guess that is the bunk, err bulk of what I believed in my misspent youth. All that and I never touched drugs, then or now lol.
 
Well lapsed Catholic, but always asked the awkward questions like:

'Does your Guardian Angel even watch you when you're on the toilet*?' I was probably about seven at that point.

Still haven't learnt that asking questions really annoys some people.


*Trans: for the US: 'in the bathroom'.


Used to read Tarot cards, although I didn't actually believe that they worked by magic. I reckoned they were just an aid to spinning out your subconcious perceptions.
 
Has Randi ever spoke about his early beliefs? I wonder if he ever had a phase as a child where he was interested in the paranormal? Every sceptic I've ever known, including myself, usually arrived at scepticism by at first having an interest in things such as ufos, ghosts and so forth. I often try to explain to people that I would LOVE to see a flying saucer, or bigfoot, or a ghost, or a display of psychic powers. But until there is scientific proof, well...
 
I was always fascinated by those "Unexplained" books when I was a kid and believed in all of it, including stories of spontaneous combustion.

That sort of wore off gradually, with the attitudes shifting to "it would be so much fun if this was true but I don't buy it". I remember playing with Ouija boards as a teenager, fascinated by how well and confidently the planchette moved. I knew the messages were coming from us, and that made it all the more "magical" to me that involuntary control could work so well. And some of the story lines spelled out were so much fun. At one party, every single person in the room was descended from someone around the time of the Salem witch trials (a few hung as witches). I was an innkeeper who died of natural causes at the age of 101. I thought that was delightful but never believed it. I was so disappointed to learn MUCH later that even the stories of witch hangings were largely a myth.

An earlier Ouija experience, probably around age 12, predicted the early demise of one of our number, at the age of 16. That would seem to be a pretty startling prediction, except everyone in the room knew that Tommy had cystic fibrosis and wasn't expected to reach 16. As it turned out, he graduated college and survived into his mid-20s.

I think that I was insulated against Ouija by getting a "pendulum" kit with The Amazing Kreskin's name on it as a Christmas gift as a kid. The pendulum was basically a plumb bob, and could be used in the same way as a Ouija. Kreskin went into a great deal of explanation about how it actually works. One thing you can do is "magically" move such a pendulum just by moving your eyes. Think about the pendulum swinging left-right, forward-back, clockwise or counterclockwise in circles and move your eyes accordingly while holding your hand "perfectly still". The pendulum follows your thoughts. The explanation, of course, is that you can not hold perfectly still and your HAND follows your thoughts.

To this day, I would love to believe in ghosts and to have an actual experience, and I am endlessly fascinated by "true accounts" and supposedly haunted sites. Alas, the actual experience still eludes me and I remain, to my own dismay, a skeptic. I actually DID have one experience in our house (which some people believe to have a haunt or two) but, sadly, the symptoms fall well within the range of sleep paralysis experiences (it wasn't a classic old hag nor were there any feelings of evil, but it was definitely tactile and felt like I was awake).
 
Still running 4 to 1 for the former loons, then. I see now that there was one question I didn't ask. If you are a sceptic who has NEVER believed weird things, how do you explain that? Is there something wrong with you? Or were you brought up as a Strict Atheist?
 
I voted "no," even though I was raised as a Southern Baptist, and really believed that line. I also was excited about the prospects of the JFK assassination conspiracy, UFOs, telekensis, ESP, and hell, even biorhythms. But I can't say I ever really believed any of those.

I've realized over the years that I now think differently from how I did pre-university. I've found myself contemplating the same idea that I did as a youth, and wondering why I didn't just see straight to the right answer like I can do now. I'm not sure whether it's just an issue of maturity, or whether college taught me to take apart problems more methodically. I think it's the latter.
 
It seems to me that Randi never had any woo woo beliefs, at least that is what he indicated on one of the webcasts. But I could be wrong there.
 
Dr Adequate said:
Still running 4 to 1 for the former loons, then. I see now that there was one question I didn't ask. If you are a sceptic who has NEVER believed weird things, how do you explain that? Is there something wrong with you? Or were you brought up as a Strict Atheist?

I do believe in a Weird Thing: skepticism. Must be something terribly wrong with me...
 
The usual stuff..God,the Bible etc. Then as a teenager I just loved The unexplained stuff Arthur C Clarke-who finished EVERY programme with "I do not believe(whatever phenomenen it was that week,green shield stamps etc)exsists" Spontaneous combustion,Ouija board,evil spirits ad nauseum! Mediums always intrigued me,the first I recall was Doris Stokes " Have you lost a little one ,lovey?" But similiar to paj I rekindled my interest in magic and slowly found my way here,and is the reason why I keep getting banned on believer forums.I think Whitley Strieber had me going for a while though!:)
 
73% former Believers, so far. Thanks to everyone who's responded --- I really wanted to know. Keep posting, folks. These are heartwarming stories. Testifiy to how you Lost Jesus! But in the meantime, there are two conclusions to be drawn

(1) Aussie Skeptic and his ilk, his elk, and the horse he rode in on, should be less rude. It is possible to Believe Weird Things without being nuts or stupid.
(2) The people who talk about "closed-minded debunking sceptics" blah, jabber, froth are clearly way off base. What I see here is a community consisting, by a huge majority, of people who have OPENED their minds to the possibility that they were wrong, investigated, and found out that they were. This looks like an open mind to me.
 
Yeah_Right said:
It seems to me that Randi never had any woo woo beliefs, at least that is what he indicated on one of the webcasts. But I could be wrong there.

http://www.skeptic.com/01.1.randi-paranormal.html
I guess they carried on until late that night. I fell asleep, woke up the next morning, came staggering into the kitchen in time to see them eating up more of my groceries in the form of breakfast at this time. I sat down, got a half cup of coffee into me and straightened up the table. Alexis looked at me and said, "What's with you?" I said, "I think last night I might have actually had a classic example of the O.B.E." That's the out-of-body experience. It means that somehow you find yourself out of your body and looking down on it or from a distance. Alexis looked at me and said, "Sure. You?" I said, "Yes, I have to be honest. It appears to me as if I did undergo such an experience."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom