Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Considering that these expulsions are at least ten floors down from where the collapse initiated, and happen the same moment or even before the upper portion starts moving.

The collapse initiated in the aircraft impact zone. Surely you're not suggesting your magic explosives are also impervious to that impact and fire?
 
The only thing in your response that wasn't about the silent explosives meme was that verniage demolitions make "squibs".


There is no sound of CD explosions as the WTC buildings collapsed and it is clearly evident from the Verinage demolition process that the squibs are produced by compressed air.

Using the laws of physics in my argument to debunk your claim, you understand.
 
What you're really avoiding if how, rather than that being caused by the dismembering building, there is clear photographic evidence that it is actually causing the building to dismember. Why does that happen on at least two occasions in the South and North tower?


Do you mean, like this? You will notice objects flying away from the buildings as they collapse, keeping in mind this demolition technique does not use explosives.


Verinage Demolition Video: No Explosives Used

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwFHEoiUZ7o


Now, explain why a huge bomb failed to bring down WTC 1 in 1993. You will notice that the steel structure remains standing within that huge bomb crater. Explain in detail, what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.


1993 WTC 1 Bombing

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/10/WTC_1993_ATF_Commons.jpg
 
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.
”Simple logic requires then that we accept that the evident damage and evident large fires are the most probable, by far, cause of the building's demise.’

Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.

Scoff at a full CD investigation.

At that point, the logic does become very simple.

If it was not a CD than of course the fire must have caused it.

The NIST stalled for over 7 years before offering that as the foundation for their collapse hypothesis?

The long delay worked well for the Bush presidency.

The NIST could not, and still do not, address the question below;

How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?
 
Last edited:
The buckling is the result of structural weakening from uncontrolled fires raging within the buidling, which had nothing to do with explosives.

What? Fail. The event happened in a floor above the fire-affected area. A giant steel spandrel plate bolted and welded to the perimeter wall units can not buckle like any member, the corner ejection on the south tower comes way above the collapse zone. You also didn't explain the corner ejection on the North Tower. Or why squibs have been shown to emit from the building before the roofline even dropped a floor.

There is no sound of CD explosions as the WTC buildings collapsed and it is clearly evident from the Verinage demolition process that the squibs are produced by compressed air.

Using the laws of physics in my argument to debunk your claim, you understand.

SkyEagle, check out this angle of the South Tower collapse and see how dust is only being pushed out of the windows, and not on the perimeter-corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PV4HtDGokhk

You're specialty is not really responding to every point you're given.

Now, explain why a huge bomb failed to bring down WTC 1 in 1993. You will notice that the steel structure remains standing within that huge bomb crater. Explain in detail, what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.

Because air blast from a single bomb is nearly impossible to destroy an entire building? If that's what you're getting at, then what's your opinion on the Murrah Building collapse? Multiple bombs?
 
Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.

Scoff at a full CD investigation.

Politically expedient?!?! :jaw-dropp

We're talking about CD being PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE at the site in NYC, DC and Pennsylvania given the circumstances of the day. And the complete lack of a clue brought forth by your side.

Blaming politics in this case is so beyond stupid it's not even funny. CD at those sites is the single most mentally retarded idea in the history of humankind.
 
What? Fail. The event happened in a floor above the fire-affected area.


Structural buckling is a clear indication of structural load redistribution due to uncontrolled fires and impact damage. In other words, structural buckling debunks the claim that WTC 7 collapsed due to explosives.


SkyEagle, check out this angle of the South Tower collapse and see how dust is only being pushed out of the windows, and not on the perimeter-corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PV4HtDGokhk


The dust squibs are the result of compressed air, not explosives. That is also evident by the fact that no explosions are heard as WTC 2 collapsed and once again, no CD explosions detected on seismographs.


You're specialty is not really responding to every point you're given.


I've noticed that you have ignored facts surrounding the Verinage demolition method that doesn't use explosives.


Because air blast from a single bomb is nearly impossible to destroy an entire building? If that's what you're getting at, then what's your opinion on the Murrah Building collapse? Multiple bombs?


That won't fly because I have seen the results of buildings that absorbed multiple cruise missile and bomb strikes yet they remained standing. That is because the blast waves flow around structural columns like wind flowing around a flag pole and if explosives are not firmly attached to steel columns and the steel columns are not preweakened, the building will remain standing.

Once again, you will notice that the steel columns remained standing within the huge bomb crater.
 
Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.


Fire, in conjunction with impact damage, is the most logical explanation and I can point to steel frame buildings that collapsed due to fire alone.


Scoff at a full CD investigation.


Since it is illogical to think that explosives were used, why waste time and money on another investigation?


If it was not a CD than of course the fire must have caused it.


Let's take a look at two examples, one where a building withstood multiple bomb strikes, yet remained standing.


Chinese Embassy Photo

http://www.paulmidler.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a.jpg


Next, where fire destroyed steel frame buildings.


Kader Toy Factory Fire

At about 4pm on May 10th, 1993, a small fire was discovered on the first floor of part of the E-shaped building. Workers were instructed to keep working as the fire was thought to be minor. The fire alarm in this building did not sound.

The building was reinforced with un-insulated steel girders which quickly weakened and collapsed. This part of the building was dedicated to the storage of finished products and the fire spread quickly. Other parts of the factory were full of raw materials which also burnt very fast... Fire-fighters arrived at the factory at about 4:40pm, to find Building One about to collapse.

The Kader buildings,...collapsed relatively early in the fire because their structural steel supports lacked the fireproofing that would have allowed them to maintain their strength when exposed to high temperatures.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kader_Toy_Factory_fire


The NIST stalled for over 7 years before offering that as the foundation for their collapse hypothesis?

You will have noticed after all of these years, not one shred of evidence of explosives was ever found, even in today's videos and photos and the recorded seismic data.


How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?


You seem to forget that you have to provide visual and audio evidence of explosives. I might add that none exist.
 
Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.


Fire, in conjunction with impact damage, is the most logical explanation and I can point to steel frame buildings that collapsed due to fire alone.


Scoff at a full CD investigation.


Since it is illogical to think that explosives were used, why waste time and money on another investigation?


If it was not a CD than of course the fire must have caused it.


Let's take a look at two examples, one where a building withstood multiple bomb strikes, yet remained standing.


Chinese Embassy Photo

http://www.paulmidler.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a.jpg


Next, where fire destroyed steel frame buildings.


Kader Toy Factory Fire

At about 4pm on May 10th, 1993, a small fire was discovered on the first floor of part of the E-shaped building. Workers were instructed to keep working as the fire was thought to be minor. The fire alarm in this building did not sound.

The building was reinforced with un-insulated steel girders which quickly weakened and collapsed. This part of the building was dedicated to the storage of finished products and the fire spread quickly. Other parts of the factory were full of raw materials which also burnt very fast... Fire-fighters arrived at the factory at about 4:40pm, to find Building One about to collapse.

The Kader buildings,...collapsed relatively early in the fire because their structural steel supports lacked the fireproofing that would have allowed them to maintain their strength when exposed to high temperatures.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kader_Toy_Factory_fire


The NIST stalled for over 7 years before offering that as the foundation for their collapse hypothesis?

You will have noticed after all of these years, not one shred of evidence of explosives was ever found, even in today's videos and photos and the recorded seismic data.


How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?


You seem to forget that you have to provide visual and audio evidence of explosives. I might add that none exist. Did you really think that explosives would have survived uncontrolled raging fires for several hours?

Secondly, there was no way to properly prepare the WTC buildings for explosive implosion in secret. To demolish a steel frame building with explosives takes many months of preparation and the process of structural pre-weakening is a very noisy and dirty operation that would not have been tolerated by those working within those buildings.

Secondly, I have said in the past that I could have planted 1000 pounds of explosives on each floor of the WTC buildings and detonate them all at once. Now, do you know why the buildings would have remained standing? I am very sure that you can find a video where a steel structure remained standing despite absorbing the blast waves from a nuclear detonation.
 
Last edited:
@ skyeagle:

Quickly - and without glancing up at the thread title: Can you please jot down what the thread topic is? Do you even remember it?
Do you believe you are debating on topic?
 

The time of that explosion is 11:01:07. There are 3 other videos capturing this same explosion. The time can be nailed down to the second because it was also recorded in the seismic record. In fact all of the explosions recorded or mentioned in videos on 9/11 can be linked to the times 11:01:07 11:15:04 and 11:29:46






The most likely explanation for the bangs are a series of gas leak explosions originating from here:



The 11:29:46 explosion can be confirmed as a gas explosion by people running down the street yelling gas leak, gas leak, run, before the explosion occurs in two different videos.

If these explosions that you are waving in our face are recorded in the seismic
record, why aren't the explosion you claim destroyed the buildings also recorded in the seismic record?
 
@ skyeagle:

Quickly - and without glancing up at the thread title: Can you please jot down what the thread topic is? Do you even remember it?
Do you believe you are debating on topic?


4.5 Office fire simulations valid
 
Just a quick reminder:

Tony tried to insinuate that 4 or 4.5 hours of heat exposure to the WTC7 structure in certain models by NIST and WAI are too much because a certain fire test had shorter durations and/or office cubicle fires do not burn that long in any one location.

In the meantime, several posters, myself included, have pointed out to Tony the simple error implied in his question: That fire duration in any one location (such as a single office cubicle) is not the same as heat exposure of an entire structure or floor. I suppose it must have embarrassed him that this easy mistake was spotted by us, but nor him.
Parallelly, benthamitemetric has thoroughly taken apart the faulty structure of his debate approach.

As a result to these embarrassments, and in a typical example of his well-known style, Tony last posted personal insults.
That was a week ago. He ran away after having been carded for the insults.

I wish Tony showed the integrity of admitting he made an easy mistake. That would conclude this thread.
Unfortunately, he can now hide behind a full page of the same old same old discussion of everything, trolling and troll-feeding.
 
Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.

Scoff at a full CD investigation.

At that point, the logic does become very simple.

If it was not a CD than of course the fire must have caused it.

The NIST stalled for over 7 years before offering that as the foundation for their collapse hypothesis?

The long delay worked well for the Bush presidency.

The NIST could not, and still do not, address the question below;

How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?

And yet the insurers and reinsurers (many of whom were foreign entities) who lost billions from the collapses never alleged anything other than fire took down the buildings, not even in their multi-billion dollar litigations in connection with which they retained many of the world's most renowned structural engineers to independently analyze the collapses. In fact, to date, not a single one of the many tens of thousands people or companies who actually suffered direct or indirect losses as a result of the collapses of the WTC buildings has brought a suit against the owners of those buildings for the grossly negligent demolition of said buildings in the middle of downtown Manhattan that you allege to be obvious. Odd.
 
The meme is yours. You're the one who says "literally silent explosives"
Umm, no,,,,,
Aside from the fact that you attribute a quote of "literally silent explosives" to me when you just quoted my post in which I said you are invoking explosives that are "some unknown type that is relatively silent" :
There are no sounds of explosives, that is to say that there are no sounds that are consistent with those produced by a supersonic pressure wave which are characteristic of high explosives.

YOU say there were explosives used and therefore YOU are claiming the supposed existence of silent explosives.



A flash of light, a puff of material, physical deformation. You can actually see something that looks like a hole in the aluminum cladding covering the corner of the South Tower.
Odd, I see the expulsion of material flowing around the corner column. At no point at all do I see the corner column pushing outward.
Sounds good enough to be considered photographic evidence for explosions, or some other demolition device that may be capable of producing a bright flash of light and expulsion of material. What do you mean by "what possible use"? The upper portion needed to be destroyed to make sure it had enough momentum to totally destroy the lower portion.
The only light I see is the brightening of the existing fires as air is pushed through the combusting material when the upper floors and upper section begin coming down. Start a bonfire and blow on it and marvel that it gets brighter!


Considering that these expulsions are at least ten floors down from where the collapse initiated, and happen the same moment or even before the upper portion starts moving.
What of it? Yes, a floor collapses lower down, loads shift in the structure and collapse ensues. Is there some reason why it would have to begin at the 89th floor where, it would seem, the 90th floor collapsed?


So you think that the dismemberment of that area of the corner perimeter was directly caused by that apparent jet of material, however you think this phenomenon happened naturally?

I simply don't see the corner column being "dismembered". What I see is expulsion of material around the corner column leading the exterior collapse zone where the building exterior is coming apart.



It has the sound of a classic linear shaped charge.
Really?
Now when is this from? At what point in the day?
These guys are close to GZ apparently. Obviously at least one tower is already down, probably both towers (otherwise why would the FFs be walking away?) Is it some time near 5 pm? Maybe. If this sound is the precursor to the collapse of WTC7 its rather odd that we do not hear the collapse immediately following this loud sound. Nope, it's a one-off sound, an isolated boom. If this is somehow an 'explosive' going off then please shoehorn it into the collapse sequence of WTC 7.


It depends on how they're used and what they're used for. If explosives are used to do "small jobs", then the sound was certainly be comparable to the sound of the collapsing WTC towers
I see, cutting through the massive columns of WTC 1, 2, & 7 are "small jobs". Whatever you need to float your boat I suppose.:rolleyes:

In the video, the guy points out that "new smoke" seems to be emerging from the area of WTC 7 after an explosion he heard. On one recorded later in the video, he literally saus "There's another explosion..." *points camera towards WTC 7* "...coming from the federal building, I think".
From the Federal building you say. New smoke from a building that's been burning for hours you say. Colour me aghast! At what time on Sept 11/01 did the federal building collapse?
It IS NOT UNUSUAL for stuff to blow up in fires, fire extinguishers, transformers, CRT screens, propane bottles......


But don't you see how that noise happened about 3 seconds before the East Penthouse fell? The CBS footage makes it clear that was the loudest event in the collapse, not the acceleration from the other columns straight down to the ground.
Yeah I do. You do know what the NIST and ARUP and others say is the most probable sequence of collapse is, right? Column 79 fails low down in the structure and floors begin failing above that point as col 79 draws down. You for some reason expect that a) column 79 failing shouldn't be noisy, and b ) that it's failure should instantaneously transmit to the roof and cause the EPH to fall immediately.


The point is that such a collapse destroys everything except for steel.
Um, yeah sort of. The facade of WTC 7 was in many areas still recognizable as it lay on the ground towards WTC6. It was however 47 storeys tall. Stuff dropping 47 storeys amid the wreckage of a lot of other stuff is , as I have described before, a high rise, high speed rock crusher.
What's your point? Stuff broke? WOW! oooh I see, too much stuff broke. That's an opinion, back it up.

BTW you did not answer the question, you do know what a 50 ton press is and that you could put one in your garage. I suppose I should also ask how you know for certain that no one found a badly damaged 50 ton press that you claim was in WTC7? (or was it in WTC1 or 2?)

If it bothers you so much, why not just support what the demolition crowd asks for? If it's conclusive enough, you should hope and expect to see a max exodus.
What "demolition crowd"? Demolition experts? What are they asking for?
 
Simple logic requires then that we accept that the evident damage and evident large fires are the most probable, by far, cause of the building's demise.
Simpleton logic.

Put all your eggs in one basket.
As opposed to creating a plethora of baskets out of thin air and distributing your eggs in them. Even if some of those baskets are mutually exclusive ofg the other baskets(ok the metaphor fails to convey that 911truth is not above invoking mutually exclusive memes.)

Start with a politically expedient reason for the cause of the collapse.
No, go and read my post again. I STARTED WITH the well documented mechanisms of structural damage to the buildings.
FIRE IS THERE. IMPACT DAMAGE DID OCCUR. There is absolutely no politics in noting that these exist. There is politics involved in trying to minimize or ignore it in favour of a political world view that demands the existence of a shadowy extra-governmental cadre of plotters of a vast and overly complex conspiracy.

Scoff at a full CD investigation.
Yes, I do because after a decade and a half there is still no evidence that explosives were used that stands up to even cursory examination. ITS ALL MADE UP.

At that point, the logic does become very simple.
I already said that, yes it is simple, no evidence of anything other than imapct damage and continuing fire damage.
If it was not a CD than of course the fire must have caused it
.
Nope, read again. Looking at the obvious and well documented evidence of impact damage, and of large area fires in all three structures, one can logically assume that they were the cause of collapse. Others come along and say,"what about explosives" then for 15 years no evidence of explosives are forthcoming. Thus the null hypothesis stands, impact damage and fire.

The NIST stalled for over 7 years before offering that as the foundation for their collapse hypothesis?

Are you ignorant or simply ignoring what you know to be true?
NIST waited to complete the WTC7 report until all other WTC 1 & 2 reports were finished. They did this because the towers saw large loss of life while WTC 7 had no one killed.

The long delay worked well for the Bush presidency.
How so?
The NIST could not, and still do not, address the question below;

How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?
No, in fact if one looks through the collapse sims one sees why the lower section offered no resistance once full collapse had progressed 1.75 seconds( approx 14-16 seconds AFTER collapse initiation. (initiation occurring when col 79 failed, or even slightly before that when the probable failure of girder 79-44 led to multiple floor failures).

Your own politically motivated incredulity does not mean that a made up fable of explosives is any more probable than invisible pixies bringing the buildings down.
 
And yet the insurers and reinsurers (many of whom were foreign entities) who lost billions from the collapses never alleged anything other than fire took down the buildings, not even in their multi-billion dollar litigations in connection with which they retained many of the world's most renowned structural engineers to independently analyze the collapses. In fact, to date, not a single one of the many tens of thousands people or companies who actually suffered direct or indirect losses as a result of the collapses of the WTC buildings has brought a suit against the owners of those buildings for the grossly negligent demolition of said buildings in the middle of downtown Manhattan that you allege to be obvious. Odd.

oh yeah and ^^ THAT too!:D

Insurance companies are so easy to bambozzle, they just love paying out millions of dollars in loss coverage.:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom