Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Note to Yrreg:
Staying on topic is not, I repeat is not, I say three times IS NOT the same thing as agreeing to every single silly premise that you put forward. I don't know who you think you are making points with, but I can guarantee you that nobody else in this thread is impressed with your so-called line of reasoning so far.
 
I'm embracing non stamp collecting.

Big time.


What a hobby. Wish I'd known about it sooner.

My favorite Hobby is non-debating. Judging by everyone's participation in a yrreg thread, I can see I'm not the only one.
 
Atheists act with complete logic in being ateist. Define embracing. (Yes, I know what embracing means but you seem to be using it as if atheists had an atheist religion or some such to embrace. That is fallacious).
 
Yerrg, your decision to try and preclude non-humans serves no useful purpose. It is a fudge factor created by you to avoid dealing with reality. That is why we mentioned that you definition is flawed by bringing up animals.

Now if you care to explain why animals should be excluded from your definition we may be willing to accept it.

If you were really interesting in having a discussion rather than preaching at us, you would back up a whole lot and start asking yourself what premises are mutual to your position and many of those here. Instead, all we get from you are arbitrary arguments based on what you want to believe about people rather than what people really think.

Here is one thing you need to toss by the roadside. Disagreeing with you does not mean we are not thinking. It means we reject the very premise your arguments are based on.

So before you accuse anyone else of not thinking you are going to have to try a lot harder to stop assuming positions for other people.
 
My favorite Hobby is non-debating. Judging by everyone's participation in a yrreg thread, I can see I'm not the only one.

I've heard that Yrreg considers himself a master debater, although he does get pangs of guilt about it.
 
.....
Then compare atheists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their atheistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence


One way of non-thinking is the assumption of ominiscience.
 
Last edited:
On this "presence of a working brain" as a criterion for intelligence. Doesn't that mean that either "God" is not intelligent, or that it has a brain?
 
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Posted by yrreg
How many times do I have to tell you guys that we are talking about human persons?
​


Animals are not irrelevant. A working brain is a necessary but not sufficient condition for intelligence. We brought up animals as an example of a brain without intelligence.

If you have more conditions to present, feel free to move on.


Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.

Title of thread: Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?


[ Have I already done a thread on this topic here? ]



In this thread I hope to discuss first what are the criteria of intelligence.


Then compare atheists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their atheistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence.




Addressing atheists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​





Yrreg



[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]​


I really have very serious doubt whether atheists are born naive or playing naive, either way they are not exhibiting intelligence before people who take them seriously, for continuously failing to take into their attention that this thread is about human persons in regard to intelligence in their worldviews, specifically the intelligence of atheists in embracing the worldview of atheism.



I will be back later in the evening and see whether atheists here after this post are now attending to themselves as human persons in regard to their intelligence in embracing their worldview of atheism.


And don't give me that facile excuse that you can't know whether you are acting intelligent or not without comparing yourselves with animals, compare yourselves with other humans and see whether you are intelligent like them or more or less.

That for me is an absolutely certain ground to suspect the absence of the phenomenon of intelligence in your brain -- your having to bring in animals to verify the presence of your intelligent brain.




Yrreg
 
Can't you guys read intelligently the title of the thread and the first post?

Here, let me reproduce them for you to intelligently read them and get it into your brain that this thread is about intelligence of human persons.





[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]​


I really have very serious doubt whether atheists are born naive or playing naive, either way they are not exhibiting intelligence before people who take them seriously, for continuously failing to take into their attention that this thread is about human persons in regard to intelligence in their worldviews, specifically the intelligence of atheists in embracing the worldview of atheism.



I will be back later in the evening and see whether atheists here after this post are now attending to themselves as human persons in regard to their intelligence in embracing their worldview of atheism.


And don't give me that facile excuse that you can't know whether you are acting intelligent or not without comparing yourselves with animals, compare yourselves with other humans and see whether you are intelligent like them or more or less.

That for me is an absolutely certain ground to suspect the absence of the phenomenon of intelligence in your brain -- your having to bring in animals to verify the presence of your intelligent brain.




Yrreg

Oh, that's an easy one. Compared to <posters who post and run, posters who don't address points brought up, posters who try to dictate the rules of a thread and don't adhere to their own rules> atheists are super-intelligent. Maybe you should go back and revisit some of your earlier threads and address the points brought up there. Use 20 words or less.
 
Last edited:
[ I have not read the posts subsequent to this one from KingM, which comes after my last post here before the present one, in which preceding post I reminded people to keep to human persons in this thread. ]​

Is this an intelligence test?

Can we set you tasks too, before we pay attention to what you say?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom