Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

When I was a Boy Scout I volunteered, with others, to vist strangers in the hospital and that led to a 2 hour endurance test to go through one patient's stamp collection. I couldn't agree with you more. :)

He past away not long after that. I would do it again.

Bravo on both accounts!

:):)
 
If by "embracing" we mean adopting a belief, then atheists are definitely embracing something. They embrace the belief in the non-existence of a God or gods. I know, there are different grades of atheism. But all of them embrace or accept a concept. I really don't see why the word is taken negatively. Anyone care to explain?
 
If by "embracing" we mean adopting a belief, then atheists are definitely embracing something. They embrace the belief in the non-existence of a God or gods. I know, there are different grades of atheism. But all of them embrace or accept a concept. I really don't see why the word is taken negatively. Anyone care to explain?
I'm on ignore but--
  • You embrace non-Scientology the same way atheists do.
  • You embrace non-Mormonism the same way atheists do.
And many if not most of us embrace non-stamp collecting.

But this raises a question, what does it mean to embrace non-stamp collecting?
 
When I was a Boy Scout I volunteered, with others, to vist strangers in the hospital and that led to a 2 hour endurance test to go through one patient's stamp collection. I couldn't agree with you more. :)

He past away not long after that. I would do it again.
Ouch. Almost enough to make you find, or lose, faith in God, depending on your starting position.

Bravo from me as well :)
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.

<snip>

What do you say to that?

I say that you have a nasty case of sesquipedalianism.
 
I'm on ignore but--
  • You embrace non-Scientology the same way atheists do.
  • You embrace non-Mormonism the same way atheists do.
And many if not most of us embrace non-stamp collecting.

But this raises a question, what does it mean to embrace non-stamp collecting?

I'm not opposed to say that I embrace rationality as a position. Certainly, one must "embrace" something to make a choice regarding the validity of a point.

I had no opinion on scientology, until I learned of it. At which point, I "embraced" the idea it's a bunch of silly (and dangerous) nonsense.

I had no opinion on child vaccinations and autism links, but after reading the multiple cases demonstrating that no link exists, I "embrace" the idea that there is no link and vaccines are the safe and NEEDED treatment to protect children.
 
I'm not opposed to say that I embrace rationality as a position. Certainly, one must "embrace" something to make a choice regarding the validity of a point.

I had no opinion on scientology, until I learned of it. At which point, I "embraced" the idea it's a bunch of silly (and dangerous) nonsense.

I had no opinion on child vaccinations and autism links, but after reading the multiple cases demonstrating that no link exists, I "embrace" the idea that there is no link and vaccines are the safe and NEEDED treatment to protect children.
Fair enough. I'll admit that one needs to at least understand a concept before one can embrace the "belief" of it not existing. It's not per se wrong to use the word "embrace" I guess. It's not the term I would use though but that's fine. If others want to say I embrace the idea that religion is nonsense then I can accept that. :)
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​










Yrreg

deleted
 
Last edited:
I'm on ignore but--
  • You embrace non-Scientology the same way atheists do.
  • You embrace non-Mormonism the same way atheists do.
And many if not most of us embrace non-stamp collecting.

But this raises a question, what does it mean to embrace non-stamp collecting?
Exactly.

Christians do not want to have Scientology shoved down their throats.
Most Christians do not want to have Mormonism shoved down their throats.

These positions held by many Christians are not positive statements against Scientology and Mormonism but the unwillingness to be force-fed those religions in every aspect of their lives.

This is exactly the case with Atheists, except the list of things they don't want shoved down their throats is at least one item longer.

And nobody better try to force me to collect stamps.:mad:
 
I'm on ignore but--
  • You embrace non-Scientology the same way atheists do.
  • You embrace non-Mormonism the same way atheists do.
And many if not most of us embrace non-stamp collecting.

But this raises a question, what does it mean to embrace non-stamp collecting?
Why do religious people keep making claims that, if true, clearly applies to them as well? Do they repeatedly forget there are so many other religions out there which they don't believe in?
 
Why do religious people keep making claims that, if true, clearly applies to them as well? Do they repeatedly forget there are so many other religions out there which they don't believe in?

The part that gets me is that in a debate about god, the christian will almost always start to argue from a generic god position and not the god of the bible. As though they are free from having to explain why this generic god is the god of the bible.
 
Thanks for getting to the topic instead of tergiversating.

Criteria of intelligence, as I see it:

* The ability to solve problems
* High order intentions (second or third order, for example)




There, happy?


I've now answered both of your questions (Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?, and What are your criteria of intelligence?)

I'm not being evasive. I have tried to make my posts and points clear and unambiguous.

Yet you paint me with the same broad brush as everyone else, and claim I am being "tergiversating" (it is possible to over-use a word, you know). But I've answered your questions.

Now please do me the favour of answering my previous post (#14).


[ From X ]

Criteria of intelligence, as I see it:

* The ability to solve problems
* High order intentions (second or third order, for example)​


I will just for the present concentrate and ask you to do likewise on the first criterion you bring up of intelligence in a person, namely:

The ability to solve problems.​


But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is

The presence of a working brain in a person.​

-----------------


About your post in #14, what is your point tthere, briefly?




Yrreg


ANNEX:

[ In case people here want to be intelligently relevant, please read these two posts and abstain from tergiversating.

For a starter we are talking about intelligence in humans.

Title: Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​


Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?


[ Have I already done a thread on this topic here? ]



In this thread I hope to discuss first what are the criteria of intelligence.


Then compare atheists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their atheistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence.




Addressing atheists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​





Yrreg




Title: Tergiversating as per routine, ain't you guys here? ​


When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​



What do you say to that?





Yrreg
 
  • The ability to solve problems
  • High order intentions (second or third order, for example)
Why don't you check out the Puzzles Forum, yrreg. I think you'll find that a number of atheists are not only adept at solving problems, they actually enjoy doing so.

As for "higher order intentions", perhaps you'd better define the term better to avoid inappropriate answers.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom