Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Fire, in conjunction with impact damage, is the most logical explanation and I can point to steel frame buildings that collapsed due to fire alone.
Let's take a look at two examples, one where a building withstood multiple bomb strikes, yet remained standing.


Chinese Embassy Photo

http://www.paulmidler.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a.jpg


Next, where fire destroyed steel frame buildings.


Kader Toy Factory Fire

.....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kader_Toy_Factory_fire

I might have chosen the Delft University fire induced building collapse. After all how the ech-ee-double-toothpicks can a fire in a coffee machine cause half a classroom and office building to collapse!?
 
50 ton press, 500 pounds of stupid

... The collapses were powerful enough to destroy 420 cubic yards of concrete, a 50 ton hydraulic press, and every electric transformer in the building, it is enough to simply speculate that any such demolition fittings may have been lost in the collapse. ...

You understand the 50 ton hydraulic press weighs just over 500 pounds? lol, you repeat tag-lines from a failed movement based on a delusional CD fantasy. http://www.globalindustrial.com/p/m...mpaignId=T9F&gclid=CMz6qOfyxs4CFU5lfgod87QKSA

The 50 ton press - pretty much sums up 9/11 truth followers knowledge on 9/11 - below zero.

As for energy in the collapse of a WTC tower>? It is equal in energy to 130 2,000 pounds bombs.

Thus the damage to the WTC complex was due to E=mgh released.

9/11 truth failed to do the physics, and added idiotic claims of some inside job based on paranoia and overwhelming ignorance.

Is that the total of all concrete in the WTC? BTW, the floors of the Towers were light weight concrete... no big deal, but you don't seem to understand physics.

Failed tag-lines, and repeating the 50 ton press stuff?
What does the 50 ton press, which weighs 500 to 600 pounds mean? Do you have any idea what a press does? lol, this can't keep repeating;;; okay, that is a lie, 9/11 truth lies will repeat as long as people fail to use critical thinking skills.

... a 50 ton hydraulic press...
What year is this?:dl::dl::dl:

the legacy of nonsense in reruns
 
Last edited:
I never claimed silent explosives, just pointing out that demolition theorists have tended to think that something exotic was used, like a hypothetical device where the weld point of the columns are directly heated to extremely high temperature before a final explosive blow is delivered.

Odd, I see the expulsion of material flowing around the corner column. At no point at all do I see the corner column pushing outward.

How does this fit into a coherent explanation that includes the bright flashes of light (which aren't fire), and apparent dismemberment of the actual steel structure (not just gypsum wallboard)?

The only light I see is the brightening of the existing fires as air is pushed through the combusting material when the upper floors and upper section begin coming down. Start a bonfire and blow on it and marvel that it gets brighter!

To understand the unlikelihood of your argument, we must examine video footage. First, check out this opposite angle showing the explosion on the NE corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPB9MHgHWB

Here's a compilation of South Tower collapse footage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA

This is an online utility to watch Youtube videos frame-by-frame: http://rowvid.com/?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA

Pay close attention to the upper portion, going through footage frame-by-frame, to see the flashes of light in the windows.

What of it? Yes, a floor collapses lower down, loads shift in the structure and collapse ensues. Is there some reason why it would have to begin at the 89th floor where, it would seem, the 90th floor collapsed?

Dust needs time to move through the building.

I simply don't see the corner column being "dismembered". What I see is expulsion of material around the corner column leading the exterior collapse zone where the building exterior is coming apart.

There are no slender "corner columns". There are large spandrel plates that are welded and bolted on the corners to join the perimeter wall units.

I see, cutting through the massive columns of WTC 1, 2, & 7 are "small jobs". Whatever you need to float your boat I suppose.:rolleyes:

Not like you're saying. See further above.


From the Federal building you say. New smoke from a building that's been burning for hours you say. Colour me aghast! At what time on Sept 11/01 did the federal building collapse?
It IS NOT UNUSUAL for stuff to blow up in fires, fire extinguishers, transformers, CRT screens, propane bottles......

The footage was taken right after the North Tower collapsed.

Yeah I do. You do know what the NIST and ARUP and others say is the most probable sequence of collapse is, right? Column 79 fails low down in the structure and floors begin failing above that point as col 79 draws down. You for some reason expect that a) column 79 failing shouldn't be noisy, and b ) that it's failure should instantaneously transmit to the roof and cause the EPH to fall immediately.

If the east corner of WTC 7 was gutted in a progressive collapse, the noise of this event should not have been louder than the noise of the entire rest of the structure falling to the ground.

BTW you did not answer the question, you do know what a 50 ton press is and that you could put one in your garage. I suppose I should also ask how you know for certain that no one found a badly damaged 50 ton press that you claim was in WTC7? (or was it in WTC1 or 2?)

What?
 
The footage was taken right after the North Tower collapsed.

No that footage was taken 46 minuets after the collapse of the North Tower.

It's the 11:15:04 explosion he is talking about. The building shadows in the video confirm it.
 
I never claimed silent explosives, just pointing out that demolition theorists have tended to think that something exotic was used, like a hypothetical device where the weld point of the columns are directly heated to extremely high temperature before a final explosive blow is delivered.



How does this fit into a coherent explanation that includes the bright flashes of light (which aren't fire), and apparent dismemberment of the actual steel structure (not just gypsum wallboard)?



To understand the unlikelihood of your argument, we must examine video footage. First, check out this opposite angle showing the explosion on the NE corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPB9MHgHWB

Here's a compilation of South Tower collapse footage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA

This is an online utility to watch Youtube videos frame-by-frame: http://rowvid.com/?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA

Pay close attention to the upper portion, going through footage frame-by-frame, to see the flashes of light in the windows.



Dust needs time to move through the building.



There are no slender "corner columns". There are large spandrel plates that are welded and bolted on the corners to join the perimeter wall units.



Not like you're saying. See further above.




The footage was taken right after the North Tower collapsed.



If the east corner of WTC 7 was gutted in a progressive collapse, the noise of this event should not have been louder than the noise of the entire rest of the structure falling to the ground.



What?

...four publicly available independent wtc 7 forensic collapse investigations later and we're back to the same nonsense. let's just pretend such things didn't happen and the reports don't exist and that this entire thread isn't based on the only active engineer in the entire truther movement essentially conceding he hasn't done the analyses necessary to raise fundamental questions about any of them, let alone all of them together. let's just rehash stupid conjecture instead.

or let's watch some more videos of WAI getting the prestigious ACEC grand award for its independent forensic study of WTC 7 collapse scenarios:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VGDqoJWXf0&feature=youtu.be&t=1m16s
 
Last edited:
I never claimed silent explosives, just pointing out that demolition theorists have tended to think that something exotic was used, like a hypothetical device where the weld point of the columns are directly heated to extremely high temperature before a final explosive blow is delivered.


No matter how you look at it, CD explosives make a lot of noise that can be heard miles around.


How does this fit into a coherent explanation that includes the bright flashes of light (which aren't fire),


What bright flashes? Nothing to do with explosives.


... and apparent dismemberment of the actual steel structure (not just gypsum wallboard)?


Talk about dismemberment, take a look at this photo and the condition of a steel frame building that collapse without the aid of explosives.


21-Story Steel Frame Building Collapse Photo

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipe...arthquake_-_Pina_Suarez_Apartment_Complex.jpg


No explosives and yet, that steel frame building collapsed. To sum it up, you either show us videos and audio depicting the sound of CD explosions as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapse or simply, you have no case for explosives.

In case you have never heard CD explosions, you can take a look here and hear what you don't hear as the WTC buildings collapsed.



The Sound of Demolition Explosions


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65tzBUqxqd8
 
Last edited:
...four publicly available independent wtc 7 forensic collapse investigations later and we're back to the same nonsense. let's just pretend such things didn't happen and the reports don't exist and that this entire thread isn't based on the only active engineer in the entire truther movement essentially conceding he hasn't done the analyses necessary to raise fundamental questions about any of them, let alone all of them together. let's just rehash stupid conjecture instead.

or let's watch some more videos of WAI getting the prestigious ACEC grand award for its independent forensic study of WTC 7 collapse scenarios:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VGDqoJWXf0&feature=youtu.be&t=1m16s

If you are speaking of me, I have certainly done analyses showing the NIST and ARUP reports have fatal flaws and are thus non-explanatory. Don't put words in my mouth either. I never conceded what you are saying. You are starting to spin things. Why?

We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.

You act as though you don't know these reports are highly controversial and that they are somehow beyond reproach. Unfortunately, nothing could be further from the truth.

What is the fourth report on WTC 7 you are referring to? FEMA?
 
Last edited:
I never claimed silent explosives, just pointing out that demolition theorists have tended to think that something exotic was used, like a hypothetical device where the weld point of the columns are directly heated to extremely high temperature before a final explosive blow is delivered.

Is there a working model of this device?

If not, isn't this just an appeal to magic?
 
We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.


Controversial where? I haven't seen any disagreement about it on any news outlet, nor in any engineering journal. I could have missed the latter, though; can you point me to where the heated public disagreement is taking place?
 
How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?

Heat induced deformation resulted in a collapse that yanked the building from inside to out, resulting in forces on the moment frame that yanked the camera visible parts down at accelerations up to and possibly over g. The collapse was somewhat uniform because the moment frame held the exterior intact through and past collapse initiation.

Oh and yes, explosive demolitions have distinctive high decibel explosions not in evidence.

Now back to our regularly scheduled debate on whether 4-4.5 hour fire simulations are valid. I think also that at this point, although never answered, we can all agree that MSPaintFire is unsuitable for this purpose.
 
....the Weidlinger report ... is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.
...

Tony,

please go back to August 9 in this thread, and find out that at least 3 posters have already tried to SCHOOL you on a simple error you committed:

the 4.5 hours do NOT refer to "fire duration in a single location".
They refer to the run time of a simulation.
During that runtime, modeled fires moved from location to location, and distribution of hot gases and radiation was tracked.

Please find at least MY posts from last week, quote them, and answer the questions I asked you, lest you create the impression you run away from those questions.

You have NOT scrutinized anything. You merely compared an apple with a computer simulation of an apple tree, and insinuated vaguely something sinister because the tree is older than the apple.
You never, however, really spelled out what your question is, your scope, your beef.
 
Guys,

could you please please please all refrain from entertaining Micah's and Criteria's derails of Tony's fail?

The topic is the duration of certain fire sims - NOT another general "all things WTC7" mole slap fest.

Unless you wish to provide Tony with an escape.
 
If you are speaking of me, I have certainly done analyses showing the NIST and ARUP reports have fatal flaws and are thus non-explanatory. Don't put words in my mouth either. I never conceded what you are saying. You are starting to spin things. Why?

We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.

You act as though you don't know these reports are highly controversial and that they are somehow beyond reproach. Unfortunately, nothing could be further from the truth.

What is the fourth report on WTC 7 you are referring to? FEMA?

You keep claiming you've done the analysis, but you simply ignore requests to share it. I gave you the benefit of the doubt for quite some time, but I'm not longer going to simply take your word for it re your model.

And you claiming the heating model is "controversial" (let alone "highly controversial") without any actual articulable reason for saying that does not make it so.

There are four independent reports for which the collapse mechanism was fulsomely modeled:

1. NIST (which was subjected to a lengthy public comment period and which was peer reviewed and republished in the Journal of Structural Engineering)

2. Colin Bailey's Aegis expert report

3. ARUP's analysis for Nordenson's expert report

4. Weidlinger Associates' analysis in connection with the Aegis litigation defense, which they independently published and submitted to ACEC, winning themselves one of only eight Grand Awards awarded by a panel of ACEC's experts in 2015
 
Last edited:
No matter how you look at it, CD explosives make a lot of noise that can be heard miles around.
You failed to answer my second question:
@ skyeagle:
...
Do you believe you are debating on topic?
Please answer now: Do you believe you are debating on topic?

What bright flashes? Nothing to do with explosives.
Do you believe you are debating on topic?

Talk about dismemberment, take a look at this photo and the condition of a steel frame building that collapse without the aid of explosives.
...
No explosives and yet, that steel frame building collapsed. To sum it up, you either show us videos and audio depicting the sound of CD explosions as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapse or simply, you have no case for explosives.

In case you have never heard CD explosions, you can take a look here and hear what you don't hear as the WTC buildings collapsed.
Do you believe you are debating on topic?

Do you believe you are debating on topic?
 
If you are speaking of me, I have certainly done analyses showing the NIST and ARUP reports have fatal flaws and are thus non-explanatory. Don't put words in my mouth either. I never conceded what you are saying. You are starting to spin things. Why?

We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.

You act as though you don't know these reports are highly controversial and that they are somehow beyond reproach. Unfortunately, nothing could be further from the truth.

What is the fourth report on WTC 7 you are referring to? FEMA?
Show us!
At the first request for even a free body, showing the loads and reactions, you bailed out and started questioning the fire analysis.

Professional ethics, anyone? Nothing to see here...
 
Snipped a bunch of useless drivel

You were asked a long while ago to produce a simple video that has the sounds of a controlled demolition, so far you've failed miserably. Care to try again?
There were thousands of videos captured that day. Why can't you find one with those sounds?????

Do better the lurkers are getting bored.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom