Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Please be correct with your citation.

Originally Posted(?) by yrreg [ wrong attribution ]

* The ability to solve problems
* High order intentions (second or third order, for example)


Why don't you check out the Puzzles Forum, yrreg. I think you'll find that a number of atheists are not only adept at solving problems, they actually enjoy doing so.

As for "higher order intentions", perhaps you'd better define the term better to avoid inappropriate answers.


Please, moderator Tricky, check what you are quoting and see whether you are attributing them to the right person.

For your guidance, please read carefully my post in #58, above.

And also the message of X, which I was reacting to.




Yrreg
 
But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is
The presence of a working brain in a person.​

​
No. This has been answered. It's an awful definition. A person in a persistent vegetative state has a working brain. It might not work as well as we might like but it works well enough to keep the person alive, open eyes, smile, etc..
 
About your post in #14, what is your point tthere, briefly?

Since you seem to appear intelligent, post #14 shouldn't be that difficult for you to figure out....:rolleyes:

ETA: If you need X to further explain his post, perhaps you can further explain yours when asked.
 
Last edited:
Please, moderator Tricky, check what you are quoting and see whether you are attributing them to the right person.

For your guidance, please read carefully my post in #58, above.
It is not listed in a quote box from X nor is it enclosed in quotation marks, so it is reasonable to assume that it is your input. If you need explanation in learning to use the quote boxes I will be happy to help.

I seem to recall though that you have listed the ability to solve problems as one hallmark of intelligence. I am providing you a link that gives evidence that people here, many of whom are atheists, are indeed able to solve problems.
I have read your post #58 carefully and apart from the two items I highlighted, I cannot discern your criteria for identifying intelligence other than:
yrreg said:
The presence of a working brain in a person.

I think it has been aptly argued and demonstrated that each person posting here has a working brain, otherwise it would be impossible for them to post (or do much of anything else.) I strongly suspect that this "criterion" was intended as a snarky comment about how stupid atheists are, but I will put those suspicions aside and encourage you to further refine by what you mean by "working brain" so that such misunderstandings are minimized in the future.

Oh, and I'm just posting as Tricky. If I post as a moderator, I will make sure it is enclosed in a mod box or within the context of a Forum Management thread. You can treat me the same way as you do any other poster here.
 
I'm embracing non stamp collecting.


Big time.


What a hobby. Wish I'd known about it sooner.
 
ANNEX:

[ In case people here want to be intelligently relevant, please read these two posts and abstain from tergiversating.

For a starter we are talking about intelligence in humans.

Would you say that you are becoming increasingly unintelligently irrelevant within your own threads?
 
But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is
The presence of a working brain in a person.
​
For a starter we are talking about intelligence in humans.

I would say a functioning brain is necessary for intelligence, yes. A brain is not a sufficient condition though. Unintelligent creatures have brains too after all.
 
Don't bring in people in a vegetative condition, don't tergiversate.

By a working brain I refer to what is understood as one with consciousness activated and senses intact.


What is known as compos mentis.



Please keep to the topic, I am talking about whether atheists are acting intelligently in embracing atheism, or in other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.


People can be and act compos mentis, viz., not insane, and not in a vegetative condition, and not under general anaesthesia, and not in deep dreamless sleep, and not in a fainting state, and still not proceeding intelligently.


But I will not give attention to your posts even though you appear to be compos mentis and à propos, if you are playing naive.

-------------------

So, again, is or is not the first criterion of intelligence in a human the possession of a working brain?


[ And I will also not give any attention to your posts if I notice that you are into nitpicking, wasting readers' time here and wasting the forum's bandwidth. ]​




Yrreg

PS -- If you feel frustrated because I don't react to your posts, at least you have readers here who can appreciate them and admire the intelligence that you are exhibiting in your posts.
 
But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is
The presence of a working brain in a person.​
I disagree. Things that aren't "persons" can be intelligent too.

The presence of a working brain is a necessary criterion for intelligence, but it is not a sufficient one. There needs to be some ability to react to the environment in new and creative ways, and some ability to solve problems. However, even some animals fulfil all these criteria. The clause "in a person" should be discarded from the definition.
 
Please keep to the topic, I am talking about whether atheists are acting intelligently in embracing atheism, or in other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.


People can be and act compos mentis, viz., not insane, and not in a vegetative condition, and not under general anaesthesia, and not in deep dreamless sleep, and not in a fainting state, and still not proceeding intelligently.
By what criteria would you judge whether or not a person was or was not "proceeding intelligently"? Logic? Continuity of thought? Ability to handle complex concepts? Or is it, dare I suggest, belief in God that you recognize as a criterion?
 
So, again, is or is not the first criterion of intelligence in a human the possession of a working brain?
In hopes that you will actually make a point, I'll humor you.

Yes, let's say a working brain is a prerequisite.

The Ball is in your court, Yrreg.
Huli man daw at magaling, naihahabol din.
 
So by not believing anything you are embracing somethng else? If I don't believe in fairies I am embracing the non-belief in fairies? Anything you fail embrace means you are embracing something else?
 
By what criteria would you judge whether or not a person was or was not "proceeding intelligently"? Logic? Continuity of thought? Ability to handle complex concepts? Or is it, dare I suggest, belief in God that you recognize as a criterion?

Your onto him Tricky, although you may be accused of tergiversating.

To Me, the OP seems to be as question directed toward logic involved to reach the conclusions of atheism while Yrreg goes a roundabout way to how he wants his argument to ask ; "Is embracing atheism an intelligent thing to do if god(s) exist(s)?"
 
Last edited:
How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?

Posted by yrreg
But I like to ask you whether you agree with me that the very first criterion of intelligence in a person is

The presence of a working brain in a person.​

I disagree. Things that aren't "persons" can be intelligent too.

The presence of a working brain is a necessary criterion for intelligence, but it is not a sufficient one. There needs to be some ability to react to the environment in new and creative ways, and some ability to solve problems. However, even some animals fulfil all these criteria. The clause "in a person" should be discarded from the definition.


How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?



That is why I don't give any attention to a lot of the posts here from atheists, they are not being intelligently attentive to read things carefully, completely, and get to the gist quickly.

Instead they go into irrelevancies left and right, up and down, in and out, and think that they are so smart.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom