Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

At this point a question that doesn't need to be asked.............

With Gage, I tend to assume the worst re lying for profit. With someone like Tony? I honestly don't know. I think he's more an example of confirmation bias an sunk cost fallacy run amok than the sort of naked con man that Gage represents. Of course, Tony himself can be deliberately deceptive at times. Is that a conscious choice to maximize his "internet fame and credibility" among the truther lot? Or is it really the result of a pathological obsession with a (false) cause to which he has devoted so many years of his life?

I bet its more the latter than the former, though I reckon the two are in a battle of sorts at the edges of his mind. I still think he is capable of having an "ah-ha!" moment where he realizes the error of his ways, and that this is reflected in his comments when he is pushed to focus on a given issue. Whenever he comes close to an epiphany, however, his pathological need to be right in his initial (now demonstrably silly) theory forces him to back away from the cognitive dissonance and refortify his beliefs in the truther bubble, where the echo chamber is more than happy to reassure (and even exalt) him. Eventually, as others have observed, he'll come back when he's comfortable that he does not have to immediately address the biggest holes in his arguments and claims.

It's fascinating, if somewhat sad, to watch it all unfold in real time, in any event.
 
Last edited:
It's amazing that when we started pushing to see his "analysis" and he couldn't even produce a free body of the beam, he immediately shifted to the fire simulations...
 
The whole question is ridiculous.

WTC7 fire sims modeled the fire spread over an entire floor space of a very large building.
While it is common for material in any office cubicle to be exhausted within an hour, it is quite uncommon for a large office area to exhaust all its fuel in less than better part of a day----WITH active fire fighting!
It should be a no brainer to note that fire 'moves', spreads throughout an office floor as well as vertically through the structure. It should also be a no brainer for anyone with a bit of technical knowledge, that as it spreads it would be common for ceiling level gas temps to remain high in areas where the fuel directly below have actually exhausted the fuel.
-where are the hot gases flowing? how is turbulence affecting flow and ignition? are there places where gases will collect?(for eg. at the column connections to support girders?)
-how much drop ceiling is still intact?
-when did those ceiling level hot gases ignite in a flashover? are hot gases from newly ignited fuel flowing into the volume of combusting ceiling level gases?

Now that's just me, a most certain non-expert in fire science. I tend to feel that proven fire sim programs, written BY experts in the field would take these factors into consideration as well as fuel load and type, air ingest and flow etc.

However, Tony, following the "expert" analysis of Chris Sarns, takes into account ONE averaged aspect of office fires, that fuel in any particular office cubicle will tend to burn out within an hour.

Apparently now that Tony has destroyed the structural response analysis by several leading forensic engineering firms, he is moving on to destroy the analysis done by leading fire science experts.
 
Last edited:
The whole question is ridiculous.

WTC7 fire sims modeled the fire spread over an entire floor space of a very large building.
While it is common for material in any office cubicle to be exhausted within an hour, it is quite uncommon for a large office area to exhaust all its fuel in less than better part of a day----WITH active fire fighting!
It should be a no brainer to note that fire 'moves', spreads throughout an office floor as well as vertically through the structure. It should also be a no brainer for anyone with a bit of technical knowledge, that as it spreads it would be common for ceiling level gas temps to remain high in areas where the fuel directly below have actually exhausted the fuel.
-where are the hot gases flowing? how is turbulence affecting flow and ignition? are there places where gases will collect?(for eg. at the column connections to support girders?)
-how much drop ceiling is still intact?
-when did those ceiling level hot gases ignite in a flashover? are hot gases from newly ignited fuel flowing into the volume of combusting ceiling level gases?

It gets worse, as the highlighted bit isn't quite true (actually, sometimes it isn't at all true ;)). Lack of flames can simply indicate that all the volatile compounds - the ones that produce easily visible flames - have been driven off, while the carbonised remains are generating heat quite happily.

Think charcoal on a bbq, where the fuel starts off relatively clean of complex volatiles - it will still cook the food, though pure charcoal flames are only visible in dark conditions.
 
The whole question is ridiculous.
Which is, of course, the general case.

Dave
More than the question is ridiculous. It is the wrong question(s) about an irrelevant derail topic.

Tony is once again succeeding at avoiding the real question by erecting red herrings which people willingly follow.

Apparently now that Tony has destroyed the structural response analysis by several leading forensic engineering firms, he is moving on to destroy the analysis done by leading fire science experts.
Begging the question as to whether he has in reality "destroyed" any of those papers...."destruction" is not his objective. His objective is to keep discussion in the details of the wrong topic. There is a potentially unlimited source of professional papers which Tony can "destroy" seriatem - so bleeding what? No matter how many papers he "proves wrong" does not make hs own claims right. And he has been playing that false dichotomy - successfully - for several months. A shift of his mendacious tactics which should allow him to keep discussion going nowhere for at least another couple of years.

He continues to succeed at his tricks.

Do we congratulate Tony? Or those who are willing to play his mendacious game?
 
It gets worse, as the highlighted bit isn't quite true (actually, sometimes it isn't at all true ;)). Lack of flames can simply indicate that all the volatile compounds - the ones that produce easily visible flames - have been driven off, while the carbonised remains are generating heat quite happily.

Think charcoal on a bbq, where the fuel starts off relatively clean of complex volatiles - it will still cook the food, though pure charcoal flames are only visible in dark conditions.
Certainly,,,,

Actually I was referring to the point in time after even the last of the carbonized material has fully turned to ash. Its quite possible (again in my non-expert opinion) that at ceiling level gases from other areas are happily gathering and igniting. Turbulence creating ceiling structure could create eddies in gas flow and a concentration of hot gases irrespective of what is happening directly below at floor level.
 
More than the question is ridiculous. It is the wrong question(s) about an irrelevant derail topic.

Tony is once again succeeding at avoiding the real question by erecting red herrings which people willingly follow.

Begging the question as to whether he has in reality "destroyed" any of those papers...."destruction" is not his objective. His objective is to keep discussion in the details of the wrong topic. There is a potentially unlimited source of professional papers which Tony can "destroy" seriatem - so bleeding what? No matter how many papers he "proves wrong" does not make hs own claims right. And he has been playing that false dichotomy - successfully - for several months. A shift of his mendacious tactics which should allow him to keep discussion going nowhere for at least another couple of years.

He continues to succeed at his tricks.

Do we congratulate Tony? Or those who are willing to play his mendacious game?

"Teach the controversy "
 
"Teach the controversy "
Provided it is the same controversy. ;)

as per DGM's "sig":
"How many leaves on the seventh branch of the fourth tree?" is meaningless when you are in the wrong forest:

:rolleyes:

For those who like metaphor or analogy - Tony is in effect claiming:

"the third tree in row four of Forest A is NOT an OAK -- THEREFORE -- the second tree in row five of MY Forest B MUST be an oak."
 
Last edited:
Why don't Tony and Richard Gage et al ever start the conversation from an honest place and share with their fellow travelers all of the massive amount of professional opinion that exists re the fire induced collapse hypotheses?

That would require professional integrity.
 
Don't be so hard on the skeptics here. I mean, I know they are crazy, but be nice.

Please don't employ that sort of puerile comment in response to my posts. Your misrepresentation is mendacious and I have no time for such dishonesty.

Just don't...ok? There is no need for such lowbrow tactics if you have a decent case.
 
Please don't employ that sort of puerile comment in response to my posts. Your misrepresentation is mendacious and I have no time for such dishonesty.

Just don't...ok? There is no need for such lowbrow tactics if you have a decent case.

The coward got himself banned, so no need to worry.
 
Provided it is the same controversy. ;)

as per DGM's "sig":
"How many leaves on the seventh branch of the fourth tree?" is meaningless when you are in the wrong forest:

:rolleyes:

For those who like metaphor or analogy - Tony is in effect claiming:

"the third tree in row four of Forest A is NOT an OAK -- THEREFORE -- the second tree in row five of MY Forest B MUST be an oak."

AND that tree is a whole half an inch off, so there is NO way its branches could hit the other tree's branches.
 
AND that tree is a whole half an inch off, so there is NO way its branches could hit the other tree's branches.

Well, with all the rain and wind lately is it possible that some ground movement or changes to the angle of the tree pushed a branch or two closer to touching another tree?

Just asking, I am neither a forester nor an aborist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom