Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Congratulations yrreg, after 30 years of using first milnet, then arpanet, and finally the internet, I found someone worth ignoring.
 
Yrreg can you stop with your obsessive nitpicking?

Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.





[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]​


I really have very serious doubt whether atheists are born naive or playing naive, either way they are not exhibiting intelligence before people who take them seriously, for continuously failing to take into their attention that this thread is about human persons in regard to intelligence in their worldviews, specifically the intelligence of atheists in embracing the worldview of atheism.



I will be back later in the evening and see whether atheists here after this post are now attending to themselves as human persons in regard to their intelligence in embracing their worldview of atheism.

Sure, you will go away again and return later to nitpick about somebody else who is only utilizing their sense of humor. Unless you have something to add to your argument so this thread can move forward, I will assume you have nothing else to add and failed in your quest.
 
What he hell, I'll give it a shot. Please keep the insults to a minimum (non-thinking, naive, etc.) if you want to get serious responses.

Your original question was: What are your criteria of intelligence?

My necessary criteria for intelligence (a human lacking any of these would not have intelligence):

1) Life
2) A brain
3) The ability to differentiate oneself from the environment. (The Mirror Test is a good start.)
4) The understanding that adapting the environment can achieve goals.
5) The ability to learn from past mistakes.

Is that what you want or did I misunderstand? Are you looking for something more specific to humans? I don't understand what this has to do with atheism. What am I missing?

Edit: I think I get what yrreg is asking but I'll let him clarify first.
 
Last edited:
Atheism as a result of skepticism is intelligent. Atheism as a result of emotion-based rejection/rebellion is not.
 
Is that what you want or did I misunderstand? Are you looking for something more specific to humans? I don't understand what this has to do with atheism. What am I missing?

If yrreg decides to take his argument forward, I have a hunch he will try to make the intelligence argument into why would the brain consider a concept of God.
 
3) The ability to differentiate oneself from the environment. (The Mirror Test is a good start.)


Dang. I missed that one.

I still think "working brain" adds nothing to the definition and is thus not needed. But I'm sorely tempted to add the above bit into mine.
 
Dang. I missed that one.

I still think "working brain" adds nothing to the definition and is thus not needed. But I'm sorely tempted to add the above bit into mine.

Having a "working brain" as a criteron shows that you do not believe in mind/body dualism.
 
Dang. I missed that one.

I still think "working brain" adds nothing to the definition and is thus not needed. But I'm sorely tempted to add the above bit into mine.

If we limit our definition to being purely human intelligence, classifying a working brain is acceptable. Although, not very useful.

If we allow for intelligence of any type, than I'd say it's not a requirement at all. For example, if we ever achieve AI, then we can definitely state that a functioning brain is not a prerequisite.

So, yes. Let's help Yrreg move to the next part of his argument (if there is one).

-----
Yrreg,
I completely and fully agree that a working brain is needed for human intelligence. and taht intelligence would require the ability to form rationalized conclusions based upon a set of conditions and be capable of generalizing those conclusions toward a wider scope of conditions not previously described.
 
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.

You may as well say ..hey guys lemme go fetch my flip chart and crayon maybe you will get it then?:rolleyes:

Talk about patronizing?

You want others to take in your posts but at the same time try and patronize them?:confused:

There is a word that best describes people like this and at home we call them - Pretentious Idiots !!!!!!!!
 
I think you're missing something. You probably don't believe in Zeus, or Thor, or Shiva, or Baal. I doubt you believe that the sun is daily drawn across the heavens in a chariot by the god Ra. If you deny the existence of these gods, then you would be considered an atheist by adherents of these religions.

We're all atheists of one variety or another- it's just that some of us go one deity further than others.
 
There is a word that best describes people like this and at home we call them - Pretentious Idiots !!!!!!!!



In Britain we call people like yregg 'pretentious wankers'.
 
There is a word that best describes people like this and at home we call them - Pretentious Idiots !!!!!!!!



In Britain we call people like yregg 'pretentious wankers'.
That raising the interesting question
Is pretentious wanking guiltless?
 
There is a word that best describes people like this and at home we call them - Pretentious Idiots !!!!!!!!



In Britain we call people like yregg 'pretentious wankers'.

:DI was trying to be polite what ith me being a lady an all (not a little britain I'm a lady lol)...but I was thinking of the word that sounds like bankers!!!!!!! LOL
 
That raising the interesting question
Is pretentious wanking guiltless?

Of course not. In order to be pretentious there has to be some guilt involved. Depending on the slant of the pretension, guilt may or may not be a major issue, but it's there.
 
Last edited:
I beg to differ. I think pretentious wanking can be completely guiltless... especially if done by an exhibitionist.
 
Exhibitionists are unpretentious. That's practically the definition. Pretension is a form of arrogance, but specifically blended with self-doubt. The self-doubt causes one to feel guilty for the arrogance.

The unpretentious don't have a need to act better than other to assuage their own self doubt, and thus can be exhibitionist.[/********]
 
Guiltless exhibitionists could be referred to as tugging the tergiversater. :D
 
Do you embrace the existence or non-existence of gunfunitwaddle?

Everyone, deep in their heart of hearts, is really a gunfunitwaddlist!

It only those who wish to wranglemangle who might embrace agunfunitwaddlism.


Hmm...it seems my spellchecker is taking issue with me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom