Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?

Animals are not irrelevant. A working brain is a necessary but not sufficient condition for intelligence. We brought up animals as an example of a brain without intelligence.

If you have more conditions to present, feel free to move on.
 
Last edited:
How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?



That is why I don't give any attention to a lot of the posts here from atheists, they are not being intelligently attentive to read things carefully, completely, and get to the gist quickly.

Instead they go into irrelevancies left and right, up and down, in and out, and think that they are so smart.




Yrreg

Such a serious person you are...So why don't you move this to the next point of your discussion...You know, like, moving the argument forward to something tangible.
:popcorn2
 
Last edited:
Animals are not irrelevant. A working brain is a necessary but not sufficient condition for intelligence. We brought up animals as an example of a brain without intelligence.

If you have more conditions to present, feel free to move on.

Humans ARE animals. And I find many non-human animals more intelligent than yrreg.

What non-human animal worships and invisible undetectable entity and imagines that this entity has a "plan" for them?
 
How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?
A person in a persistent vegetative state has a working brain but no intelligence.

How many times do I have to tell you that?
 
How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?
My post was not off-topic. If you want to define words so narrowly that no-one agrees with you, then you'll find that no-one agrees with you!

ETA: I guess that means I'm on yrreg's ignore list now...
 
Last edited:
I'd say that athieisim is no more or less as an intelligent world view as thieism.

An individual has thier own reasons for having or not having a belief in god. I have known many people who are intelligent, responsible, and moral and I would not have know them to be athiest or thieist unless I asked them or the subject came up.

People who believe in god have all they need to emotinaly and intellectually believe in a god.
People who do not believe in god have all they need to emotionaly and intellectually to not have a belief in god.

They dissagree on the validity of each others respective criteria for the belief or non belief but the fact remains that thier respective views works for them. (except in the case of extremisim)

Yrreg, if you want to understand the athiest mindset concerning the non-existance of god, all you have to do is think about why you have no belief in something you do not think exists.

I assume there are things that you do not belif to exist, right? Why do you think those things do not exist? No evidence?, does not make sense?, There is something that you take as evidence or argument for the non existance of that thing?

But that's what it all comes down to, What works for you. What gets you through the day. It's a fallacy to think that all athiests are sad, hollow, cold, bitter and lost people. The truth is quite the opposite.

And I've known a few people who have aith to dispare and even commit suicide in one instance. What ever happen to them, thier faith could not get them through it.
 
It seems that Yrreg's definition of intelligence is simple:

"Intelligence is only evident in the worldview that Yrreg follows."

No-one else is thinking, acting, or being intelligent.

To answer.

Yes. People are acting intelligently in embracing Atheism.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing Christianity.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing Mormonism.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing Buddhism.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing Stamp Collecting.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing Hinduism.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing the Force.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing paganism.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing witchcraft.

Just as:

People are acting intelligently in embracing pretty much ANYTHING AT ALL.

Now if people don't bother to consider what they embrace, and simply blindly accept what they are told, then no, they may not be acting intelligently.
 
But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is

The presence of a working brain in a person.​


You asked this before, and it was answered before. Will you continue to ask it until such time as we eventually agree with your position?

The answer is "No." Your criterion is silly. It is also focused on the means, not the result. If you want a criterion for intelligence, look to Turing.
 
Atheism needn't be embraced. Its more of a default zone. Religion is what needs the embracing. Its very needy.

Needy is the operative word for it

Religion NEEDS followers...Atheists DONT CARE...

Too many think because Atheists don't agree with their views and because Atheists don't believe in their deity, all of a sudden they lack intelligence...

I say why is that? lacking intelligence all because they think from OUTSIDE the box?

Because they don't follow what is dictated to them?

Free thinkers?

I'm not an atheist but I understand where they come from.....

What is it?
 
That is why I don't give any attention to a lot of the posts here from atheists, they are not being intelligently attentive to read things carefully, completely, and get to the gist quickly.

Instead they go into irrelevancies left and right, up and down, in and out, and think that they are so smart.

Since you seem to be incapable of answering questions which ask you to define your terms more carefully, I am going to make one obvious assumption:

You believe that you have a functioning brain. This assumption is obvious because if you didn't, you wouldn't be able to judge whether or not anyone else here had a functioning brain.

So, using your functioning brain as a criterion, the question must be, "Do the atheists here have brains that function as well or better than yours?"

To that question, the answer is obviously and demonstrably, "yes". Almost all of them. I can cite examples if you like.
 
Thank you for replying to one of my posts, Yrreg. It's nice to know I'm not being totally ignored.



Criteria of intelligence, as I see it:

* The ability to solve problems
* High order intentions (second or third order, for example)

I will just for the present concentrate and ask you to do likewise on the first criterion you bring up of intelligence in a person, namely:

The ability to solve problems.​


But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is

The presence of a working brain in a person.​


I can't say that I agree.
A person will have a brain, by definition. But I cannot use it as a definition of intelligence (and you didn't specify human at the start of this thread).

I think that intelligence does not depend on a brain,a s we know it. Extra-terrestrial intelligences might not have anything similar to the organ we are familiar with as a "brain".

Further, computers may very well one day be intelligent. If they can write their own code, make their own decisions, make inferences and solve problems, then they will be, by my definition intelligent, and entitled tot he same rights, privileges and responsibilities as any other intelligent being.

Recognizing such possibilities, I will not use the presence of a brain to help define intelligence.

Besides, I have no need of it in my definition. It adds nothing.





About your post in #14, what is your point there, briefly?


For convenience, post 14 is linked here

My point was to undercut your whole argument.

Atheism is not a worldview I embrace. It is simply a statement of fact.
The fact is that I don't believe in god.

Whether or not I view it as intelligent does not matter. Frankly, I view it as a completely separate issue.

Quite simply: I don't believe in any supernatural deities (or other beings, for that matter).

Much as you don't believe in Thetans, or fairies, or Invisible Pink Unicorns.

It has nothing to do with viewing atheism as intelligent, or the ability to masturbate guilt free.

I simply have no belief in god(s). I see no reason to have one, nor do I see any obligation to do so.

Which renders all your threads about why atheists "choose" atheism (for the record: I didn't choose, I simply realized I didn't believe in god) pointless.

Not only that, but by pursuing the topics and refusing to listen to people telling you exactly what I made abundantly clear both here, in post 14, and elsewhere, you are, shall we say, barking up the wrong tree in your quest to understand atheism and atheists.

Frankly, I'm starting to wonder if you are even in the right forest.


In 13 words: Atheism is not a worldview. It is simply a lack of a belief.
 
Last edited:
So by not believing anything you are embracing somethng else? If I don't believe in fairies I am embracing the non-belief in fairies? Anything you fail embrace means you are embracing something else?

If by embracing you mean accepting the opposite view as preferable then the answer is yes.

embrace definition | Dictionary.com
to take or receive gladly or eagerly; accept willingly: to embrace an idea.
http://av.rds.yahoo.com/_ylt=A0geul...ttp://dictionary.reference.com/browse/embrace
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom