Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

NO! All tree parts must only be AS PLANTED. No variations. No shifting.
clap.gif
clap.gif


I guess I'd better highlight this in case it gets missed.

A BRILLIANT metaphoric reference to Tony Sz's primary error in his claims for WTC7 girder walk off collapse.
 
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]

I guess I'd better highlight this in case it gets missed.

A BRILLIANT metaphoric reference to Tony Sz's primary error in his claims for WTC7 girder walk off collapse.

I kinda think he bailed when we showed that he had never done any analysis at all. At least, that's when he switched to the fire simulation being wrong...
 
It seems as if Tony's approach is CD by default as he believes he believes he flaws in all technical analysis of the fire initiated gravity driven collapse. Since these analysis are wrong to him... then:

the fire initiation is wrong
there is a cover up being made by asserting the fire driven initiation claim
the cover up is offered to conceal... a) the real cause - CD b) the fact that the officials etc. making this claim were the perps c) the hijackers were patsies set up to take the blame. A similar MO - the false flag seen many times in the past.

There is a certain internal consistency to this logic. However a fire initiated gravity driven collapse is certainly possible and more than likely the best fit explanation.
 
It seems as if Tony's approach is CD by default as he believes he believes he flaws in all technical analysis of the fire initiated gravity driven collapse. Since these analysis are wrong to him... then:

the fire initiation is wrong
there is a cover up being made by asserting the fire driven initiation claim
the cover up is offered to conceal... a) the real cause - CD b) the fact that the officials etc. making this claim were the perps c) the hijackers were patsies set up to take the blame. A similar MO - the false flag seen many times in the past.

There is a certain internal consistency to this logic. However a fire initiated gravity driven collapse is certainly possible and more than likely the best fit explanation.

Tony either A, can't understand complexity, or B. is intentionally oversimplify to promote pure
Hucksterous behavior.
I believe it is B but I could be wrong.
 
Tony either A, can't understand complexity, or B. is intentionally oversimplify to promote pure
Hucksterous behavior.
I believe it is B but I could be wrong.

I personally feel that TSz isn't a huckster and that he actually believes that the WTC destruction was brought about be deliberate extra-governmental plot that included using explosives to demolish 3 or 7 WTC structures.
However, his belief interferes with rational discussion and investigation, confirmation bias at its most extreme.
Same goes for some others, Chris Sarns comes to mind.

As for your point "A" above, IMHO it comes from a strict literal mindset, what I call "binary thinking". If this then not that, uncertainties cannot enter such thinking.
For eg. walk off of the girder in WTC 7. Missing 0.5 inch. This is supposedly a deal killer for walk off but it completely ignores the possibility that the damages to WTC 7 farther afield from that specific location could have affected the outcome in this specific location at all. To most people the several girder failure modes shown by several different engineering firms simply illustrates that yes, it is very probable that this was the initiating event in the progression to global collapse. TSz and others reject this in a god-of-the-gaps type of argument, then employ that binary thinking, if not this then CD.
 
”There is a certain internal consistency to this logic.

However a fire initiated gravity driven collapse is certainly possible and more than likely the best fit explanation.”

Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.
 
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.

In truth, CD is the easiest thing to rule out.

An you clearly don't understand fire, and you leave out the key factor of 7's demise which is the impact damage caused by debris from WTC1. You act as if 7 burned and collapsed in a vacuum, and not part of a much larger event. An event with hundreds of thousands of eye witnesses, with the closer witnesses being firefighters and police officers (who'd know explosives when they hear them).

WTC7 was brought down by the mythical "Golden BB", that one lucky arrow of fate where all the factors lined up perfectly and fatally.:thumbsup:
 
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.


Then, you should have no problem pointing the time lines depicting explosions in the following video.


WTC 7 Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A

Truthers took the CD bait and ran off with it. Apparently, they do not seem to understand that explosives, when detonated, make a lot of noise that can be heard for miles around and yet, no evidence of CD explosions was evident on video, audio nor in the seismic data. In fact, not one shred of hardware evidence was ever found within the rubble of WTC 7.

To sum it up, Truthers were duped because they were too lazy to do their homework to understand they were duped.

.
 
Last edited:
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.

Conjecture? How hypocritical can you get sir?

There WERE large area fires in WTC7.
There WAS very significant strutural damage to the South side.

These are documented fact.

There is little to no evidence of CD beyond bald conjecture on the part if truthers.
 
Then, you should have no problem pointing the time lines depicting explosions in the following video.


WTC 7 Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A

Truthers took the CD bait and ran off with it.

Apparently, they do not seem to understand that explosives, when detonated, make a lot of noise that can be heard for miles around

The video you linked is spliced with another clip taken at a different location. Why isn't the WTC 7 collapse as loud as demolitions done by companies? Well, the demolition crowd have almost always maintained that the demolition charges would have been something unusual. They kind of already knew that with the weeks of molten metal and all. Depends on how you feel to piece it together.

and yet, no evidence of CD explosions was evident on video,

I have to differ.

The Northeast corner of the South Tower begins to deform at the same location where an expulsion of material and a bright flash of light originates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETntmSrT7g8&t=0m24s

In fact, several bright flashes of light are seen originating from the upper portion of the collapsing South Tower.

The first possible expulsion of material from the North Tower associated with the collapse originated from at least 10 floors under floor 98, where the collapse initiated, before the upper portion's roofline had dropped one floor. This one expulsion of material can be seen on at least one (low quality) video to continue expanding to a larger cloud within less time than the upper portion has dropped two floors: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTuvo4b4E9Y

A piece of the North Tower's perimeter, left sticking up in the air, suddenly falls down at the exact moment an expulsion of material is seen on the north west corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoAD8HlrLZg


Obsessing over "silent explosives" and the loudness of ordinary commercial explosive charges will not excuse the anomalies in the audio/video record that you do not want to address. Anomalies like this include:

1.The payphone video which may depict a loud explosive noise happening before or very shortly after WTC 1 collapsed.

2. This author's found evidence that the South Tower began emitting percussive noises briefly before the upper portion began falling, once the speed of sound is adjusted: http://911review.com/articles/reijden/911_my_own_review.htm#evidence.

3. The beginning of the South Tower collapse generally sounds louder than the rest of it, as noticed on many videos taken closely (this may be why many witnesses described an explosion in the South Tower right before it began collapsing)

4. As you probably know, the sounds of explosions from the area of WTC 7 got pretty loud, even before any fires in the WTC complex developed after the North Tower collapse.

5.The explosive noise(s) heard on the CBS and Ashleigh Banfield videos of the collapse.

Question: Why were these noises louder than the rest of the total collapse?

nor in the seismic data.

It is already known through actual demolitions, like one hotel in Las Vegas, that explosive demolitions can have a minuscule impact on the seismic record depending on where you place the explosives. However, the seismic data has been shown to be more ambiguous than you push.

In fact, not one shred of hardware evidence was ever found within the rubble of WTC 7.

Why would you expect anything like that to stand out? The collapses were powerful enough to destroy 420 cubic yards of concrete, a 50 ton hydraulic press, and every electric transformer in the building, it is enough to simply speculate that any such demolition fittings may have been lost in the collapse.

You seem to like classic debunker copypasta. I can copypasta all day on what warrants some investigations into insider involvement in the WTC destruction including the possibility of explosive use, but I'll be copying the NFPA 921. If it bothers you so much, why not just support what the demolition crowd asks for? If it's conclusive enough, you should hope and expect to see a max exodus.
 
Last edited:
The video you linked is spliced with another clip taken at a different location. Why isn't the WTC 7 collapse as loud as demolitions done by companies? Well, the demolition crowd have almost always maintained that the demolition charges would have been something unusual. They kind of already knew that with the weeks of molten metal and all. Depends on how you feel to piece it together.
Your point is not clear, please try again.
ETA:Wait, are you saying that the explosives may have been some unknown type that is relatively silent. Are you invoking the "You don't know what THEY have" meme? So you believe in magic then!


The Northeast corner of the South Tower begins to deform at the same location where an expulsion of material and a bright flash of light originates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETntmSrT7g8&t=0m24s

In fact, several bright flashes of light are seen originating from the upper portion of the collapsing South Tower.
Yes, this is just as easily explained by internal floor collapses. Bright flashes that you seem to be able to see occurring within the upper section, AFTER the upper section is already moving? What possible use would that be?

The first possible expulsion of material from the North Tower associated with the collapse originated from at least 10 floors under floor 98, where the collapse initiated, before the upper portion's roofline had dropped one floor. This one expulsion of material can be seen on at least one (low quality) video to continue expanding to a larger cloud within less time than the upper portion has dropped two floors: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTuvo4b4E9Y
And?? Is there some reason why a floor collapse cannot occur at the 89th floor and cause an expulsion of material?

A piece of the North Tower's perimeter, left sticking up in the air, suddenly falls down at the exact moment an expulsion of material is seen on the north west corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoAD8HlrLZg
Again? So what? Something failed DURING the collapse. That is to be expected.


Obsessing over "silent explosives" and the loudness of ordinary commercial explosive charges will not excuse the anomalies in the audio/video record that you do not want to address. Anomalies like this include:

Ignoring the fact that explosives produce supersonic pressure waves and are loud does not make the issue go away.


Or its recording the sound of a large chunk of one of the damaged structures falling to the ground.

2. This author's found evidence that the South Tower began emitting percussive noises briefly before the upper portion began falling, once the speed of sound is adjusted: http://911review.com/articles/reijden/911_my_own_review.htm#evidence.
To be expected with internal floor collapses.
3. The beginning of the South Tower collapse generally sounds louder than the rest of it, as noticed on many videos taken closely (this may be why many witnesses described an explosion in the South Tower right before it began collapsing)
Explosives are very sharp loud sounds. There is NO evidence of such sounds at all.

4. As you probably know, the sounds of explosions from the area of WTC 7 got pretty loud, even before any fires in the WTC complex developed after the North Tower collapse.
As you are aware, I am sure, pieces of several buildings were falling off during this time. That would include the very real possibility of chunks of the NW corner of WTC 7 letting go and falling a dozen storeys to the ground. THAT goes BOOM.

5.The explosive noise(s) heard on the CBS and Ashleigh Banfield videos of the collapse.
Explosives noises? I expect that the internal failure of col 79 made quite a rumble. What we do note is that the guy recording this doesn't even notice these supposed explosions.

Question: Why were these noises louder than the rest of the total collapse?
ANSWER: They werern't. There is a low rumble about the same level as the earlier booming noises that starts about the same time the person remarks on the collapsing building.



It is already known through actual demolitions, like one hotel in Las Vegas, that explosive demolitions can have a minuscule impact on the seismic record depending on where you place the explosives. However, the seismic data has been shown to be more ambiguous than you push.

Ok, so the seismic data gives absolutely no help to your cause. Got it!



Why would you expect anything like that to stand out? The collapses were powerful enough to destroy 420 cubic yards of concrete, a 50 ton hydraulic press, and every electric transformer in the building, it is enough to simply speculate that any such demolition fittings may have been lost in the collapse.
You understand that a 50 ton press does not weigh 50 tons right?
Are you now stating that there were explosives placed within the concrete and strapped to every transformer? Why?

Sure I suppose demolitions equipment could have been destroyed, or it could simply NEVER HAVE BEEN THERE at all. What you are doing is pointing out that you have no evidence of explosive use.

You seem to like classic debunker copypasta. I can copypasta all day on what warrants some investigations into insider involvement in the WTC destruction including the possibility of explosive use, but I'll be copying the NFPA 921. If it bothers you so much, why not just support what the demolition crowd asks for? If it's conclusive enough, you should hope and expect to see a max exodus.

Please provide a list of the people in the professional "demolition crowd" that is clamouring for an investigation.
 
Last edited:
Conjecture? How hypocritical can you get sir?

There WERE large area fires in WTC7.
There WAS very significant strutural damage to the South side.

These are documented fact.

There is little to no evidence of CD beyond bald conjecture on the part if truthers.

Let's face facts here: all three WTC structures had large area fires and impact damage prior to their respective collapses. The towers had had multi-floor fires accelerated by the thousands of gallons of aircraft fuel. Each fire on each floor was, within seconds, covering an area that in a common office fire would take 30 minutes to an hour to develop and this was occurring simultaneously on several vertically adjacent floors. AND they had had significant damage to columns and floor pans caused by the aircraft impacts.

WTC 7 had significant impact damage as well. Even if you discount the reported south central face gouge, no one can dispute the loss of the SW corner over a height of a dozen+ storeys.
After that and over the course of 8 hours WTC7 began burning. There were several large area fires, each of which would have been considered major fires in and of themselves.

SO, we have known damage and a mechanism for continuing damage in all three structures.

What there is NOT, is any definitive physical or documentary evidence of explosives on par with the evidence of impact and fires. Instead, we have conjecture, supposition and confirmation bias to support the idea that there were explosives on site.

Simple logic requires then that we accept that the evident damage and evident large fires are the most probable, by far, cause of the building's demise.
 
The video you linked is spliced with another clip taken at a different location.

Proof! There are several other WTC 7 videos and not one depicts CD explosions.

Why isn't the WTC 7 collapse as loud as demolitions done by companies? Well, the demolition crowd have almost always maintained that the demolition charges would have been something unusual.

That doesn't fly because explosions make a lot of noise, PERIOD!! Secondly, no CD explosions were depicted on seismographs at ground zero that day. If explosives were firmly attached to the steel columns and detonated, shock signals would have been detected. Imagine your ears placed at one end of a steel beam and someone at the other end strikes a heavy blow to that steel beams. Chances are, you are going to hear the results and what you are implying is that such a hammer blow does not generate sound waves.

I might further add that WTC 7 burned for several hours and heavily damaged from impacts from WTC 1, yet no CD explosions were noted.

They kind of already knew that with the weeks of molten metal and all. Depends on how you feel to piece it together.

First of all, thermite and explosives do not leave behind molten metal for hours, days, weeks or even months. That is another fabricated that duped a number of Truthers.


The Northeast corner of the South Tower begins to deform at the same location where an expulsion of material and a bright flash of light originates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETntmSrT7g8&t=0m24s


That had nothing to do with a CD explosions. There are no explosions and the northeast corner of WTC 2 buckled due to fire, not explosives. Notice there is no sound of explosions in this video.


WTC 2 Collapse

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SSS0DDqfm0


Just to let you know that video has been used to discredit the Truth movement.


In fact, several bright flashes of light are seen originating from the upper portion of the collapsing South Tower.


False!! Sounds to me like you are fabricating as you go because there are no seismic data signals from the WTC Towers.


The first possible expulsion of material from the North Tower associated with the collapse originated from at least 10 floors under floor 98, where the collapse initiated, before the upper portion's roofline had dropped one floor. This one expulsion of material can be seen on at least one (low quality) video to continue expanding to a larger cloud within less time than the upper portion has dropped two floors: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTuvo4b4E9Y


The squibs are the result of compressed air, not from explosives. We can take a look here at the Verinage demolition process that does not require the use of explosives.


Verinage Demolition Video


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwFHEoiUZ7o


Veringage Demolition Photo

https://www.metabunk.org/data/MetaM..._E2_80_A22e203ef45d6fceb66abba893219a1052.jpg


As you can see, compressed air is responsible for the squibs you see in the photo and video, but apparently, Truthers were unaware of that fact.


A piece of the North Tower's perimeter, left sticking up in the air, suddenly falls down at the exact moment an expulsion of material is seen on the north west corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoAD8HlrLZg


There are no CD explosions in that video either. Just to let you know that Truthers supply the ammunition we use to discredit their movement because much of what they have posted was deliberately placed disinformation.


Disinformation Killed 9/11 “Truth”

By 2009, the 9/11 “Truth” Movement was so inundated with disinformation that it had become a laughingstock. The easily-discredited claims (lies) contaminated the greater issue and soiled dissenters across the board. “Turd blossom” was a Karl Rove phrase that could describe what the movement had devolved into. The media, whether corporate or foundation-funded, could find people ranting about “the Jews” or the Illuminati, the Lizard People, the missiles, holograms, mini-nukes or space beam weapons vaporizing the Twin Towers.

Many trolls, and some public personalities, appeared to be professional disinformation artists hard at work concocting and posting this crap online, which others repeated to their own detriment. One cannot easily prove that a specific person is a paid shill, a disinformation agent, a cyber agent provocateur, but be assured they are out there, and “out there.”

http://www.911truth.org/disinformation-killed-911-truth/


Thanks for proving my point about Truthers and how easy they are duped with disiformation and outright lies.
 
Last edited:
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.

Oh good. We still have one chew toy.

Where's the evidence that it was only office cubicles on fire, and that they were roaming, as opposed to traversing, sashaying, or hopping?
 
The video you linked is spliced with another clip taken at a different location. Why isn't the WTC 7 collapse as loud as demolitions done by companies? Well, the demolition crowd have almost always maintained that the demolition charges would have been something unusual. They kind of already knew that with the weeks of molten metal and all. Depends on how you feel to piece it together.


Explosives will keep metal molten for weeks?

Do tell.
 
Your point is not clear, please try again.
ETA:Wait, are you saying that the explosives may have been some unknown type that is relatively silent. Are you invoking the "You don't know what THEY have" meme? So you believe in magic then!

The meme is yours. You're the one who says "literally silent explosives"

Yes, this is just as easily explained by internal floor collapses. Bright flashes that you seem to be able to see occurring within the upper section, AFTER the upper section is already moving? What possible use would that be?

A flash of light, a puff of material, physical deformation. You can actually see something that looks like a hole in the aluminum cladding covering the corner of the South Tower. Sounds good enough to be considered photographic evidence for explosions, or some other demolition device that may be capable of producing a bright flash of light and expulsion of material. What do you mean by "what possible use"? The upper portion needed to be destroyed to make sure it had enough momentum to totally destroy the lower portion.

And?? Is there some reason why a floor collapse cannot occur at the 89th floor and cause an expulsion of material?

Considering that these expulsions are at least ten floors down from where the collapse initiated, and happen the same moment or even before the upper portion starts moving.

Again? So what? Something failed DURING the collapse. That is to be expected.

So you think that the dismemberment of that area of the corner perimeter was directly caused by that apparent jet of material, however you think this phenomenon happened naturally?

Or its recording the sound of a large chunk of one of the damaged structures falling to the ground.

It has the sound of a classic linear shaped charge.

To be expected with internal floor collapses.

Explosives are very sharp loud sounds. There is NO evidence of such sounds at all.

It depends on how they're used and what they're used for. If explosives are used to do "small jobs", then the sound was certainly be comparable to the sound of the collapsing WTC towers.

As you are aware, I am sure, pieces of several buildings were falling off during this time. That would include the very real possibility of chunks of the NW corner of WTC 7 letting go and falling a dozen storeys to the ground. THAT goes BOOM.

In the video, the guy points out that "new smoke" seems to be emerging from the area of WTC 7 after an explosion he heard. On one recorded later in the video, he literally saus "There's another explosion..." *points camera towards WTC 7* "...coming from the federal building, I think".

Explosives noises? I expect that the internal failure of col 79 made quite a rumble. What we do note is that the guy recording this doesn't even notice these supposed explosions.

ANSWER: They werern't. There is a low rumble about the same level as the earlier booming noises that starts about the same time the person remarks on the collapsing building.

But don't you see how that noise happened about 3 seconds before the East Penthouse fell? The CBS footage makes it clear that was the loudest event in the collapse, not the acceleration from the other columns straight down to the ground.

You understand that a 50 ton press does not weigh 50 tons right?
Are you now stating that there were explosives placed within the concrete and strapped to every transformer? Why?

Sure I suppose demolitions equipment could have been destroyed, or it could simply NEVER HAVE BEEN THERE at all. What you are doing is pointing out that you have no evidence of explosive use.

The point is that such a collapse destroys everything except for steel.

Please provide a list of the people in the professional "demolition crowd" that is clamouring for an investigation.

What?
 
v=oTuvo4b4E9Y[/url]




Obsessing over "silent explosives" and the loudness of ordinary commercial explosive charges will not excuse the anomalies in the audio/video record that you do not want to address. Anomalies like this include:

1.The payphone video which may depict a loud explosive noise happening before or very shortly after WTC 1 collapsed.

2. This author's found evidence that the South Tower began emitting percussive noises briefly before the upper portion began falling, once the speed of sound is adjusted: http://911review.com/articles/reijden/911_my_own_review.htm#evidence.

3. The beginning of the South Tower collapse generally sounds louder than the rest of it, as noticed on many videos taken closely (this may be why many witnesses described an explosion in the South Tower right before it began collapsing)

4. As you probably know, the sounds of explosions from the area of WTC 7 got pretty loud, even before any fires in the WTC complex developed after the North Tower collapse.

5.The explosive noise(s) heard on the CBS and Ashleigh Banfield videos of the collapse.

Question: Why were these noises louder than the rest of the total collapse?


Ever heard the sound of structrual failure? From one of your links.


"The idea that this clip contains the sound of a bomb going off in or near WTC7 isn't supported by the evidence"


It is already known through actual demolitions, like one hotel in Las Vegas, that explosive demolitions can have a minuscule impact on the seismic record depending on where you place the explosives. However, the seismic data has been shown to be more ambiguous than you push.


Just to let you know that your link is full of flaws not supported by demolition experts.
 

The only thing in your response that wasn't about the silent explosives meme was that verniage demolitions make "squibs". Of course, not every apparent expulsion of dust in a CD-style building collapse is the direct result of air blast from a nearby explosive. Here's a video of the J.L. Hudson Department Store demolition, in which we see that jets of material appear to "flow" out of the building, rather than rapidly explode out of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JP1HJoG-1Pg

Each individual squib from the Twin Towers has some degree of similarity to a demolition squib.

What you're really avoiding if how, rather than that being caused by the dismembering building, there is clear photographic evidence that it is actually causing the building to dismember. Why does that happen on at least two occasions in the South and North tower?
 
The meme is yours. You're the one who says "literally silent explosives"


That is exactly what you are implying



A flash of light, a puff of material, physical deformation.


The buckling is the result of structural weakening from uncontrolled fires raging within the buidling, which had nothing to do with explosives.


You can actually see something that looks like a hole in the aluminum cladding covering the corner of the South Tower. Sounds good enough to be considered photographic evidence for explosions, or some other demolition device that may be capable of producing a bright flash of light and expulsion of material. What do you mean by "what possible use"? The upper portion needed to be destroyed to make sure it had enough momentum to totally destroy the lower portion.


False across the board!! No evidence of any kind that depicts CD explosions as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed.

* No visual evidence of CD explosions

* No audio evidence of CD explosions

* No seismic evidence of CD explosions

* No hardware evidence of CD explosives

Just to let you know that CD explosions are not supported by the evidence.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom