Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Tergiversating as per routine, ain't you guys here?

When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​



What do you say to that?





Yrreg
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​



What do you say to that?





Yrreg


You have a working brain. I therefore refute your definition.
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​



What do you say to that?





Yrreg

Seems too closed. And how do you define a brain?
 
Yrreg, define "working" in 5 words or less, as you mean it in reference to the human brain.
 
Folks, regardless of what you may think of the "politeness" of the topic, it is not an excuse to discuss each other rather than the topic. I've moved about half this thread to AAH, and more could go too unless you remember rules 11 & 12.

Thank you for using your intelligence before posting.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.
If you wish to have an actual discussion, you have to answer questions, not just ask them.
 
There is the non-intelligence criteria some people tend to embrace willingly in a tergiversating manner. You could call it faith-based and apparently Yrreg has embraced it fully.
Expect evasion on your inquires directed to Yrreg. That is all.
 
Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​

What do you say to that?

Yrreg

That is a non-starter.

Any working brain? That would include worms.

Come up with a useful definition and get back to us.

Or rethink the flawed assumption you started with. Arti already covered it but here is a good way to approach the this flaw in your thinking:

"Atheism is to belief as baldness is to hair color."

Not sure who came up with that, but it covers the problem quite well. Non-belief is not a form of belief.
 
Criteria of intelligence, as I see it:

* The ability to solve problems
* High order intentions (second or third order, for example)




There, happy?


I've now answered both of your questions (Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?, and What are your criteria of intelligence?)

I'm not being evasive. I have tried to make my posts and points clear and unambiguous.

Yet you paint me with the same broad brush as everyone else, and claim I am being "tergiversating" (it is possible to over-use a word, you know). But I've answered your questions.

Now please do me the favour of answering my previous post (#14).
 
Last edited:
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.

I for one am stunned that you ignored the legitimate posts above yours because they weren't what you wanted to hear.
 
Last edited:
Atheists aren't "embracing" anything. They are simply not embracing any of the vast assortment of unsupported fairy tales which some many find comfort and meaning in.
 
Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:
The presence of a working brain in a person.
​
What do you say to that?
  • It's wrong. A person in a persistent vegitiative state has a "working brain" otherwise he or she would be clinicly dead.
  • George Bush has a working brain but I'm not certain about his inteligence.
 
When you atheists have some serious criteria of intelligence, please pm me, otherwise I will continue to ignore your tergiversating posts.



Here is my first criterion (plural = criteria) of intelligence:

The presence of a working brain in a person.​



What do you say to that?





Yrreg

I say it's insufficient. Since you habitually refuse to accept any defiinitions but your own, perhaps you should work on one.

In the mean time, it is deplorably impolite, and a sign of premeditated bad faith, to start a public thread and then refuse to respond other than to private messages. You should be ashamed of yourself for such nonsense.
 
Except, perhaps, for stamp collecting.
When I was a Boy Scout I volunteered, with others, to vist strangers in the hospital and that led to a 2 hour endurance test to go through one patient's stamp collection. I couldn't agree with you more. :)

He past away not long after that. I would do it again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom